ArticlePDF Available

Fallout from nuclear tests: Dosimetry in Kazakhstan

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

The populations that appear to have been the most exposed to radioactive fallout as a result of nuclear weapons testing at the Semipalatinsk test site (STS) can be divided into two groups. The first group is located in the areas of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the vicinity of the STS and the second group is located in the Altai krai (i.e. Altai region) of the Russian Federation. The purpose of this paper is to estimate doses for the populations of the Republic of Kazakhstan that resided in the vicinity of the STS at the time when nuclear weapons tests were conducted in the atmosphere. The methodology that was used to estimate doses is based on the radiation measurements that were made after each test. It was developed by joint efforts of the scientists of the Institute of Biophysics and other Institutes of the Ministry of Health of the USSR, biologists and physicists of the STS, as well as of the specialists from other organizations involved in radiation protection problems. That methodology is currently applied to the estimation of doses received by subjects living near the STS, as part of an epidemiological study carried out by the U.S. National Cancer Institute [1].
Content may be subject to copyright.
Background and aim of the study
The populations that appear to have been the most ex-
posed to radioactive fallout as a result of nuclear weap-
ons testing at the Semipalatinsk test site (STS) can be di-
vided into two groups. The first group is located in the
areas of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the vicinity of the
STS and the second group is located in the Altai krai (i.e.
Altai region) of the Russian Federation. The purpose of
this paper is to estimate doses for the populations of the
Republic of Kazakhstan that resided in the vicinity of the
STS at the time when nuclear weapons tests were con-
ducted in the atmosphere.
The methodology that was used to estimate doses is
based on the radiation measurements that were made af-
ter each test. It was developed by joint efforts of the sci-
entists of the Institute of Biophysics and other Institutes
of the Ministry of Health of the USSR, biologists and
physicists of the STS, as well as of the specialists from
other organizations involved in radiation protection
problems. That methodology is currently applied to the
estimation of doses received by subjects living near the
STS, as part of an epidemiological study carried out by
the U.S. National Cancer Institute [1].
Methodology of dose estimation
The methodology of dose estimation is based on the
coupling of data on radiation exposure of the populations
of the Republic of Kazakhstan and environmental trans-
fer models. The usable data are maintained in the ar-
chives of the Ministry of Defense and of the Ministry of
Health, as well as those of other organizations of the
Russian Federation that took part in nuclear testing oper-
ations at the STS. The most useful data are exposure
rates measured along the trajectories of the radioactive
clouds. The exposure-rate measurements, which were
usually taken aboard low-flying aircraft, were sometimes
supplemented with ground-level monitoring. In the ar-
chives of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federa-
tion, the measurement data of exposure rates are present-
ed in different forms:
1. Original measurements with indication of time, loca-
tion, height above ground surface, and reading of the
instrument, and
2. Maps showing isopleths of exposure rates normalized
to some definite postdetonation time. In addition, the
results of some measurements of radionuclide content
in soil, vegetation, grain crops, milk, and other envi-
ronmental samples are available.
The model used to predict or reconstruct the radiological
conditions after each test, in areas where measurements
were lacking, requires information on test yield, type and
composition of fission material, date and time of explo-
sion, height of radioactive cloud top, height of detona-
tion above ground surface, and average wind speed over
the height of the radioactive cloud [2].
The main parameters characterizing the radiological
conditions at the location of interest are derived by
means of the model:
Fallout arrival time, H+t (h)
Duration of fallout t (h)
Fraction of the activity of the radionuclides in fallout
assigned to the biologically active particles, defined
as those with diameter d50 µm, η
d50
(unitless)
Average concentration of radionuclides in ground air
during the time of radioactive fallout
K. Gordeev · I. Vasilenko · A. Lebedev · Y. Stepanov · S. Shinkarev
State Research Center – Institute of Biophysics
of the Ministry of Health, Moscow, Russian Federation
A. Bouville (
) · N. Luckyanov · S.L. Simon
Division of Cancer Epidemiology and Genetics,
National Cancer Institute, National Institutes of Health,
Bethesda, MD 20892, USA
e-mail: bouvilla@exchange.nih.gov
L. Anspaugh
Department of Radiology, University of Utah,
Salt Lake City, UT 84108, USA
Radiat Environ Biophys (2002) 41:61–67
DOI 10.1007/s00411-001-0139-y
ORIGINAL CONTRIBUTION
K. Gordeev · I. Vasilenko · A. Lebedev · A. Bouville
N. Luckyanov · S. L. Simon · Y. Stepanov
S. Shinkarev · L. Anspaugh
Fallout from nuclear tests: dosimetry in Kazakhstan
Received: 16 October 2001 / Accepted: 10 December 2001 / Published online: 9 March 2002
© Springer-Verlag 2002
Radionuclide ground deposition density at time
H+24 h, σ
Σ,24
(Bq m
–2
)
Exposure rate at time H+24 h, P
24
(mR h
–1
).
Whenever possible, the values of exposure rate, P
24
, and
of radionuclide ground deposition density at time
H+24 h, σ
Σ,24
, were derived from the available measure-
ments of exposure rate in the location of interest or in its
vicinity [3, 4, 5, 6].
The next step in the dosimetry calculation is to take
into account the lifestyle and dietary habits of the popu-
lation groups living at the location of interest:
Age-dependent number of hours spent outdoors, used
to derive the effective doses from external irradiation,
and
Type of milk consumed and age-dependent milk con-
sumption rates, used to derive the thyroid doses from
internal irradiation.
For the purpose of determining those tests most likely to
have affected the local population, dosimetric calcula-
tions were used to classify the 111 atmospheric tests ac-
cording to whether the estimated effective dose to an
adult living off-site at the point of maximum exposure
rate during the year following the nuclear explosion
would exceed 5 mSv. Eleven events were found to satisfy
that criterion and thus to contribute substantially to radia-
tion exposure. They were conducted on 29 August 1949,
24 September 1951, 12 August 1953, 5 May 1954,
30 October 1954, 29 July 1955, 2 August 1955, 16 March
1956, 24 August 1956, 22 August 1957, and 7 August
1962. Important characteristics of those tests are present-
ed in Table 1, while the airmass trajectories of the corre-
sponding radioactive clouds are shown in Fig. 1.
