Discussion
Started 16 February 2025
  • Independent Researcher

What is Value-driven Thinking?

Human life is conditioned by the essence of time, the bounds of space, and the depth of meaning. Eternal values, as universal guides to truth, illuminate the night of lost illusions and become stars of resilience. In today's consumeristic world, where justice has been dressed as an outsider, where truth and kindness are being sent on vacation, and where the beauty of endurance is not considered a modern trend, the passport of eternal values loses its validity.
In your perspective, what is value-driven thinking?

Most recent answer

Amalya Sukiasyan
Independent Researcher
Karl Pfeifer, I agree that ethics does not have any authority for gangsters, especially given their self-made and morally unapproved philosophy. As said in The Human Comedy by William Saroyan: "The wicked people of the world don’t know they are wicked. That’s why they are wicked. And that’s why they come to be kind."
The right direction in life is found by following the compass based on eternal truth and undiminishable values, which are objective and exist independent of consciousness.

All replies (6)

Karl Pfeifer
University of Saskatchewan
Value-driven thinking is just a decision to pursue certain preferences. They may not be preferences that you favor and they may not be salutary from your point of view. Nazis and gangsters are driven by their own values.
Amalya Sukiasyan
Independent Researcher
Thank you for your response. I think values should be considered moral responsibilities rather than personal preferences. Gangsters are motivated by their 'world-destroying profession,' not by value-driven thinking.
Karl Pfeifer
University of Saskatchewan
You assume all values that drive people must be, according to your standards, morally positive values. Unfortunately some folks value conquest, acquisition, and status. Also, Old Norse religion regarded warrior values as especially worthy and their embodiment as a requirement for admission to Valhalla.
Amalya Sukiasyan
Independent Researcher
It's true that objective values, which have been morally accepted, carry less or no weight to some, expressing the contrasting nature of subjectivity. However, there are values, which are non-negotiable from the perspective of ethics, absolutist thinking, and epistemic obligations.
Karl Pfeifer
University of Saskatchewan
You wrote: "However, there are values, which are non-negotiable from the perspective of ethics,"
Maybe so, and in fact that's my position too. But you have now shifted the goal posts. Your question was "What is Value-driven Thinking?" and not "What is thinking driven by absolutist ethical values?" For sure, some values are better than others, but not everyone is driven by those better values. And there's a further problem, since some of those people driven by value systems you and I might disagree with nonetheless regard their values as ethical and obligatory. Although it's certainly true that gangsters may recognize but reject or ignore many ethical values and obligations, it is not obvious that the warrior values of Old Norse religion were a rejection of ethical values and obligations they recognized rather than constituting an ethical system based on different values.
Amalya Sukiasyan
Independent Researcher
Karl Pfeifer, I agree that ethics does not have any authority for gangsters, especially given their self-made and morally unapproved philosophy. As said in The Human Comedy by William Saroyan: "The wicked people of the world don’t know they are wicked. That’s why they are wicked. And that’s why they come to be kind."
The right direction in life is found by following the compass based on eternal truth and undiminishable values, which are objective and exist independent of consciousness.

Similar questions and discussions

Related Publications

Article
Quantitative evidence is the “bones,” qualitative evidence is the “flesh,” and evaluative reasoning is the “vital organs” that bring them both to life. True “beauty” in evaluation is a clearly reasoned, well-crafted, coherent evaluation story that weaves all three of these together to unlock both truth and justice with breathtaking clarity. This ch...
Article
Comment forger la confiance des futurs officiers ? Le lieutenant-colonel Brice Erbland, commandant de bataillon à Saint-Cyr Coëtquidan, livre sa « recette » : agir pour donner confiance, d’abord, en employant l’exemplarité, la justice et l’amour, puis faire confiance et encourager en donnant de la liberté d’action et en poussant à rechercher les tr...
Got a technical question?
Get high-quality answers from experts.