ArticlePublisher preview available

Children's interpersonal behaviours and teacher–child relationships

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

Relations between kindergartners' (N = 199; M age = 5 years 6 months) behavioral orientations and features of their 1st-grade teacher-child relationships (i.e., conflict, closeness, dependency) were examined longitudinally. Early behavioral orientations predicted teacher-child relationship quality in that (a) unique associations emerged between children's early antisocial behavior and features of their 1st-grade teacher-child relationships (i.e., negative relation with closeness, positive relation with conflict and dependency) and between asocial behavior and teacher-child dependency, and (b) prosocial behavior was correlated with but not uniquely related to any feature of children's 1st-grade teacher-child relationships. In addition, specific features of the teacher-child relationship (e.g., conflict) predicted changes in children's behavioral adjustment (e.g., decreasing prosocial behavior).
Developmental Psychology
1998,
Vol. 34, No. 5, 934-946Copyright 1998 by the American Psychological Association, Inc.
0012-1649/98/$;!.
(X)
Children's Interpersonal Behaviors and the Teacher-Child Relationship
Sondra H. Birch and Gary W. Ladd
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Relations between kindergartners' (N = 199; M age = 5 years 6 months) behavioral orientations
and features of their Ist-grade teacher-child relationships (i.e., conflict, closeness, dependency)
were examined longitudinally. Early behavioral orientations predicted teacher-child relationship
quality in that (a) unique associations emerged between children's early antisocial behavior and
features of their Ist-grade teacher-child relationships (i.e., negative relation with closeness, positive
relation with conflict and dependency) and between asocial behavior and teacher-child dependency,
and (b) prosocial behavior was correlated with but not uniquely related to any feature of children's
Ist-grade teacher-child relationships. In addition, specific features of the teacher-child relationship
(e.g., conflict) predicted changes in children's behavioral adjustment (e.g., decreasing prosocial
behavior).
The linkages between children's interpersonal behaviors and
their classroom relationships occupy a prominent position in
recent models of early school adjustment and have garnered
considerable empirical attention. Most of the studies conducted
in this domain have been focused on children's peer relation-
ships (i.e., ties with classmates). However, peers are not the
only persons with whom children form relationships and interact
in classrooms; the classroom teacher is also a significant figure
in the school environment. Compared to the evidence assembled
on children's relationships with classmates, far less is known
about the determinants or consequences of children's teacher-
child relationships.
Tt is likely that children's behaviors affect the relationships
that they form with teachers, and the relationships that children
form with teachers affect their subsequent behavioral adjust-
ment. These two premises are consistent with those addressed
by researchers in the field of children's peer relations and with
a growing corpus of empirical evidence in that domain (see
Asher & Coie, 1990; Berndt & Ladd, 1989; Bukowski, New-
comb,
& Hartup, 1996; Rubin & Asendorpf, 1993). Findings
show that (a) antisocial behavior is an antecedent of peer rejec-
Sondra H. Birch, Department of Educational Psychology, University
of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign; Gary W. Ladd, Department of Educa-
tional Psychology and Department of Psychology, University of Illinois
at Urbana-Champaign.
This study was supported by National Institute of Mental Health
Grants 1-RO1MH-49223 and 2-RO1MH-49223. This article was pre-
pared while Gary W. Ladd was a fellow at the Center for Advanced
Study in the Behavioral Sciences at Stanford University, with support
provided by Spencer Foundation Grant 199400132. Special appreciation
is expressed to all the children and parents who made this study possible
and to members of the Pathways Project for assistance with data
collection.
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Sondra
H. Birch or Gary W. Ladd, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign,
183 Children's Research Center, 51 Gerty Drive, Champaign, Illinois
61820. Electronic mail may be sent to g-ladd@uiuc.edu.
tion during early and middle childhood (e.g., Coie & Kuper-
smidt, 1983; Dodge, 1983; Ladd, Price, & Hart, 1988), (b)
asocial behavior forecasts peer relationship problems as children
grow older (Rubin & Asendorpf, 1993), and (c) prosocial be-
havior predicts peer acceptance (Dodge, 1983; Ladd et al.,
1988).