Estimation of doses for population groups
in Kazakhstan
Settlements of interest: location and population habits
On the basis of the analysis of the radiological condi-
tions in the Semipalatinsk Oblast as a result of nuclear
testing and after taking into account the opinion of the
specialists of local medical facilities, eight settlements
(see Table 2) were selected by the U.S. National Cancer
Institute for the purpose of an epidemiological study [1].
62
Table 1 Characteristics of the 11 most significant events conducted at the Semipalatinsk Test Site (STS)
Characteristics Events
Event number [1] 1 2 4 13 18 19 20 26 28 41
b
148
Date (dd.mm.yy) 29.08.49 24.09.51 12.08.53 05.10.54 30.10.54 29.07.55 02.08.55 16.03.56 24.08.56 22.08.57 07.08.62
Local time 7:00 13:10 7:30 9:00 10:00 8:00 9:00 11:00 6:15 12:30 9:00
of explosion
Height above 30 30 30 0 55 2.5 2.5 0.4 93 1880 0
ground (m)
Total yield, q, kt 22 38 400
a
4.0 10 1.3 12 14 27 520 9.9
Maximum height 9 11.6 16 5 10.2 5.1 6.2 8.5 12 18.8 5.7
of radioactive
cloud (H
max
, km)
Average wind 47 26.4 64.6 43.3 32.9 42 36.6 39 71.2 29 10
speed
a
Estimated value assuming that the total yield of thermonuclear
event 4 was partly due to fission of
238
U (75% of total energy) and
to fusion of light nuclei (25% of total energy).
b
Explosion was at high altitude. Radioactive fallout occurred at
distances of 37–260 km from the experimental field of the STS.
Table 2 Location of the settle-
ments of interest in Kazakhstan
Settlement Location
Latitude Longitude Distance from the experimental field
of the STS (km)
Northeastern group
Dolon 50°40 79°18 106
Bolshaya Vladimirovka 50°53 79°29 127
Kanonerka 50°43 79°42 135
Novopokrovka 50°40 80°28 186
Korostelevskii 51°3 81°0 233
Southern group
Kaynar 49°12 77°23 139
Sarzhal 49°36 78°23 112
Kara-Aul 48°57 79°15 191
The locations of the eight settlements, which are be-
lieved to include those sites in which the highest levels
of exposure occurred, as well as other sites where radia-
tion exposure was very low, are given in Table 2 and are
shown in Fig. 1.
The eight settlements listed in Table 2 can be divided
into two groups: northeastern and southern, differentiat-
ed according to the prevalent nationality of the inhabit-
ants, the northeastern group being mainly of Russian
descent, and the southern group being mainly of Kazakh
descent. Lifestyle and dietary parameters that impact the
dose estimates were collected or estimated for the two
population groups. With respect to external irradiation,
the lifestyle parameters that are important are the aver-
age time spent outdoors and the type of residence. With
respect to internal irradiation of the thyroid, the con-
sumption rate of cow’s milk is the most important die-
tary parameter.
The northeastern group of settlements is located in the
northern part of the Semipalatinsk Oblast on the northern
bank of the Irtysh river, close to the Altai region of Rus-
sia. Five settlements are in this group: Dolon, Bolshaya
Vladimirovka, Kanonerka, Novopokrovka, and Koroste-
levskii. The populations of those villages are primarily
Russian and have specific life-style and dietary habits of
that nationality. In addition, there is a small percentage
of Germans, whose life-style and diet are close to those
of Russians. They typically lived in wooden houses that
afforded little protection from the gamma radiation emit-
ted from the radioactive cloud or from the activity de-
posited on the ground. For Russian settlements, the ratio
of the outdoor and indoor exposure rates is taken to be 1
for the gamma radiation emitted from the radioactive
cloud and 3 for the activity deposited on the ground.
Also, the residents of Russian settlements typically
drank cow’s milk. Age-dependent values of the average
time spent outdoors and of consumption rate of cow’s
milk for the inhabitants of Russian settlements are pro-
vided in Table 3.
The other (southern) group of settlements is located
in the steppe part of northern Kazakhstan and includes
Kaynar, Sarzhal, and Kara-Aul, typical villages with
primarily Kazakh populations and with life-style and
dietary habits typical of that population. One of the
main differences between Russian and Kazakhs is that
the Kazakhs drank horse’s milk instead of cow’s milk.
In addition, they usually lived in adobe (mud) houses,
which afforded more protection from outdoor gamma
radiation than the wooden houses inhabited by the Rus-
sians. For Kazakh settlements, the ratio of the outdoor
and indoor exposure rates is derived from measure-
ments to be 2.5 for the gamma radiation emitted from
the radioactive cloud and 13 for the activity deposited
on the ground. Age-dependent values of the average
time spent outdoors and of consumption rate of horse’s
milk for the inhabitants of Kazakh settlements are
listed in Table 3.
63
Fig. 1 Trajectories of the radioactive clouds related to the most
important tests and location of some of the settlements of interest
(Altai Krai=Altai region)
Radiological conditions in the settlements of interest
The first step of the dosimetry modeling was to charac-
terize the fallout radiation field in the settlements of in-
terest for each test that contributed to the radiation expo-
sure there. The methodology that was used for that pur-
pose is described in [2]. The characteristics of fallout
(time of arrival, duration of fallout, fraction of the activi-
ty of the radionuclides in fallout assigned to the biologi-
cally active particles with diameter d50 µm, average ac-
tivity concentration in ground-level air during the radio-
active fallout, ground deposition density at time H+24 h,
and external gamma-exposure rate at H+24 h) were mea-
sured or estimated for each settlement and each signifi-
cant test. The results are presented in Table 4.
In a second step, the concentrations of
131
I and of
133
I
in the type of milk predominantly consumed in each of
the eight settlements were estimated using the methodol-
ogy described in [2]. In these calculations, it is assumed
that dairy animals were on pasture during a time period
of a few weeks after each test and that only milk of local
origin was consumed. Under those conditions, the contri-
butions of other foodstuffs e.g., leafy vegetables or meat,
to the thyroid doses from internal irradiation are minor;
hence, they have not been considered in this paper. Esti-
mates of radioiodine concentrations in milk in each of
the villages following the most important tests are pre-
sented in Table 5.
