ArticlePublisher preview available

An assessment of long-term reaction o rape

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

Examined reactions to rape by interviewing 27 female rape victims at least 1 yr after the assault and assessing their current functioning through such measures as the Beck Depression Inventory and Profile of Mood States. Victims were significantly more depressed and reported less pleasure in daily activities than 26 matched nonvictim controls. Ss who had been victims of sudden violent attacks by complete strangers showed the most severe reactions, being even more depressed, fatigued, and fearful and getting less satisfaction from activities than victims of other types of assaults. (14 ref)
Journal
of
Abnormal
Psychology
1981,
Vol.
90, No. 3,
263-266
Copyright
1981
by the
American
Psychological
Association,
Inc.
0021-843X/81
/9003-0263J00.75
Short Reports
*
An
Assessment
of
Long-Term Reaction
to
Rape
Elizabeth
M.
Ellis, Beverly
M.
Atkeson,
and
Karen
S.
Calhoun
University
of
Georgia
To
examine long-term reactions
to
rape,
27
adult women
who had
been rape
victims
were interviewed
and
their current
functioning
assessed through
a
variety
of
written
measures. Victims were
significantly
more depressed
and
reported less
pleasure
in
daily
activities than matched
nonvictim
controls. Women
who had
been victims
of
sudden violent attacks
by
complete strangers showed
the
most
severe
reactions,
being even more
depressed,
fatigued,
and
fearful,
and
getting
less satisfaction
from
activities than victims
of
other types
of
assaults.
Interest
in the
psychological adjustment
of
rape
victims
has
been spurred
in the
past decade
by
several
reports,
most
of
them
based
on
interviews
with
victims (Burgess
&
Holmstrom, 1974; Not-
man
&
Nadelson, 1976; Sutherland
&
Scherl,
1970).
A
general pattern
of
reactions occurring
in
the
months
following
the
assult
has
been iden-
tified
and
labeled
"rape
trauma syndrome" (Bur-
gess
&
Holmstrom, 1974). More recent studies
have begun
to
systematically examine specific ele-
ments
of
these reactions
and
changes over time.
Kilpatrick,
Veronen,
and
Resick (1979)
found
that
6
months
following
the
assault, victims were
still
reporting increased fears, especially those
re-
lated
to
attack vulnerability cues.
Feldman-Sum-
mers,
Gordon,
and
Meagher
(1979)
found
de-
creases
in
sexual activity immediately following
the
assault
and
long-term effects
on
sexual sat-
isfaction.
However, knowledge about
the
longer-
term
effects
of
rape
are
still quite limited
and
short-
and
long-term effects
are
often
confounded
in
rape reaction studies
(Queen's
Bench Foun-
dation, 1976).
The
present
study examined long-term effects
of
rape
in
victims
who had
been assaulted
at
least
1
year previously. Empirically derived measures
were
selected
to
assess
both intra-
and
interper-
sonal
functioning
of
victims. Interview questions
were designed
to
supplement information gained
from
paper-and-pencil
measures.
A
matched group
of
nonvictims provided
a
norm against which
to
compare victims.
This
research
was
supported
by
Grant
MH29750
from
the
National Institute
of
Mental Health.
Requests
for
reprints should
be
addressed
to
Elizabeth
M.
Ellis, Atlanta Center
for
Psychotherapy,
174
West
Wieuca, Atlanta,
Georgia
30342.
Method
Research Participants
Twenty-seven
victims
from
the
metropolitan
Atlanta area
who had
been raped
at
least
1
year
previously
(M = 3
years,
range
=1-16
years)
participated.
At the
time
of the
interview,
92%
were
in
their
20s or
30s.
The
majority
(59%) were
middle
class (Myers
&
Bean, 1968),
and 93%
were
white. They learned
of the
study through
newspaper
ads, rape crisis center counselors,
or
public
speaking
by the
research
staff.
A
control
group
of 26
women
who
matched
the
victims
on
age, race, socioeconomic level,
and
marital status
were recruited through bulletins posted
at a
YWCA
and
human service agencies.
The
study
was
described
as an
investigation
of
stresses
in
women's lives.