In addition, qualities of children's peer relationships,
such as rejection by the peer group, have been linked to later
behavioral adjustment outcomes, such as externalizing (e.g.,
antisocial, conduct problems) and internalizing (e.g., asocial,
shy-anxious behavior) problems (see DeRosier, Kupersmidt, &
Patterson, 1994; Parker & Asher, 1987).
Of the research that has been conducted on the origins and
outcomes of children's teacher-child relationships, the premise
that has received the least empirical attention is that children's
interpersonal behaviors affect the relationships that they form
with teachers. Prior research on instructional environments
(e.g., Brophy & Evertson, 1981) has shown that teachers' per-
ceptions of students' behaviors are associated with the attitudes
that teachers form toward specific children. Perhaps not surpris-
ingly, teachers tend to prefer children who exhibit cooperative,
cautious, and responsible behavior in the classroom over those
who display disruptive, assertive, and independent behaviors
(see Wentzel, 1991). In addition, Pianta and Steinberg (1992)
have shown that problem behaviors, including conduct, internal-
izing, and learning difficulties, are negatively associated with
the quality of early teacher-child relationships.'
Somewhat greater investigative attention has been focused
on the premise that the teacher-child relationship influences
children's development and adjustment. Defining the teacher-
child relationship and its features has been an essential point
of departure in this area of investigation, and researchers have
developed differing conceptual models for this purpose. Howes
and colleagues (e.g., Howes & Hamilton, 1992, 1993; Howes &
1 Whereas Pianta and Steinberg (1992) investigated conduct, internal-
izing, and learning problems, this investigation was focused on three
distinct interpersonal behavioral orientations that may characterize chil-
dren's early dispositions in the school environment.
934
This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.
... In particolare, un rapporto con l'insegnante caratterizzato da vicinanza, calore, affetto e basso livello di conflitto sembra avere un effetto positivo sullo sviluppo socio-emotivo del bambino (Cefai e Cavioni, 2014), sui suoi progressi nell'apprendimento (Downer, Rimm-Kaufman e Pianta, 2007), sul suo comportamento (Meehan, 2004), sulla relazione con i pari (Pianta, 1999, Molinari e Melotti, 2010. Al contrario, un rapporto con l'insegnante caratterizzato da conflitto e/o dipendenza è correlato negativamente con la regolazione emotiva e il comportamento (Birch e Ladd 1997, 1998; Murray e Greenberg, 2000) e con i risultati scolastici (Hamre & Pianta, 2001). ...
Article
Full-text available
Riassunto Questo studio ha lo scopo di indagare il ruolo dell'intelligenza emotiva di docenti di scuola primaria, nella qualità della relazione insegnante-studente. La novità di questo lavoro consiste nell'uso di metodologie diversificate per dare voce sia agli insegnanti sia agli alunni allo scopo di indagare il nesso tra intelligenza emotiva dei docenti e la qualità della relazione insegnante-studente. In particolare, ai docenti sono stati somministrati due questionari self report mentre con gli alunni (età media 8,67; DS=.59) è stato utilizzato lo strumento del disegno. Si tratta, in particolare, di un primo studio esplorativo condotto su un piccolo campione composto da 6 inse-gnanti di classi terze e quarte e da 79 bambini. I risultati, ottenuti dai questionari e dai disegni, mettono in evidenza che le insegnanti con livelli di EI più alti hanno anche migliori relazioni con gli studenti. Invece confrontando il punto di vista di docenti e alunni sulla loro relazione si evidenzia una correlazione moderata.
