Discussion
Started 12 August 2018

Proof of Stake Interest Money and Islam

Is it Halal to trade cryptocurrencies or tokens using the Proof of Stake protocol if one does not participate in activities such as validation which result in the accumulation of interest money? In banking, Islamic scholars have suggested a number of ways to tackle the interest money given by a bank using ways such as opening a checking account and doing timely payments, disposing of the interest in the form of charity or, rejecting it altogether from the bank. But what approach will apply in this aforementioned case of cryptocurrencies and tokens?
This question is a part of the future research process after my recent research paper was published on cryptocurrencies.

Most recent answer

Sudais Asif
Lahore School of Economics
But even if the value of the underlying currency is coming from an impermissible protocol?

All replies (4)

Frédéric Ouimet
McGill University
I'm not 100% sure what can be considered Halal, but it seems that you can't pay fees or collect interest. The cryptocurrency NANO has feeless transactions and is Proof Of Stake.
Frédéric Ouimet
McGill University
So, for NANO specifically, if you don't confirm transactions on the network (run nodes), then it should be Halal (I don't see a reason why it wouldn't be).
Frédéric Ouimet
McGill University
It wouldn't be any different than trading currencies on a FOREX islamic trading account (which is Halal).
Sudais Asif
Lahore School of Economics
But even if the value of the underlying currency is coming from an impermissible protocol?

