ArticlePDF AvailableLiterature Review

Legal Aspects of Telepathology

Authors:
  • Dierks+Company

Abstract

In some legal surroundings telepathology is considered a breach of registrational barriers. The recommendation of the G 8 states in Europe for required legislation in telemedicine suggests to recognise that the localization of the remote health care professional defines the site not only of licensure but also of liability. This approach must be considered helpful, since it can solve many problems brought about by the doubtful results of private international law and conventions like the European Union (EU) and Lugano Convention. Under today's conditions in private international law it must be considered essential to agree upon a choice of law and stipulate a court of jurisdiction when doing telepathology. However, the opposing aims of insuring the patients claims and avoiding jurisdictions that exceed the local expectations of the medical professional must be reconciled. Data protection and data security are other crucial topics that require attention. Generally speaking, the principles of minimum data exchange, anonymity, pseudonymity and cryptography must be established as a basis for all telepathology procedures. Only when personal data is needed, its use can be legitimated. Written consent of the patient is advised. To guarantee a cross-border security level the regulations of the EU-Data Protection Directive need to be transformed into national law. In practise, cross-border dataflow shall only take place where the security level can be maintained even within the other country. Finally, reimbursement questions must be answered to establish a sound economical basis for telepathology. The spatial distance between the participants may yield the question, whether the service has been rendered to an extent necessary and sufficient for reimbursement. If reimbursement takes place on a cross-border or cross-regional level, severe disturbances of the health systems can occur. Regulation schemes or treaties need therefore to be developed to avoid such disturbances and encompass mutual standards of care as well as methods to balance reimbursement.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... In terms of professional liability, telemedicine services are comparable to any diagnostictherapeutic health service considering that it does not replace the traditional health service but integrates the latter to improve its effectiveness, efficiency, and appropriateness. Hence, the health service mediated by ICT is normally considered equal to the service provided in traditional forms [29,30]. Despite the importance of the doctor-patient relationship, malpractice, standardization of adopted practices, and economic reimbursement in telemedicine [31], these issues have not yet been received and analyzed by the community that deals with tele-orthopedics. ...
Article
Full-text available
The use of technologies in medicine has great potential to reduce the costs of health care services by making appropriate decisions that provide timely patient care. The evolution of telemedicine poses a series of clinical and medicolegal considerations. However, only a few articles have dealt with telemedicine and orthopedics. This review assesses the ethical and medicolegal issues related to tele-orthopedics. A systematic review was performed including papers published between 2017 and 2021 focusing on the main medicolegal and clinical-governance aspects of tele-orthopedics. Most of the articles were published during the COVID-19 pandemic, confirming the impetus that the pandemic has also given to the spread of telemedicine in the orthopedic field. The areas of interest dealt with in the scientific evidence, almost exclusively produced in the USA, Europe, the UK, and Canada, are quality, patient satisfaction, and safety. The impact of telemedicine in orthopedics has not yet been fully evaluated and studied in terms of the potential medicolegal concerns. Most of the authors performed qualitative studies with poor consistency. Authorizations and accreditations, protection of patient confidentiality, and professional responsibility are issues that will certainly soon emerge.
... The quality of care a sleep centre provides is mainly determined by individual patient management over the long term, including continuing efforts to maintain optimal CPAP therapy, rapid detection of low compliance and personalised consideration of alternatives to CPAP where appropriate [154,155]. Telemedicine offers possibilities to diagnose and follow-up OSA patients [156][157][158][159][160][161][162][163][164][165][166], but several open questions, including ethics, data ownership, prescription, storage, usage and reimbursement issues, slow down its implementation [156]. It remains unclear if telemedicine can replace direct patient-nurse contact and/or permit better treatment customisation [167][168][169]. ...
Article
Obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA) is a major challenge for physicians and healthcare systems throughout the world. The high prevalence and the impact on daily life of OSA oblige clinicians to offer effective and acceptable treatment options. However, recent evidence has raised questions about the benefits of positive airway pressure therapy in ameliorating comorbidities. An international expert group considered the current state of knowledge based on the most relevant publications in the previous 5 years, discussed the current challenges in the field, and proposed topics for future research on epidemiology, phenotyping, underlying mechanisms, prognostic implications and optimal treatment of patients with OSA. The group concluded that a revision to the diagnostic criteria for OSA is required to include factors that reflect different clinical and pathophysiological phenotypes and relevant comorbidities (e.g. nondipping nocturnal blood pressure). Furthermore, current severity thresholds require revision to reflect factors such as the disparity in the apnoea–hypopnoea index (AHI) between polysomnography and sleep studies that do not include sleep stage measurements, in addition to the poor correlation between AHI and daytime symptoms such as sleepiness. Management decisions should be linked to the underlying phenotype and consider outcomes beyond AHI.