Procedure
After
giving written
informed
consent,
all
par-
ticipants
were given
the
Beck
Depression
Inven-
tory
(BDI;
Beck, Ward, Mendelson, Mock,
&
Erbaugh, 1961),
the
Profile
of
Mood
States
(POMS;
McNair, Lorr,
&
Droppleman, 1971),
the
short
form
of the
Pleasant Events Schedule
(PES; MacPhillamy
&
Lewinsohn, 1976),
the
Social
Adjustment
Scale-Self
Report Form
(SAS-
SR;
Weissman
&
Bothwell, 1976),
and the
Mod-
ified
Fear
Survey (MFS; Veronen
&
Kilpatrick,
1980)
which
is
based
on
Wolpe
and
Lang's
(1964)
scale, with
the
addition
of 42
items relating
to
rape
and
violence.
Participants were then given
a
semistructured
interview
concerning history
and
current
func-
tioning
in the
following
areas:
work, interpersonal
263
... A. Resick, 1993). Specific mental health symptoms associated with sexual violence include anxiety (K. S. Calhoun et al., 1982;Ellis et al., 1981;Kilpatrick et al., 1981), depression Kilpatrick et al., 1979), and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD; Dworkin et al., 2023;H. S. Resick et al., 1993). ...
... Over 50% of adult women survivors report that they experience PTSD symptoms for several months after the assault, and some report that they never recovered from their experience (Campbell et al., 2009; M. P. Koss & Figueredo, 2004;Najdowski & Ullman, 2009). Long-term effects include shock, fear, trauma symptoms, anxiety, depression, diminished self-esteem, betrayed sense of self, identity and safety, social problems, sexual problems, alcohol and substance abuse, anger and hostility, fatigue, and social withdrawal (Becker et al., 1982(Becker et al., , 1986Burgess & Holmstrom, 1979;Burnam et al., 1988;Ellis et al., 1981;Herman, 1992;Kilpatrick et al., 1987; M. P. Koss, Heise, & Russo, 1994;Moor, 2007;P. A. Resick et al., 1988). ...
Article
Full-text available
Objective: The primary objective of this study was to identify healing strategies directly from women who experienced sexual assault and sexual exploitation. The second objective was to explore secondary themes related to healing from sexual assault. This study included two quantitative objectives. The first was to examine if the frequency of reported sexual assault experienced predicted greater coping strategies and if rape that occurred in juvenile years and during college uniquely predicted reported use of more coping strategies. Method: Using a mix-method design of college women who endorsed experiencing unwanted sexual contact as part of a survey, 283 provided details about healthy healing strategies. Qualitative responses were transcribed verbatim, and thematic classification followed an iterative process. Linear regressions were used to examine the relationships between sexual assault frequency and use of coping strategies. Results: The most frequently endorsed categories as being helpful to one’s healing were social support, proactive behavioral strategies, forgetting/ignoring/shifting focus, positive cognitive strategies, and counseling. Other themes related to healing included long-term effects, unsuccessful strategies, and posttraumatic growth. Secondary themes include validation, denial of/modified recognition of sexual assault, and specific campus environmental factors. Individuals who reported more sexual assault reported using more healing strategies. Conclusions: This study underscores the benefits of social support and specific strategies. Results suggest a positive relationship between the number of unwanted sexual experiences and coping strategies utilized.
... Sexual violence can devastate victims. As well as dealing with the psychological trauma of abuse (Kilpatrick et al, 1981;Briere et al, 1995;Elliott et al, 2004;Elkit and Christiensen, 2010;Stermac et al, 2014), some have to contend with injuries (Bowyer and Dalton, 2005), unwanted pregnancies (Holmes et al, 1996), sexually transmitted infections (Sena et al, 2015), sexual dysfunction (Ellis et al, 1981; Bartoi and Kinder, 1998;Feldman-Summers et al, 1979;Orlando and Koss, 1983;Becker et al, 1986;Burgess and Holstrom, 1979;Letourneau, 1996), and the inability to work (Loya, 2014). Effects can be mutually compounding. ...
