Article

Doctors in Spite of Themselves: The Limits of Radical Health Criticism

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

This paper distinguishes a materialist from a medical approach to health (including as medical the clinical, epidemiological, sociological, environmental, and radical approaches). Three themes are developed. The first concerns a broad definition of medicine. Derived from the actual strategies that capital and labor adopt to health, this definition encompasses all attempts to manage the social factors responsible for ill-health as "conditions" while maintaining (or concealing) the contradictory basis for these conditions in capitalist social relations. The second theme concerns the roots of medicine. Radicals treat scientific medicine as a tool introduced by capitalists and a professional elite to maximize profits, increase productivity, and control women and other oppressed minorities. The materialist view, by contrast, emphasizes the role of worker initiatives in transforming the relations responsible for epidemic disease in the 19th century and the extent to which this transformation led directly to the utility of medical care after 1900. The fact that modern medicine can acknowledge its dependence neither on these initiatives nor on the progress of suffering created through the accumulation process is far more important than the market position of doctors in determining medicine's limits and the ideology of professional doctors. The third theme concerns the utility of a materialist epidemiology for reinterpreting many of the same issues examined by radicals, including medicalization, victim blaming, professional ideology, elitism, the exclusion of certain oppressed groups from "the sick role," and medicine's failure to combat the diseases of stress. The basic contention is that a revolutionary health strategy is impossible as long as medical care remains the centerpiece of our analysis.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.

... However, in more recent years attention has begun to focus on the lack of information about domestic violence within health care agencies and the identification of health as an area of concern. North American research has lead the way in establishing the existence of domestic violence within the caseloads of health professionals, illuminating the implications of domestic violence on women's health and professional practice (Stark, 1982;Stark andFlitcraft, 1995, 1996). ...
... However, in more recent years attention has begun to focus on the lack of information about domestic violence within health care agencies and the identification of health as an area of concern. North American research has lead the way in establishing the existence of domestic violence within the caseloads of health professionals, illuminating the implications of domestic violence on women's health and professional practice (Stark, 1982;Stark andFlitcraft, 1995, 1996). ...
... Researchers have argued that this resistance may serve to impact upon women at the point of contact resulting in their misdiagnosis and health professionals' denial of women's actual experience (Kurtz, 1987;Abbott and Williamson, 1999;Williamson, 2000). A number of researchers have highlighted concern regarding what they identify as potential problems associated with the 'medicalisation' of a hitherto social issue (Stark, 1982;Reissman, 1983). ...
Article
Full-text available
This report presents the findings of a research study exploring the health service response to domestic violence within Wakefield. Recent international, national and local research has identified domestic violence as a serious health care issue resulting in a wide range of long and short term health implications for women1 (Butler, 1995: Stark and Flitcraft, 1995, 1996: Campbell, 2002). The research highlights the changing face of domestic violence considering the implications of the recent reframing of domestic violence from a social care issue into an integrated health and social care issue (Glendinning, 2003). Explored is the impact of such changes for health policy makers, health professionals and women who having experienced domestic violence then access health care services in the District. Eastern Wakefield Primary Care Trust
... In rich countries the concept of health has come under fierce scrutiny in the late twentieth century. Part of this has been due to a reaction against what has been perceived to be the dehumanising effects of medical ideology and technology when carried to extremes -as in features of the modern practice of chemotherapy, surgery and obstetrics (see, for example, Powles, 1973;Illich, 1975;Navarro, 1976;Ehrenreich, 1978;Stark, 1982). Medicine is felt to be too narrowly concerned with diseases, rather than with people. ...
... Such views are presented with the full authority of science, but to reiterate our earher arguments, the biomedical approach is not reahty but merely one way of looking at reality, and it is not necessarily the 'best' or the most rational. Indeed, a number of commentators have attacked the biomedical model, and we will first discuss those criticisms made from within medicine by three 'radical doctors' (Stark, 1982): Cochrane, Dubos, and M c K e o w n. We will then proceed to the critiques of lUich (a theologian) and Doyal (a marxist sociologist). ...
