ArticlePublisher preview available

An assessment of long-term reaction o rape

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

Examined reactions to rape by interviewing 27 female rape victims at least 1 yr after the assault and assessing their current functioning through such measures as the Beck Depression Inventory and Profile of Mood States. Victims were significantly more depressed and reported less pleasure in daily activities than 26 matched nonvictim controls. Ss who had been victims of sudden violent attacks by complete strangers showed the most severe reactions, being even more depressed, fatigued, and fearful and getting less satisfaction from activities than victims of other types of assaults. (14 ref)
Journal
of
Abnormal
Psychology
1981,
Vol.
90, No. 3,
263-266
Copyright
1981
by the
American
Psychological
Association,
Inc.
0021-843X/81
/9003-0263J00.75
Short Reports
*
An
Assessment
of
Long-Term Reaction
to
Rape
Elizabeth
M.
Ellis, Beverly
M.
Atkeson,
and
Karen
S.
Calhoun
University
of
Georgia
To
examine long-term reactions
to
rape,
27
adult women
who had
been rape
victims
were interviewed
and
their current
functioning
assessed through
a
variety
of
written
measures. Victims were
significantly
more depressed
and
reported less
pleasure
in
daily
activities than matched
nonvictim
controls. Women
who had
been victims
of
sudden violent attacks
by
complete strangers showed
the
most
severe
reactions,
being even more
depressed,
fatigued,
and
fearful,
and
getting
less satisfaction
from
activities than victims
of
other types
of
assaults.
Interest
in the
psychological adjustment
of
rape
victims
has
been spurred
in the
past decade
by
several
reports,
most
of
them
based
on
interviews
with
victims (Burgess
&
Holmstrom, 1974; Not-
man
&
Nadelson, 1976; Sutherland
&
Scherl,
1970).
A
general pattern
of
reactions occurring
in
the
months
following
the
assult
has
been iden-
tified
and
labeled
"rape
trauma syndrome" (Bur-
gess
&
Holmstrom, 1974). More recent studies
have begun
to
systematically examine specific ele-
ments
of
these reactions
and
changes over time.
Kilpatrick,
Veronen,
and
Resick (1979)
found
that
6
months
following
the
assault, victims were
still
reporting increased fears, especially those
re-
lated
to
attack vulnerability cues.
Feldman-Sum-
mers,
Gordon,
and
Meagher
(1979)
found
de-
creases
in
sexual activity immediately following
the
assault
and
long-term effects
on
sexual sat-
isfaction.
However, knowledge about
the
longer-
term
effects
of
rape
are
still quite limited
and
short-
and
long-term effects
are
often
confounded
in
rape reaction studies
(Queen's
Bench Foun-
dation, 1976).
The
present
study examined long-term effects
of
rape
in
victims
who had
been assaulted
at
least
1
year previously. Empirically derived measures
were
selected
to
assess
both intra-
and
interper-
sonal
functioning
of
victims. Interview questions
were designed
to
supplement information gained
from
paper-and-pencil
measures.
A
matched group
of
nonvictims provided
a
norm against which
to
compare victims.
This
research
was
supported
by
Grant
MH29750
from
the
National Institute
of
Mental Health.
Requests
for
reprints should
be
addressed
to
Elizabeth
M.
Ellis, Atlanta Center
for
Psychotherapy,
174
West
Wieuca, Atlanta,
Georgia
30342.
Method
Research Participants
Twenty-seven
victims
from
the
metropolitan
Atlanta area
who had
been raped
at
least
1
year
previously
(M = 3
years,
range
=1-16
years)
participated.
At the
time
of the
interview,
92%
were
in
their
20s or
30s.
The
majority
(59%) were
middle
class (Myers
&
Bean, 1968),
and 93%
were
white. They learned
of the
study through
newspaper
ads, rape crisis center counselors,
or
public
speaking
by the
research
staff.
A
control
group
of 26
women
who
matched
the
victims
on
age, race, socioeconomic level,
and
marital status
were recruited through bulletins posted
at a
YWCA
and
human service agencies.
The
study
was
described
as an
investigation
of
stresses
in
women's lives.
Procedure
After
giving written
informed
consent,
all
par-
ticipants
were given
the
Beck
Depression
Inven-
tory
(BDI;
Beck, Ward, Mendelson, Mock,
&
Erbaugh, 1961),
the
Profile
of
Mood
States
(POMS;
McNair, Lorr,
&
Droppleman, 1971),
the
short
form
of the
Pleasant Events Schedule
(PES; MacPhillamy
&
Lewinsohn, 1976),
the
Social
Adjustment
Scale-Self
Report Form
(SAS-
SR;
Weissman
&
Bothwell, 1976),
and the
Mod-
ified
Fear
Survey (MFS; Veronen
&
Kilpatrick,
1980)
which
is
based
on
Wolpe
and
Lang's
(1964)
scale, with
the
addition
of 42
items relating
to
rape
and
violence.