... For some, negative impacts are resolved in the months following an assault, while for others they endure over the long term. Sexual dysfunction and mental health challenges -including guilt, anger, anxiety, depression, sleep disturbance and symptoms of trauma -have been found among some survivors several years following an assault (Ellis et al, 1981;Burgess and Holmstrom, 1979;Kilpatrick et al, 1981;Krug et al, 2002;Elliot et al, 2004;Stermac et al, 2014). Other key long-term impacts include repeat victimisation and the fear of it -over half of all victims have been previously sexually assaulted (ONS, 2018), with victims known to the perpetrator being at particular risk. ...
Article
Full-text available
This article outlines a feasibility study to investigate the potential of measuring the support needs of adult service users of a sexual assault referral centre (SARC). A self-completion questionnaire was designed with the aim of capturing these needs, as well as how they change over time and with support provided. The questionnaire underwent revisions following consultations with organisations representing survivors. Survivors of sexual assault who attended Saint Mary’s SARC were invited to complete a questionnaire at three-month intervals after their first visit to the SARC. The process of recruitment was necessarily complex, potentially compounding the issue of low response: only 18 participants completed the questionnaire at the first time point, and only nine of those completed a follow-up questionnaire three months later. The responses demonstrated the value of connecting information gathered by forensic physicians with a social survey. This study design reduced the potential of re-traumatisation by avoiding the need for participants to revisit any details of the alleged assault. More work is required to understand what methods will help establish an enduring commitment to completing follow-up questionnaires from a population dealing with the aftermath of trauma.
... When Ainura asked the owner to let her go, she was punished by henchmen who had mercilessly beaten the young woman and brutally had raped her [ibid., 40]. In return, Gulnara was involved in sexual activity as a prostitute against her will in Dubai and if she refused to do, she was threatening by the recruiter "Adele" to "call twenty Arabs to rape" her and she would do that job just to get them off of her"  PSYCHOLOGICAL PROBLEMS: -Most of them have psychological effects that include: Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), Low self-esteem; emotional effects include Guilt, shame, self-blame, and physical effects include: changes in eating or sleeping patterns, Concerns about physical safety [Borja, a al., 2006;Ellis, et al., 1981;Erdreich, et al., 1995]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The research paper was inspired by a true story that depends on two women who suffered from trafficking. To sum up, the paper discusses the factors and risks of trafficking, specifically women. Trafficking of women is a horrible crime; it needs to put an end to women’s suffering. Two examples of females from the book “Two Kyrgyz Women”, had been exposed to many risks. They were beaten, threatened, and raped. The aim of the paper is to discuss that if the factors that aided women to be trafficked were treated from the early beginning, there would be no trafficking women. Those factors are many such as: - cheated by promising jobs, unstable political conditions, social and cultural practices that devalue women in their society, gender roles in society that shows society prefers boys more than girls, and the misconception of social norms. But in fact, those factors are not determined and banned with the help of Kyrgyz society, on the contrary, the society itself is the main factor that encourages women to leave their country for the sake of living. On the other hand, male partner does not take any part for supporting women; this is going to be discussed and proved in the coming pages
... Sexual abuse can often exert long-standing, deleterious changes in individual functioning. Individuals who experience sexual abuse tend to exhibit symptoms of depression, anxiety and posttraumatic stress (Atkeson, Calhoun, Resick, & Ellis, 1982;Boudreaux, Kilpatrick, Resnick, Best, &Saunders, 1998;Ellis, Atkeson &Calhoun, 1981;Kilpatrick, Resick, & Veronen, 1981;Santiago, McCall-Perez, Gorcey, & Beigel, 1985) and mood disorders (Boudreaux et al., 1998). Livingston (1987), Mc-Clellan et al., (1995) & Wells, McCann, Adams, Voris & Ensign, (1995 added that these individuals suffer poor self-esteem, suicidal ideation and attempts, nightmares and sleep disturbances, somatic complaints, and feelings of isolation. ...