... In clinging to a moralistic evaluation of alcoholism, physicians express clinical fatalism, but their failure to heal is projected onto their patients "as the inevitable result of a unique biography or cultural predisposition" [122]. Applied anthropology and other service disciplines rush to fill the breach, investigating, describing, and quantifying isolatable psycho-social correlates of drinking abuse. ...
Article
This paper addresses a shortcoming in the existing anthropological and related social science literature on alcohol use and abuse, namely the general inattention to global political-economic forces that have in the past and continue to reshape social relations and drinking practices cross-culturally. Following a critical review of the dominant approaches adopted in the varying explanations of heavy drinking and alcoholism, several alternative concepts are presented and developed in order to lay the ground for the emergence of a political-economy of alcoholism. The paper urges transcedence of the existing narrow boundaries of inquiry and perspective characteristics of most anthropological study of drinking and drinking problems.
Article
Health professionals and the mass media have reported a sharp rise in the incidence of a variety of syndromes and neuroses in postwar Japan. The origins of these “diseases of civilization” are often explicitly associated with a breakdown of traditional values, and especially with the rise of the nuclear family. The remaking of a postwar cultural identity is discussed, with emphasis on the roles that the family, in particular the mothers, are assigned in this endeavor. A new disease, “menopausal syndrome,” is used as an example in order to examine the relationship of postulated physical distress during midlife, individual personality and behavior, and the social role assigned to middle-class housewives. It is shown that the rhetoric about menopause is one part of the larger cultural debate about modernization in Japan. Although this rhetoric is accepted as accurate by the majority of women, survey research shows that it is erroneous and bears no relationship to the incidence of the physical discomfort it seeks to explain. The attempted medicalization of menopause and its relationship to the cultural debate is also discussed. [Japan, modernization, medicalization]
Article
This article examines the medical care sector in New York City in the wake of that city's fiscal crisis. Against a changing national background of medical care politics, it describes existing inequalities and distortions in the medical care system, a system whose inequities are partially reinforced by federal and state intervention. The process of subordination of the 'place-of-last-resort' public sector is defined. Although attention on this sector is justified, the service crisis of the medical care sector is more correctly to be seen as one afflicting all those services used by minorities and the working class. The policy of retrenchment in New York is seen as a prelude to Reagan's austerity programme, and calls for reassessment of current health activism.
Article
Many clinicians are moving away from the traditional expert role towards a more collaborative approach to clinical decision making. Collaboration with patients has implications for the power distribution between clinician and patient, how health is defined, and what counts as evidence in the decision-making process. A critical social science perspective provides the philosophical and theoretical underpinnings for collaborative clinical decision making. Key issues of critical social science are critical self-reflection, questioning taken-for-granted practice, and transforming current practice. The way that clinicians define their role in clinical decision making reflects their beliefs and values about health, power and practice knowledge. Clinicians who adopt a collaborative clinical decision-making approach reject the objective scientific view of evidence-based practice, and embrace cultural and political influences on what counts as evidence. The purpose of collaboration is to increase understanding between the clinician and the patient. A distinction is made in this debate between manipulating and emancipating patients. Including patients in the decision-making process promises to result in more realistic and appropriate treatments, reduced patient concerns and complaints and better, sustainable health outcomes, and increased patient and clinician satisfaction. In this article we re-think practice knowledge and the notion of clinician–patient relationships.
Article
The political economy of health is a multifaceted label that subsumes at least three separate theoretical perspectives: orthodox Marxist approaches, cultural critiques of medicine, and dependency theories. Anthropologists who advocate greater attention to the political economy of health have tended to overemphasize dependency theories, which have in fact been widely assailed in the sociological literature. In this article I examine some basic premises of dependency theories and analyze their contributions and limitations for the development of theory in the political economy of health. I also maintain that political economy must learn from anthropology as well as the other way around. Through this reciprocal integration of concepts, political economic approaches will enter into regular medical anthropology to provide a synthetic new perspective on sickness and health.