64
Table 3 Age-dependent values
of the average time spent out-
doors and of the consumption
rate of milk by inhabitants of
Kazakh and of Russian settle-
ments
Lifestyle and dietary parameters Age (years)
1341618
Kazakh settlements
Time spent outdoors (h per day) 4 5 6 12 16
Consumption rate of horse’s milk (l per day) 0.25 0.35 0.5 0.7 0.7
Russian settlements
Time spent outdoors (h per day) 3 5 8 8 16
Consumption rate of cow’s milk (l per day) 0.3 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.7
Table 4 Characteristics of fallout in the eight settlements considered in Kazakhstan for the most significant tests
Settlement Event Time of Duration Biologically Average Ground Exposure rate
a
arrival of fallout active activity deposition at H+24 h, P
24
Date Number of fallout t, h fraction concentration density at time mR h
–1
H+t, h of fallout in ground- H+24 h, σ
Σ,24
η
d50
level air Bq m
–2
during fallout
Dolon 29.08.49 1 2.4 2.0 0.03 5.5 10
8
4.3·10
9
1150
29.07.55 19 3.1 2.1 0.3 2.0·10
5
1.9·10
6
0.5
07.08.62 148 10.5 7.6 1.0 1.2·10
5
3.7·10
6
1.0
Bolshaya 29.08.49 1 2.9 2.3 0.05 4.5·10
5
4.1·10
6
1.1
Vladimirovka 29.07.55 19 4.0 2.7 0.54 2.2·10
5
2.6·10
6
0.7
07.08.62 148 13 9.3 1.0 1.1·10
5
4.1·10
6
1.1
Kanonerka 29.08.49 1 3.0 2.4 0.06 9.7·10
7
9.3·10
8
250
29.07.55 19 4.2 2.8 0.58 1.8·10
5
2.2·10
6
0.6
07.08.62 148 13.2 9.4 1.0 9.1·10
4
3.7·10
6
1.0
Novopokrovka 29.08.49 1 4.0 3.1 0.13 7.0·10
4
8.5·10
5
0.23
07.08.62 148 17.3 12.3 1.0 7.1·10
4
4.1·10
6
1.1
Korostelevskii 29.08.49 1 5.1 3.4 0.25 8.0·10
6
1.2·10
8
32.7
Kaynar 24.09.51 2 5.2 4.2 0.14 1.7·10
7
2.6·10
8
71.3
05.10.54 13 3.7 2.6 0.48 1.4·10
5
1.5·10
6
0.4
Sarzhal 12.08.53 4 1.7 1.7 0.003 5.1·10
8
3·10
9c
950/807
b
Kara-Aul 12.08.53 4 2.9 2.7 0.01 1.8·10
8
1.8·10
9c
777/466
b
a
For reasons of convenience, exposure rates are reported in
mR h
–1
. The SI unit for exposure is the Coulomb per kilogram
(1 R=2.58 10
–4
C kg
–1
).
b
The first value is the estimated total exposure rate from fission
debris and neutron-activated products (P
Σ,24
), while the second in-
cludes only that part of the exposure rate that is determined by fis-
sion debris (P
fission,24
).
c
Ground deposition density, σ
Σfission,24
, was calculated on the basis
of P
fission,24
.
Initial results
External effective doses and internal thyroid doses
for the residents of the settlements of interest
in the Republic of Kazakhstan
Using the data on the radiological conditions and on the
lifestyle and dietary habits of the population in the settle-
ments, effective doses from external irradiation and thy-
roid doses from internal irradiation have been estimated.
Both the external and the internal doses are age-depen-
dent. Doses were calculated for people who were adults
at the time of the tests (i.e., born before 1930), as well as
for 1-year-old children at the time of the first test (i.e.,
born in 1948).
The thyroid doses from internal irradiation were cal-
culated for:
Inhalation intake of
131
I,
133
I, and
135
I, and
Ingestion intake with milk of
131
I and
133
I.
The values of the thyroid dose coefficients were taken
from [7].
The estimated doses, assuming that no countermea-
sures were taken, are presented in Table 6. In fact, coun-
termeasures were only taken for test no. 4, which oc-
curred on 12 August 1953, and affected only the popula-
tions of Sarzhal and of Kara-Aul:
The residents of Sarzhal and their cattle were evacua-
ted to non-exposed areas before the detonation of
event 4 occurred. Those residents returned to Sarzhal
16 days after the event.
The residents of Kara-Aul were hurriedly evacuated a
few hours after the arrival of the radioactive cloud in
their settlement. However, out of the 1,620 residents
of Kara-Aul, 191 adults were left behind in order to
guard the properties of the residents. Those residents
were also evacuated at a later time. All residents re-
turned to Kara-Aul 10 days after the event. Table 6
also presents dose estimates for the evacuated resi-
dents of Sarzhal and Kara-Aul.
This method was also used by Gordeev [8] to calculate
thyroid doses for inhabitants of other settlements in
Semipalatinsk oblast. For example, thyroid doses for
1-year-old children were estimated to be 25.7 mGy for
residents of Semipalatinsk city, while for Znamenka,
thyroid doses for 1-year-olds were estimated to be
380 mGy for Kazakh children and 160 mGy for Russian
children [8].
Problems, limitations and potential solutions
1. The dose estimates presented in this paper should be
considered as preliminary reconstructions. Efforts are
under way to assess their validity and improve them
where possible. On-going activities include a detailed
comparison of the environmental transfer models
used in Russia and in the U.S., as well as the estima-
tion of external doses from EPR measurements in
teeth taken from local residents and thermolumines-
cence measurements in bricks obtained from local
buildings.
2. The upper ranges of estimated doses are about 1 Sv
(effective doses) from external irradiation and about
2 Gy (thyroid doses) from internal irradiation. How-
ever, there is not yet validation of these estimates by
physical measurements.
