Content uploaded by Basil George Issa
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Basil George Issa
Content may be subject to copyright.
CASE REPORT
Undetectable urinary free cortisol concentrations in a case of
Cushing’s disease
B G Issa
1
, M D Page
4
, G Read
2
, R John
2
, A Douglas-Jones
3
and M F Scanlon
1
Departments of
1
Medicine,
2
Medical Biochemistry and
3
Histopathology, University Hospital of Wales, Cardiff and
4
Department of Medicine,
East Glamorgan General Hospital, Pontypridd, UK
(Correspondence should be addressed to M F Scanlon, Department of Endocrinology, University Hospital of Wales, Heath Park, Cardiff CF4 4XN, UK)
Abstract
Measurement of the 24-h urinary free cortisol is a valuable screening test of endogenous hyper-
cortisolism and, although false positive results may occur in a few situations, for example endogenous
depression, false negative results are unusual. We report a case of a 48-year-old lady with pituitary-
dependent Cushing’s disease, whose 24-h urinary free cortisol excretion was consistently undetectable
in association with increased plasma and salivary cortisol concentrations and reduced dexamethasone
suppressibility. The patient had chronic renal impairment (creatinine clearance 21 ml/min) as a
consequence of hypertension, despite only modestly increased urea and creatinine concentrations.
Urinary free cortisol measurements must be interpreted with caution in patients with renal
impairment.
European Journal of Endocrinology 140 148–151
Introduction
Several modifications in the methodology of measuring
urinary free cortisol (UFC) have been introduced since
it was first proposed as a test of adrenal function
(1). At present, it is considered the best screening test of
endogenous hypercortisolism, assuming complete collec-
tion of urine (2). The test has superseded measurements
of the excretion of 17-hydroxycorticosteroids and
17-ketogenic steroids, which are dependent on body
weight (3) and creatinine clearance, and are less
sensitive (4, 5) than measurements of UFC. In addition,
UFC excretion is relatively simple to measure in the
laboratory.
Conditions that may lead to false positive UFC are well
recognised by most endocrinologists and physicians.
However, the causes of false negative UFC measure-
ments are not clearly identified in the literature and the
incidence varies between ‘virtually absent’ (2) to 36%
(6). Studies that have demonstrated high false negative
rates for UFC assay were all conducted in the late 1950s
and ’60s; since then, the sensitivity and specificity of the
UFC assay have improved considerably. The effects of
renal impairment on UFC are variable and reduction
of UFC excretion in Cushing’s syndrome has been
shown mostly only in severe renal impairment (creati-
nine clearance <20 ml/min) (7). We report a case of
Cushing’s disease and moderately severe renal impair-
ment with undetectable UFC concentrations.
Case report
A 48-year-old lady presented to her local hospital with
dyspnoea caused by congestive cardiac failure (CCF) and
uncontrolled hypertension. There was no significant
past history, apart from peptic ulceration 20 years
previously. In particular, there was no history of steroid
treatment or alcohol misuse. Examination revealed an
increased blood pressure of 190/130 mmHg and signs
of biventricular failure. The patient was noted to be
Cushingoid, with a ‘moon face’, central adiposity and
slight proximal muscle weakness. There was no
evidence of a ‘buffalo hump’, supraclavicular fat pads,
ecchymosis, abdominal striae or hirsutism. She had
noticed a change in her facial appearance and easy
bruising over the past 3 years and had been amenorr-
hoeic for 1 year before presentation. Her CCF and
hypertension partially improved with frusemide, lisino-
pril and long-acting nifedipine. Plasma electrolytes,
liver function tests and full blood count were normal,
but the patient had increased urea and creatinine
concentrations (10 mmol/l and 220 mol/l respectively).
The electrocardiogram was normal. There was loss of
diurnal rhythm for cortisol and adrenocorticotrophic
hormone (ACTH), and failure of cortisol suppression
with low-dose (0.5 mg 6 hourly for 48 h), but not
high-dose (2 mg 6 hourly for 48 h) dexamethasone. A
computed tomography (CT) scan of the pituitary gland
was normal, but adrenal CT revealed bilateral adrenal
European Journal of Endocrinology (1999) 140 148–151 ISSN 0804-4643
q1999 Society of the European Journal of Endocrinology
hyperplasia. Throughout these investigations, 24-h
UFC concentrations were low normal or undetectable
(<28 nmol/24 h). Concomitant salivary cortisol con-
centrations were increased and failed to suppress with
low-dose dexamethasone, consistent with the view that
the undetectable UFC concentrations were misleading.
The results of the biochemical investigations are
summarised in Table 1. In view of the increased serum
urea and creatinine concentrations, we suspected renal
failure as the cause of low UFC. Creatinine clearance
was reduced to 21 ml/min, but ultrasound scan of the
renal tract was unremarkable. MRI of the pituitary
gland showed a 5-mm focal non-enhancing lesion in the
left side of the pituitary fossa, consistent with an
adenoma (Fig. 1). A diagnosis of pituitary-dependent
Cushing’s syndrome was made and the patient under-
went selective transsphenoidal removal of a pituitary
adenoma. Histology confirmed a pituitary micro-
adenoma staining for immunoreactive ACTH (Fig. 2).