... 17 In addition to the discussed concerns, several issues should be considered before the implementation of telemedicine 18 and also the telepathology system. 19 One of these issues is the financial and insurance reimbursement matters that are the major topics in the field of telemedicine and have a large share in the nonproliferating the use of this technology in some countries, especially Iran. This means that there are no rules and guidelines that determine which side, the service recipient, or service provider must pay the cost of the service provided, and also no insurance company attempts to reimburse telehealth services yet. ...
Article
Full-text available
Static telepathology is one of the telepathology methods, in which the captured images of the slides are transmitted for consultation at a later time. This study aimed to compare the diagnostic accuracy of the conventional pathology and static telepathology systems. Eighty-two cases that had been selected randomly from 4 pathology centers in the city of Kerman were diagnosed by a pathologist, first based on light microscopy and then after 2 months based on static images (2 images per case) captured by a Nikon 50i microscopic camera. The images were sent to the pathologist via e-mail. The diagnostic accuracy of the telepathology system was calculated. The light microscopic diagnoses were concordant with the telepathologic diagnoses in 71 of 82 reviewed cases. Different diagnoses of 7 cases were due to the images captured from the inappropriate location of the slides. The diagnostic accuracy of the telepathology system was 86.5%. The results of this study showed that static telepathology is very accurate and can be widely used in Iran. However, efficient implementation and use of telepathology require paying attention to different issues such as educational, legal, ethical, financial, and security and observance of the standards related to this field.
... The quality of care a sleep centre provides is mainly determined by individual patient management over the long term, including continuing efforts to maintain optimal CPAP therapy, rapid detection of low compliance and personalised consideration of alternatives to CPAP where appropriate [154,155]. Telemedicine offers possibilities to diagnose and follow-up OSA patients [156][157][158][159][160][161][162][163][164][165][166], but several open questions, including ethics, data ownership, prescription, storage, usage and reimbursement issues, slow down its implementation [156]. It remains unclear if telemedicine can replace direct patient-nurse contact and/or permit better treatment customisation [167][168][169]. ...
Article
Obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA) is a major challenge for physicians and healthcare systems throughout the world. The high prevalence and the impact on daily life of OSA oblige clinicians to offer effective and acceptable treatment options. However, recent evidence has raised questions about the benefits of positive airway pressure therapy in ameliorating comorbidities. An international expert group considered the current state of knowledge based on the most relevant publications in the previous 5 years, discussed the current challenges in the field, and proposed topics for future research on epidemiology, phenotyping, underlying mechanisms, prognostic implications and optimal treatment of patients with OSA. The group concluded that a revision to the diagnostic criteria for OSA is required to include factors that reflect different clinical and pathophysiological phenotypes and relevant comorbidities ( e.g. nondipping nocturnal blood pressure). Furthermore, current severity thresholds require revision to reflect factors such as the disparity in the apnoea–hypopnoea index (AHI) between polysomnography and sleep studies that do not include sleep stage measurements, in addition to the poor correlation between AHI and daytime symptoms such as sleepiness. Management decisions should be linked to the underlying phenotype and consider outcomes beyond AHI.
... The quality of care a sleep centre provides is mainly determined by individual patient management over the long-term, including continuing efforts to maintain optimal CPAP therapy, rapid detection of low compliance, and personalised consideration of alternatives to CPAP where appropriate (151,152). Telemedicine offers possibilities to diagnose and follow-up OSA patients (153)(154)(155)(156)(157)(158)(159)(160)(161)(162)(163), but several open questions including ethics, data ownership, prescription, storage, usage, and reimbursement issues slow down their implementation (153). It remains unclear if telemedicine can replace direct patient-nurse contact and/or permit better treatment customisation (164)(165)(166). ...
... For store-and-forward encounters that may use digital images of patients for the purpose of rendering a diagnosis or medical opinion, without the presence of the patient, this has been proved feasible for some specialties, like radiology (teleradiology), pathology (telepathology), and dermatology (teledermatology). 110,111 Sleep electroencephalography and polysomnography can also have the interpretation performed remotely. 44 However, in telemedicine with more complex patient/physician encounters using electronic communication and electronic patient records with personally identifiable data, this will be a less achievable goal. ...
Article
Full-text available
Telemedicine as a means of remote patient-physician interaction is growing and virtual consultations with sleep specialists are feasible. Potential benefits of telemedicine include improved access to health care, reduced waiting time for appointments, and increased adherence to treatment plans. Telematic communications and new information technologies could also be useful to establish diagnostic and therapeutic strategies. It is important to install cost-efficient technologies for an initial simple diagnosis, rapid treatment initiation and for long-term monitoring of treatment adherence and compliance. Diagnostic telemedicine applications include telemonitored polysomnography, long-term polygraphic monitoring, and remote continuous positive airway pressure titration and monitoring.
