University Centre of Maghnia
Question
Asked 5 July 2013
What is the best method for case analysis?
Base on strategic models
Most recent answer
Start with defining the identification of the problems and using in case analysis the management concept of SWOT ( Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats )
1 Recommendation
Popular answers (1)
For case study analysis, first & foremost is to understand and note the situations in the case. Further study of the case, must lead to identification of the problems which the organization, under study, is facing. These two factors, viz, Situations & Problems in the case, will help in further analysis, using strategic model. Case analysis could be done, using the concept of SWOT ( Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats ), ETOP ( Environmental Threat and Opportunity profile) & SAP ( Strategic Advantage Profile) analysis, Matrix analysis ( e.g. BCG, GE Nine Cell etc. ). The strategic decision on analysis, must lead to competitive advantage & value creation for the organization to overcome the problems.
This method is based on basic concept of strategic management. There could be other methods of analysis.
7 Recommendations
All Answers (9)
For case study analysis, first & foremost is to understand and note the situations in the case. Further study of the case, must lead to identification of the problems which the organization, under study, is facing. These two factors, viz, Situations & Problems in the case, will help in further analysis, using strategic model. Case analysis could be done, using the concept of SWOT ( Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats ), ETOP ( Environmental Threat and Opportunity profile) & SAP ( Strategic Advantage Profile) analysis, Matrix analysis ( e.g. BCG, GE Nine Cell etc. ). The strategic decision on analysis, must lead to competitive advantage & value creation for the organization to overcome the problems.
This method is based on basic concept of strategic management. There could be other methods of analysis.
7 Recommendations
I agree with Jaharkanti that it depends entirely on the context and objectives of the case analysis. Also, tools are available for management practice, but methods for management research are still pretty rare. For an actual methodical approach, I recommend writings on the use of critical realist approaches in the field, for example:
Easton, G., 2010. Critical realism in case study research. Industrial Marketing Management, 39(1), pp.118–128.
Miller, K.D. & Tsang, E.W.K., 2010. Testing Management Theories: Critical Realist Philosophy and Research Methods. Strategic Management Journal, 158(May), pp.139–158.
1 Recommendation
FORE School of Management
Putting yourself in the shoe of decision maker...
!!! No need to do any thing !!!
La Trobe University
If you could provide a little more context, it would be helpful. Are you asking about undertaking research in an organisation and therefore using a case methodology, or are you asking about how to 'solve' a case - as in the kind that are usually published at Harvard University and their ilk?
Texas A&M University – Commerce
Case Methodology Analysis
The case method of analysis involves studying actual business situations—written as an in-depth presentation of a company, its market, and its strategic decisions—in order to improve a manager's or a student's problem-solving ability. Cases typically investigate a contemporary issue in a real-life context.
1 Recommendation
Italian National Institute of Statistics
If the basis is scientific, principal component analysis and cluster analysis.
1 Recommendation
Similar questions and discussions
Related Publications
The present research aimed at proposing a practical model for strategic analysis of national and macro issues using the strengths and successful experiences with the techniques from both descriptive and prescriptive approaches to strategic management. The documented studies of the present research indicate that the schools and the dozens of techniq...
This chapter explores deeper into the meaning of strategy through the theme ‘Strategy Making and Implementing’. Specifically, it focuses on strategic thinking, strategic analysis, and strategic planning. Major works on these concepts are reviewed and assessed, including the contributions of Ohmae, Hamel and Prahalad, Mintzberg, and Rumelt. Asian an...
The article discusses modern concepts and approaches to the strategic planning development and managers’ strategic thinking formation. Today the strategic thinking is considered as one of the most important and most demanded management competencies. However, there is still no understanding how managers can develop that competencies. The article pro...