Participants were then given
a
semistructured
interview
concerning history
and
current
func-
tioning
in the
following
areas:
work, interpersonal
263
... Sexual abuse can often exert long-standing, deleterious changes in individual functioning. Individuals who experience sexual abuse tend to exhibit symptoms of depression, anxiety and posttraumatic stress (Atkeson, Calhoun, Resick, & Ellis, 1982;Boudreaux, Kilpatrick, Resnick, Best, &Saunders, 1998;Ellis, Atkeson &Calhoun, 1981;Kilpatrick, Resick, & Veronen, 1981;Santiago, McCall-Perez, Gorcey, & Beigel, 1985) and mood disorders (Boudreaux et al., 1998). Livingston (1987), Mc-Clellan et al., (1995) & Wells, McCann, Adams, Voris & Ensign, (1995 added that these individuals suffer poor self-esteem, suicidal ideation and attempts, nightmares and sleep disturbances, somatic complaints, and feelings of isolation. ...
Article
Full-text available
Sexual abuse is usually accompanied by some problems. In a bid to cope with these problems, victims adopt some strategies which may not have been effective at tackling the problems associated with sexual abuse. Therefore, this study investigated the coping strategies adopted by sexually abused victims in Anambra state with a view of assessing the effectiveness of these strategies. The study formulated three research questions and reviewed literature on sexual abuse. the study anchored on trait theory as propounded by Gordon Allport because, it effectively explains the adoption and effectiveness of a coping strategy for sexually abused victims. The study adopted a qualitative research design because; qualitative method of data collection technique and data analysis was adopted in this study. Data was derived through Key Persons Interview (KPI) and secondary sources of data collection technique. 6 males and 6 females; from different religious, ethnic, educational and occupational background who are resident in Anambra state and have been sexually abused in one way or the other were selected for this study using a snowball sampling technique. The data derived from the study was analysed using an ethnographic summary and verbatim quotation for better comprehension. Findings revealed that sexually abused victims suffer physically and emotionally. It was also reviewed that, while some of the victims relied on time to heal their wound, some others reported to their parents, while others found solace in participating in church activities. However, none of these strategies was an effective coping strategy. It was recommended that, parents build a friendly relationship with their children. Also, government and non-government organization (NGOs) to establish a formal body or agency that will provide social support for sexually abused victims.
... ‫האונס‬ ‫מקורבנות‬ (Kilpatrick et al., 1985) . ‫המיני‬ ‫בתפקוד‬ ‫פגיעה‬ ‫לגבי‬ , ‫האונס‬ ‫לאחר‬ ‫מייד‬ , ‫מין‬ ‫מיחסי‬ ‫הימנעות‬ ‫ובעיקר‬ , ‫מין‬ ‫יחסי‬ ‫מקיום‬ ‫והימנעות‬ ‫קשיים‬ ‫על‬ ‫דווחו‬ ‫אונס‬ ‫קורבנות‬ ‫מין‬ ‫מיחסי‬ ‫ופחד‬ ) (Ellis, Atkeson & Calhoun, 1981 . ‫גב‬ ‫רמות‬ ‫בעקביות‬ ‫מראות‬ ‫אונס‬ ‫שקורבנות‬ ‫כך‬ ‫על‬ ‫מצביעים‬ ‫מחקרים‬ ‫וחרדה‬ ‫פחד‬ ‫של‬ ‫והות‬ , ‫אונס‬ ‫מקרה‬ ‫אחרי‬ ‫שנים‬ ‫עשרה‬ ‫שבע‬ ‫עד‬ ‫אפילו‬ Hanson, 1990 (Gordon & Riger, 1989;Warr, 1985 (et al., 1994 , ‫טראומטיים‬ ‫שלאירועים‬ ‫וכן‬ ) ‫מיני‬ ‫אופי‬ ‫בעלי‬ ‫אירועים‬ ‫דווקא‬ ‫לאו‬ ( ‫השפעה‬ ‫יש‬ ‫מצטברת‬ (Norris, 1992) , ‫על‬ ‫חזרה‬ ‫מפני‬ ‫פחד‬ ‫ותחושת‬ ‫האישי‬ ‫הביטחון‬ ‫ערעור‬ ‫משום‬ ‫בה‬ ‫שיש‬ ‫הטראומה‬ ) Herman, 1993 .( ...