Article
Full-text available
Sexual abuse is usually accompanied by some problems. In a bid to cope with these problems, victims adopt some strategies which may not have been effective at tackling the problems associated with sexual abuse. Therefore, this study investigated the coping strategies adopted by sexually abused victims in Anambra state with a view of assessing the effectiveness of these strategies. The study formulated three research questions and reviewed literature on sexual abuse. the study anchored on trait theory as propounded by Gordon Allport because, it effectively explains the adoption and effectiveness of a coping strategy for sexually abused victims. The study adopted a qualitative research design because; qualitative method of data collection technique and data analysis was adopted in this study. Data was derived through Key Persons Interview (KPI) and secondary sources of data collection technique. 6 males and 6 females; from different religious, ethnic, educational and occupational background who are resident in Anambra state and have been sexually abused in one way or the other were selected for this study using a snowball sampling technique. The data derived from the study was analysed using an ethnographic summary and verbatim quotation for better comprehension. Findings revealed that sexually abused victims suffer physically and emotionally. It was also reviewed that, while some of the victims relied on time to heal their wound, some others reported to their parents, while others found solace in participating in church activities. However, none of these strategies was an effective coping strategy. It was recommended that, parents build a friendly relationship with their children. Also, government and non-government organization (NGOs) to establish a formal body or agency that will provide social support for sexually abused victims.
... They conclude that this would suggest that sexual assault is a particularly powerful driver of short-term and long-term psychopathology, in particular PTSD and depression. This was supported by Ellis et al. (1981), Kilpatrick et al. (1987) and Resick et al. (1988) who found that between a third and a half of rape survivors had contemplated suicide (Kilpatrick et al. found this to be three times the proportion of non-crime victims) and Resick et al. reported that 17% of the rape survivors in their research had attempted suicide. Also identifying the negative impact of rape, Joiner et al. (2007) and Hetke et al. (2008) concluded from their research that the combination of physical violence and physically violent sexual assault are a strong predictor of future suicide attempts. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Domestic abuse is a widespread problem that has far reaching and grave consequences. To date, very little systematic data have been gathered on the relationship between domestic abuse and victim suicide. To address this gap, we conducted three strands of research, including: 1) Rapid evidence review. The review examined the long- and short-term causes, drivers and aggravating factors of domestic abuse (e.g., physical, emotional, psychological, financial) related suicide, to deliver a strong evidence base for identifying risk factors. 2) Fieldwork. A qualitative study with domestic abuse victims was conducted to better understand the relationship between domestic abuse and risk factors for suicide. 3) Quantitative evaluation. A quantitative study of domestic abuse incidents and suicide to better understand how the incidence of suicide differs amongst the victims and perpetrators of domestic violence, and how this is correlated with its form. Based on our results, we recommend the creation and testing of an assessment tool that aims to identify the predictors of suicide by gathering information from the survivor. Administration of the tool should include gathering information from whether they have experienced life-threatening abuse; sexual assault/rape, coercion and control; multiple abuses and repetition of abuse, as well as information about their feeling states, including feelings of despair, hopelessness and burdensomeness/ isolation/self-hatred. The tool should also take into account the effects of the abuse on the survivor’s self-identity, such as the number of relationships which have been disrupted or terminated. This should also elicit information about a survivor’s perceptions of/relationship with the police (and health services) and may assist in building trust; and any previous or childhood experiences which were trauma or terror-inducing, such as, some form of abuse, disaster (e.g., house fire), accident or medical procedure. Further information should be gathered about the survivor’s coping strategies, such as whether they are using self-harm and/or alcohol and drugs to cope. We also recommend the development of guidelines for police forces and health services to introduce and maintain a domestic abuse survivor suicide prevention/welfare pathway, with local statutory and VCS partners. The framework should contain the information in this report, and any other/up-dated information about how domestic abuse dismantles the survivor’s identity and the link with suicide translated into operational understanding and practice. Additionally, we recommend that a small amount of additional funding is made available to explore the information collected in this research about the contact survivors have had with services other than the police and health services (e.g. children’s social care, schools, housing, immigration services, the Family courts and voluntary and community sector services). Moreover, more nuanced research needs to be undertaken to track the trajectory from abuse to suicidality and, in the process, to differentiate suicide ideation from suicidality. The research should incorporate evaluation of any of the above pilot activities.Finally, given that the quantitative analysis highlights the high rate of suicide amongst male perpetrators of domestic violence, further research is necessary to better understand this relationship and how it is affected by socio-economic factors, mental health, and substance abuse.