3. Effective doses from external irradiation are expected
to be reliable where based on measurements of expo-
sure rates after each test. The limiting factor, howev-
65
Table 5 Estimation of peak ac-
tivity concentrations of radio-
iodines in locally produced and
consumed milk
Settlement Event Peak activity concentration in milk, Bq l
–1
Date Number Cow Horse
131
I
133
I
131
I
133
I
Dolon 29.08.49 1 78,000 290,000
29.07.55 19 360 1,300
07.08.62 148 4,550 11,000
Bolshaya 29.08.49 1 130 460
Vladimirovka 29.07.55 19 1,000 3,500
07.08.62 148 5,300 12,000
Kanonerka 29.08.49 1 34,000 120,000
29.07.55 19 930 3,250
07.08.62 148 4,800 10,000
Novopokrovka 29.08.49 1 73 250
07.08.62 148 5,600 9,900
Korostelevskii 29.08.49 1 22,000 72,000
Kaynar 24.09.51 2 160,000 510,000
05.10.54 13 4,500 15,000
Sarzhal 12.08.53 4 23,000 87,000
Kara-Aul 12.08.53 4 110,000 380,000
er, is the sparseness of such data. Uncertainty of ex-
ternal doses to residents is mainly due to lack of
knowledge about the number of hours spent outdoors
each day among different age groups.
4. Thyroid doses from internal irradiation due to the
consumption of milk contaminated with
131
I and
133
I
are difficult to estimate reliably because they cannot
be confirmed by any present-day measurement. More-
over, the dose estimates depend on highly uncertain
parameters, including the fraction of fallout debris in-
tercepted by plants, the solubility of fallout of differ-
ent particles sizes and at different locations, transfer
coefficients for different types of dairy animals, and
the origin and amount of milk consumed by each per-
son.
5. Intakes via consumption of foodstuffs other than milk
are likely to provide small contributions to the inter-
nal thyroid dose.
66
Table 6 Estimates of effective
doses from external irradiation
and of thyroid doses from inter-
nal irradiation for the average
residents of the settlements of
interest in the Republic of
Kazakhstan
Event Year of External Internal thyroid dose (mGy) Total
birth effective effective
Date Number dose (mSv) Inhalation Ingestion Total dose (mSv)
Dolon
29.08.49 1 1930 1240 10 1050 1100 1300
1948 890 26 2000 2000 990
29.07.55 19 1930 0.7 0.06 3.5 3.6 0.9
1948 0.4 0.2 9.3 9.5 0.9
7.08.62 148 1930 1.1 1.9 33 35 2.8
1948 0.8 3.6 56 60 3.8
Bolshaya Vladimirovka
29.08.49 1 1930 1.1 0.02 1.7 1.7 1.2
1948 0.8 0.05 3.2 3.2 1.0
29.07.55 19 1930 0.9 0.2 9.3 9.5 1.4
1948 0.55 0.6 25 25 1.8
07.08.62 148 1930 1.2 2.6 37 39.5 3.2
1948 0.9 4.9 64 68.5 4.3
Kanonerka
29.08.49 1 1930 250 5.8 440 450 270
1948 190 15 840 855 230
29.07.55 19 1930 0.8 0.2 8.5 8.7 1.2
1948 0.5 0.5 23 23 1.6
07.08.62 148 1930 1.1 2.4 33 35 2.8
1948 0.8 4.4 57 61 3.9
Novopokrovka
29.08.49 1 1930 0.2 0.02 0.9 0.9 0.25
1948 0.2 0.04 1.7 1.8 0.25
07.08.62 148 1930 1.1 3.5 37 41 3.1
1948 0.8 6.5 65 71 4.3
Korostelevskii
29.08.49 1 1930 28 6.2 260 270 41
1948 23 15 510 520 49
Kaynar
24.09.51 2 1930 52 7.1 1300 1300 120
1948 26 18 2200 2200 140
05.10.54 13 1930 0.5 0.1 25 25 1.7
1948 0.2 0.3 76 76.5 4.0
Sarzhal
12.08.53 4 1930
a
1310 0.3 130 130 1300
1948
a
440 0.6 280 280 450
1930
b
210 12 12 210
1948
b
83 31 31 84
Kara-Aul
12.08.53 4 1930
a
690 1.2 520 520 720
1948
a
220 2.5 1100 1100 280
1930
b
110 0.4 63 64 110
1948
b
37 0.9 150 150 44
1930
c
150 0.4 63 64 150
a
Estimates of the doses that
the residents of Sarzhal and
Kara-Aul would have received
if they had not been evacuated.
b
Estimates of actual doses to
the residents of Sarzhal and
Kara-Aul, taking their evacua-
tion into account.
c
Estimates of doses to the 191
residents who were evacuated
from Kara-Aul at a later date.
Future plans
The dose estimates presented in this paper relate to un-
specified residents of the settlements that are considered.
In order to estimate the thyroid doses to the specific indi-
viduals who are members of the epidemiological study
undertaken by NCI, account should be taken of the resi-
dence histories of those individuals, as well as of their
personal life-style and dietary habits, especially with re-
gard to the type and amount of milk consumed. This ef-
fort is under way.
It is also important to note that it would be highly de-
sirable to confirm the validity of the dose estimates pre-
sented in this paper. It is for that purpose that it is
planned to conduct a detailed comparison of the environ-
mental transfer models used in Russia and in the U.S.
and that EPR measurements in teeth taken from local
residents and thermoluminescence measurements in bricks
obtained from local buildings are being envisaged.
Acknowledgements This study was funded by the U.S. National
Cancer Institute, Division of Cancer Epidemiology and Genetics
References
1. Grosche B, Land C, Bauer S, Abylkassimova ZN, Gusev BI
(2002) Studies on the population of Kasakhstan: health effects.
Radiat Environ Biophys 41:(This issue)
2. Gordeev KI, Vasilenko IYa, Grinev MP, Ilyin LA, Keirim-
Markus IB, Kiselev MPh, Savkin MN, Stepanov YuS, Lebedev
AN (2000) Assessment of absorbed and effective doses from
ionizing radiation to the populations living in areas of local
fallout from atmospheric nuclear explosions. Methodical di-
rections MU 2.6.1.1001–00. Official publication. Ministry of
Public Health of the Russian Federation, Sanitary State Ser-
vice of the Russian Federation, Moscow (in Russian)
3. Kobzev AF, Ryadov VG, Stepanov YuS, Turapin SL (1960)
The results of study of radiological situation in some areas of
Semipalatinsk and Pavlodar Oblasts of Kazakh SSR in 1959.