Article
This article uses the current controversies in the British debate about health to illustrate the need to theorize, and therefore critically evaluate, the links between medicine and health policies, including health care policies. The medical model of health is deeply embedded in institutional practices in many countries, and while this model has attracted deserved criticism in recent years, an alternative social model, or one that incorporates indispensable aspects of the medical model, has attracted much less attention and requires sustained development. Comparative study of patterns of inequality in health, and especially of the correlation between material deprivation and premature mortality, necessarily reveals causal determinants of both health and ill-health in populations and invites ambitious programs to develop a social model.
Article
In this article, we contend that the standard definition of risk factors in pregnancy is not the neutral or technical process that women may assume it to be, but is colored by the prejudice of its context: a capitalist and patriarchal society. In such a society, only paid work is valued, and thus there is little study of the ill effects of housework on pregnant women; such a study would mean considering and possibly changing our sex-biased division of labor. Physicians and the mass media stress risk factors such as smoking, while omitting to mention that drugs prescribed by doctors are not always safe, and some are prescribed for years before-and even after-their harmful effects are known. Further examples are given from the field of childbirth, and we advance the hypothesis that, especially in fee-for-service medical systems, the physician can represent a risk factor. "Information" is often offered as the solution for pregnancy risks, the responsibility for this being the woman's. The mystification and narrowness of such a victim-blaming approach are evident. The key factor in prenatal preventive care is the mother's level of education: to admit this would be to acknowledge the need for change of a social system that keeps women in ignorance. We point out the limitations of the proposed individualistic solutions and conclude that, in redefining risk factors for women and their babies, we must analyze our society in feminist terms and in terms of social class.
Article
This article makes a review of 1.) dominant analyses of health and medicine in the social sciences of the U.S. and 2.) Marxist critiques of these analyses. It presents the roots of Marxist scholarship in the study of health and medicine and discusses the main Marxist critiques of the hegemonic pluralist and power elite interpretations of the institutions of medicine and of their corporatization. It also reviews Marxist studies of 1.) the crisis of medicine; 2.) the relationship between production, work, and health; and 3.) imperialism, health, and medicine. It concludes with a discussion of the operational meaning of Marxism in health and medicine, with presentation of current Marxist debates on socialist medicine and their consequences for political praxis.
Article
This article presents a critique of recent radical interpretations of medicine and provides an alternative explanation of such interpretations. It analyzes 1) the articulation of medical practices, knowledge, and institutions within specific modes of production and social formations; 2) the dual functions of medicine within capitalist relations of production; 3) the reproduction of power within medicine; and 4) the meaning of capitalist, socialist, and communist medicine. The political practice derived from these analyses is also elaborated.
Article
This paper derives a conception of ideal socialist and communist medical care and health policy. This model is based on a review of Marxist and allied critiques of capitalist medical care policy and on theoretical work on socialist social policy. The ideal conception, operationalized in terms of 16 criteria, is then applied to a review of medical care and health policy in the Soviet Union. Hungary, and Poland. It is concluded that medical care policy in all three countries exhibits very few characteristics of socialist medical care. The possibility (for the moment repressed) provided by the Solidarity movement in Poland of a new development toward a more genuine socialist medical care and health policy is also described.
Article
Full-text available
Recent discussion in critical medical anthropology has turned to the issue of application beyond the academy. Building on Gorz's notion of "non-reformist reform," that is, applied work that unmasks rather than mystifies the sources of social inequality and ill health, this article argues for the possibility of an applied critical medical anthropology, suggests concrete opportunities for such work in health settings, and identifies problems and social conditions that affect the development of a critical health praxis. These points are illustrated by reviewing case studies of anthropological work with the Farm Labor Organizing Committee in Indiana, the United Farm Workers Union in California, and the Hispanic Health Council in Connecticut. The article concludes with an examination of the skills and resources critical medical anthropology has to offer system-challenging movements in health care.
