ArticlePublisher preview available

A Test of a Model for Commitment

American Psychological Association
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

Presents a theoretical model for the role of commitment, defined as a binding of the individual to behavioral acts, in attitude change. The derivation tested is: the greater the inducement offered S for performing an act consistent with his beliefs, the less committed he is to that act, and the less the resistance to subsequent countercommunications. Ss were differentially paid for performing an act consistent with their prior beliefs: later all Ss received a strong countercommunication on the same topic. The hypothesis was confirmed: Ss receiving the greater payment for performing the consonant act later showed greater attitude change in the direction advocated by the countercommunication. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2006 APA, all rights reserved).
BRIEF
ARTICLES
349
LESSER,
G. S.,
KRAWITZ,
RIIODA
N., &
PACKARD,
RITA.
Experimental arousal
of
achievement motivation
in
adolescent
girls. Journal
of
Abnormal
and
Social
Psychology, 1963,
66,
59-66.
MANDLER,
G.,
&
SARASON,
S. B. A
study
of
anxiety
and
learning.
Journal
of
Abnormal
and
Social Psy-
chology, 19S2,
47,
166-173.
MCCLELLAND,
D. C.,
ATKINSON,
J. W.,
CLARK,
R.
A.,
&
LOWELL,
E. L. The
achievement
motive.
New
York:
Applelon-Cenlury-Crofts,
1953.
MILLER,
N. E.
Experimental studies
of
conflict
be-
havior.
In J.
McV.
Hunt
(Ed.),
Personality
and
the
behavior disorders. Vol.
1. New
York:
Ronald
Press, 1944.
Pp.
431-465.
NEWCOMB,
T. M.
Social
psychology.
New
York:
Holt,
Rinehart,
&
Winston, 1950.
ROSENPELD,
H. M.
Social
choice
conceived
as a
level
of
aspiration. Journal
of
Abnormal
and
Social
Psychology, 1964,
68,
491-499.
ROSENPELD,
H.
M.,
&
FRANKLIN,
S. S.
Arousal
of
need
for
affiliation
in
women. Journal
of
Personal-
ity and
Social
Psychology,
1966,
3,
245-248.
VEROFF,
J.,
ATKINSON,
J.
W.,
FELD, SHEILA,
C.,
&
GURIN,
G. The use of
thematic
apperception
to
assess motivation
in a
nationwide interview
study.
Psychological Monographs, 1960,
74(12,
Whole
No.
499).
(Received
September
28,
1964)
Journal
of
Personality
and
Social Psychology
1966, Vol.
3, No. 3,
349-353
A
TEST
OF A
MODEL
FOR
COMMITMENT
CHARLES
A.
KIESLER
1
Yale
University
JOSEPH
SAKUMURA
Ohio
State
University
Commitment
is
defined
as a
binding
of the
individual
to
behavioral acts,
and a
theoretical model
is
presented
for the
role
of
commitment
in
attitude change.
The
derivation tested here
is: the
greater
the
inducement
offered
S for
perform-
ing
an act
consistent
with
his
beliefs,
the
less
committed
he is to
that
act,
and the
less
the
resistance
to
subsequent
countercommunications.
Ss
were
differentially
paid
for
performing
an act
consistent with their prior beliefs.
Later
all Ss
received
a
strong
countercommunication
on the
same
topic.
The
hypothesis
was
confirmed:
Ss
receiving
the
greater payment
for
performing
the
consonant
act
later showed greater attitude change
in the
direction
advocated
by the
countercommunication.
There
is a
rapidly
increasing body
of
evidence
indicating
that
a
thorough understanding
of the
role
of
commitment
is a
necessary
requisite
to an
adequate
theory
of
attitude change. Perhaps
Brehm
and
Cohen (1962),
in
their discussion
of
dissonance
theory
(Festinger,
1957)
have
voiced
the
most explicit interest
in
commitment
as a
variable,
but
other authors (e.g., Hovland, Janis,
&
Kelley,
1953;
Secord
&
Backman,
1964;
Sherif
&
Hovland, 1961) have also been concerned with
the
topic. Although theoretical
interest
has
been
increasing,
there have been
few
efforts
to
deal
directly
with
the
concept experimentally.
Recently,
however,
Kiesler2
proposed
a
pre-
liminary
theoretical model
for the
role
of
com-
mitment
in
attitude
change.
He
defines commit-
ment
as a
pledging
or
binding
of the
individual
1
The
data
were
collected
while
the
senior author
was
at
the
Ohio
State
University.
2
"Psychological
Commitment
in
Attitude
Change,"
proposal submitted
to the
National Institute
of
Men-
tal
Health,
United States Public Health
Service,
1964.
to
behavioral acts,
and
discusses
how
commit-
ment
to
specific
behaviors will relate
to
attitudes
and
their resistance
to
change. Some
of the
basic
assumptions
and
hypotheses
are
presented below.
1.
The
individual attempts
to
resolve incon-
sistencies
between
the
attitudes
he
holds
and be-
havioral acts which
he, for one
reason
or an-
other,
is
induced
to
perform.