Report of the State Research Center-Institute of Biophysics (in
Russian)
4. Enko AV, Remezov IV, Alekseev IV, Khovanovich AI (1949)
Report on measurements of the trace of the radioactive cloud
of fission products from the 1949 explosion. Training polygon
#2 of the Ministry of Military Forces of the USSR (in Russian)
5. Kobzev AF, Agranat VZ, Venitskovsky-Zolotykh YuV,
Stepanov YuS, Turapin SL (1960) Characteristics of radiation
conditions in areas bordering on the nuclear weapons testing
territory, and of the health status of their population. Report of
the State Research Center-Institute of Biophysics (in Russian)
6. Stepanov YuS, Dolgikh AP, Mikhalikhina LA, Bogdanenko
NA (1997) Some data on outdoor radiation doses and doses to
the population in areas contaminated by radioactive fallout
from atmospheric nuclear tests (on the basis of the archival
documents in State Research Center-Institute of Biophysics
and in Federal Agency “Medbioextrem”). Report:Retrospec-
tive assessment of radioactive contamination of different areas
and reconstruction of doses to the population of the Russian
Federation as a result of nuclear explosions conducted on the
territory of the USSR (code – “Atlas”). State Research Center-
Institute of Biophysics (in Russian)
7. IAEA (1996) International basic safety standards for protec-
tion against ionizing radiation and for the safety of radiation
sources. Safety series No 115. International Atomic Energy
Agency, Vienna
8. Gordeev KI (2001) Assessment of external effective doses and
internal absorbed doses to thyroid for the population living in
additional settlements of the Republic of Kazakhstan and of
the Russian Federation, included by the NCI in the list of the
cohort subjects for the epidemiological study of the medical
effects due to radiation exposure as a result of nuclear testing
at the Semipalatinsk Polygon. Internal Report IV-2 for NCI,
Moscow
67
... The 1956 test affected settlements to the east, including the city of Ust-Kamenogorsk . Figure 1 shows the trajectories leading to significant exposures of the general population (Gordeev et al. 2002). ...
... This aim was initially based on information collected in a Kazakh-Japanese activity (Ogiu et al. 2008;Yoshinaga et al. 2018). However, during the course of Fig. 1 Trajectories of the radioactive clouds related to the most important nuclear tests, and location of some of the settlements of interest (Altai Krai = Altai region) (Gordeev et al. 2002) Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved. ...
... These estimates are cumulative doses from 1949 to 1960 and include both internal and external exposure. Later, maximum external doses for an adult having been exposed in Dolon were estimated as 1.3 Sv (Gordeev et al. 2002) or 0.63 Gy . When applying the joint Information on availability of biomaterials (blood, DNA, tissue) See Table 3 Number of official documents: 221,411 ...
Article
Full-text available
Direct quantitative assessment of health risks following exposure to ionizing radiation is based on findings from epidemiological studies. Populations affected by nuclear bomb testing are among those that allow such assessment. The population living around the former Soviet Union’s Semipalatinsk nuclear test site is one of the largest human cohorts exposed to radiation from nuclear weapons tests. Following research that started in the 1960s, a registry that contains information on more than 300,000 individuals residing in the areas neighboring to the test site was established. Four nuclear weapons tests, conducted from 1949 to 1956, resulted in non-negligible radiation exposures to the public, corresponding up to approximately 300 mGy external dose. The registry contains relevant information about those who lived at the time of the testing as well as about their offspring, including biological material. An international group of scientists worked together within the research project SEMI-NUC funded by the European Union, and concluded that the registry provides a novel, mostly unexplored, and valuable resource for the assessment of the population risks associated with environmental radiation exposure. Suggestions for future studies and pathways on how to use the best dose assessment strategies have also been described in the project. Moreover, the registry could be used for research on other relevant public health topics.
... All the estimations of doses described above had been derived from the average group doses for the most affected settlements (Gordeev et al. 2002). In the first four decades of nuclear testing direct individual measurements of the radiation burden to the members of the overexposed population were not carried out either by bioassay or external retrospective dosimetry assays. ...
... Overall, the dose estimates based on the internal contamination measurements and biological and EPR dosimetry are generally lower than those obtained by historical reconstruction of external exposure rate (range of 1-4.5 Gy) (Gusev et al. 1997;Gordeev et al. 2002). ...
Article
Full-text available
This work presents an overview of the applications of retrospective dosimetry techniques in case of incorporation of radionuclides. The fact that internal exposures are characterized by a spatially inhomogeneous irradiation of the body, which is potentially prolonged over large periods and variable over time, is particularly problematic for biological and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) dosimetry methods when compared with external exposures. The paper gives initially specific information about internal dosimetry methods, the most common cytogenetic techniques used in biological dosimetry and EPR dosimetry applied to tooth enamel. Based on real-case scenarios, dose estimates obtained from bioassay data as well as with biological and/or EPR dosimetry are compared and critically discussed. In most of the scenarios presented, concomitant external exposures were responsible for the greater portion of the received dose. As no assay is available which can discriminate between radiation of different types and different LETs on the basis of the type of damage induced, it is not possible to infer from these studies specific conclusions valid for incorporated radionuclides alone. The biological dosimetry assays and EPR techniques proved to be most applicable in cases when the radionuclides are almost homogeneously distributed in the body. No compelling evidence was obtained in other cases of extremely inhomogeneous distribution. Retrospective dosimetry needs to be optimized and further developed in order to be able to deal with real exposure cases, where a mixture of both external and internal exposures will be encountered most of the times.
... Some papers about radioactive contaminations in the former SU have common features. A major part of the literature about EURT and SNTS e.g., [160][161][162][163][164][165][166] are characterized by large volume, being overloaded by details and mathematical computations, but not permitting clear insight into medical consequences of the contamination. Papers on dosimetry or retrospective dose estimation also contain lengthy discourses e.g., about consumption of cow and horse milk or ethnic origin of people living in or relocated to the Semipalatinsk area (ethnic Germans) but provide no clear information on the average annual or total individual doses, radiation-induced morbidity and mortality. ...
