Creating a Peaceful School Learning Environment: A Controlled Study of an Elementary School Intervention to Reduce Violence

Waialae Elementary School, Topeka, Kansas, United States
American Journal of Psychiatry (Impact Factor: 12.3). 06/2001; 158(5):808-10. DOI: 10.1176/appi.ajp.158.5.808
Source: PubMed


The impact of a manual-based antiviolence program on the learning climate in an elementary school over 4 years was compared with the outcome in a control school.
The two schools were matched for demographic characteristics. The intervention in the experimental school was based on zero tolerance for bullying; the control school received only regular psychiatric consultation. Disciplinary and academic achievement data were collected in both schools.
The experimental school showed significant reductions in discipline referrals and increases in scores on standardized academic achievement measures.
A low-cost antiviolence intervention that does not focus on individual pathology or interfere with the educational process may improve the learning environment in elementary schools.

Download full-text


Available from: Peter Fonagy, Sep 14, 2015
  • Source
    • "Major questions are at hand, though few receiving definitive answers in the present report. These include: (1) Is the RNT method feasible with children past preschool age? (2) Does the RNT method applied within a school affect school climate as defined by Twemlow et al. (2001) Wilson (2004) and The Department of Education and Skills (2007)? (3) Does RNT-induced school climate change correlate with a child's cognitive and emotional development? "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Expanding the utility of Reflective Network Therapy (RNT) schoolwide and to school pupils far beyond preschool age is now occurring. The process encouraged my integration of several psychoanalytic theories, as well as shed light on the unique dynamics of classroom life. Several psychoanalytic concepts germane to dyadic interaction are reviewed and new approaches are brought into new light by exploring the multiperson world of the school classroom teacher. Reflective Network Schools (RNS) can serve as vehicles for creating spaces in today's classrooms for both investigation and application of various psychoanalytic orientations. The model used shows how a few basic tenets of psychoanalytic thinking allowed a lay analyst to rediscover many theorists who followed Freud's discovery. With the use of its time-tested method in new ways, along with the inception of an article series starting here, RNT has a wider clinical and academic scope than previously expected. When I became a child analyst in the 1960s, there was nearly a line around the block waiting for my intensive treatment in the form of four-and five-times-a-week analytic sessions and, customarily, a weekly parent guidance session. Few child analysts have that in-demand experience today. The decline of demand for child analysis, despite enormous numbers of children in need, is caused by many factors. Among them are financial barriers, logistic difficulty, insufficient numbers of practitioners, and scientific outcome collection obstacles. The treatment is expensive and the logistics of bringing a child to treatment multiple times a week are daunting to many modern families. A full-scale child analysis is financially out of the reach of most of the population in need. It is not a treatment that most third-party payers will fully support. That is partly because the profession has not achieved the scientific credibility, feasibility, and outcome research it richly deserves. Even if demand for child analytic treatment were as great as it should be, there are insufficient numbers of practitioners to meet a greater demand. Relevant to the following article, U.S. professional training lacks widespread and affordable pathways for engaging and training young child analytic practitioners. Little hope exists to engage and train child psychiatrists as child analysts. Recruiting for child psychiatric jobs is the most difficult of all medical recruiting tasks and the small profession of child psychiatry is mostly prescription-oriented. Perhaps this is because insurance will not pay for psychotherapy at medical rates. Nonmedical child analysts are also in short supply. There are probably fewer than 3,000 nonmedical child analysts in the world trained sufficiently to receive child analytic certifications from the
    Full-text · Article · Oct 2015 · Psychoanalytic Inquiry
    • "therapy when the client ' s immediate experience is hunger , or educational reintegration when the immediate concern is about threatened legal culpability for a recent offence . Equally , in developed settings , a large multidisciplinary " team around the child " often gathers , offering the promise of specialist multi - domain interventions ( see Twemlow et al . , 2001 ) . However , paradoxically , this may challenge a young person whose capacity simulta - neously to develop not just one , but numerous trusting relationships with different profes - sionals is severely limited . While biologically we are all prepared to create bonds with multiple caregivers , this generic process inevitably becomes con"
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Adolescent Mentalization-Based Integrative Treatment (AMBIT) is a developing approach to working with "hard-to-reach" youth burdened with multiple co-occurring morbidities. This article reviews the core features of AMBIT, exploring applications of attachment theory to understand what makes young people "hard to reach," and provide routes toward increased security in their attachment to a worker. Using the theory of the pedagogical stance and epistemic ("pertaining to knowledge") trust, we show how it is the therapeutic worker's accurate mentalizing of the adolescent that creates conditions for new learning, including the establishment of alternative (more secure) internal working models of helping relationships. This justifies an individual keyworker model focused on maintaining a mentalizing stance toward the adolescent, but simultaneously emphasizing the critical need for such keyworkers to remain well connected to their wider team, avoiding activation of their own attachment behaviors. We consider the role of AMBIT in developing a shared team culture (shared experiences, shared language, shared meanings), toward creating systemic contexts supportive of such relationships. We describe how team training may enhance the team's ability to serve as a secure base for keyworkers, and describe an innovative approach to treatment manualization, using a wiki format as one way of supporting this process.
    No preview · Article · Mar 2015 · Attachment & Human Development
  • Source
    • "On the basis of these results, an intervention aimed at modeling adolescents' habitual attitudes towards the phenomenon of school violence could significantly reduce violent episodes (Zun, Downey, & Rosen, 2004). However, most of the programs aimed at prevention of bullying follow a global approach like that proposed by Olweus (1993, 1996, 2005), requiring a multidisciplinary approach, as well as its integration in the study plans, and this could be complex and expensive for most school centers (Farrell, Meyer, & White, 2001; Olweus, 1996; Twemlow et al., 2001). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: There is growing interest in the phenomenon of school violence, which has been associated in diverse works with youth's attitudes towards violence, and it has been the focus of many intervention programs. However, the high human and economic cost entailed can impede its administration in some school centers. Therefore, the goal of the present study is to assess the efficacy of a brief intervention aimed at modifying attitudes towards violence to reduce the phenomenon of school bullying. The sample was obtained from a Secondary Education Institute during the 2010–2011 school term, and was made up of 252 students aged between 12 and 15 years. A controlled and randomized design was used in order to assess the effects of the program “Count on Me.” Ten classrooms were randomly assigned either to the intervention or to a waiting-list. Results show a significant reduction of playground violence perceived by the students, especially among the girls. Implications for the development of future brief programs for the prevention of school violence are discussed.
    Full-text · Article · Sep 2013 · Children and Youth Services Review
Show more