Content uploaded by Duangrurdee Wattanasirichaigoon
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Duangrurdee Wattanasirichaigoon on Jun 07, 2014
Content may be subject to copyright.
correspondence
nature genetics • volume
21 •
april
1999
353
T
he α-actinins are actin-binding
proteins encoded by a multigene
family. In skeletal muscle, they are a
major structural component of the Z-
lines that anchor the actin-containing
thin filaments and maintain the spatial
relationship between myofilaments
1
. In
humans, two genes (ACTN2 and ACTN3)
encode the closely related α-actinin-2
and α-actinin-3 skeletal muscle iso-
forms
2
. ACTN2is expressed in all skeletal
muscle fibres, whereas expression of
ACTN3 is limited to a subset of type 2
(fast) fibres
3
. We have previously demon-
strated absence of α-actinin-3 in muscle
biopsies from several patients with mus-
cular dystrophy
3
. A follow-up study iden-
tified additional α-actinin-3−negative
biopsies from neuromuscular patients
with other known diseases, suggesting
that this deficiency was not the primary
cause of muscle weakness
4
. Subsequently,
we screened muscle specimens with dys-
trophic (118 specimens), myopathic (74),
neurogenic (20) and normal (55) features
(Fig. 1a−d). Although these biopsies con-
tained normal α-actinin-2 expression,
deficiency of α-actinin-3 was identified
by immunocytochemistry and western
blot in 51 of 267 cases (19%), a finding
not associated with any particular histo-
pathological or clinical phenotype. To
ascertain whether α-actinin-3 deficiency
was associated with mutations of ACTN3,
we used an RT-PCR approach to amplify
mRNA isolated from diagnostic muscle
biopsies. Using primer pairs AB16/AB9
(5´–GATGGTTATGCAGCCCGAGG–3´
and 5´–AGCAACGCCCGCACCTCCT–3´)
and AB8/AB1 (5´–TGCACGAAGCCTG-
GACCC–3´ and 5´–AGAGAGGGATCTT-
TATTCAG–3´), we PCR-amplified two
overlapping fragments encompassing
bases 24−2,852 of ACTN3 mRNA (ref. 2).
Initially, we focused on one family with
two affected male siblings with congeni-
tal muscular dystrophy and complete
deficiency of α-actinin-3. Sequencing of
ACTN3 cDNA from the proband identi-
fied two changes relative to controls and
the previously determined sequence
M86407. These were an A→G transition
at nt 1,586 in exon 15, changing a gluta-
mine (CAG) to an arginine (CGG) at
residue 523 (Q523R), and a C→T trans-
version at position 1,747 in exon 16, con-
verting an arginine to a stop codon at
residue 577 (R577X; Fig. 1e−g). Direct
sequencing of genomic DNA from the
proband and the affected sibling con-
firmed homozygosity for both point
mutations. Subsequent testing of the par-
ents and two unaffected siblings revealed
that these phenotypically normal indi-
viduals had the same genotype as the
proband and were thus homozygous for
the ACTN3577X nonsense mutation.
The R577X change creates a novel DdeI
site (Fig. 1h). An additional 125 biopsies
for which matched DNA samples were
available were tested for α-actinin-3
expression and ACTN3 genotype (48 α-
actinin-3−deficient and 77 α-actinin-3−
positive biopsies with a mixture of
histological and clinical phenotypes).