Postoperative assessment showed suppression of 0900-h
cortisol to less than 28 nmol/l with 1mg dexamethasone,
with normal pituitary function otherwise indicating cure
of her Cushing’s disease. The 24-h UFC remained
undetectable. Serum cortisol binding globulin (CBG) was
within the normal range, at 300 nmol/l (normal range
290–420 nmol/l). Antihypertensive medication was with-
drawn, with the blood pressure remaining in the normal
range. There was regression of some of the clinical
features of Cushing’s syndrome.
Methods
Serum and urinary cortisol were measured by a
competitive chemiluminescent immunoassay (Chiron
Diagnostics, East Walpole, MA, USA) on an ACS-180
automated immunoassay analyser (Chiron Diagnostics).
The method for measurement of UFC involved a prior
extraction step of the urine with dichloromethane. UFC
was also measured using an in-house extraction radio-
immunoassay, confirming the UFC results obtained by
the first technique. ACTH was measured by a two-site
chemiluminometric assay (Nichols Institute, San Juan
Capistrano, CA, USA).
Discussion
UFC represents the plasma protein unbound fraction
of cortisol that is produced by ultrafiltration at the
glomerulus after reabsorption of most (95%) of
the filtered load. Measured by HPLC or radioimmuno-
assay, it is considered the best screening test for
hypercortisolism (7, 8). Our patient had low or
undetectable UFC concentrations, despite increased
plasma and salivary cortisol concentrations secondary
to an ACTH-producing pituitary adenoma. The prob-
able explanation for this discrepancy is the effect of
renal impairment on cortisol filtration by the kidney.
West (9) confirmed the findings of Gilliland & Phillips
(10), who demonstrated a clear correlation between
UFC and creatinine clearance in 28 consecutive
urine samples, but found normal or increased UFC
in another group of patients with renal failure. In
contrast, Ogunlesi et al. (11) found the concentrations
of 24-h UFC excretion in 10 uraemic subjects (creati-
nine clearance <30 ml/min, fixed urine specific gravity
and bilaterally shrunken kidneys on ultrasonography)
to be significantly greater than those in nine controls.
This was in association with loss of the circadian
rhythm for cortisol secretion and failure of serum
cortisol to be suppressed in response to dexamethasone
(1 mg).
Renal failure may affect cortisol metabolism in various
ways, including alteration in the hypothalamo–
pituitary–adrenal axis (12), a prolonged half-life of
serum cortisol (13) and decreased oxidation of tetra-
hydrocortisone to tetrahydrocortisol (14). However,
this marked effect of renal impairment on UFC excretion
is not widely appreciated, and this, together with
abnormal cortisol binding, metabolite interference
with assays for serum cortisol and poor absorption
of dexamethasone from the gastrointestinal tract of
patients with renal failure, may lead to obvious
diagnostic difficulties.
Several investigators have suggested measuring
alternative cortisol metabolites in the urine of patients
with Cushing’s syndrome to be a superior predictor of
hypercortisolism than measurement of UFC (15–17).
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ENDOCRINOLOGY (1999) 140 Undetectable urinary free cortisol in Cushing’s disease 149
Table 1 Summary of baseline and dynamic tests of adrenalfunction.
Cortisol (nmol/l) ACTH (ng/l) Salivary cortisol (nmol/l) UFC
0900h 2400h 0900h 2400h 0900h 2400h (nmol/24h)
Basal 498 502 84.1 74 <28
Basal 559 504 84.3 53.4 32.4 21.6 50
Basal 646 510 86.8 76.6 41.2 20.8 <28
Low Dex, Day 1 453 18 <28
Low Dex, Day 2 254 7.6 <28
High Dex, Day 1 130 2.9 <28
High Dex, Day 2 <28 0.9 <28
Dex, dexamethasone.
Voccia et al. (17) studied 10 children with Cushing’s
syndrome and found that concentrations of urinary
6b-hydroxycortisol excretion were a better test for
hypercortisolism than was UFC or 17-hydroxycortico-
steroids. In 40 patients with pathologically proven
Cushing’s syndrome due to different causes, 20a-
dihydrocortisol was found to be a better index of
hypercortisolism than was UFC (15, 16). Despite these
observations, UFC remains the standard screening
test for hypercortisolism in most laboratories. Because
Cushing’s syndrome is usually associated with
hypertension and possible alterations in renal function,
it is imperative to recognise and, if possible, study
further the relationship between the degree of renal
impairment and excretion of UFC. Despite the known
regulatory effects of CBG on plasma cortisol transport
and clearance (18), serum CBG concentrations in our
patient were normal. Finally, the diagnosis of cyclical
Cushing’s disease was considered in our patient, but
was believed to be unlikely, as UFC concentrations
remained undetectable on many occasions and con-
commitant plasma and salivary cortisol concentrations
were increased.