... Globalement la plupart des é tudes ne rapportent pas de pré valence supé rieure en termes de symptomatologie post-viol par un agresseur é tranger ou connu [14,34,61], même si certaines montrent une diffé rence en termes de ESPT (É tat de Stress Post-Traumatique) complet. Ainsi de maniè re contradictoire, Bownes et al. [8] et Ullman et al. [60] parlent des pré valences plus fortes en cas de viol par un é tranger, ce qui pourrait s'expliquer par des agressions gé né ralement plus violentes [22] mais é galement par un danger vital perçu comme plus important que dans les agressions par une connaissance. À l'inverse, Lawyer et al. [35] trouvent des symptomatologies plus marqué es aprè s un viol dont l'agresseur est une connaissance. ...
Article
Résumé Cet article interroge les notions de viols prototypiques et non prototypiques¹, en replaçant dans une perspective de psychologie interculturelle (historique, sociale et culturelle) la question des violences sexuelles sur les femmes. Les recherches sur cette question sont rares, voire inexistantes dans le contexte francophone interrogeant généralement la perception d’un observateur extérieur sur un scénario prototypique ou non et questionnant ainsi la perception sociale de l’agression. D’autres questionnent l’adhésion aux mythes concernant le viol par les agresseurs, venant poser la question des « viols non intentionnels », mais très peu nombreuses sont celles s’intéressant à l’impact de la non-prototypicité d’un viol sur les victimes, le développement d’un syndrome psychotraumatique. L’objectif ici est de faire un état des lieux de la question et de montrer en quoi celle-ci peut intéresser la recherche dans le domaine de la psychologie psychotraumatique afin d’améliorer les prises en charge, mais aussi de mettre en avant l’importance de la prévention dans la psychologie de la santé et de l’éducation.
... In most cases of child sexual abuse, the offender is recognized by the victim [32]. In some of the studies performed, it has been reported that the aggressor's being a foreigner does not cause any difference in terms of rape-related mental findings, and in others increases in the frequency of PTSD and depression [21,[33][34][35][36]. ...
Article
Full-text available
In the study; it is aimed to examine the personal, environmental, and incident factors that may affect the mental health of the victims of sexual abuse and to discuss the data in the light of the literature. Total 449 (8.7%) cases that were sent with a history of sexual abuse in 5157 cases, which were reported between 2005 and 2012 in the Department of Forensic Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Duzce University, were examined. Among these cases, 68 (15.1%) cases, which were judged to have committed sexual abuse, were included in the study. Of the cases, 44 (64.7%) were female and 24 (35.3%) were male. In their second mental examination, which was made six months after the date of the incident; there were no psychiatric pictures in 43 (63.2%) cases, Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) in 14 (20.6%) cases, depression in three (4.4%) cases, PTSD in three (4.4%) cases, and depression, anxiety disorder in one (1.5%) case, depression, and anxiety disorder in one (1.5%) case. Three (4.4%) cases were referred to another center without a diagnosis. The risk of being affected of mental health in the late period was found increased by 11.32 times in the cases which have psychiatric findings during the first examination, by 12.52 times if the action took place in the form of anal penetration, by 6.9 times if deprived of liberty and by 15.88 times if the attacker was a foreigner. Long-term follow-up of victims of sexual abuse by the psychiatry clinic is important in terms of continuing their normal social life as healthy individuals. [Med-Science 2020; 9(3.000): 766-73]
... Analysis reveals that the effect of workplace violence in the study area did not save any baseline variable, such as ages, ethnicity, religious, educational level, marital status, types of occupation, level of income, and years of experiences. NSVRC (2015) and Ellis et al. (1981) supported the current finding on the ground that workplace violence happens to people of all ages, races, genders, sexual orientations, religions, professions, incomes, and ethnicities. Note. ...
Article
Full-text available
Workplace violence is a serious public problem affecting millions of women employees each year throughout the world. Researchers have established the prevalence, nature, and the degree of this violence; however, less is known about the effect of workplace violence on women's psycho social functioning. This research addresses this knowledge gap by examining (a) the relationship between demographics variables and workplace violence, (b) the association between sociodemographic variable and emotional labor, and (c) the effects of workplace violence on emotional demand and social relation. This research draws on a sample of women (n = 201) from Dabat district's civil service sectors, derived using systematic and proportionally stratified simple random sampling techniques. Data were analyzed using univariate analysis, post hoc Dunnett test, and binary logistic regression. Results show that workplace violence affected women employees without the discrimination of baseline variables. However, single women (16.43 [±2.91]) who have bachelor degree and above (16.88 [±2.19]) experienced more workplace violence by managers and colleagues when compared to other sociodemographic variables. Workplace violence mostly made women employees show their emotions to customers match with what they truly feel. From respondents, unmarried women and above degree holders had more likely to show their emotions to the customers directly (unadjusted odds ratio [UOR] = 5.44, 95% confidence interval [CI] = [5.29, 6.25]; adjusted odds ratio [AOR] = 4.88, 95% CI = [4.67, 5.23]), arguably engaging in less emotional dissonance and high emotional labor. Sixty-one percent of respondents were also forced to accept others' points: ideas, concern, and feeling without believing in those views. From these findings, we argue that the workplace violence that women employees experience enables a wave of visible conflict and tension as they had reflected their internal feelings to the clients, coworkers, and managers, and if the women workers have had miscommunication with managers at workplace, it will endanger the institutions to accomplish day-today activities.