Homozygosity for the stop codon at posi-
tion 577 was identified in 46 of 48 (96%)
cases in which α-actinin-3 staining was
negative. In the two remaining cases, the
genotype was 577R/577X; however, fibre
typing of both muscle biopsies demon-
strated a type 1 fibre predominance, with
less than 5% type 2 fibres. Thusα-actinin-
3 deficiency in these two discordant cases
is likely a secondary phenomenon due to
loss of type 2 fibres
5
. There was no signifi-
cant difference in the frequency of
homozygous null genotypes among
patients with dystrophic, myopathic, neu-
rogenic or normal biopsies, and α-
actinin-3 deficiency did not alter
A common nonsense mutation
results in α-actinin-3 deficiency
in the general population
Fig. 1 Molecular analysis of α-actinin-3 genes and proteins. Indirect immunofluorescence (a−c) and western-
blot analysis (d) of human skeletal muscle (quadriceps muscle biopsy with normal histology) using affinity
purified antibodies (5B) specific for α-actinin-3 (a,c; refs 3,8) and mouse myosin heavy chain (fast, MY32)
specific for type 2 fibres (b). Methodology as described in North and Beggs
3
. Normal expression of α-actinin-
3 is restricted to type 2 (fast) fibres (a) as indicated by double staining with MY32 (b). Corresponding fibres
in each section are indicated by the same symbol. c, Complete deficiency of α-actinin-3 in a patient homozy-
gous for the stop codon in exon 16 (577X). d, Western-blot analysis of α-actinin-3 in skeletal muscle from
individuals with normal α-actinin-3 expression (genotype 577R/577X; lanes 1,3) and α-actinin-3 deficiency
(genotype 577X/577X; lanes 2,4). α-actinin-3 migrates at approximately 100 kD. The ACTN3 577X allele
encodes a truncated 66-kD protein, which is thought to be incapable of dimerization
10
. Since the anti-α-
actinin-3 5B antibody is directed towards the amino terminus of the protein
3,8
, it should detect the trun-
cated protein if it is stable. All individuals homozygous for the stop codon demonstrated complete absence
of detectable α-actinin-3 by immunocytochemistry, and there was no evidence of the truncated protein in
577R/X or 577X/X individuals on western blots. e,f,g,h, DNA sequence and restriction endonuclease analysis
of ACTN3 exon 16 demonstrating the three possible ACTN3 genotypes at position 577. Products were either
directly sequenced (e−g) or subjected to DdeI digestion and agarose gel electrophoresis (h).
e
f
g
h
d
b
a
c
© 1999 Nature America Inc. • http://genetics.nature.com
© 1999 Nature America Inc. • http://genetics.nature.com
correspondence
354 nature genetics • volume
21 •
april
1999
fibre-type distribution in control muscle.
None of the 77 α-actinin-3−positive
biopsies were from 577X homozygotes
(53 were heterozygous and the remaining
24 individuals were homozygous ‘wild
type’ 577R/577R). These data suggest that
hereditary α-actinin-3 deficiency is com-
mon and may not be associated with an
abnormal neuromuscular phenotype.
To determine the frequency and ethnic
distribution of the ACTN3 577X allele in the
general population, we genotyped an addi-
tional 485 DNA samples. The relative allele
frequency of 577X ranged from 0.22±0.05
to 0.52±0.04 in ethnic populations from
Asia and the Americas, Australasia, Africa
and Europe (data not shown). Approxi-
mately 16% of the world population are
predicted to have congenital deficiency of
α-actinin-3, suggesting that other factor(s)
likely compensate for its absence at the Z
lines of skeletal muscle fast fibres.
Individuals genotyped for R577X were
also genotyped for Q523R (which creates
a novel MspI site). Fifteen 523Q/577X and
thirteen 523R/577R halotypes were
detected among the 674 alleles from 337
subjects who were homozygous for at least
one of the loci. The remaining ACTN3
haplotypes were all either 523Q/577R or
523R/577X. Tests for linkage disequilib-
rium
6
, using maximum likelihood esti-
mates of haplotype frequencies, were
significant in all populations (P<10
–5
,
except in a small Bantu sample where
P<0.05). Thus, 577X likely results from a
single mutational event and not from
multiple independent mutations in differ-
ent chromosomal backgrounds. Although
we can not rule out some subtle selective
pressure keeping these alleles together, it
appears unlikely that the 577X protects
against a deleterious effect of 523R, as all
13 individuals with 523R/577R haplotypes
(including one of the authors) were phe-
notypically normal.
The high allelic frequency of ACTN3
577X in the general population demon-
strates that this stop codon is a non-path-
ogenic polymorphism in humans.
Absence of a structural protein caused by
homozygosity for a null mutation cannot
be assumed to be disease-related without
additional family and population data.
These findings should also prompt re-
evaluation of previous studies describing
apparent loss of fast-fibre α-actinin in
patients with Duchenne muscular dystro-
phy
5
. The high frequency of α-actinin-3
deficiency and absence of an obvious asso-
ciated disease phenotype suggests that α-
actinin-3 is functionally redundant in
humans. Although mouse studies have
identified a number of genes whose
homozygous null mutant phenotypes are
apparently normal, genetic redundancy is
not a well-characterized phenomenon in
humans
7
. We propose that α-actinin-2,
which is structurally and functionally
highly similar to α-actinin-3 (Table 1;
refs 2,8), is able to compensate for α-
actinin-3 absence in type 2 (fast) fibres.
