"Having the right chemistry": A qualitative study of mentoring in academic medicine

Department of Medicine, Dana Farber Cancer Institute, Brigham and Women's Hospital, and Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts 02115, USA.
Academic Medicine (Impact Factor: 2.93). 04/2003; 78(3):328-34.
Source: PubMed


To develop a deeper understanding of mentoring by exploring lived experiences of academic medicine faculty members. Mentoring relationships are key to developing productive careers in academic medicine, but such alliances hold a certain "mystery."
Using qualitative techniques, between November 1999 and March 2000, the authors conducted individual telephone interviews of 16 faculty members about their experiences with mentoring. Interviews were taped and transcribed and authors identified major themes through multiple readings. A consensus taxonomy for classifying content evolved from comparisons of coding by four reviewers. Themes expressed by participants were studied for patterns of connection and grouped into broader categories.
Almost 98% of participants identified lack of mentoring as the first (42%) or second (56%) most important factor hindering career progress in academic medicine. Finding a suitable mentor requires effort and persistence. Effective mentoring necessitates a certain chemistry for an appropriate interpersonal match. Prized mentors have "clout," knowledge, and interest in the mentees, and provide both professional and personal support. In cross-gender mentoring, maintaining clear boundaries is essential for an effective relationship. Same-gender or same-race matches between mentor and mentee were not felt to be essential.
Having a mentor is critical to having a successful career in academic medicine. Mentees need to be diligent in seeking out these relationships and institutions need to encourage and value the work of mentors. Participants without formalized mentoring relationships should look to peers and colleagues for assistance in navigating the academic system.

Download full-text


Available from: Anita Palepu
  • Source
    • "Mentoring for junior medical faculty: Existing models and suggestions for low-resource settings A considerable body of evidence shows that mentorship programmes in health sciences can positively impact scholarly productivity and career satisfaction among junior faculty (Jackson et al., 2003; Woods et al., 1997). Perhaps, due to the rapid changes in work allocation such as increasing emphasis on clinical, research and administrative responsibilities coupled with lack of protected time and resources for scholarly activities, more physicians, today, experience symptoms of burnout and are moving away from academia (Tijdink et al., 2014). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Globally, there is increasing recognition about the positive benefits and impact of mentoring on faculty retention rates, career satisfaction and scholarly output. However, emphasis on research and practice of mentoring is comparatively meagre in low and middle income countries. In this commentary, we critically examine two existing models of mentorship for medical faculty and offer few suggestions for an integrated hybrid model that can be adapted for use in low resource settings.
    Full-text · Article · Jan 2016 · Asian Journal of Psychiatry
    • "Matches are assigned by departmental heads or by mentee choice, so other informal personal factors or understandings might influence matches. The mentor–mentee match is of crucial significance to the success of a mentoring relationship (Jackson et al., 2003;Karcher, Nakkula, & Harris, 2005); not specifying matching mechanisms omits an important part of a mentoring model from description and analysis. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: More than three decades of mentoring research has yet to converge on a unifying definition of mentoring; this is unsurprising given the diversity of relationships classified as mentoring. This article advances beyond a definition toward a common framework for specifying mentoring models. Sixteen design elements were identified from the literature and tested through specification of two different mentoring models from higher education contexts. This framework provides researchers and practitioners with a detailed yet concise method of communicating exactly what they mean when using the word mentoring; it may also act as a useful set of prompts for educators designing new mentoring interventions.
    No preview · Article · Apr 2014 · Educational Researcher
  • Source
    • "The emotional experience is a central 94 S.E. Kim feature of social exchange such as the mentoring process that can affect developmental networking, which is a major social structure to engage in exchange behavior (Jackson et al., 2003). A mentor who has positive emotion and feels responsibility for a protégé's career success would supply a stream of information and human connections that are not typically available from other types of training programs in the organization. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Despite increasing role of mentoring in public organizations, mentoring and its outcomes have been under-investigated in public management. The purpose of the study is to fill the void by focusing on the mentor-protégé relationship and its effect on mentoring outcomes. Given the complexity of psychological interactions between mentor and protégé, this study examined the influence of the mentor-protégé affinity on mentoring outcomes both directly and indirectly through developmental networking. The results found that the mentor and protégé affinity did not have a direct impact on mentoring outcomes. Instead, its effects were fully mediated by internal and external developmental networking, which were the direct predictors of mentoring outcomes. This implies that finding a good match between mentor and protégé is important, but it is effective to mentoring outcomes only through the establishment of developmental networking.
    Full-text · Article · Apr 2014 · International Review of Public Administration
Show more