Similar questions and discussions

What are the key determinants of building a risk management system for investing in cryptocurrencies?
Discussion
5 replies
  • Dariusz ProkopowiczDariusz Prokopowicz
What are the key determinants of building a risk management system for investing in cryptocurrencies conducted in speculative financial operations and investment transactions carried out on online trading platforms?
In recent years, there has been a rapid development of cryptocurrencies and their applications in online payments and settlements and their treatment as alternative investment instruments. Internet-based trading platforms are being developed, where speculative trading and investment using cryptocurrencies is expanding. Some investment banks, internationally operating corporations, social media sites are creating their own cryptocurrencies. Some investment funds have been investing part of their active funds in selected cryptocurrencies for many years. However, due to the lack of a developed institutional oversight system for transactions, payments and investments using cryptocurrencies. Consequently, speculative financial operations and investment transactions carried out on online trading platforms are characterised by a high level of investment risk. Consequently, it is important to build a risk management system for investing in cryptocurrencies.
In view of the above, I address the following question to the esteemed community of researchers and scientists:
What are the key determinants of building a risk management system for cryptocurrency investment conducted in speculative financial operations and investment transactions carried out on online trading platforms?
What do you think about this topic?
What is your opinion on this subject?
Please respond,
I invite you all to discuss,
Thank you very much,
Best wishes,
Dariusz Prokopowicz
Are current financial markets over-regulated or overly deregulated in their functioning?
Discussion
4 replies
  • Dariusz ProkopowiczDariusz Prokopowicz
Are today's financial markets over-regulated, optimally normatively regulated or overly deregulated and liberalised in their functioning?
Since the commodity crisis of the 1970s, financial markets have been deregulated in many respects. The Bretton Woods international monetary system based on USD dollar parity collapsed (gold parity for the USD dollar was abolished). In the 1990s, many issues of the operation of deposit-credit commercial banks and investment banks were deregulated again.
It was made possible for the two types of banking to merge. This had its effects in generating the global financial crisis of 2007-2009. Due to the deregulation of financial markets, systemic credit risk increased significantly. The importance of improving the credit risk management process implemented in financial institutions, including commercial and investment banks, also increased. In many countries, the practice of money printing without coverage of manufactured products was practised, leading to increased inflation and, in some countries, to the occurrence of hyperinflation. Too low interest rates and government guarantees and other elements of a soft monetary policy led to too cheap money, too high a level of credit for economic activity and too high a level of credit risk, a decline in the repayment of bank loans and, as a consequence, to financial, economic and debt crises, etc. Derivatives specifically generated for this purpose, including credit derivatives such as subprime bonds, CDOs, etc., sold by investment banks to successive investors to generate additional money for unreliably (with practically no credit checks) granted mortgages, led to the major global financial crisis of 2008 in 2007-2009. I have been researching this issue. I have included the conclusions of my research in articles which, when published, I posted on my profile of this Research Gate portal. I invite research collaboration. I would like to hear your views on this issue.
In view of the above, the following question is topical:
Are the current financial markets over-regulated, optimally normatively regulated or are they too deregulated and liberalised in their functioning?
What do you think about this topic?
Please reply,
I invite you all to discuss,
Thank you very much,
Greetings,
Dariusz Prokopowicz
Is the issue of Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) still in the realm of concepts or has it already been implemented in some countries?
Discussion
3 replies
  • Dariusz ProkopowiczDariusz Prokopowicz
Is the issue of Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) still in the realm of concepts likely to be introduced in the future or has this solution already been implemented in some countries?
The Covid-19 pandemic has resulted in the acceleration of the digitization and Internetization of various aspects of the business activities of companies and enterprises, Internet-implemented processes for the sale of products and services, Internet-implemented payments and settlements, Internet-implemented marketing communications with customers, and so on. Much earlier, in the 1990s, in some countries, the first companies began to develop their business activities, including the sale of certain products and/or services via the Internet, the first Internet businesses began to operate, Internet startups, dotcoms growing rapidly, portals offering Internet information services, earning money from the sale of Internet advertising, and so on. At that time, electronic banking was already developing rapidly, offering its banking services remotely, first to institutional clients, and then to individual clients, to citizens. Electronic banking initially providing remote banking services in the form of so-called home banking, and then at the turn of the century transformed into online banking and then into mobile banking. Successively, therefore, the electronification, digitization and Internetization of banking is progressing year by year. In some countries, as early as the late 1990s, there were already considerations about the future of Internet banking development. The possibility of a full transition of banking to online banking was considered, as well as the full replacement of money existing in traditional form, i.e. in the form of banknotes and coins, to the form of electronic money. Already at that time there were theories suggesting that soon, in a few years, all banking will become Internet banking, that physically existing bank branches will disappear completely, physically existing money will disappear from citizens' wallets and will be completely replaced by its electronic counterpart. A continuation of this kind of considerations is the transition of central banks to a kind of form of electronic central banking and the replacement of traditional money with digital currency generated and introduced into the economy by central banks within the framework of shaped monetary policy. In a situation where the progressive processes of digitization and internetization would also apply to central banking then monetary policy could also be subject to these processes. Well, during the Covid-19 pandemic, there was also an increased interest in the development of central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) in some countries. Some countries have attempted to introduce digital currencies of central banks. An interesting issue is the possibility of involving Blockchain technology in the development of systems based on central banks' digital currencies, which could ensure a high level of security for these digital currencies. However, both the positive aspects of the introduction of central banks' digital currencies for the formation of monetary policy, which would also be implemented more digitally, are still not fully recognized. The negative aspects of the introduction of financial systems and their development based on central banks' digital currencies are also not diagnosed. It is not fully explored what new risks in financial markets can be generated by the introduction of central banks' digital currencies. It is not known how the introduction of digital currencies of central banks could affect the stability of financial systems, the situation in financial markets and the macroeconomic stability of the economy as a whole.
I have described the key issues of the central banking problem in my articles below:
Synergy of post-2008 Anti-Crisis Policy of the Mild Monetary Policy of the Federal Reserve Bank and the European Central Bank
Analysis of the effects of post-2008 anti-crisis mild monetary policy of the Federal Reserve Bank and the European Central Bank
A safe monetary central banking policy as a significant instrument for liquidity maintenance in the financial system
ACTIVATING INTERVENTIONIST MONETARY POLICY OF THE EUROPEAN CENTRAL BANK IN THE CONTEXT OF THE SECURITY OF THE EUROPEAN FINANCIAL SYSTEM
Anti-crisis state intervention and created in media images of global financial crisis
I invite you to get acquainted with the issues described in the above-mentioned publications and to scientific cooperation in these issues.
In view of the above, I address the following question to the esteemed community of scientists and researchers:
Is the issue of Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) still in the realm of concepts likely to be introduced in the future or has it already been implemented in some countries?
Is the issue of Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) still in the realm of concepts or has this solution already been implemented in some countries?
What do you think about this topic?
What is your opinion on this issue?
Please answer,
I invite everyone to join the discussion,
Thank you very much,
Best wishes,
Dariusz Prokopowicz
The above text is entirely my own work written by me on the basis of my research.
In writing this text, I did not use other sources or automatic text generation systems.
Copyright by Dariusz Prokopowicz

Related Publications

Article
What is an economic platform? I address this question by focusing on the case of cryptocurrency exchange platforms. The research draws on interviews with platform actors, fieldwork in one exchange, and computational text analysis of the terms of service of all cryptocurrency exchanges in the world. I argue that cryptocurrency exchange platforms go...
Data
Currency system has been constantly evolving since the concept of money has been introduced. In this age of information technology, the next level in the currency system is digital currency, popularised since the last few years by its main sub-type, the cryptocurrency. Cryptocurrencies are open-source algorithms which can be programmed by anyone an...
Got a technical question?
Get high-quality answers from experts.