On the other hand, ACTN3 has been
highly conserved over a long period of
evolutionary time, implying a constraint
on evolutionary rate imposed by contin-
ued functioning of the gene (Table 1). The
force-generating capacity of type-2 mus-
cle fibres at high velocity, the speed and
tempo of movements and the capacity of
an individual to adapt to exercise training
are all genetically influenced
9
. Although
we have not yet identified any subtle phe-
notypes associated with α-actinin-3 defi-
ciency, ACTN3 genotype may be one of
the factors that influence normal variation
in muscle function, both within patient
groups (that is, as a disease-modifying
locus) and in the general population.
Acknowledgements
We thank S. Kim and H.-Q. Tong for technical
assistance, M. Ettore for help with ACTN3
genotyping and P. Gunning, L. Kunkel and J.
Scharf for their suggestions and critical reading
of the manuscript. The authors acknowledge a
gift of anonymous DNA samples from D. Bing
and R. Houranieh at the Boston Center for
Blood Research. This work was supported by an
RACP Glaxo Wellcome Australia Fellowship to
K.N.N. and by grants from the Muscular
Dystrophy Association and the National
Institutes of Health (NIAMS R01 AR44345
and K02 AR02026) to A.H.B.
Kathryn N. North
1,2
, Nan Yang
1
,
Duangrurdee Wattanasirichaigoon
3
,
Michelle Mills
1
, Simon Easteal
4
& Alan H. Beggs
3
1
Neurogenetics Research Unit, Royal Alexandra
Hospital for Children, Sydney, N.S.W., Australia.
2
Department of Paediatrics and Child Health,
University of Sydney, Sydney, N.S.W., Australia.
3
Genetics Division, Children’s Hospital, Harvard
Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
4
Human Genetics Group, John Curtin School of
Medical Research, Australian National
University, Canberra, A.C.T., Australia.
Correspondence should be addressed to K.N.N.
(e-mail: kathryn@nch.edu.au).
1. Blanchard, A., Ohanian, V. & Critchley D. J. Muscle
Res. Cell Motil. 10, 280–289 (1989).
2. Beggs, A.H. et al. J. Biol. Chem. 267, 9281–9288
(1992).
3. North, K.N. & Beggs, A.H. Neuromuscul. Disord. 6,
229–235 (1996).
4. Vainzof, M. et al. Neuropediatrics 28, 223–228
(1997).
5. Minetti, C., Ricci, E. & Bonilla, E. Neurology 41,
1977–1981 (1991).
6. Slatkin, M. & Excoffier, L. Heredity 76, 377–383
(1996).
7. Cooke, J. et al. Trends Genet. 13, 360–364 (1997).
8. Chan, Y.-m. et al. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Comm.
248, 134–139 (1998).
9. Simoneau, J.-A. & Bouchard, C. in Paediatric
Anaerobic Performance (ed. Van Praagh, E.) 5−21
(Human Kinetics Publishers, Champaign, Illinois,
1998).
10. Flood, G., Rowe, A.J., Critchley, D.R. & Gratzer, W.B.
Eur. Biophys. J. 25, 431–435 (1997).
11. Li, W.-H. J. Mol. Evol. 36, 96–99 (1993).
12. Kimura, M. J. Mol. Evol. 16, 111–120 (1980).
Table 1 • Sequence conservation of α-actinin genes
Gene chk Actn2 hum ACTN2 hum ACTN3 hum ACTN4
chk Actn2 2.9±0.4 14.2±0.9 14.9±0.9
hum ACTN2 117.6±10.2 13.6±0.9 14.8±0.9
hum ACTN3 261.2±88.1 143.7±19.5 17.3±1.0
hum ACTN4 230.1±53.3 146.4±20.2 98.0±10.6
Numbers of nucleotide substitutions, and their standard errors, per 100 synonymous sites (above diago-
nal) and per 100 nonsynonymous sites (below diagonal) between indicated α-actinin genes (estimated as
described
11
, with correction for multiple substitution using the two parameter method
12
). chk
Actn2=X13874; hum ACTN2=M86406; hum ACTN3=M86407; hum ACTN4=D89980. The substitution rate
per nonsynonymous site
11
between human (hum) ACTN2 and ACTN3 is 1.43, whereas the rate per syn-
onymous site is only 0.14. Similar results are obtained for the comparison between both human and
chicken (chk) ACTN2 genes. This implies that the proteins encoded by both genes have evolved very
slowly since their divergence.
© 1999 Nature America Inc. • http://genetics.nature.com
© 1999 Nature America Inc. • http://genetics.nature.com