Chapter
The book is available at: https://novapublishers.com/shop/advances-in-environmental-research-volume-83/ RELATED ARTICLES: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/357239677_The_overestimation_of_medical_consequences_of_low-dose_exposures_Cui_bono https://www.researchgate.net/publication/357221693_Epidemiological_Research_with_Special_Reference_to_Nuclear_Worker_Studies_Commentary https://www.researchgate.net/publication/353807681_Chernobyl-related_cancers_vs_controls_from_other_countries_a_comment BOOK: https://www.cambridgescholars.com/the-overestimation-of-medical-consequences-of-low-dose-exposure-to-ionizing-radiation RUSSIAN: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/317011004_O_preuvelicenii_posledstvij_povysenia_radiacionnogo_fona https://www.researchgate.net/publication/275659592_K_voprosu_o_zavysennoj_ocenke_medicinskih_posledstvij_avarii_na_CAES_priciny_i_mehanizmy_Overestimation_of_Chernobyl_consequences_motives_and_mechanisms https://www.researchgate.net/publication/331996611_K_voprosu_o_giperdiagnostike_i_giperterapii_karcinomy_sitovidnoj_zelezy_posle_avarii_na_CAES https://www.researchgate.net/publication/275659614_O_preuvelicenii_radiacionnyh_posledstvij_avarii_na_Cernobylskoj_AES_Overestimation_of_Chernobyl_consequences https://www.researchgate.net/publication/275659661_Nedostovernye_publikacii_o_radiacionnom_kancerogeneze_v_rajone_Semipalatinska_Unreliable_publications_on_radiation_carcinogenesis_in_Semipalatinsk_area
... The citation burst is an integral indicator that takes into account not only citation frequency of the document, but as well how soon and how long it has been cited after publication. The works with highest citation burst are by Gordeev et al. (2002) 19 and gusev et al. (1997) 9 . ...
Article
Full-text available
The article presents the analysis of a documentary array on Semipalatinsk nuclear test site using analytical services of the Web of Science database. It identifies the authors, organisations, countries, leading in the publications number at the research field. Shows the journals in which articles on the studied problem are published most frequently. Enumerates scientific meetings where the problems of Semipalatinsk test site were discussed and identifies the most cited publications. Using CiteSpace software, the paper reveals and visualises research fronts and its intellectual bases by means clustering and cluster automated labelling of Semipalatinsk test site papers co-citation network. Document co-citation network and research clusters are revealed using CiteSpace software. It shows, that studies are related to research of medical and biological (genetic changes, diseases as a result of ionizing radiation) effects of nuclear tests and its effects on the environmental situation (degree of contamination of the territory); the effectiveness of various dosimetry methods to determine the degree of radiation exposure on living organisms and objects of inanimate nature. The work represents scientometric visualisation of the documentary array showing research trends on Semipalatinsk nuclear test site.
Article
This article addresses and contributes to the discussion on nuclear supply chain socio-environmental conflicts in Soviet and post-Soviet contexts by bringing it together with nuclear peripheralization and environmental justice approaches. Descriptive statistics and qualitative coding were applied to 14 cases identified in the Global Atlas of Environmental Justice. Visible protests were first detected in 1976. The cases analysed comprise the whole nuclear supply chain; uranium mining bans, stopping nuclear reactors, and nuclear testing bans. Seven of the conflictive projects have been suspended by neighbours, citizens and communities, women, industrial workers, and Indigenous groups. However, nuclear projects remain of ongoing concern related to nuclear waste and potential nuclear accidents. Military violence intrinsic to nuclear power domination encounters anti-nuclear resistance in areas where nuclear socio-environmental legacies and current injustices are lived.
Article
Full-text available
The Trinity test device contained about 6 kg of plutonium as its fission source, resulting in a fission yield of 21 kT. However, only about 15% of the Pu actually underwent fission. The remaining unfissioned plutonium eventually was vaporized in the fireball and after cooling, was deposited downwind from the test site along with the various fission and activation products produced in the explosion. Using data from radiochemical analyses of soil samples collected postshot (most many years later), supplemented by model estimates of plutonium deposition density estimated from reported exposure rates at 12 h postshot, we have estimated the total activity and geographical distribution of the deposition density of this unfissioned plutonium in New Mexico. A majority (about 80%) of the unfissioned plutonium was deposited within the state of New Mexico, most in a relatively small area about 30-100 km downwind (the Chupadera Mesa area). For most of the state, the deposition density was a small fraction of the subsequent deposition density of Pu from Nevada Test Site tests (1951-1958) and later from global fallout from the large US and Russian thermonuclear tests (1952-1962). The fraction of the total unfissioned Pu that was deposited in New Mexico from Trinity was greater than the fraction of fission products deposited. Due to plutonium being highly refractory, a greater fraction of the Pu was incorporated into large particles that fell out closer to the test site as opposed to more volatile fission products (such as Cs and I) that tend to deposit on the surface of smaller particles that travel farther before depositing. The plutonium deposited as a result of the Trinity test was unlikely to have resulted in significant health risks to the downwind population.
Article
Full-text available
Trinity was the first test of a nuclear fission device. The test took place in south-central New Mexico at the Alamogordo Bombing and Gunnery Range at 05:29 AM on 16 July 1945. This article provides detailed information on the methods that were used in this work to estimate the radiation doses that were received by the population that resided in New Mexico in 1945. The 721 voting precincts of New Mexico were classified according to ecozone (plains, mountains, or mixture of plains and mountains), and size of resident population (urban or rural). Methods were developed to prepare estimates of absorbed doses from a range of 63 radionuclides to five organs or tissues (thyroid, active marrow, stomach, colon, and lung) for representative individuals of each voting precinct selected according to ethnicity (Hispanic, White, Native American, and African American) and age group in 1945 (in utero, newborn, 1-2 y, 3-7 y, 8-12 y, 13-17 y, and adult). Three pathways of human exposure were included: (1) external irradiation from the radionuclides deposited on the ground; (2) inhalation of radionuclide-contaminated air during the passage of the radioactive cloud and, thereafter, of radionuclides transferred (resuspended) from soil to air; and (3) ingestion of contaminated water and foodstuffs. Within the ingestion pathway, 13 types of foods and sources of water were considered. Well established models were used for estimation of doses resulting from the three pathways using parameter values developed from extensive literature review. Because previous experience and calculations have shown that the annual dose delivered during the year following a nuclear test is much greater than the doses received in the years after that first year, the time period that was considered is limited to the first year following the day of the test (16 July 1945). Numerical estimates of absorbed doses, based on the methods described in this article, are presented in a separate article in this issue.