... Importantly, Henricsson and Rydell (2004) report that poor teacher-child relationships tend to be stable over time. However, when teachers respond to a child's externalizing behavior with increased support, they have the potential to disrupt this negative cycle (e.g., Baker, 2006;Birch & Ladd, 1998;Hamre & Pianta, 2001). Therefore, focusing on the teacher, child, and classroom factors that may improve relationships between teachers and children with challenging behavior is an important goal. ...
Article
Full-text available
In early care and education settings, children who display challenging behaviors tend to have higher rates of conflict with their teachers than children without such problems. This proof-of-concept study examines the extent to which early childhood teacher’s classroom management self-efficacy is associated with conflictual teacher–child relationships with children who have been screened for and exhibit elevated levels of externalizing behaviors (i.e., focal children). In addition, we examine whether this association varies by a child’s ordinal level of challenging behavior relative to their classroom peers who also exhibit elevated levels of challenging behaviors. This study included 312 focal children (66% male), identified as at risk of Emotional and Behavioral Disorders (EBD), and 125 classrooms in which teachers completed surveys to assess teacher–child conflict, classroom management self-efficacy, and child challenging behavior. Findings revealed that in classrooms with three focal children, a disordinal interaction was present. The relation between teacher self-efficacy and teacher–child conflict differed as a function of child ordinal behavior rank. We conclude with a discussion of the implications of this work for research and practice.
... Time constraints could make it difficult for teachers to get to know their students personally and meet each student's specific requirements. Building strong connections might be difficult in classes with different students due to linguistic and cultural obstacles [32]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The relationship between teachers and students has been a topic of interest for educators, researchers, and policymakers worldwide. This critical study aims to delve into the impact of teacher-student relationships on academic success. By delving into existing literature and conducting a comprehensive analysis, this study investigates the crucial role that relationships play in shaping students' educational outcomes. The study examines various components of teacher-student relationships, including trust, communication, support, and engagement, and their contribution to academic achievement.
... Il primo artefice per operare un cambio di prospettiva è certamente il docente specializzato che, opportunamente formato e competente, deve diventare il regista di questo cambiamento (Ianes, 2023), in quanto gli studenti con ADHD che hanno un basso rendimento scolastico e vivono con grande difficoltà, il tempo trascorso a scuola, devono essere sostenuti da un docente che, comprendendo la loro unicità, sappia sviluppare programmi di apprendimento ad hoc per loro. I docenti curricolari spesso lamentano l'iperattività degli studenti insieme alla disattenzione, come gli atteggiamenti più problematici da riuscire a gestire; dalle ricerche compiute si evidenzia come i docenti sperimentino una maggiore conflittualità e una minore vicinanza con gli studenti iperattivi e disattenti, rispetto a coloro che non mostrano tale comportamento (Birch & Ladd, 1998;Kapalka, 2008). Del resto, tali comportamenti generano negli insegnanti delle emozioni negative che spesso sfociano in sanzioni disciplinari (Nurmi, 2012), anche se è stato dimostrato come le azioni punitive, le critiche severe, le sanzioni comportamentali e le ammonizioni verbali adottate per riuscire a gestire il comportamento delle studentesse e degli studenti risultino spesso inefficaci, in generale (Hattie, 2009) e in particolare per le studentesse e gli studenti con ADHD (Kapalka, 2008). ...
Article
Full-text available
For students with ADHD (Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder) it is essential that the choices and teaching actions made by teachers (both class teacher and support teacher) are oriented towards an educational project aimed at synergistically developing their processes. cognitive, emotional, social-relational and motivational. The contribution intends to present a theoretical reflection on the importance of training “future” support teachers, didactic mediation figures within class councils, in the planning and management of inclusive teaching for students with ADHD, through courses to obtain specialization for support activities (Ministerial Decree 30 September 2011). The theoretical reflections and research conducted regarding the training of support teachers recognize the need to be able to identify adequate methodological approaches aimed at promoting consciously inclusive learning processes, which allow the school to be a welcoming environment for each and every one of them, directing our gaze towards what gives shape to true inclusion at school.