In conclusion, we report a patient with Cushing’s
disease and moderately severe renal failure with
persistently low or undetectable UFC concentrations.
Further studies should investigate the effect of various
degrees of renal impairment on UFC. Clinicians should
be aware that UFC measurements can be unreliable in
patients with renal impairment, which limits the value
of this test in screening for hypercortisolism in such
patients.
150 B G Issa and others EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ENDOCRINOLOGY (1999) 140
Figure 1 (a, b) Coronal and sagittal T1-weighted pre- and
post-gadolinium pituitary MRI scans showing a 5-mm
non-enhancing lesion (arrow) consistent with a pituitary
microadenoma.
Figure 2 Immunostaining for ACTH. (a) Background
(non-adenomatous) pituitary tissue showing normal staining.
Compare with sections through microadenoma (b), showing
marked immunostaining for ACTH.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Mr Colin Selby, Department of
Clinical Chemistry, City Hospital, Nottingham for
performing the cortisol-binding globulin assay.
References
1 Cope CL & Black EG. Urinary cortisol measurement in adrenocortical
hyperfunction. British Medical Journal 1959 21117–1119.
2 Tigos C, Papanicolaou DA & Chrousos GP. Advances in the
diagnoses and treatment of Cushing’s syndrome. Bailliere’s
Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism 1995 9315–336.
3 Streeten DHP, Stevenson CT, Dalakos TG, Nicholas JJ, Dennick LG
& Fellerman H. Diagnosis of hypercortisolism. Biochemical
criteria of differentiating patients from lean and obese normal
subjects and females on oral contraceptives. Journal of Clinical
Endocrinology and Metabolism 1969 29 191–211.
4 Murphy BEP. Clinical evaluation of urinary cortisol determination
by competitive protein binding radioassay. Journal of Clinical
Endocrinology and Metabolism 1968 28 343–348.
5 Mattingly D & Tyler C. Simple screening tests for Cushing’s
syndrome. British Medical Journal 1967 4394–397.
6 Streeten DHP, Dalakos TG & Anderson Jr GH. Diagnosis and
treatment of Cushing’s syndrome. In New Concepts in Endocrinol-
ogy and Metabolism, pp 57. Eds LI Rose & RL Lavine. New York:
Grune and Stratton, 1977.
7 Burke CW & Beardwell CG. Cushing’s syndrome: an evaluation of
the clinical usefulness of urinary free cortisol and other steroid
measurements in diagnosis. Quarterly Journal of Medicine 1973 42
175–204.
8 Eddy RL, Jones AL, Gilliland PF, Ibarra JD, Thompson JQ,
MacMurray FR et al. Cushing’s syndrome: a prospective study of
diagnostic methods. American Journal of Medicine 1973 55 621–
630.
9 West P. Application of a modified Cortipac procedure for the
estimation of urinary free cortisol in various clinical situations.
Journal of Clinical Pathology 1980 33 89–92.
10 Gilliland J & Phillips PJ. Urinary free cortisol excretion and renal
function. Journal of Clinical Pathology 1978 31 671–672.
11 Ogunlesi AO, Akanji AO, Kadiri S & Osotimehin B. Uraemia and
adrenocortical function in Nigerian subjects. African Journal of
Medical Sciences 1990 19 43–48.
12 Wallace EZ, Rosman P, Toshav N, Sacerdote A & Balthazar A.
Pituitary adrenocortical function in chronic renal failure. Journal
of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism 1980 50 46–51.
13 Bacon GE, Kenny FM, Mardaugh HV, Richards C et al. Prolonged
serum half-life of cortisol in chronic renal failure. Johns Hopkins
Medical Journal 1973 132 127–131.
14 Vanluchene E, Vandekerckhove D, Thiery M & Van Holder R.
Changes in cortisol metabolism in various physiological and
pathological situations. Annales d’Endocrinologie 1981 42
284–285.
15 Schoneshofer M, Weber B, Oelkers W, Nahoul K & Mantero F.
Measurement of urinary free 20a-dihydrocortisol in biochemical
diagnosis of chronic hypercorticoidism. Clinical Chemistry 1986
32 808–810.
16 Schoneshofer M, Weber B & Nigam S. Increased urinary excretion
of free 20a- and 20b-dihydrocortisol in a hypercortisolemic but
hypocortisoluric patient with Cushing’s disease. Clinical Chemistry
1983 29 385–389.
17 Voccia E, Saenger P, Peterson RE, Rauh W, Gottesdiener K,
Levine L & New MI. 6b-Hydroxycortisol excretion in hyper-
cortisolemic states. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism
1979 48 467–471.
18 Bright GM. Corticosteroid-binding globulin influences kinetic
parameters of plasma cortisol transport and clearance. Journal of
Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism 1995 80 770–775.
Received 7 October 1998
Accepted 7 October 1998
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ENDOCRINOLOGY (1999) 140 Undetectable urinary free cortisol in Cushing’s disease 151