Article
Background The COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 posed significant communication challenges, especially in the healthcare sector. Telepathology provides a valuable means for healthcare providers to communicate. This study investigated the key challenges and benefits of telepathology in education through a systematic review of relevant studies conducted during this period. Methods This systematic review was conducted in 2022. We utilized databases, including PubMed, Google Scholar and ScienceDirect. Our search was performed from 7 February 2022 to 13 February 2022. We selected articles based on inclusion criteria and used the Critical Appraisal Skills Program checklist to assess study strengths and limitations. We extracted data using a checklist and synthesized the results narratively. Results We initially identified 125 articles, and after screening, 15 were included in the study. These studies reported various challenges, including cost, technology, communication problems, educational difficulties, time wasting, legal issues and family distraction problems. Conversely, studies mentioned benefits, such as care improvement, better education, time efficiency, proper communication, cost and technology advancement. Conclusions The results of this study will help future efforts and investigations to implement and set up telepathology. Based on our review, despite the challenges, the benefits of telepathology in education are greater than these obstacles, indicating its potential for future use.
Chapter
Digital image capture, storage, searching, retrieval, processing, and manipulation are surveyed. These are detailed by describing how to select suitable digital camera, perform digital photomicrography, and process digital images. Medical applications include education, telepathology aided by automated slide scanners, computer-assisted image analysis of immunohistochemical specimens, and quality assurance and control in histopathology. Image formats and commonly encountered limitations of digital photography and photomicrography are described. Documentation includes listings of suppliers of camera-to-microscope couplers, digital still cameras, slide scanners, and image-processing software. Signal-to-noise (S/N) ratio. Abbreviations of image formats are shown in Tab.2.
Article
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to find the key innovative principles for evaluating the long-term care (LTC) cloud system by exploring contradictory and complex points in its development. Design/methodology/approach The theory of inventive problem solving (TRIZ) and the decision-making trial and evaluation laboratory (DEMATEL) approaches are integrated to resolve complex contradictions in the system. The heuristic reasoning of TRIZ is applied to obtain innovation principles for an LTC cloud mining system. However, the importance and feasibility of these innovative principles require further assessment. In this study, DEMATEL is employed to clarify the complex relationships among the principles and evaluate their key influences. Findings This paper identifies six primary contradictions and derives 25 innovative principles for the resolution of these conflicts. Further analysis confirms three key innovative principles. First, the government should consider the overall planning of the cloud system platform, followed by the participation of other medical and LTC institutions. Second, the information capability of LTC institutions should be unified by recording the pathology data of care recipients to create an information exchange system. Third, LTC institutions should act in cooperation with medical institutions to provide professional medical capabilities. Originality/value The contributions of this paper are two-fold. First, this study provides an integrated methodology integrating the TRIZ and DEMATEL approaches to resolve LTC problems. Second, this research identifies the key innovative principles for developing an LTC cloud system in Taiwan.
Article
Background: Telepathology is the work of a pathologist at a distance. It is useful to distinguish two applications, namely on-line and off-line telepathology. Several field tests have been shown that this technology can be successfully applied in frozen section services, remote control measurements, expert consultations, training and education. What is to be expected from this technology in the future? Technology and pathology disciplines: Frozen section service is an interactive end-to-end diagnostic discipline with contemporary visual and acoustic information transfer. The commercially available systems will probably become integrated into pathology documentation systems, and to be integrated into teaching and training systems. Interdisciplinary connection (for example with radiology or endoscopy) is on the way. These systems will probably remain stationary in contrast to expert consultation and training systems. The trend in expert consultation directs to off-line consultation, mainly by use of the internet. The new generation of cellular phones will provide non-stationary data transfer and will permit a closer integration of expert teleconsultation into the workflow of diagnostic pathology. It will be combined with visual data bases allowing first step diagnosis with integrated image sources. Allocation with other medical fields will construct multidimensional image data bases with strict timing in terms of final diagnosis and access to information spread into the internet (electronic publication). Thus, off-line teleconsultation will be one point in a multidimensional telepathology system which can be projected on different scales such as expert consultation, on-the-spot diagnosis, telemeasurements, education, or publication. Teleeducation and training systems will, again, become distributed by the internet and be connected with interactive TV systems which might be located at home or in transportation vehicles (cars, trains, airplanes). Information connection and time schedules: Computer networking is now to be installed between numerous European research centers to be connected by broad band connections. Large university pathology institutions will have access to these lines at reasonable costs in contrast to small institutions which will have to rely on ISDN lines, wireless connections or powerline information transfer. It can be expected that new technologies will increase the gap between large and small institutions giving enormous technical advantages to large institutions. This process has already started in large cities (for example Berlin) although real new pathology applications are still missing. It can be foreseen that within the next five years expert consultation systems will be handled by large institutions to be accessible for diagnostic support by small pathology institutes within Europe. Outlook: Telepathology has already started to become a routine tool in various institutes of pathology. It is no more only a replacement of missing experts or non-available pathologists at locations of surgery. It has already opened a new technology door giving chances for the combination of research, diagnosis, education and publication in pathology, i.e., we will step into a new world of pathology.