... Contradictory teacher-student relationships can lead to negative classroom environments, increased truancy, negative attitudes towards school and decreased trust and teamwork among students. High levels of conflict in teacher-student relationships have been found to correlate with decreased prosocial behavior and increased problem and aggressive behaviors in children (Birch & Ladd, 1998). ...
Article
Full-text available
This study examines the self-perceptions of Indonesian primary education teachers as transformational leaders. A quantitative survey was conducted with 400 randomly selected teachers from Lampung Province, Indonesia to assess their transformational leadership (TL) practices using the Transformational Teaching Questionnaire (TTQ) adapted and validated for use in the Indonesian context. The instrument's reliability and validity were confirmed ensuring its robustness. This study found that 15 out of 16 items demonstrated strong factor loadings indicating good construct validity while one item was excluded due to low factor loading. Overall, teachers rated themselves highly on TL scales emphasizing the importance of respect and adherence to cultural norms within their educational practices. These results highlight the potential of TL in improving student outcomes and fostering school improvement. Promoting TL among teachers can create a more effective teaching environment positively impacting student success and overall school quality. The study also emphasizes the need for continuous professional development in TL for teachers. The study supports the integration of TL training in teacher development programs highlighting its relevance to educational policy and practice. Future research should include diverse educational contexts employ longitudinal designs to observe changes over time and incorporate multiple data sources to enhance the robustness of findings.
... Healthy TSRs have been associated with a wide variety of positive outcomes in previous studies (Hamre et al., 2013). Rudasill (2010) found associations between positive TSRs and prosocial behavior at school, and other researchers have used TSRs to predict academic performance (Birch & Ladd, 1998;Hamre & Pianta, 2001). Some studies have attempted to identify predictors that would positively impact TSRs (Cook et al., 2017;Driscoll & Pianta, 2010;Gehlbach et al., 2016), however, more research should be done to develop a better understanding of these factors. ...
Research
Full-text available
This study is motivated by the primary research question, "Is Project Lead the Way (PLTW) instruction associated with elementary teachers' perceptions of their relationships with students and how?" Previous research has attempted to identify predictors that would positively impact teacher-student relationships (TSRs), however few studies have sought to understand associations between TSRs and instructional styles. The purpose of this mixed methods sequential explanatory study was to explore associations between the teacher participants' perceptions of their TSRs and their use of the PLTW curriculum. The two-phase investigation obtained quantitative results from a 19-item online survey of 83 elementary teachers in a public school district and then followed up with interviews of nine purposefully selected individuals. A mixed regression analysis of the quantitative data from the present study found that teachers from the PLTW-trained group had significantly lower STRS-SF scores (B =-2.713, β =-.287, t =-2.625, p < .05). The equation explained about 14 percent of the variance in STRS-SF scores (R 2 = .139, Adj. R 2 = .095). Two meta-inferences were developed from four themes that emerged from a line-by-line analysis of the qualitative interview data. Overall, this study found that the quantitative and qualitative strands of data combined to show that significantly lower STRS-SF scores within the PLTW group related to a supplanting of the teacher's role as facilitator and a limitation of opportunities for student-centered instruction.
Article
Full-text available
This study investigated parent-child and teacher-pupil relationship as predictors of academic motivation and achievement among school children. Participants were 299 Primary 5 and 6 school pupils. They were randomly selected from two primary schools in southeast Nigeria. Their ages ranged from 7-12 years, with a mean age of 10.06 years. Three instruments were used to elicit information from respondents. They include Parent as a Social Context Questionnaire (Child Report Version), Teacher as a Social Context Questionnaire (Child Report Version), and the adapted version of Herman's Questionnaire Measure of Need Achievement. The students' cumulative results were assessed from the official school record to determine their academic achievements. The study tested four hypotheses and the results of the regression analyses showed that parent-child relationship was a significant predictor of academic achievement. Teacher-pupil relationship also significantly predicted academic achievement and academic motivation, whereas parent-child relationship did not predict academic motivation. Implications and limitations of the study were discussed and suggestions were made for further studies.