This
assumption
is
quite
similar,
if not
identical,
to the
main assump-
tion
of the
"consistency" models proposed
by
Festinger
(19S7),
Heider
(1958),
and
Osgood
(1960),
and
hence
is
supported
by
evidence
re-
lated
to
those theories.
We
assume that
to
resolve
the
inconsistency,
one may
change either
the at-
titude
or the act
(including
the
psychological
im-
plications
of the
act).
2.
The
effect
of
commitment
is to
make
an act
less changeable. Thus,
utilizing
Assumptions
1 and
2,
we may
hypothesize:
(a) if the act is
consistent
with
the
subject's previous belief system then
commitment
to the act
makes
the
subject more
resistant
to
subsequent attack
on his
beliefs;
(b)
if
the act is
inconsistent with
the
subject's previ-
... In their scoping review, Hastie et al. (2022) showed that engagement could be an individual behaviour or a theoretical framework, with many definitions and a need for consensus. Kiesler and Sakumura (1966) provided a definition of engagement in PA as "the connection between an individual and their behavioural actions" (p. 30). ...
Article
Physical activity (PA) is linked to numerous health advantages, but adolescents typically demonstrate inadequate levels of PA, with girls engaging in less PA than boys. This study aims to explore the factors hindering and promoting PA among girls aged 11–18 years, examining how existing literature addresses these factors through an ecological framework. A scoping review was conducted using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analysis extension for Scoping Reviews protocol. Six databases were searched between October 2022 and November 2024, and 41 articles published between 1993 and 2024 were analyzed. The main barriers to PA for girls were their relationship with their bodies and the influences of peers and teachers, while the main facilitators were social interactions, family or teacher support, and choice of activity. These findings highlight the importance of developing a socioecological framework that addresses personal, interpersonal, and environmental factors to enhance understanding of the issue of girls’ engagement in PA.
... Ces derniers insistent sur la nécessité de mieux identifier les processus par lesquels les membres du personnel en oncologie font face au stress lié à leur métier. Abernethy et al, quant à eux, non seulement présentent des stratégies similaires, mais affirment que bien que les stratégies pour faire face à la surcharge de travail abondent, le personnel soignant d'oncologie doit faire preuve de diligence dans l'application des options disponibles pour éviter l'épuisement professionnel (8 (17)(18)(19), où ils démontrent l'importance des facteurs externes et internes dans le comportement qu'on adopte et la nécessité de la motivation dont l'absence influence la survenue d'une souffrance. ...
Article
Full-text available
Management of psychological distress of health care professionals of the Oncology Department of Cameroon: the case of Yaoundé General Hospital ABSTRACT Introduction: The health care providers in oncology departments are exposed to continual stress, which causes psychological distress. This study aimed to describe the strategies used by the medical and nursing staff of the medical oncology department at the Yaoundé General Hospital to manage psychological distress and the proposed solutions. Material and methods: A qualitative study was carried out from July to December 2017, involving all the medical and the nursing staff of the medical oncology department of the Yaoundé General Hospital. The information was collected through an interview, and a content analysis was performed. Results: Seventeen healthcare providers were interviewed. Physical exercise, dialogue, cheerfulness, acceptance, humility, prayer, rebellion, silence, adaptation, surpassing oneself, and withdrawal were the defence mechanisms and coping strategies proposed to deal with the distress perceived by the medical and the nursing staff. Improving working conditions was the staff's main proposal, based on a number of themes, including the provision of work equipment, the motivation of care staff, staff training, conviviality and relaxation within the work team, improved communication, better organisation of work, staff psychological support, subsidising patient care, and improving the working environment. Conclusion: Participative management and improved working conditions were proposed as ways of managing this psychological distress. Key words: management, psychological distress, healthcare providers, medical oncology department of the Yaoundé General Hospital.
... Commitment is the process linking behaviors (i.e., observable outputs) to the individual's attitudes and cognitive processes (Kiesler & Sakumura, 1966). Commitment contributes to determining people's behaviors through the actions they have previously taken and not only through their opinions and values. ...
Article
Full-text available
In the Japanese philosophy of life, ‘ikigai’ broadly refers to having a ‘reason for living’, or a purpose in life. From a phenomenological and empirical viewpoint, ikigai is reported to increase human well-being and even life expectancy. However, it remains difficult to translate, define and formalize with regard to contemporary psychological theories. In this respect, the aim of this paper is twofold: to capture as accurately as possible what ikigai is, and to examine whether the concept applies to a professional context. We first offer a comprehensive overview of ikigai, bridge the gap between this specific body of literature and related psychological theoretical frameworks, such as those addressing motivation, well-being, and attention. On this basis, we conceptualize an integrated cognitive-motivational model of ikigai using an IPO (Input-Process-Output) framework: we organize dispositional or situational factors supposedly supporting ikigai as inputs, fueling the core process of ikigai (mainly built from motivational and attentional mechanisms), which produce outcomes (including well-being). A feedback loop completes the model and allows the process to maintain over time. This conceptual proposal is a first step towards applying and testing the model in professional contexts, in order to renew our approach of engagement, well-being, and performance at work as well as inspire workplace evolution.