... When Ainura asked the owner to let her go, she was punished by henchmen who had mercilessly beaten the young woman and brutally had raped her [ibid., 40]. In return, Gulnara was involved in sexual activity as a prostitute against her will in Dubai and if she refused to do, she was threatening by the recruiter "Adele" to "call twenty Arabs to rape" her and she would do that job just to get them off of her"  PSYCHOLOGICAL PROBLEMS: -Most of them have psychological effects that include: Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), Low self-esteem; emotional effects include Guilt, shame, self-blame, and physical effects include: changes in eating or sleeping patterns, Concerns about physical safety [Borja, a al., 2006;Ellis, et al., 1981;Erdreich, et al., 1995]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The research paper was inspired by a true story that depends on two women who suffered from trafficking. To sum up, the paper discusses the factors and risks of trafficking, specifically women. Trafficking of women is a horrible crime; it needs to put an end to women’s suffering. Two examples of females from the book “Two Kyrgyz Women”, had been exposed to many risks. They were beaten, threatened, and raped. The aim of the paper is to discuss that if the factors that aided women to be trafficked were treated from the early beginning, there would be no trafficking women. Those factors are many such as: - cheated by promising jobs, unstable political conditions, social and cultural practices that devalue women in their society, gender roles in society that shows society prefers boys more than girls, and the misconception of social norms. But in fact, those factors are not determined and banned with the help of Kyrgyz society, on the contrary, the society itself is the main factor that encourages women to leave their country for the sake of living. On the other hand, male partner does not take any part for supporting women; this is going to be discussed and proved in the coming pages.
... ‫האונס‬ ‫מקורבנות‬ (Kilpatrick et al., 1985) . ‫המיני‬ ‫בתפקוד‬ ‫פגיעה‬ ‫לגבי‬ , ‫האונס‬ ‫לאחר‬ ‫מייד‬ , ‫מין‬ ‫מיחסי‬ ‫הימנעות‬ ‫ובעיקר‬ , ‫מין‬ ‫יחסי‬ ‫מקיום‬ ‫והימנעות‬ ‫קשיים‬ ‫על‬ ‫דווחו‬ ‫אונס‬ ‫קורבנות‬ ‫מין‬ ‫מיחסי‬ ‫ופחד‬ ) (Ellis, Atkeson & Calhoun, 1981 . ‫גב‬ ‫רמות‬ ‫בעקביות‬ ‫מראות‬ ‫אונס‬ ‫שקורבנות‬ ‫כך‬ ‫על‬ ‫מצביעים‬ ‫מחקרים‬ ‫וחרדה‬ ‫פחד‬ ‫של‬ ‫והות‬ , ‫אונס‬ ‫מקרה‬ ‫אחרי‬ ‫שנים‬ ‫עשרה‬ ‫שבע‬ ‫עד‬ ‫אפילו‬ Hanson, 1990 (Gordon & Riger, 1989;Warr, 1985 (et al., 1994 , ‫טראומטיים‬ ‫שלאירועים‬ ‫וכן‬ ) ‫מיני‬ ‫אופי‬ ‫בעלי‬ ‫אירועים‬ ‫דווקא‬ ‫לאו‬ ( ‫השפעה‬ ‫יש‬ ‫מצטברת‬ (Norris, 1992) , ‫על‬ ‫חזרה‬ ‫מפני‬ ‫פחד‬ ‫ותחושת‬ ‫האישי‬ ‫הביטחון‬ ‫ערעור‬ ‫משום‬ ‫בה‬ ‫שיש‬ ‫הטראומה‬ ) Herman, 1993 .( ...
Article
Full-text available
Scholars from various fields have suggested that criminal victimization can shatter generalized trust. Whereas small average effects in longitudinal studies provide only weak support for this claim, victimization effects may be stronger for specific crime types and multiple victimization. To test this assumption, we estimated various victimization effects by combining Energy weighting with lagged dependent variable models, using data from two-wave panel surveys conducted in 2014/2015 (cohort 1; N = 3401) and 2020/2021 (cohort 2; N = 2932) in two German cities. We found weak evidence that trust-undermining effects of victimization were more pronounced for severe crime types or multiple victimization. Effects were only stronger for violent crimes and some forms of multiple victimization in 2014/2015 but not in 2020/2021. Besides, our weighting procedure implies that our (and probably others’) findings for more intense victimization conditions must be viewed with caution, as they suffer from lower internal validity.
