ArticlePDF Available

The Impact of Past Relationships on Interpersonal Behavior: Behavioral Confirmation in the Social–Cognitive Process of Transference

American Psychological Association
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
Authors:
Michele Berk at Stanford University
Michele Berk
Susan M. Andersen
Susan M. Andersen
Susan M. Andersen
  • This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract and Figures

This study extended research on transference in social perception (e.g., S. M. Andersen, I. Reznik, & L. M. Manzella, 1996) into the realm of social behavior by examining behavioral confirmation (e.g., M. Snyder, 1992) in transference. Each perceiver participated in a brief conversation with a naive target participant, who either did or did not appear to resemble the perceiver's own positively or negatively regarded significant other. Trained judges rated positive affect expressed in targets' behavior. As predicted, targets expressed more positive affect in their behavior when they allegedly resembled the perceiver's own positively versus negatively toned significant other, an effect not found in the control condition. This evidence demonstrates behavioral confirmation in transference, suggesting a means by which present relationships may resemble past ones.
Figures - uploaded by Michele Berk
Author content
All figure content in this area was uploaded by Michele Berk
Content may be subject to copyright.
Content uploaded by Michele Berk
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Michele Berk on Dec 30, 2015
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
A preview of this full-text is provided by American Psychological Association.
Learn more
Content available from Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
... Although this conception of RS is clearly relevant to the attachment construct, it is more specific and precise in its definition, operations, and predictions (for a more complete discussion of the relation of RS to attachment and attributional approaches, see Ayduk et al., in press;Downey & Feldman, 1996;Downey, Lebolt, Rincon, & Freitas, 1998;Feldman & Downey, 1994). Thus, the RS model is consistent with efforts in social cognition over the past decade to develop precise, testable accounts of the content, structure, organization, and dynamics of internal working models (Andersen et al., 1996;Baldwin, 1999;Berk & Andersen, 2000;Collins & Read, 1994;Reis & Downey, 1999). ...
Regulating the Interpersonal Self: Strategic Self-Regulation for Coping With Rejection Sensitivity
Article
Full-text available
  • Nov 2000
People high in rejection sensitivity (RS) anxiously expect rejection and are at risk for interpersonal and personal distress. Two studies examined the role of self-regulation through strategic attention deployment in moderating the link between RS and maladaptive outcomes. Self-regulation was assessed by the delay of gratification (DG) paradigm in childhood. In Study 1, preschoolers from the Stanford University community who participated in the DG paradigm were assessed 20 years later. Study 2 assessed low-income, minority middle school children on comparable measures. DG ability buffered high-RS people from interpersonal difficulties (aggression, peer rejection) and diminished well-being (e.g., low self-worth, higher drug use). The protective effect of DG ability on high-RS children's self-worth is explained by reduced interpersonal problems. Attentional mechanisms underlying the interaction between RS and strategic self-regulation are discussed.
View
... With the triggering of a significant-other representation come shifts in the "relational self"-that is, changes in attention, affect, motivation, and behavior that reflect the self that one becomes when with the significant other (e.g., Hinkley & Andersen, 1996). These shifts can occur in everyday encounters, often unconsciously, leading to feelings of liking or disliking a new person who has triggered the mental representation, wanting to be close to or distant from this person, expecting acceptance or rejection, and even eliciting behavior in the new person that is consistent with the activated significant-other representation (e.g., Berk & Andersen, 2000)-in other words, eliciting behavior in the new other consistent with how the significant other is expected to act. Such expectancies, resulting from the activation of a network of implicit self-other relational procedures, is very much in keeping with our theorizing about organizing patterns and their impact on subjectivity and behavior. ...