Article
Full-text available
A developmental model of antisocial behavior is outlined. Recent findings are reviewed that concern the etiology and course of antisocial behavior from early childhood through adolescence. Evidence is presented in support of the hypothesis that the route to chronic delinquency is marked by a reliable developmental sequence of experiences. As a first step, ineffective parenting practices are viewed as determinants for childhood conduct disorders. The general model also takes into account the contextual variables that influence the family interaction process. As a second step, the conduct-disordered behaviors lead to academic failure and peer rejection. These dual failures lead, in turn, to increased risk for depressed mood and involvement in a deviant peer group. This third step usually occurs during later childhood and early adolescence. It is assumed that children following this developmental sequence are at high risk for engaging in chronic delinquent behavior. Finally, implications for prevention and intervention are discussed.
Chapter
How are children's social lives at school related to their motivation to achieve and how do motivational and social processes interact to explain children's adjustment at school? This volume, first published in 1990, features work by leading researchers in educational and developmental psychology and provides perspectives on how and why children tend to thrive or fail at school. The individual chapters examine the unique roles of peers and teachers in communicating and reinforcing school-related attitudes, expectations, and definitions of self. Relations of children's school adjustment to school motivation, interpersonal functioning, and social skillfulness are also explored. The developmental and social perspectives on motivation and achievement presented in this volume provide new insights into the complex processes contributing to school success.
Chapter
How are children's social lives at school related to their motivation to achieve and how do motivational and social processes interact to explain children's adjustment at school? This volume, first published in 1990, features work by leading researchers in educational and developmental psychology and provides perspectives on how and why children tend to thrive or fail at school. The individual chapters examine the unique roles of peers and teachers in communicating and reinforcing school-related attitudes, expectations, and definitions of self. Relations of children's school adjustment to school motivation, interpersonal functioning, and social skillfulness are also explored. The developmental and social perspectives on motivation and achievement presented in this volume provide new insights into the complex processes contributing to school success.
Article
73 teachers of kindergarten to 8th grade viewed disruptive- or nondisruptive-context videotaped vignettes and rated each portrayal in terms of severity, manageability, tolerance, and contagion to investigate the effects of context on Ss' perceptions of 5 problem behaviors (blaming, poor peer cooperation, negative aggression, inattention, and failure anxiety). ANCOVA showed that contagion yielded significant differences (stronger within the disruptive context), suggesting that the target child was held responsible for the classroom disorder. Correlational data explained the relationship between the 4 areas, suggesting a dichotomy between quality (type of behavior) and quantity (degree or severity of behavior) for interpreting perceptions. Low tolerance was associated with higher levels of severity and more outer-directed behaviors. Contagion had more active, observable components and was related more to the qualitative dimension. Manageability (also active, observable, and teacher centered) was strongly influenced by quantitative factors (greater extremes of atypical behavior). (25 ref)
Chapter
With certain exceptions, the literature on social support has not emphasized personality issues, focusing instead on the availability of support networks, and the ways in which they contribute to health and well-being. Similarly, little attention has been paid to those factors that might influence the probability of either developing or accessing a supportive social network. Research on relationships and interpersonal behavior more broadly conceived, however, suggests that individuals vary considerably in their ability to achieve interpersonal goals as well as in the skill and confidence necessary to interact with others effectively. The purpose of the present paper then is to consider the role of personality and individual differences in the experience of loneliness and by implication in the process of social support.
Chapter
A number of intervention programs have been developed to teach children the skills necessary for effective interactions with others (see Furman, 1984; Hops, 1982). Some investigators have developed programs to improve the sociometric status of children who are not liked or who are disliked by their peers. Others have designed interventions to increase the rates of peer interaction of children who are isolated from their peers. Although there is considerable controversy concerning which of these approaches is more appropriate, the objective of both is to enhance children’s relationships with their peers.