Article
Under incomplete contracts, the mutual belief in reciprocity facilitates how traders create value through economic exchange. Creating such beliefs among strangers can be challenging even when they are allowed to communicate, because communication is cheap. In this paper, we first extend the literature showing that a truth-telling oath increases honesty to a sequential trust game with pre-play, fixed-form, and cheap-talk communication. Our results confirm that the oath creates more trust and cooperative behavior thanks to an improvement in communication; but we also show that the oath induces selection into communication — it makes people more wary of using communication, precisely because communication speaks louder under oath. We next designed additional treatments featuring mild and deterrent fines for deception to measure the monetary equivalent of the non-monetary incentives implemented by a truth-telling oath. We find that the oath is behaviorally equivalent to mild fines. The deterrent fine induces the highest level of cooperation. Altogether, these results confirm that allowing for interactions under oath within a trust game with communication creates significantly more economic value than the identical exchange institutions without the oath.
Article
Full-text available
Given the popularity of influencer marketing, this study aimed to determine the effectiveness of influencer authenticity in achieving intention to co-create brand value and purchase intention in Pakistan. Grounded in the Elaboration Likelihood Model, the study explored the central and peripheral routes to achieving desired behavioral intentions. Using a self-administered questionnaire, data were collected from 421 fashion and lifestyle social media influencers followers in Pakistan by the time-lagged approach, over a period of four months, and partial least squares structural equation modeling was performed for data analysis. The results showed a significant impact of influencer authenticity on behavioral intentions. Serial mediation indicated that consumers followed the central route of persuasion. The study aimed to fill gaps in the influencer marketing research literature by conceptualizing influencer authenticity as a composite higher-order construct and examining its impact on the intention to co-create brand value. Second, it elaborated on the cognitive and affective components of attitude formation using central and peripheral routes, respectively. Third, it highlighted relational attitude (the customer-brand relationship) as a bridge to achieving targeted behavioral intentions. The outcomes of this study may assist managers in designing effective influencer marketing campaigns by emphasizing brand attributes rather than relying on social media influencer followership.
Article
Full-text available
People feel committed to other individuals, groups, organizations, or moral norms in many contexts of everyday life. Such social commitment can lead to positive outcomes, such as increased job satisfaction or relationship longevity; yet, there can also be detrimental effects to feeling committed. Recent high-profile cases of fraud or corruption in companies like Enron or Volkswagen are likely influenced by strong commitment to the organization or coworkers. Although social commitment might increase dishonest behavior, there is little systematic knowledge about when and how this may occur. In the present project, we reviewed 20,988 articles, focusing on studies that experimentally manipulated social commitment and measured dishonest behavior. We retained 445 effect sizes from 121 articles featuring a total of 91,683 participants across 33 countries. We found no evidence that social commitment increases or reduces dishonest behavior in general. Nonetheless, we did find evidence that the effect strongly depends on the target of the commitment. Feeling committed to other individuals or groups reduces honest behavior (g = −0.17 [−0.24, −0.11]), whereas feeling committed to honesty norms through honesty oaths or pledges increases honest behavior (g = 0.27 [0.19, 0.36]). The analysis identified several moderating variables and detected some degree of publication bias across effects. Our findings highlight the diverging effects of different forms of social commitment on dishonest behavior and suggest a combination of the different forms of commitment could be a possible means to combat corruption and dishonest behavior in the organizational context.
Article
The seminal work that led to the "Yale Studies in Attitudes and Communication," reporting a series of experiments on communicator credibility, general persuasibility, role playing, fear arousal, order of presentation, and group norms. Much of the later work in attitude change flows directly from this early volume. Harvard Book List (edited) 1971 #487 (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
The various models of cognitive consistency are in agreement that changes in belief follow from the psychological stress created by inconsistencies and that the magnitude of stress toward modification increases with the degree of inconsistency. The model of congruity, employing the measurement technique of the semantic differential, differs from the other models in its more detailed specifications of the cognitive interaction occurring within the individual and its more precise quantitative predictions about the resolution of inconsistencies.
Article
Derivations from the theory of cognitive dissonance, which postulates a drive to reduce discordant beliefs, behavior, and perceptions, can be experimentally tested with respect to problems of attitude change. One derivation from dissonance theory is that experiences entailing deprivation and suffering will be valued highly to justify the effort they entail. Students subjected to embarrassing and unpleasant experiences in the attainment of group membership placed a high value upon such membership. Another derivation is that high reward for engaging in actions counter to one's beliefs will produce less attitude change than low reward. High reward, by adding compelling cognitions for compliance, may make the act of compliance less a matter of one's own choice and hence lead to less dissonance and consequent attitude change. Different groups of school children were given varying degrees of reward for writing essays in favor of shorter summer vacations. The high-reward group showed less actual changes in attitudes in a post-test than the low-reward group.
A theory of cognitive dissonance
  • L Festinoer
FESTINOER, L. A theory of cognitive dissonance. Stanford: Stanford Univer. Press, 1957.
Cognitive consequences of forced compliance
  • L Festinger
  • J M Caelsmith
FESTINGER, L., & CAELSMITH, J. M. Cognitive consequences of forced compliance. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1959, 58, 203-210.