... In a study, 50% of rape victims lost their jobs or were forced to quit their jobs within a year following the incident of rape. 33 Other significant consequences reported following SHA include weight loss/gain, 34 bed wetting, 35 increase in fatigue/ decreased energy, and acting out behaviors causing physical harm. 36,37 Apart from these symptoms, problems with interpersonal relationships including ambivalence toward family members and fear of men 38 were observed. ...
Article
Full-text available
Introduction: The volcanic eruption of the #MeToo movement shows that the problem was there for long and was simmering on. The movement was initiated with the aim of knowing the magnitude of the problem and has now spread worldwide. The cases of the Me Too sexual wave are recent and have not yet attracted much scientific attention, though literature on sexual harassment is widely available and the psychological mechanisms implicated in this movement can be understood and examined through it. Objectives: This article aims to attract attention of the medical fraternity to update themselves of this issue which is essential for better understanding of the movement which has potentially good, bad, and ugly undercurrents. We will call attention to these aspects perusing the literature both at national and international levels. This would also be subjected to an analysis of the established concepts and principles of human psychology and behavior. Conclusion: It is amply clear that the time for sweeping things under the carpet is over and the catharsis that flooded the social media, print media, and TV just show how important it is to make the future workplace fair to both genders.
Article
Full-text available
This questionnaire study of rape victims' reactions, causal attributions for the rape, coping behaviors after the rape, and psychological adjustment to the rape were examined. As in previous research, high levels of behavioral and characterological self-blame for rape were found. Contrary to prior hypotheses, behavioral self-blame was not associated with good adjustment. Rather, both behavioral and characterological self-blame were associated with poor adjustment. Societal blame was the only causal attribution for rape that was unassociated with adjustment. Remaining at home and withdrawing from others were both associated with poor adjustment, and the use of stress reduction techniques was associated with good adjustment. The implications of the results for theories of victimization and for clinical interventions with rape victims are discussed.
Article
Sexual assault is one of the most challenging experiences to manage since it can have devastating effects on the individual's mental and physical health, and can cause many psychological problems, especially PTSD and depression. In this study, a psychotherapy process based on the schema therapy model was conducted with six women who were sexually assaulted in Turkey, and the psychotherapeutic change process was examined with both qualitative and quantitative methods. According to the descriptive results from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder Symptoms Scale‐Self‐Report (PSS‐SR), Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) and Symptom Check list‐90 (SCL‐90), the scores in the post‐test and follow‐up stages decreased compared to the pre‐test stage, and this decrease also had clinical significance for PSS‐SR both at post‐test (p < .05, .01 and .001 for each participant) and at follow‐up (p < .01 and .001 for each participant) stages. From the results of the narrative analysis, on the other hand, it was concluded that the psychotherapy process was completed in three stages (the introduction, the body, the conclusion); the participants conveyed the stories of some schema modes (the abused child, the punitive parent, the demanding parent, the angry‐protector, the avoidant and detached protector); and an important transitional stage was experienced (meeting the psychological needs, self‐awareness, self‐acceptance, self‐control and healthy boundaries, confrontation and normalisation) during the transformation of these stories into healthy adults. It is recommended that this discovered transitional stage is investigated in further schema therapy research. All findings are discussed in detail and a brief intervention protocol based on the schema therapy model is proposed.
Article
This article has discussed the most common sequelae of victimization with regard to incest, rape, and battering. Although legislators and law-enforcement officials have traditionally been viewed as having primary responsibility for the prevention and control of violence, it is now known that physicians must also act in this regard. Their action is especially required with regard to victim assessment and treatment. Physicians serve as the entry points not only to the health care system, but also to other resources for victims of violence. By identifying their victimized patients and by understanding the antecedents of their patients’ symptoms, physicians can go much further in meeting their patients’ needs for physical, mental, and social well-being. Given the scope and impact of violence, physicians have a moral and ethical obligation to inquire about the possibility of current violence, past violence, or both in their patients’ lives.