View
... In doing so, the recipient's perspective is adopted and new aspects of the gift experience are explored, thus opening a new area of inquiry and contributing to a "relational" view of gift giving, which has traditionally focused on the giver-recipient and, only recently, on giver-brand viewpoints (Eggert et al., 2019). Second, literature on interpersonal relationships has typically investigated the process of transference within interpersonal encounters (e.g., when interacting with a "new" relationship partner; Andersen et al., 1995;Baldwin, 1992;Berk & Andersen, 2000;Horberg & Chen, 2010;Kraus & Chen, 2009, Horberg & Chen, 2010Przybylinski & Andersen, 2015). By identifying a consumer-relevant phenomenon in which the process of transference occurs, we suggest that transference might affect a broader spectrum of aspects within individuals' lives, thus paving new avenues for future research. ...
The Influence of Interpersonal Relationships on Brand‐related Behaviors for Gifted Brands
Article
  • Jun 2022
The present work studies a novel perspective on gift‐giving research by examining the effect of the giver–recipient relationship on the recipient–brand relationship. A study examining gift exchanges in real‐life relationships and two laboratory experiments demonstrate that the effect of the recipient’s relationship satisfaction with the gift giver on self‐brand connections and, consequently, on brand‐related behaviors is conditional on the durability of the gift. The findings are robust to manipulating the durability of the same product category and using durable and nondurable categories of the same (actual or fictitious) brand. This research offers important implications for managers who position their brands as desirable gifts.
View
... This effect is even found in the type of facial expressions made by participants when reading a description; facial affect is positive when the significant other target is positive, negative when the significant other target is negative, and no effect is found with neutral, control targets (Andersen et al., 1996). When engaged in conversations with a target that resembled a significant other, participants were judged as displaying more positive behavior toward the positively valenced target and more negative behavior toward the negatively valenced target (as assessed via tone of voice and emotional expressions; Berk & Andersen, 2000). ...
Proof of Concept and Moderators of Transference Processes in an Online Setting
Article
Full-text available
  • Jun 2021
Previous research examining transference – which posits people draw on past experiences with close others to inform novel interactions – has found that people attribute qualities to and express preferences for novel targets based on their similarity to significant others. However, classic tasks for testing transference required multiple sessions over many weeks, limiting the test of this process to relatively small, college student samples. The purpose of the current study (N = 532, Mage = 34.81, SD = 9.83, 61.47% Men, 63.35% White) was to create an online version of a transference task administered in one session and replicate the effect of transference with a larger sample of participants across the lifespan, and test whether targets resembling parents and ex-partners were preferable to control targets. The effects of transference and preference were replicated in the online version of the transference task. We also found preliminary evidence that the effects of transference and preference were slightly stronger in older individuals and secure individuals, albeit the effects were small. Results are discussed in the context of how individuals use previous and existing relationships to guide their behavior in new relationships.
View
The Humbling Effect of Significant Relationships: A Field Experiment Examining the Effect of Significant-Other Activation on Leaders’ Expressed Humility
Article
  • Mar 2024
Recent research has consistently highlighted the benefits of leader humility within organizations. However, much less is known about how leader humility can be contextually promoted beyond individual predispositions. This paper draws from the social-cognitive model of transference to illuminate how the contextual activation of significant-other schemas can enhance a leader’s expressed humility in the workplace. Specifically, we propose that the activation of significant-other schemas can lead to increased interpersonal warmth and psychological safety among leaders, which in turn, promote humility in their interactions with followers. Furthermore, we posit that these effects are amplified in leaders who possess a strong relational identity. To test our hypotheses, we conducted a field experiment with 97 leaders and their 194 followers, where we randomly applied daily significant-other activation interventions to the leaders and surveyed the leaders and their corresponding followers across 10 consecutive workdays. Our findings provide support for the positive impact of significant-other schema activation on leader humility and confirm the moderating role of a leader’s relational identity. We discuss the theoretical and practical implications of our findings. Funding: This research was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China [Grants 72022022 and 72332009] and the John Templeton Foundation [Grant 62265] entitled “Applied Research on Intellectual Humility.” Supplemental Material: The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.2023.17377 .
