Article

Method to Monitor the Precision of Milk Yields Recorded at Individual Milking Stalls on a Daily Basis

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

Automated systems to record individual milk weights of cows at each milking are now common on dairy farms. These data are used by Dairy Herd Improvement Association (DHIA) for testing purposes and by farmers to monitor herd performance. Despite the importance of these data, little effort has been made to monitor the function and reliability of milking stalls and recording equipment on a daily basis. Described is an algorithm that allows for continuous monitoring of the function of individual milking stalls. The basis of the algorithm is the comparison of milk yield of individual cows over a period of days. For each cow, milk production at a selected stall is compared with production of that same cow when milked at any other stall. These ratios are averaged across all cows milked at least once in the selected stall and once at any other stall. Ideally, the mean ratio for each stall should be 1. Stalls where the mean ratio deviates from 1 by more than 5% are assumed to be malfunctioning. This algorithm was implemented as a computer program and was used to identify 3 malfunctioning stalls out of 12 at the USDA dairy facility (Beltsville, MD). The algorithm can easily be incorporated into existing management programs or used as a separate program. In either case, routine use of this algorithm can improve the reliability of DHIA test programs and potentially reduce the incidence of new mastitis infections by enabling detection of malfunctioning milking equipment.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.

... Further, to measure both the milk flow accurately for a reaction in a three second interval and the individual quarter milkflow in the milk tube represents a substantial challenge. Despite the importance of automated measured milk flow data, little effort has been made to monitor the reliability of recording equipment on a daily basis [2]. The milk-air mixture in the milk tube excludes methods of measurement which have been developed for homogeneous liquids in pipelines. ...
Article
Full-text available
A problem of the currently available milking technology is that the teat-end milking vacuum always falls as the milk flow increases. A recently developed unit for the quarter individual control of the teat-end vacuum therefore constitutes the focus of this paper, which compares the vacuum behaviour at the teat end of the cow in the Multilactor® milking system with and without a control unit. As a result, the following differences with and without a control unit were observed: In low-flow milking stages, the milking vacuum is set to 8 kPa (release) and 17.5 kPa (suction) with a control unit in both pulse-cycle phases. By contrast, the milking vacuum reaches values of 29 kPa (release) and 33.5 kPa (suction) without a control unit. In high-flow milking phases, the milking vacuum remains relatively high at approximately 31 kPa, in both settings, with and without using the control unit. That allows a speedy and udder-tissue-friendly milking process. Copyright © (2014) by the American Society of Agricultural & Biological Engineers All rights reserved.
... Further, to measure both the milk flow accurately for a reaction in a three second interval and the individual quarter milkflow in the milk tube represents a substantial challenge. Despite the importance of automated measured milk flow data, little effort has been made to monitor the reliability of recording equipment on a daily basis [2]. The milk-air mixture in the milk tube excludes methods of measurement which have been developed for homogeneous liquids in pipelines. ...
Article
Full-text available
Progress in sensor technique and electronics has led to a decrease in the costs of electronic and sensor components. In modern dairy farms, having udders in good condition, a lower frequency of udder disease and an extended service life of dairy cows will help ensure competitiveness. The objective of this study was to develop a teat-end vacuum control system with individual quarter actor reaction. Based on a review of the literature, this system is assumed to protect the teat tissue. It reduces the mean teat-end vacuum in the maximum vacuum phase (b) to a level of 20 kPa at a flow rate of 0.25 L/min per quarter. At flow rates higher than 1.50 L/min per quarter, the teat-end vacuum can be controlled to a level of 30 kPa, because in this case it is desirable to have a higher vacuum for the transportation of the milk to the receiver. With this system it is possible for the first time to supply the teat end with low vacuum at low flow rates and with higher vacuum at increasing flow rates in a continuous process with a three second reaction-rate on individual quarter level. This system is completely automated.
... The daily monitoring of milk yield of each cow is an important tool for fine-tuning milk production and maximizing herd performance (Lefcourt, 1999). Yield data can be profitably used by farmers to calculate the actual lactation curve and evaluate long-term milk production for individual cows, in order to plan breeding and culling; to calculate and evaluate feed rations for individual cows avoiding over or under feeding; to group cows by yield, that means a faster milking. ...
Article
Accurate milk yield measurement is important to maintain production efficiency and improve farm management: yield data enable to implement and evaluate feed rations for individual cows or groups, calculate actual lactation curves and identify potential health problems proactively. Nowadays, many electronic milk metering devices, based on different methods of measurement, are available on the market. Vacuum drop across the meter, accuracy over a wide range of flow rates and farm conditions (e.g. foaming of milk) are the key problems of currently available electronic milk meters. Aim of this project was the development of a free-flow milk meter, able to work with different flow rates and different combination of air-milk flows, with a measuring chamber essentially made by a portion of linear pipe, horizontally disposed and with no mechanical movement parts, to minimize the interferences with the milk flow and on the electric conductivity (EC), to calculate the milk yield, in order to obtain a low-cost device. A prototype was built up and laboratory and farm tests were carried out during 2004 and 2005, in order to evaluate the accuracy and reproducibility of the new device. Laboratory and farm tests were carried out following the guidelines of the International Committee for Animal Recording (ICAR). Laboratory tests showed a bias of 1.4% and a standard deviation of 5.0%, while farm tests showed a bias of -4.5% and a standard deviation of 12.7%. (c) 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Conference Paper
Accurate milk yield measurement is important in maintaining production efficiency and improving farm management: yield data enable to implement and evaluate feed rations for individual cows or groups, calculate actual lactation curves and identify potential health problems proactively. Actually, many electronic milk metering devices based on different methods of measurement are available on the market. Accuracy over a wide range of flow rates, foaming effect on milk yield measurement, vacuum drop across the meter and reliability under widespread farm conditions are the key problems of currently available electronic milk meters. Aim of this project was the development of a low-cost and compact “straight-thru” milk meter that bases its functionality on the measurement of the electrical conductivity of the milk flowing through the meter. A prototype of the milk meter was built up during 2004 and tested in laboratory during 2005 using as experimental setup: a conductimetric card, a portable PC with a data acquisition and A/D conversion card and a software application developed by LabVIEW© 6.01 embedded, a suitable milking unit (artificial udder). The tests were made at constant flow rates, from 1.0 kg/min. to 12.0 kg/min, and carried out as requested from the approval procedures of the International Committee for Animal Recording (ICAR). Obtained results showed: a good accuracy at all the flows rates tested (average bias of 1.4 %) but at the same time a low reproducibility (SD of 5.0%) on the measurement.
Article
The objectives of this study were to compare the multiple trait prediction (MTP) model estimate of 305-d lactation yield with the 305-d daily milk yield data from on-farm automated meters and software and to examine the accuracy of electronic identification (ID). Twenty-four-hour milk and component yields are calculated by using milk weights and samples collected 8 to 10 times/yr by Dairy Herd Improvement (DHI) organizations. Daily milk weights were collected from cows on 20 Canadian farms that used parlor milking systems with electronic ID and that were enrolled in a regular DHI program. A total of 10,175 DHI test days from 1,103 cows with complete 305-d lactation yields were entered into the MTP model, and lactation yields were predicted. Test days were grouped into first, second, and third and greater lactations and within each lactation group, days in milk were categorized in 3 stages (5 to 60, 61 to 120, and 120 to 305 d in milk) for a total of 9 classes. Agreement analysis was used to compare the 305-d sum of daily milk to the MTP 305-d lactation yield predictions by using inputs from test days throughout the lactations. Results indicated that the MTP model overestimated lactation yields across all parity groups, ranging from 310 to 1,552 kg in parity 1, 640 to 2,000 kg in parity 2, and 567 to 1,476 kg in parity 3 and greater. A preliminary examination of electronic ID accuracy was conducted on 4 farms. Two electronic ID systems were examined for cow ID accuracy by verifying the ID number appearing in the parlor with the corresponding ear tag number. There were no ID errors on 3 of 4 farms tested and only a very small number of errors (3/80) on the fourth farm, indicating that the electronic ID systems used in milking parlors identify cows accurately.
Article
Liner slip or rapid air leakage past the mouthpiece of the milking machine liner is related to high rates of new cases of mastitis. A real time technique was developed to monitor the air flow into the milking machine cluster during liner slips as well as to monitor milking time and milk yield using a commercial type pipeline milking system. The air flow into the cluster was measured by recording the pressure differences across on orifice plate place in the air bypass of an air-milk separator using a differential pressure transducer. Milk yield was recorded by counting the number of milk releases from an electronic milk meter. The release solenoids of the milk meter were linked to a computer. The start and end of milking were manually recorded by switching a twopole switch connected to a digital input card on the computer, which was programmed to record air flow, milk yield, and milking time. Milk yield, milking time, and air flows during liner slips were recorded simultaneously at each milking unit in an 11-unit herringbone parlor. The system was tested with an experiment with a 4 × 4 Latin square design using four treatments (clusters) and four treatment groups (22 cows per group).
Article
Milking machine research has centered upon the relationship of the machine to mastitis in recent years. Survey data from Denmark indicates 6.6% of infections in problem herds were accounted for by milking machine factors. This review indicates that two factors, pulsation failure and the impact mechanism, consistently influence the new infection rate. Pulsation failure may consist of the mechanical failure of the pulsator, shortness of the liner barrel, or too short a rest phase of the liner. These conditions apparently fail to produce an adequate compressive load on the teat tissue to relieve congestion.The impact phenomena result from an abrupt loss of milking vacuum. Irish workers have concentrated on liner design and milking machine parameters including vacuum reserve, pulsation phase, rate and ratio, and the relationship to liner slip frequency. Reverse pressure gradients across the streak canal have been shown to occur at the end of milking with simulated liner slip by Cornell University workers.Developments such as liner shields, valved claws, chamber and flow directional claws, and improved liner design have emerged to counteract the effects of teat end impacts and cross infections. Other machine developments include electronic identification and milk metering. Robotic milking is entering the initial stages of investigation.
Article
Scientific papers estimating economic losses from mastitis were reviewed. Reduced milk production from cows with subclinical mastitis was responsible for the largest losses. Losses from mastitis in the United States in 1976 were estimated by usable responses to a survey from 33 states representing 9.5 million cows or 86% of the dairy cow population. Losses of milk yields caused by mastitis were 386 kg/cow per yr and losses of discarded milk 62 kg/cow per yr. Annual losses per cow from mastitis were a) reduced milk production, 81.32;b)discardedmilk,81.32; b) discarded milk, 12.88; c) cost of veterinary services, 1.97;d)costofdrugs,!3,86;e)increasedlabor,1.97; d) cost of drugs, !3,86; e) increased labor, 2.28; f) decreased sale value, 5.72;g)increasedreplacementcosts,5.72; g) increased replacement costs, 9.32; h) total, 117.35.Forthe11millioncowsintheUnitedStates1976lossesfrommastitiswere117.35. For the 11 million cows in the United States 1976 losses from mastitis were 1.294 billion. Mastitis research was supported publicly at 22 locations under 43 projects. Approximately 24 scientist years were involved and $2.7 million of public funds were expended annually. If economic losses from mastitis were reduced 2% per year for 10 yr by research and expenditures for mastitis research remained the same, the benefit to cost ratio from mastitis research would be approximately 9.6 to 1.
Article
A knowledge-based system for the diagnosis of mastitis problems at the herd level must search for possible causes, including malfunctioning milking machines or incorrect milking technique. A knowledge-based system on general mechanisms of mastitis infection, using hierarchical conditional causal models, was extended. Model building entailed extensive cooperation between the knowledge engineer and a domain expert. The extended knowledge-based system contains 12 submodels underlying the overview models. Nine submodels were concerned with mastitis problems arising from machine milking. These models are briefly described. The knowledge-based system has been validated by other experts after which the models were adjusted slightly. The final knowledge-based system was validated to data collected at 17 commercial dairy farms with high SCC in the bulk milk. Reports containing the farm data were accompanied by recommendations made by a dairy farm advisor. This validation showed good agreement between the knowledge-based system and the dairy farm advisors. The described knowledge-based system is a good tool for dairy farm advisors to solve herd mastitis problems caused by a malfunctioning milking machine or incorrect milking technique.
Accuracy of electronic milk metering devices
  • Hoffman
Update on mastitis. II. The role of the milking machine in mastitis
  • Grindal