Article
The legal aspects of telecommunication are discussed briefly. Telepathology induces no new legal conditions; however, due to its somewhat higher diagnostic error rate specific problems may occur. Both the pathologist and hospital should clarify the internal liability conditions. The pathologist should be aware that he is still liable for errors induced by the technician, even without having the possibility of responsibility or any supervision.
Article
Visual telecommunication (telepathology) was applied for expert consultation in intra-operative frozen sections and tumor classification of paraffin-embedded, poorly differentiated bronchial carcinoma. The Institute of Pathology, Hospital Baumgartnerhöhe, Vienna and the Department of Pathology, Thoraxklinik, Heidelberg transmitted histological images by use of commercially available computerized modems (VP 2000) and conventional telephone lines. The expert consultation of the frozen sections included the clinical history, macroscopic findings and problems of final judgement of the images. Additional useful information could be obtained in about 35% of cases, and comprised expansion of differential diagnosis, certainty of final diagnosis, and side findings, such as concurrent inflammation, sarcoid-like lesions, etc. The time required for intra-operative diagnosis was 6-10 min. Cases of the Austrian-German quality control study on lung cancer with divergent tumor classification were discussed by use of telepathology. A final congruent tumor diagnosis could be obtained in all divergent cases. The data indicate that telepathology can be successfully used for expert consultation of intra-operative frozen sections and panel discussions of difficult bronchial carcinoma cases.
Article
Telemedicine--the use of information and telecommunications technologies to provide and support health care when distance separates the participants--is receiving increasing attention not only in remote areas where health care access is troublesome but also in urban and suburban locations. Yet the benefits and costs of this blend of medicine and digital technologies must be better demonstrated before today's cautious decisionmakers invest significant funds in its development. Telemedicine presents a framework for evaluating patient care applications of telemedicine. The book identifies managerial, technical, policy, legal, and human factors that must be taken into account in evaluating a telemedicine program. The committee reviews previous efforts to establish evaluation frameworks and reports on results from several completed studies of image transmission, consulting from remote locations, and other telemedicine programs. The committee also examines basic elements of an evaluation and considers relevant issues of quality, accessibility, and cost of health care. Telemedicine will be of immediate interest to anyone with interest in the clinical application of telemedicine.
Article
Telepathology is the diagnostic work of a pathologist from a distance and includes all specific fields of diagnostic pathology, such as frozen section services, expert consultation, cytometric and histometric measurement, and continuous education. For about 15 years experience has been collected at several universities in the United States and Europe based upon analog telephone lines (9.2 kbaud), digitized lines (ISDN, 64 kbaud), broad band connections (1.5 Mbaud) and the World Wide Web (28 kbaud). Potential use can be expected in the application of telepresentation, remote slide preparation, remote central diagnostics and telediscussion. The transfer of still images is well developed; that of live images is used in only a few institutions for frozen section services. The image quality and spatial resolution as well as the transfer speed are sufficient for expert consultations, morphometric measurements, quality assurance and education. All applications focus on discontinuous work flow. Although the European Community focuses on user needs and standardization aspects of telepathology by sponsoring a widespread telepathology project (Europath), implementation of telepathology into routine application in the continuous work flow has still to be developed. The technical equipment has still to be adjusted to the labor flow charts in routine pathologic diagnostic procedures. Telepathology seems to be the appropriate technique to offer both improvement in diagnostic quality and inclusion of the "control institution" into diagnostic responsibility.
Article
Electronic mail, in addition to the sending of text messages, may be used to transfer multimedia and privacy-enhanced messages. Email can be used for so-called store-and-forward telemedicine, which can be particularly useful for remote consultations. This paper reviews the standards used in Internet email, from communication protocols to the message formats, and pays special attention to multimedia and confidential messages; it then describes some email-based telemedicine applications. The problems of the Internet are principally the lack of any guarantee of quality of service and the low bandwidth; intranets can guarantee appropriate performance.
Datenschutz bei innerärztlicher Kommunikation: Selbstzweck oder Notwendigkeit?
  • T Giesen
T. Giesen, Datenschutz bei innerärztlicher Kommunikation: Selbstzweck oder Notwendigkeit?, Aktionsforum Telematik im Gesundheitswesen, Nomos (2000), 61-67.