The Cost-Effectiveness of Intensive National School-Based Anti-Tobacco Education: Results from the Tobacco Policy Model

ArticleinPreventive Medicine 33(6):558-70 · January 2002with15 Reads
DOI: 10.1006/pmed.2001.0922 · Source: PubMed
School-based anti-tobacco education using the "social influences" model is known to reduce smoking among youth by 5-56%. Program effectiveness, however, dissipates in 1-4 years. Consequently, opinion leaders have questioned whether a more intensive national educational effort would be economically efficient. To address this question, we evaluated the cost-effectiveness of enhanced nationwide school-based anti-tobacco education relative to the status quo. To estimate cost-effectiveness, we created the Tobacco Policy Model, a system dynamics computer simulation model. The model relies on secondary data and is designed to calculate the expected costs and public health gains of any tobacco policy or intervention over any time frame. Over 50 years, cost-effectiveness is estimated to lie between $4,900 and $340,000 per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY), depending on the degree and longevity of program effectiveness. Assuming a 30% effectiveness that dissipates in 4 years, cost-effectiveness is $20,000/QALY. Sensitivity analysis reveals that cost-effectiveness varies with cost, survival, and quality-of-life estimates but cost-effectiveness ratios generally remain favorable. Although not cost saving, a much more intensive school-based anti-tobacco educational effort would be an economically efficient investment for the nation.
    • "By contrast, there is a notable shortage of contributions seeking to apply such tools to implementation challenges and opportunities associated with obesity interventions. This gap is not limited to obesity research; despite prominent highlighting of the potential for application of systems science methods to inform implementation science in prevention research (Hassmiller-Lich et al, 2013), and in spite of the success realized by the few examples of such applications (Tengs et al, 2001), this area of potential contribution of systems science remains underexplored in public health as a whole (Hassmiller-Lich et al, 2013). One of the reasons for this gap in quantitative analysis of such implementation science concerns for obesity lies in the methodological challenges involved. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract] ABSTRACT: Recent years have witnessed prominent calls to tax sugar-sweetened beverages (SSB) to prevent obesity in the United States. Despite efforts to evaluate this proposed policy, limited data and no framework exist for evaluating long-term, dynamic, cumulative health impacts of taxing SSBs while recycling revenue to support related interventions. Systems simulation models offer an important new lens for evaluating policy interventions, but such models have traditionally under-conceptualized key implementation science concerns, such as sustainability, revenue recycling, and bringing interventions to scale. Using a system dynamics model representing implementation dynamics, this study contributes a simulation model to inform policymakers' understanding of how allocating revenue collected by SSB taxation across sustainable implementation strategies might maximize benefits of such taxation for childhood obesity prevention.
    Full-text · Article · Dec 2015
    • "Shenghan Lai et al. [39] studied the association between cigarette smoking and drug abuse in the United States and suggest that cigarette smoking may act as a gateway drug to illegal drug use [39]. Developmental research shows that adolescent substance misuse (smoking, alcohol and drugs) can result in immediate and long-term health and behavioral problems [40] , particularly substance dependence [41], mental and physical health problems [42] and disruption to family and social rela- tionships [43] . To sleep well is important for school children and the association between inadequate sleep, wellbeing and various health problems have been well studied44454647. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract] ABSTRACT: To explore three school based transitions and their impact on positive self- reported- health (SRH), pre-school to elementary school (6–10 y), elementary school to junior high school (10-13y), and junior high school to upper secondary school/high school (13-16y), in a long-term longitudinal population based study. The study followed three cohorts through one school transition each. A longitudinal study with data from 6693 Health Dialogue questionnaires were used. Data were collected in the middle of Sweden during 2007–2012 with school children age 6–16 years old. Several significant factors were identified with an impact for a positive self-reported-health among children age 6-16y; not feeling sad or depressed, afraid or worried, positive school environment (schoolyard and restrooms), not bullied, good sleep, daily physical activity and ability to concentrate. There was no single factor identified, the factors differed according to gender and age. The study have identified several gender and age specific factors for successful school transitions relevant for a positive SRH. This is valuable information for school staff, parents and school children and provides a possibility to provide support and assistance when needed.
    Full-text · Article · Oct 2014
    • "Applications to public health and health services research have typically studied population-level problems, although organizational studies and models of individual level biologic or medical phenomena have been conducted. For example, system dynamics has been used to examine health care quality improvement25262728293031; patient flow and wait time optimization323334353637; clinical workforce demand383940; community-based systems of care41424344; urgent care facility utilization454647; patient-level clinical assessment484950 ; epidemiology and disease surveillance5152535455; global health care management565758; behavioral health interventions in tobacco [55,59606162, substance abuse63646566, and mental health [67, 68]; as well as in managing chronic illness [44, 69, 70]. In addition, a system dynamics model called Health- Bound was developed for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) to help people understand the critical relationship between ''upstream'' efforts to prevent illness and the demand for the relationships between a community's access to care, health status, and socioeconomic level [10]. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract] ABSTRACT: The field of quality-of-life (QOL) research would benefit from learning about and integrating systems science approaches that model how social forces interact dynamically with health and affect the course of chronic illnesses. Our purpose is to describe the systems science mindset and to illustrate the utility of a system dynamics approach to promoting QOL research in chronic disease, using diabetes as an example. We build a series of causal loop diagrams incrementally, introducing new variables and their dynamic relationships at each stage. These causal loop diagrams demonstrate how a common set of relationships among these variables can generate different disease and QOL trajectories for people with diabetes and also lead to a consideration of non-clinical (psychosocial and behavioral) factors that can have implications for program design and policy formulation. The policy implications of the causal loop diagrams are discussed, and empirical next steps to validate the diagrams and quantify the relationships are described.
    Full-text · Article · Sep 2013
Show more