Chapter
The impact of crime on the individual victim is profound but is frequently underestimated by mental health professionals. Wide-ranging personal, social, and economic consequences could be prevented if a range of appropriate interventions were available. Most post traumatic stress treatment programmes in the United Kingdom have developed in response to specific disasters, which may not be relevant to or as effective with crime victims. In order to provide appropriate treatment to crime victims, mental health professionals need to recognize the importance of active interagency liaison with the police, the courts and with voluntary organizations such as victim support schemes. Crime victims tend to be relatively invisible and disempowered; they are less likely to be supported by active campaigning groups than survivors of major disasters and, because of associated feelings of shame and stigmatization, they may be reluctant to claim their entitlement to proper care and treatment. The fact that their plight is often used as a political football is likely to reinforce feelings of helplessness and insecurity. Given its prevalence, crime represents both an ordinary and an extraordinary event; it is likely to affect everyone at some point in their lives and the fact that most crime victims recover from the experience should not deprive those who need it, to proper care.
Article
Full-text available
In order to test a social learning theory model which states that fear and anxiety responses are classically conditioned by a terror-inducing rape experience, 46 recent rape victims and 35 nonvictims matched for age, race, and neighborhood of residence were assessed with the 120-item Modified Fear Survey at four postrape intervals: (1) 6–10 days, (2) 1 month, (3) 3 months, and (4) 6 months. Victims were significantly more fearful than nonvictims, and victim fears declined somewhat over time but remained at high levels at the 6-month postrape period. Content analysis of highly feared situations revealed that most fears were rape related in that they were rape cues, rape-precipitated concerns, and/or cues signaling vulnerability to subsequent attack. Patterns of fear appeared to change such that attack vulnerability cues were most feared.
Article
Full-text available
• Current emphasis on early case finding, outpatient care, and on longitudinal studies of asymptomatic patients has focused attention on the community adjustment of psychiatric patients. Thus, simple and inexpensive methods such as self-report scales, which allow the routine assessment of patient adjustment, are potentially useful. The derivation and testing of such a method, the Social Adjustment Scale Self-Report, is described. This scale covers the patient's role performance, interpersonal relationships, friction, feelings and satisfaction in work, and social and leisure activities with the extended family, as a spouse, parent, and member of a family unit. Self-report results based on 76 depressed outpatients were comparable to those obtained from relatives as well as by a rater who interviewed the patient directly.
Article
Full-text available
Thirteen young victims of rape were seen, in most instances within 48 hours, .by a mental health team. Followup of each revealed a similar sequence of reactions, falling in three distinct phases. Understanding of this pattern permits the design of supportive mental health intervention. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2013 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
To test the hypothesis that rape victim fears are classically conditioned (i.e., present during or subsequent to the assault), 20 rape victims and 12 nonvictims completed a Modified Fear Survey which contained standard items from the Wolpe and Lang fear survey as well as items originating from victim reports of fearful situations. The survey was scored for rape fears and total fears. No difference was found between groups on mean rape fears or total fears. However, a significantly greater variance of rape fear scores was observed for victims. Subsequent analyses of items rated as extremely fear-provoking revealed differences between victims and nonvictims. Items and situations rated as most disturbing for rape victims support the hypothesis that victims are significantly disturbed by rape-related situations and associations. Content analysis of highly ranked items suggests that the violent, rather than sexual, aspects of the assaults are most fear-engendering.
Article
Rape challenges a woman's ability to maintain her defenses and thus arouses feelings of guilt, anxiety, and inadequacy. Women's individual responses are determined by life stage considerations as well as their defensive structures: concerns about separation-individuation may be aroused in the young woman; a divorced or separated woman may find her credibility questioned; older women's fears of sexual inadequacy may be compounded. In counseling, the victim's previous adjustment should be assessed, she should be given support and reassurance, and specific considerations related to her life circumstances should be acknowledged and dealt with.
Article
The authors interviewed and followed 146 patients admitted during a one yr period to the emergency ward of a city hospital with a presenting complaint of having been raped. Based upon an analysis of the 92 adult women rape victims in the sample, they document the existence of a rape trauma syndrome and delineate its symptomatology as well as that of two variations, compounded reaction and silent reaction. Specific therapeutic techniques are required for each of these 3 reactions. Crisis intervention counseling is effective with typical rape trauma syndrome; additional professional help is needed in the case of compounded reaction; and the silent rape reaction means that the clinician must be alert to indications of the possibility of rape having occurred even when the patient never mentions such an attack.