Article
The untimely recent death of French philosopher-historian Michel Foucault, at the age of 57, serves as a sad reminder that twenty years have now passed since the publication in English translation of his seminal 1961 study Historie de la Folie. In the intervening years, and largely as a result of Foucault's provocative revisionism, the history of psychiatry has emerged as one of the most exciting and controversial growth areas of the “new social history”. Scholars, in both Europe and the United States, have begun a critical re-assessment of the history of “madhouses, mad-doctors and madmen” in post-Reformation Western society. In particular attention has focused on the origins and development of the lunatic asylum in the nineteenth century. Rejecting the long-held “Whig” explanation of the institution as one of the great nineteenth century “reforms”, revisionist historians have erected a new “social control” model in its place. Recently, however, this “new orthodoxy” of interpretation has itself come under attack as a second generation of asylum studies has begun to appear in print. Still confined, for the most part, to reviews and articles, this new work, less strident and dogmatic in tone than that of the “social control” historians, points to a more balanced and nuanced account of the nineteenth century asylum experience. Psychiatric history is once again in a state of flux and it seems highly unlikely that the decade of the 1980s will close without seeing the production of one or more new synthetic overviews of nineteenth century psychiatry to match those produced by David Rothman and Andrew Scull in the 1970s.
Article
Full-text available
Modern capitalist social organization, through intensified, con flicted work and the destruction of cooperative, supportive forms of social com munity, causes a large excess mortality among adults in developed countries. This excess mortality is most strikingly evident in the comparison of vital rates for advanced capitalist societies whith those of undisrupted hunter-gatherers.
Article
Full-text available
Braverman's work has been central to the return of attention to the study of the capitalist labour process . This paper focusses on his major theme, and rejects as inadequate both his analysis of capital's generic impulsion to deskill and his location of the consummation of that impulsion in monopoly capitalism . Instead it argues for an historically located theoris- ation of the transformation of the labour process, which would explicitly locate that transformation in relation to phases of valorisation and accu- mulation and their contradictions . Some features of such an account are discussed, with particular reference to debate about the 'labour aristo- cracy', analyses of the role of Taylorism and contemporary discussions of automation.
Article
Full-text available
The concept of disease causation has changed twice, first from natural to social determining factors, and, second, from determination by social conditions to determination by stressful social relations. These changes roughly parallel the emergence of industrial capital and its change from a highly individualistic and competitive process to a “social” process. In this article, “epidemics” are treated as social events that occur amidst these changes in disease and the economic organization of society. Nineteenth-century epidemics occurred when business attempted to solve its economic problems by creating dramatic gaps between the social needs of an expanding labor force and available goods and services. The coincidence of periodic crises in production and in health ensured that “epidemics” would be occasions for labor to struggle against injustice, not simply sickness. And workers demonstrated a capacity for self-organization during epidemics that forced municipal authorities to reform fundamentally their organization of work, the market, and social service. After 1900, “reform” was a permanent part of capital's developmental strategy. The new “social” capitalist sought to organize work politically, far beyond the factory, and to extract “value” not from blue-collar workers alone but from all social activity. These developments reduced mortality due to infectious and childhood disease. But they also created the new epidemics of chronic stress. Despite the mystification of social etiology by medicine, the identity of the disease process with more general means of social reproduction indicates that illness is now “endopolic,” the product not of nature but of historically specific political and economic decisions and processes.
Article
Full-text available
This paper discusses the medical profession's underlying motivations in initiating recent changes in medical education in the United States. The first part briefly examines the transition from a holistic to a scientific theory and practice in American medicine. The second part of the paper analyzes and interprets the increasing incorporation of behavioral scientists into medical education in recent decades. A review of the debate on reforms in medical education, appearing in The Journal of the American Medical Association since the 1940s, indicates that the primary function of these behavioral scientists is to provide future physicians with techniques for managing problems in the physician-patient relationship. The concluding interpretation is that behavioral science expertise is actually used to strengthen and legitimize the traditional status of the medical profession in the existing structure of health care delivery.
Article
Full-text available
This version (one of three), published in the Review of Radical Political Economics, 1977, pp.81-103, contains an appendix where I first laid out, in print, my "circuit of the reproduction of labor power", a theoretical innovation designed to situate investment in public health into Marx's analysis of the reproduction of capital and to complement his three circuits spelled out in the first section of Volume II of Capital. A more general application of this circuit was presented in chapter 3 of my book Reading Capital Politically published a year later.