Article
Full-text available
Although numerous epidemiological studies have demonstrated an increased risk of cancer and non-cancer diseases associated with acute exposures to high doses of radiation, possible effects of protracted exposures to low-to-moderate doses of radiation remain to be investigated. Several epidemiological studies have been conducted for residents living near the Semipalatinsk Test Site in the former Soviet Union who were exposed to protracted low-to-moderate doses of both external and internal radiations. However, small population size and other limitations of the previous studies preclude a precise evaluation of the health effects. An international joint study of Kazakhstan and Japan was initiated in 2001 to investigate the health effects among residents of the exposed areas based on a new large-scale cohort of the Semipalatinsk populations. In the joint study, information was obtained on the name, date of birth, sex, residential history and vital status of individuals living in the former Semipalatinsk oblast and other exposed areas using archived and official data. By March 2009, data of 131,723 residents were collected, among which the vital status of 41,128 residents (30.7%) was ascertained. The completeness of the ascertainment depended on the place of residence with lower completeness for control areas mainly because of emigration. Although any analysis based on retrospective follow-up data is limited because of potential selection bias, the sub-population of our established cohort will be a useful resource for future prospective studies.
Article
Full-text available
http://orcid.org/0000-0003-1324-7806 Людмила М. Пивина 1 , https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8035-4866, Ерсин Т. Жунусов 1 , https://orcid.org/ 1 Государственный медицинский университет города Семей, г. Семей, Республика Казахстан; 2 Норвежский Институт Радиационной Защиты, г. Осло, Норвегия. Введение: Изучение влияния факторов окружающей среды на состояние психического здоровья населения является широко распространенным подходом среди современных ученых, что позволяет охарактеризовать состояние психического здоровья, как на индивидуальном, так и на популяционном уровнях. Оценка состояние психического здоровья необходима для разработки программ первичной и вторичной профилактики нарушений здоровья. Не смотря на закрытие Семипалатинского ядерного полигона (СИЯП) в 1989 году, многие социальные, демографические и экономические вопросы остались нерешенными. Отмечается усугубление психологической напряженности среди жителей прилежащих к полигону территорий за счет появления в средствах массовой информации сведений, недостоверно отображающих реальную радиоэкологическую ситуацию в регионе, а также последствия радиационного воздействия на здоровье населения. Цель: изучение распространенности и тяжести депрессивных расстройств и тревожности у жителей Абайского и Бородулихинского районов, пострадавших от многолетних испытаний на СИЯП, в сравнении с жителями экологически благополучного Курчумского района. Материалы и методы. Дизайн данного исследования был поперечным. Для достижения поставленной цели, нами были сформированы группы исследования из населения Восточно-Казахстанской области, в соответствии с радиационным маршрутом. Объем выборки по Абайскому району составил 222 человека, по Бородулихинскому району-233 человек, по Курчумскому району (контрольная группа)-245 человек. Для оценки наличия и тяжести депрессивных расстройств и тревожности использовались клинические шкалы PHQ-9 и GAD-7, соответственно. Статистическая обработка результатов проводилась с помощью статистического пакета программы SPSS (Statistical Package for the Social Sciences) версия 20.0 для Windows (ГМУ г. Семей). Хи-квадрат Пирсона использовался при сравнении двух независимых групп номинальных переменных. Различия между группами считались достоверными, если имели 5% уровень значимости (р<0,05) Результаты: Исследование распространенности большого депрессивного расстройства (БДР) с помощью шкалы PHQ-9 показало, что минимальная степень расстройства (0-4 балла) встречалась у жителей села Курчум чаще (199 человек-81,2%), чем у жителей Абайского и Бородулихинского районов (65,7% и 65,8%, соответственно). Аналогичная закономерность наблюдалась и в случае умеренной (10-14 баллов), тяжелой (15-19 баллов) и крайне тяжелой (20-27 баллов) степеней депрессии: их частота в контрольной группе была ниже, чем в основной. Оценка степени тяжести генерализованного тревожного расстройства (ГТР) в группах исследования показала существенное превышения показателей умеренной и средней степени тревожности жителей как Абайского, так и Бородулихинского районов в сравнении с контрольными показателями (23,2%; 23,4% и 13,1% соответственно для умеренной степени и 4,3%; 3,6% и 2,9 % соответственно для тревожности средней степени). Выводы: результаты, полученные в ходе нашего исследования, подтвердили гипотезу о том, что фактор радиационного воздействия вследствие длительного проживания на экологически неблагоприятных территориях негативно влияет на показатели распространенности и степени выраженности большого депрессивного и генерализованного тревожного расстройства среди экспонированных радиацией лиц. Ключевые слова: большое депрессивное расстройство, генерализованное тревожное расстройство, пострадавшее население, Семипалатинский ядерный полигон.