Article
Full-text available
This questionnaire study of rape victims' reactions, causal attributions for the rape, coping behaviors after the rape, and psychological adjustment to the rape were examined. As in previous research, high levels of behavioral and characterological self-blame for rape were found. Contrary to prior hypotheses, behavioral self-blame was not associated with good adjustment. Rather, both behavioral and characterological self-blame were associated with poor adjustment. Societal blame was the only causal attribution for rape that was unassociated with adjustment. Remaining at home and withdrawing from others were both associated with poor adjustment, and the use of stress reduction techniques was associated with good adjustment. The implications of the results for theories of victimization and for clinical interventions with rape victims are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
In order to test a social learning theory model which states that fear and anxiety responses are classically conditioned by a terror-inducing rape experience, 46 recent rape victims and 35 nonvictims matched for age, race, and neighborhood of residence were assessed with the 120-item Modified Fear Survey at four postrape intervals: (1) 6–10 days, (2) 1 month, (3) 3 months, and (4) 6 months. Victims were significantly more fearful than nonvictims, and victim fears declined somewhat over time but remained at high levels at the 6-month postrape period. Content analysis of highly feared situations revealed that most fears were rape related in that they were rape cues, rape-precipitated concerns, and/or cues signaling vulnerability to subsequent attack. Patterns of fear appeared to change such that attack vulnerability cues were most feared.
Article
Full-text available
Thirteen young victims of rape were seen, in most instances within 48 hours, .by a mental health team. Followup of each revealed a similar sequence of reactions, falling in three distinct phases. Understanding of this pattern permits the design of supportive mental health intervention. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2013 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
To test the hypothesis that rape victim fears are classically conditioned (i.e., present during or subsequent to the assault), 20 rape victims and 12 nonvictims completed a Modified Fear Survey which contained standard items from the Wolpe and Lang fear survey as well as items originating from victim reports of fearful situations. The survey was scored for rape fears and total fears. No difference was found between groups on mean rape fears or total fears. However, a significantly greater variance of rape fear scores was observed for victims. Subsequent analyses of items rated as extremely fear-provoking revealed differences between victims and nonvictims. Items and situations rated as most disturbing for rape victims support the hypothesis that victims are significantly disturbed by rape-related situations and associations. Content analysis of highly ranked items suggests that the violent, rather than sexual, aspects of the assaults are most fear-engendering.
Article
• Current emphasis on early case finding, outpatient care, and on longitudinal studies of asymptomatic patients has focused attention on the community adjustment of psychiatric patients. Thus, simple and inexpensive methods such as self-report scales, which allow the routine assessment of patient adjustment, are potentially useful. The derivation and testing of such a method, the Social Adjustment Scale Self-Report, is described. This scale covers the patient's role performance, interpersonal relationships, friction, feelings and satisfaction in work, and social and leisure activities with the extended family, as a spouse, parent, and member of a family unit. Self-report results based on 76 depressed outpatients were comparable to those obtained from relatives as well as by a rater who interviewed the patient directly.
Article
Rape challenges a woman's ability to maintain her defenses and thus arouses feelings of guilt, anxiety, and inadequacy. Women's individual responses are determined by life stage considerations as well as their defensive structures: concerns about separation-individuation may be aroused in the young woman; a divorced or separated woman may find her credibility questioned; older women's fears of sexual inadequacy may be compounded. In counseling, the victim's previous adjustment should be assessed, she should be given support and reassurance, and specific considerations related to her life circumstances should be acknowledged and dealt with.
Article
The authors interviewed and followed 146 patients admitted during a one yr period to the emergency ward of a city hospital with a presenting complaint of having been raped. Based upon an analysis of the 92 adult women rape victims in the sample, they document the existence of a rape trauma syndrome and delineate its symptomatology as well as that of two variations, compounded reaction and silent reaction. Specific therapeutic techniques are required for each of these 3 reactions. Crisis intervention counseling is effective with typical rape trauma syndrome; additional professional help is needed in the case of compounded reaction; and the silent rape reaction means that the clinician must be alert to indications of the possibility of rape having occurred even when the patient never mentions such an attack.