Article
Women have always been healers. They were the unlicensed doctors and anatomists of Western history. They were abortionists, nurses, and counsellors. They were pharmacists, cultivating healing herbs and exchanging the secrets of their uses. They were midwives, travelling from home to home and village to village. For centuries women were doctors without degrees, barred from books and lectures, learning from each other, and passing on experience from neighbor to neighbor and mother to daughter. They were called "wise women" by the people, witches or charlatans by the authorities. Medicine is part of our heritage as women, our history. This article can also be found at the Monthly Review website , where most recent articles are published in full. Click here to purchase a PDF version of this article at the Monthly Review website.
Article
This paper is informed by the recent attempts to construct Marxist views of nature, by the lively historical work on 19th-century British class structure, and by the dedicated work of feminist historians of medicine. Using the common disease of adolescent girls, chlorosis, as an example of a real "physical" illness, I shall argue that disease is, in part, socially constructed. Not only is the social class of both doctor and patient an important determinant in the perception of illness, but so too is the relationship between the disease and the mode of production. Both the "existence" of chlorosis and the way it was understood served ideologically to conceal the growing importance of adolescent labor and the recognition of the social genesis of illness. In doing so, chlorosis was similar to other forms of chronic illness. In a time when the conditions of work were strikingly insalubrious, the etiological emphasis was on individual failure, not on physical or social conditions of work. I argue that notions of health and disease partake of the struggles and social relations of the society that sustains them, but in a way which hides that very social nature. In this sense, they are like Marx's concept of a commodity--and in being a commodity, diseases appear not to embody social relations, but rather to be part of nature. I suggest that we see this "nature" in part as a commodity fetish--something we construct as "other" for a reason--and that we rediscover the social in the natural.
Article
This book first took shape in my mind as little more than a study of occupational shifts in the United States. I was interested in the structure of the working class, and the manner in which it had changed. That portion of the population employed in manufacturing and associated industries—the so-called industrial working class—had apparently been shrinking for some time, if not in absolute numbers at any rate in relative terms. Since the details of this process, especially its historical turning points and the shape of the new employment that was taking the place of the old, were not clear to me, I undertook to find out more about them. And since, as I soon discovered, these things had not yet been clarified in any comprehensive fashion, I decided that there was a need for a more substantial historical description and analysis of the process of occupational change than had yet been presented in print. This article can also be found at the Monthly Review website, where most recent articles are published in full. Click here to purchase a PDF version of this article at the Monthly Review website.
Article
The total death rate for 15–24-yr-olds in the U.S. rose by a fifth during the 1960s. The rise was due to a doubling of suicide and homicide and increases of a third in fatal motor vehicle and other accidents (Fig. 1).A major cause of the rise in suicide was an increase in potentially overwhelming life problems, including increased divorce among parents, increased alcohol consumption and attendant family problems, increased illegitimate pregnancy and a relative decline in income for young people as compared to their parents (Figs. 2 and 3). Also contributing to the rise in suicide was a trend toward greater social isolation due to increased parental divorce and decreased marriage among young adults.Almost half the increase in homicide was due to an increase in homicides arising from “impulsive rage” during arguments between acquaintances. This trend presumably reflects an increase in underlying tensions as well as reduced impulse control due to increased alcohol consumption per capita. The other major component of the rise in homicide was an increase in homicides committed while attempting another felony, which may be related to the general decline during the sixties in confidence in and respect for societal institutions.The rise in fatal motor vehicle accidents was due in large part to the increase in mileage driven per capita, the increase in alcohol consumption and increased suicidal behavior. The most rapidly rising category of fatal other accidents was solid and liquid poisonings, particularly opiate poisoning.In order to study the stresses on young people in greater depth, we obtained diaries from college students. The most commonly reported sources of tension were all related to academic work (Fig. 4). Much of the tension associated with academic work was due to the students' fear of failure in the increasing competition for the most desirable careers. Higher levels of tension were correlated with minor somatic symptoms, which may well be precursors of more serious somatic illness at older ages.Taken together, these trends imply a deterioration in conditions of life with serious implications for the health of young adults in the U.S.
Article
Marxist studies of medical care emphasize political power and economic dominance in capitalist society. Although historically the Marxist paradigm went into eclipse during the early twentieth century, the field has developed rapidly during recent years. The health system mirrors the society's class structure through control over health institutions, stratification of health workers, and limited occupational mobility into health professions. Monopoly capital is manifest in the growth of medical centers, financial penetration by large corporations, and the "medical-industrial complex." Health policy recommendations reflect different interest groups' political and economic goals. The state's intervention in health care generally protects the capitalist economic system and the private sector. Medical ideology helps maintain class structure and patterns of domination. Comparative international research analyzes the effects of imperialism, changes under socialism, and contradictions of health reform in capitalist societies. Historical materialist epidemiology focuses on economic cycles, social stress, illness-generating conditions of work, and sexism. Health praxis, the disciplined uniting of study and action, involves advocacy of "nonreformist reforms" and concrete types of political struggle.
Article
A theory of the response to chronic intermittent stress, intergating many diverse studies, is presented. Chronic intermittent stress is presumed to be the type of stress most frequently encountered and most likely to cause physiological changes which predispose an organism to tissue damage. The theory states that all organisms are genetically predisposed to adapt to stress and that the physiological pattern of adaptation is similar across species. This pattern consists of a conditioned endocrine response before the stressor is presented accompanied by a decrease in arousal during the stress. These changes occur because the organism is predisposed to learn cues predictive of stress and to assess the threat potential of the stressor. This pattern is adaptive because it conserves resources and promotes homeostasis. Maladaptation is discussed in terms of failure to learn situational expectancies and appropriate responses. Implications of this theoretical perspective are examined.
Article
This article describes the emergence of an ideology which blames the individual for her or his illness and proposes that, instead of relying on costly and inefficient medical services, the individual should take more responsibility for her or his health. At-risk behavior is seen as the problem and changing life-style, through education and/or economic sanctions, as the solution. The emergence of the ideology is explained by the contradictions arising from the threat of high medical costs, popular expectations of medicine along with political pressures for protection or extension of entitlements, and the politicization of environmental and occupational health issues. These contradictions produce a crisis which is at once economic, political and ideological, and which requires responses to destabilizing conditions in each of these spheres. These ideological initiatives, on the one hand, serve to reorder expectations and to justify the retrenchment from rights and entitlements for access to medical services, and, on the other, attempt to divert attention from the social causation of disease in the commercial and industrial sectors.
Article
The purpose of this study is to translate research findings on pathological effects of unemployment and other forms of economic distress into a form that would be useful for national economic policy decisions. Economic indices considered by themselves are questionable because such data permit no inferences as to quantitive social implications. In the present report, we have brought together several of the scientific findings on the impact of economic distress in a policy relevant framework which would ultimately permit quantitive estimates of that impact on social pathology. Some success has been achieved in formulating models to explain how the various sources of national economic distress may be associated with pathology. Overall, it is evident that significant relationships exist between economic policy and measures of national well-being. This study indicates that actions which influence national economic activity-especially the unemployment rate-have a substantial bearing on physical health, mental health, and criminal aggression. To the extent, therefore, that economic policy has acted to influence economic activity, it has always been related to the nation's social health. It would appear that on a day-today basis, nearly all political and deliberate economic policy decisions which affect the national, regional, and local economic situations also are associated with many aspects of the nation's well-being. Indeed, significant amelioration of many of our basic social problems may depend, in part, on national economic policy considerations.
Article
This paper is an attempt to place the Flexner Report of 1910 in the larger perspective of dynamics of American society in the years surrounding the turn of the 19th century. It looks at medicine as an integral part of society affected by the contradictions affecting the larger society. The Flexner Report is viewed as an attempt by the capitalist class to ameliorate those contradictions affecting medicine. The events preceding the publication of the Flexner Report are described in detail, and some problems with conventional accounts of the origins of the Flexner Report are discussed. In addition, the paradigm of medicine that was institutionalized with the acceptance and implementation of the Flexnerian recommendations is discussed.
Article
This article critically assesses the ideology of industrialism in light of Ivan Illich's Medical Nemesis. The paper is divided into three sections. The first section is a description of the main features of that ideology, the most prevalent and influential one used in sociological literature to explain the state both of Western societies and of our health services. Also in this section, it is shown how these features appear in Illich's analysis of our societies, of our health services, and of the different clinical, social, and structural iatrogeneses that health services create. The second section examines the assumptions underlying Illich's analysis and discusses their validity to explain the nature and function of our Western health services and their iatrogenic effects. Where Illich's explanations are considered invalid, alternative explanations are presented. Among them, it is postulated that it is not industrialism, but the assumedly transcended category of capitalism that is the cause of the social and structural iatrogeneses. The third section discusses the political implications of Illich's analysis, in a moment when our Western societies are supposedly in crisis.
Article
About 50 per cent of people in modern societies have blood pressure sufficiently elevated to result in increased mortality. This proportion is much smaller in undisrupted societies of hunter-gatherers. In most cases the elevated blood pressure in modern societies is associated with physiological changes characteristic of chronic stress. The difference between blood pressure in modern populations and that in undisrupted hunter-gatherer societies cannot be accounted for by genetic differences or differences in salt consumption. Two primary features of modern society which contribute to the elevation of blood pressure are community disruption and increased work pressure. Drug therapy and relaxation therapies for hypertension attempt to counteract the physiological effects of social stress. However, it is more appropriate to use the occurrence of hypertension as an indicator of fundamental social problems which need to be solved.
Article
This article considers some implications of the new health consciousness and movements--holistic health and self-care--for the definition of and solution to problems related to "health." Healthism represents a particular way of viewing the health problem, and is characteristic of the new health consciousness and movements. It can best be understood as a form of medicalization, meaning that it still retains key medical notions. Like medicine, healthism situates the problem of health and disease at the level of the individual. Solutions are formulated at that level as well. To the extent that healthism shapes popular beliefs, we will continue to have a non-political, and therefore, ultimately ineffective conception and strategy of health promotion. Further, by elevating health to a super value, a metaphor for all that is good in life, healthism reinforces the privatization of the struggle for generalized well-being.
Article
The opportunity to affect significantly the consumption of cigarettes in the United States through government action appears quite limited. Fifty million Americans smoke cigarettes. The United States is a leading producer of tobacco leaf and utilizes a price support system which is designed to protect tobacco growers. The industry is profitable and politicaly well connected. Several states are important producers of tobacco while others benefit from the excise tax imposed on cigarettes. The opposition to smoking is relatively weak and divided. Nevertheless, the tobacco industry worries about the future market for cigarettes.
Article
Current medical definitions of health and disease are inadequate for an understanding of public health problems. The narrowest attribute causa tion to agents of disease (e.g., germ theory); the widest (e.g., medical ecology) take into account some social factors like behavior and culture. All focus on the individual rather than the collectivity. The evidence reviewed in this article, drawn mainly from England during the industrial revolution and the rise of capi talism, suggests that changes in health status are related to class struggle and to the international division of labor. An historical approach is adopted to expalin how health and disease came to be defined medically and why politics and economics were rejected as irrelevant to medicine. The holistic perspective of Marxism, which permits analysis of the dynamic interaction of public health, social organization, and the mode of production, is offered as the basis for a socialist alternative.
  • Epstein S. S.
Psychiatric perspectives on the abuse of women
  • E Stark
  • A Flitcraft
Mining medicine: Hewing out a historical-materialist sociology of medical knowledge (miners' nystagmus and psychosomatic aetiology)
  • K Figlio
The Effects of Health Services on Adult Male Mortality in Relation to the Effects of Social and Economic Factors. Paper delivered to the International Conference on Priorities for the Use of Resources in Medicine
  • J Powles
On the proletarian revolution and the end of political- economic society
  • M J Sklar
The politics of porn: Can feminists walk the line?
  • D English