Article
Full-text available
http://orcid.org/0000-0003-1324-7806 Людмила М. Пивина 1 , https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8035-4866, Ерсин Т. Жунусов 1 , https://orcid.org/ 1 Государственный медицинский университет города Семей, г. Семей, Республика Казахстан; 2 Норвежский Институт Радиационной Защиты, г. Осло, Норвегия. Введение: Изучение влияния факторов окружающей среды на состояние психического здоровья населения является широко распространенным подходом среди современных ученых, что позволяет охарактеризовать состояние психического здоровья, как на индивидуальном, так и на популяционном уровнях. Оценка состояние психического здоровья необходима для разработки программ первичной и вторичной профилактики нарушений здоровья. Не смотря на закрытие Семипалатинского ядерного полигона (СИЯП) в 1989 году, многие социальные, демографические и экономические вопросы остались нерешенными. Отмечается усугубление психологической напряженности среди жителей прилежащих к полигону территорий за счет появления в средствах массовой информации сведений, недостоверно отображающих реальную радиоэкологическую ситуацию в регионе, а также последствия радиационного воздействия на здоровье населения. Цель: изучение распространенности и тяжести депрессивных расстройств и тревожности у жителей Абайского и Бородулихинского районов, пострадавших от многолетних испытаний на СИЯП, в сравнении с жителями экологически благополучного Курчумского района. Материалы и методы. Дизайн данного исследования был поперечным. Для достижения поставленной цели, нами были сформированы группы исследования из населения Восточно-Казахстанской области, в соответствии с радиационным маршрутом. Объем выборки по Абайскому району составил 222 человека, по Бородулихинскому району-233 человек, по Курчумскому району (контрольная группа)-245 человек. Для оценки наличия и тяжести депрессивных расстройств и тревожности использовались клинические шкалы PHQ-9 и GAD-7, соответственно. Статистическая обработка результатов проводилась с помощью статистического пакета программы SPSS (Statistical Package for the Social Sciences) версия 20.0 для Windows (ГМУ г. Семей). Хи-квадрат Пирсона использовался при сравнении двух независимых групп номинальных переменных. Различия между группами считались достоверными, если имели 5% уровень значимости (р<0,05) Результаты: Исследование распространенности большого депрессивного расстройства (БДР) с помощью шкалы PHQ-9 показало, что минимальная степень расстройства (0-4 балла) встречалась у жителей села Курчум чаще (199 человек-81,2%), чем у жителей Абайского и Бородулихинского районов (65,7% и 65,8%, соответственно). Аналогичная закономерность наблюдалась и в случае умеренной (10-14 баллов), тяжелой (15-19 баллов) и крайне тяжелой (20-27 баллов) степеней депрессии: их частота в контрольной группе была ниже, чем в основной. Оценка степени тяжести генерализованного тревожного расстройства (ГТР) в группах исследования показала существенное превышения показателей умеренной и средней степени тревожности жителей как Абайского, так и Бородулихинского районов в сравнении с контрольными показателями (23,2%; 23,4% и 13,1% соответственно для умеренной степени и 4,3%; 3,6% и 2,9 % соответственно для тревожности средней степени). Выводы: результаты, полученные в ходе нашего исследования, подтвердили гипотезу о том, что фактор радиационного воздействия вследствие длительного проживания на экологически неблагоприятных территориях негативно влияет на показатели распространенности и степени выраженности большого депрессивного и генерализованного тревожного расстройства среди экспонированных радиацией лиц. Ключевые слова: большое депрессивное расстройство, генерализованное тревожное расстройство, пострадавшее население, Семипалатинский ядерный полигон.
Studies on the population of Kasakhstan: health effects
  • B Grosche
  • C Land
  • S Bauer
  • Z N Abylkassimova
  • B I Gusev
Grosche B, Land C, Bauer S, Abylkassimova ZN, Gusev BI (2002) Studies on the population of Kasakhstan: health effects. Radiat Environ Biophys 41:(This issue)
The results of study of radiological situation in some areas of Semipalatinsk and Pavlodar Oblasts of Kazakh SSR in 1959
  • Kobzev Af
  • Vg
  • Stepanov
  • Yus
Kobzev AF, Ryadov VG, Stepanov YuS, Turapin SL (1960) The results of study of radiological situation in some areas of Semipalatinsk and Pavlodar Oblasts of Kazakh SSR in 1959. Report of the State Research Center-Institute of Biophysics (in Russian)
Report on measurements of the trace of the radioactive cloud of fission products from the 1949 explosion. Training polygon #2 of the Ministry of Military Forces of the USSR
  • Enko Av
  • Iv
  • Alekseev Iv
  • Khovanovich
  • Ai
Enko AV, Remezov IV, Alekseev IV, Khovanovich AI (1949) Report on measurements of the trace of the radioactive cloud of fission products from the 1949 explosion. Training polygon #2 of the Ministry of Military Forces of the USSR (in Russian)
Characteristics of radiation conditions in areas bordering on the nuclear weapons testing territory, and of the health status of their population
  • A F Kobzev
  • V Z Agranat
  • Venitskovsky-Zolotykh
  • Stepanov Yuv
  • Yus
  • S L Turapin
Kobzev AF, Agranat VZ, Venitskovsky-Zolotykh YuV, Stepanov YuS, Turapin SL (1960) Characteristics of radiation conditions in areas bordering on the nuclear weapons testing territory, and of the health status of their population. Report of the State Research Center-Institute of Biophysics (in Russian)
Report on measurements of the trace of the radioactive cloud of fission products from the 1949 explosion. Training polygon #2 of the Ministry of Military Forces of the USSR
  • A V Enko
  • I V Remezov
  • I V Alekseev
  • A I Khovanovich
Enko AV, Remezov IV, Alekseev IV, Khovanovich AI (1949) Report on measurements of the trace of the radioactive cloud of fission products from the 1949 explosion. Training polygon #2 of the Ministry of Military Forces of the USSR (in Russian)
The results of study of radiological situation in some areas of Semipalatinsk and Pavlodar Oblasts of Kazakh SSR in 1959
  • A F Kobzev
  • V G Ryadov
  • Stepanov Yus
  • S L Turapin
Kobzev AF, Ryadov VG, Stepanov YuS, Turapin SL (1960) The results of study of radiological situation in some areas of Semipalatinsk and Pavlodar Oblasts of Kazakh SSR in 1959. Report of the State Research Center-Institute of Biophysics (in Russian)
Some data on outdoor radiation doses and doses to the population in areas contaminated by radioactive fallout from atmospheric nuclear tests (on the basis of the archival documents in State Research Center-Institute of Biophysics and in Federal Agency
  • Stepanov Yus
  • A P Dolgikh
  • L A Mikhalikhina
  • N A Bogdanenko
Stepanov YuS, Dolgikh AP, Mikhalikhina LA, Bogdanenko NA (1997) Some data on outdoor radiation doses and doses to the population in areas contaminated by radioactive fallout from atmospheric nuclear tests (on the basis of the archival documents in State Research Center-Institute of Biophysics and in Federal Agency "Medbioextrem"). Report:Retrospective assessment of radioactive contamination of different areas and reconstruction of doses to the population of the Russian Federation as a result of nuclear explosions conducted on the territory of the USSR (code -"Atlas"). State Research Center-Institute of Biophysics (in Russian)
International basic safety standards for protection against ionizing radiation and for the safety of radiation sources. Safety series No 115
IAEA (1996) International basic safety standards for protection against ionizing radiation and for the safety of radiation sources. Safety series No 115. International Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna