Effects of developer exhaustion on the sensitometric properties of four dental films

Department of Oral Radiology, Academic Centre for Dentistry Amsterdam (ACTA), The Netherlands.
Dentomaxillofacial Radiology (Impact Factor: 1.39). 04/1999; 28(2):80-8. DOI: 10.1038/sj/dmfr/4600416
Source: PubMed


To examine the effects of exhaustion of five different processing solutions on the sensitometric properties of four dental X-ray films: Ektaspeed Plus and Ultra-speed (Kodak Eastman Co. Rochester, USA) and new and previous Dentus M2 (Agfa-Gevaert, Mortsel, Belgium).
An aluminum stepwedge was used to construct characteristic curves for the four films. All films were processed manually using three sets of chemicals for manual processing: Agfa (Heraeus Kulzer, Dormagen, Germany), Kodak (Kodak-Pathé, Paris, France) and Demat (Viscopac, Athens, Greece) and two sets for automatic processing: Dürr XR and Periomat (Dürr Dental, Bietigheim-Bissingen, Germany). Film speed and gradient were evaluated until the chemicals were completely exhausted. An analysis of variance was performed separately for each set of chemicals for manual and automatic processing.
Ektaspeed Plus was the fastest film in the manual processing solutions. The new Dentus M2 and Ektaspeed Plus films had similar speed using the chemicals for automatic processing. Ultra-speed had the lowest speed in all solutions, but it had the greatest consistency. Exhaustion of the developer caused a comparable decrease in speed of Ektaspeed Plus and the two Dentus M2 films. In fresh chemistry Agfa was the strongest manual processing solution, but it had the highest exhaustion rate. The Dürr XR chemical was stronger than Periomat over the whole test period.
The combination of film and processing solution is an important factor for achieving constant sensitometric properties. Ektaspeed Plus and the new Dentus M2 film should be used in dental practice, as they require lower exposure and have equivalent or superior properties compared with Ultra-speed.

Download full-text


Available from: P.F. van der Stelt
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Tese (doutorado)—Universidade de Brasília, Faculdade de Ciências da Saúde, 2009. O objetivo desta pesquisa é de avaliar a possibilidade de usar a imagem digital como estimadora das condições de processamento radiográfico automático. Usando filmes radiográficos expostos em um sensitômetro e processados padronizadamente, em 4 temperaturas diferentes no início dos trabalhos semanais de uma Clínica de Radiologia Odontológica, as quais foram digitalizadas e observadas pelo software: Digora for Windows 1.5.1, Digora for Windows 2.5, Gimp 2.2 for Linux e Adobe Photoshop 7.0, quanto às densidades radiográficas, ou seja o nível de cinza, que representa o grau de escurecimento da imagem. As tabelas e gráficos apresentados mostram que existe uma variação do nível de cinza, seja do grau de processamento da imagem nas quatro áreas avaliadas de cada filme e nas quatro temperaturas estudadas que são estatisticamente significantes. Os traçados característicos também mostram estas diferenças e o grau de deterioração da qualidade da imagem pelo desgaste da solução de processamento. Nossos resultados indicam que a avaliação da imagem digital, pelos softwares estudados, são eficientes e permitem o controle de qualidade do processamento radiográfico de forma adequada, mostrando que a variação dos níveis de cinza indicam o desgaste da ação das soluções de processamento, em função do tempo de uso e do aumento do número de filmes processados na rotina da clínica. ________________________________________________________________________________________ ABSTRACT The aim of this study is to evaluate the possibility of using the digital image as estimation of the conditions of automatic radiographic processing. Radiographic films exposed in a sensitometer and processed in a standardized way, at 4 different temperatures, at the beginning of the weekly services of a Dental Radiology Clinic were used. The films were digitized and observed by the software: Digora for Windows 1.5.1, Digora for Windows 2.5, Gimp for Linux 2.2, and Adobe Photoshop 7.0 regarding radiographic densities, that is, the degree of grey, which represents the level of image darkening. The tables and graphs presented show that there is a variation of the grey level, due to the degree of image processing at the four areas evaluated in each film and at the four temperatures studied that are statistically significant. The characteristic tracings also show these differences and the deterioration degree of the image quality due to the wear of the processing solution. Our results indicate that the evaluation of the digital image, by the studied software, is efficient and allow the quality control of the radiographic processing in an appropriate way, showing that the variations of grey level are markers of the wear of the processing solutions action, in function of both the time of use and the increase of the number of films processed in the clinic’s routine.
    Preview · Article ·
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: To compare the diagnostic accuracy for the detection of approximal caries of three dental X-ray films using fresh and aged processing chemicals. Fifty-six extracted unrestored premolars were radiographed under standardized conditions using the new Dentus M2 (Agfa-Gevaert, Mortsel, Belgium), Ektaspeed Plus and Ultra-speed (Kodak Eastman Co, Rochester, USA) dental films. The films were processed manually using Agfa chemicals (Heraeus Kulzer, Dormagen, Germany). The procedure was repeated once a week until the complete exhaustion of the chemicals (6 weeks). Three independent observers assessed 210 radiographs using the following rating scale: 0 = sound, 1 = enamel lesion; 2 = lesion reaching the ADJ; 3 = dentinal lesion. True caries depth was determined by histological examination (14 sound surfaces, 11 enamel lesions, eight lesions reaching the ADJ and 23 dentinal lesions). True caries depth was subtracted from the values given by the observers and an analysis of variance was performed. The null hypothesis was rejected when P < 0.05. No significant differences were found in the diagnostic accuracy between the three films when using chemicals of up to 3 weeks old (P = 0.056). After the third week, Ultra-speed was significantly better than the other two films (P = 0.012). On average caries depth was underestimated. A similar level of diagnostic accuracy for approximal caries is achieved when using the three films. Dentus M2 and Ektaspeed Plus are at present the fastest available films and they should therefore be recommended for clinical practice. Agfa chemicals should be renewed every 3 weeks. Fifty per cent reduction in average gradient is indicative of renewing processing chemicals.
    Full-text · Article · Aug 1999 · Dentomaxillofacial Radiology
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: To examine the effects of developer age on image quality. Endodontic files, size 10 and 15, were placed in upper and lower molars and premolars up to the root apex or 1.5 mm short. A series of radiographs were made with each of three film types: Dentus M2 (Agfa-Gevaert, Mortsel, Belgium), Ektaspeed Plus and Ultra-speed (Kodak Eastman Co, Rochester, USA). The films were processed bi-weekly using the same Agfa chemicals (Heraeus Kulzer, Dormagen, Germany) over a 6-week period. An additional set of Dentus M2 films was processed using Periomat chemicals (Dürr Dental, Bietigheim-Bissingen, Germany). The films were viewed by eight dentists who rated the position of the tip of the file using a 5-point confidence scale. ROC data were analysed by means of analysis of variance. Az value was the dependent variable, whereas observer age group was entered as between subject factor. The null hypothesis was rejected when P<0.05. The diagnostic accuracies of the three films were comparable during the first 4 weeks. In the sixth week Ultra-speed was significantly better than the other two films (P=0.046). The Periomat chemicals showed significantly greater consistency than the Agfa chemicals (P=0.004). Developer exhaustion significantly affected the performance of the older observers (P=0.008), especially when Agfa chemicals and file size 10 were used. Agfa chemicals older than 4 weeks significantly affect the assessment of endodontic file length. In earlier stages there are no significant differences between the three films tested. Dentus M2 and Ektaspeed Plus films should be used as they require lower exposures.
    Full-text · Article · Oct 1999 · Dentomaxillofacial Radiology
Show more