View
View
The Relationship Context of Human Behavior and Development
Article
Full-text available
  • Nov 2000
The influence of social relationships on human development and behavior is receiving increased attention from psychologists, who are central contributors to the rapidly developing multidisciplinary field of relationship science. In this article, the authors selectively review some of the significant strides that have been made toward understanding the effects of relationships on development and behavior and the processes by which relationships exert their influence on these, with the purpose of highlighting important questions that remain to be answered, controversial issues that need to be resolved, and potentially profitable paths for future inquiry. The authors' thesis is that important advances in psychological knowledge will be achieved from concerted investigation of the relationship context in which most important human behaviors are developed and displayed.
View
View
Exploring, measuring and explaining negative attitudes to own future old age
Thesis
  • Jan 2002
p>There is an urgent need to understand the factors that can influence health and well-being in later years; one such factor is the level of unfavourability adults associate with their own ageing and future old age. Given the potential for age-associated attitudes to impact adversely on health, particularly when negative, it was surprising that so little research has been carried out in this field. This thesis contributes to current knowledge in three main ways: by exploring, measuring and explaining adults’ attitudes to potentially negative and threatening aspects of their own ageing and future old age. Empirical research is reported from four main studies involving more than 3000 participants, including samples recruited personally from major cities in both the UK and the US. In exploring age-associated attitudes, results suggest: a) that negative attitudes can be understood in relation to the level of threat adults associate with their own future old age, b) that those threats cross physical, social and psychological aspects of later life, and c) that such threats can be further understood in terms of the ability of the individual to minimise losses, manage constraints and create positive gains. Replicated across sample groups, results also indicate that the ten new measures developed through this thesis do make a valuable contribution to the current field because: 1) a number of researchers have noted the paucity and inadequacy of measures in this field (e.g. Wullschleger et al, 1996), 2) the newly developed measures are short, easy to score and simple to interpret, and 3) replicated across sample groups, these measures have good psychometric properties, including good internal reliability and validity. Finally, results indicate that attachment-related variables provided the best explanation for age-associated attitudes; specifically, a model is proposed consistent with the view that experiences in early relationships influence current representations of self and others and current coping strategies, which in turn influence negative age-associated attitudes. Rival variables such as neuroticism and expected financial status did not add to the fit of the model.</p
View
Evolution of a "Classic" Psychoanalytic Institute: Escape From Rome
Article
  • Mar 2021
The author describes the evolution of theory and practice at the New York Psychoanalytic Society and Institute. The core concepts at the Institute have included the importance of unconscious fantasy, conflict and compromise theory, transference and countertransference, and defense analysis. In recent years, a variety of contemporary analytic theories have been incorporated into the theory and practice of the Institute. The importance of systematized research to theory development and practice is stressed.
View
Close Partner as Sculptor of the Ideal Self: Behavioral Affirmation and the Michelangelo Phenomenon
Article
Full-text available
  • Aug 1999
This work incorporates concepts from the behavioral confirmation tradition, self tradition, and interdependence tradition to identify an interpersonal process termed the Michelangelo phenomenon. The Michelangelo phenomenon describes the means by which the self is shaped by a close partner's perceptions and behavior. Specifically, self movement toward the ideal self is described as a product of partner affirmation, or the degree to which a partner's perceptions of the self and behavior toward the self are congruent with the self's ideal. The results of 4 studies revealed strong associations between perceived partner affirmation and self movement toward the ideal self, using a variety of participant populations and measurement methods. In addition, perceived partner affirmation—particularly perceived partner behavioral affirmation—was strongly associated with quality of couple functioning and stability in ongoing relationships.
View
Models of the Self: Self-Construals and Gender
Article
Full-text available
  • Jul 1997
The authors first describe individual differences in the structure of the self. In the independent self-construal, representations of others are separate from the self. In the interdependent self-construal, others are considered part of the self (H. Markus & S. Kitayama, 1991). In general, men in the United States are thought to construct and maintain an independent self-construal, whereas women are thought to construct and maintain an interdependent self-construal. The authors review the psychological literature to demonstrate that many gender differences in cognition, motivation, emotion, and social behavior may be explained in terms of men’s and women’s different self-construals. Recognition of the interdependent self-construal as a possible alternative conception of the self may stimulate new investigations into the ways the self influences a person’s thinking, feeling, and behaving.
View
Transference in Social Perception: The Role of Chronic Accessibility in Significant-Other Representations
Article
Full-text available
  • Jul 1995
Research has shown that the activation and application of a significant-other representation to a new person, or transference, occurs in everyday social perception (S. M. Andersen & A. Baum, 1994; S. M. Andersen & S. W. Cole, 1990). Using a combined idiographic and nomothetic experimental paradigm, two studies examined the role of chronic accessibility of significant-other representations in transference. After learning about 4 fictional people, 1 of whom resembled a significant other, participants' recognition memory was assessed. Both studies showed greater false-positive memory in the significant-other condition, relative to control, even in the absence of priming. Study 2 showed that although the effect was greater when the significant-other representation was concretely applicable to the target information, it occurred even when no such applicability was present. Results implicate the chronic accessibility of significant-other representations in transference.
View
“Do I Know You?”: The Role of Significant Others in General Social Perception
Article
Full-text available
  • Sep 1990
This research used an idiographic method to examine the proposition that significant others are mentally represented as well-organized person categories that can influence social perception even more than representations of nonsignificant others, stereotypes, or traits. Together, Studies 1 and 2 showed that significant-other representations are richer, more distinctive, and more cognitively accessible than the other categories. Study 3 replicated the accessibility data and gauged inferential power by indirectly activating each category in a learning trial about a fictional person and then testing recognition memory. The results showed that participants made more category-consistent false-positive errors about targets who activated significant others vs. any other category. This constitutes the first experimental demonstration of transference and has implications both for social categorization and for basic personality processes.
View
The Goal of Forming Accurate Impressions During Social Interactions: Attenuating the Impact of Negative Expectancies
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 1989
Investigated the idea that impression formation goals may regulate the impact that perceiver expectancies have on social interactions. In simulated interviews, interviewer Ss were given a negative expectancy about one applicant S and no expectancy about another. Half the interviewers were encouraged to form accurate impressions; the others were not. As predicted, no-goal interviewers exhibited a postinteraction impression bias against the negative-expectancy applicants, whereas the accuracy-goal interviewers did not. Moreover, the ability of the accuracy goal to reduce this bias was apparently mediated by more extensive and less biased interviewer information-gathering, which in turn elicited an improvement in negative-expectancy applicants' performances. These findings stress the theoretical and practical importance of considering the motivational context within which expectancy-tinged social interactions occur.
View
The Additive Nature of Chronic and Temporary Sources of Construct Accessibility
Article
Full-text available
  • May 1986
Both temporary and long-term sources of construct accessibility have been found to play an important role in person perception and memory. Yet the two effects heretofore have been studied in isolation from each other. We examined the joint influence of long- and short-term sources of accessibility on impression formation. Subjects with or without a long-term, chronically accessible construct for either kindness or shyness were exposed subliminally to either 0 or 80 trait-related words in a first task. Next, subjects read a behavioral description that was ambiguously relevant to the primed trait dimension, and they then rated the target on several trait scales. For both the kind and the shy trait conditions, both chronic accessibility and subliminal priming reliably and independently increased the extremity of the impression ratings. The results supported a model in which long- and short-term sources of accessibility combine additively to increase the likelihood of the construct's use. Moreover, the subliminal priming effect appeared to be a quite general and pervasive phenomenon, insofar as it occurred for both an evaluatively positive and an evaluatively neutral trait dimension and for subjects without as well as with a chronically accessible construct for the primes. Implications of these findings for the nature of construct accessibility and the generality of automatic influences on social perception are discussed.
View
View
View
View
View