Discussion
Started 11 February 2024

Encouragement, support and general counsel are ALL welcomed.

Direct confrontation often ONLY generates resentment. I think my premises, although somewhat derived from philosophy(as all science is), are rigorous(examples are all my publications on ResearchGate). I come to my conclusions with EMPIRICAL evidence AND logic. I also still seek a PhD by publication.

Popular replies (1)

Mohammed Xolile Ntshangase
University of Limpopo
Yes direct confrontation generates resentment and defense in almost all cases
6 Recommendations

All replies (3)

Mohammed Xolile Ntshangase
University of Limpopo
Yes direct confrontation generates resentment and defense in almost all cases
6 Recommendations
Tiago Horta Reis da Silva
King's College London
Dear Alexander Ohnemus very good point. Please make sure you contact a university that has the option to complete a PhD by publications and discuss what could go towards or not that degree.
3 Recommendations
Lilian Hupkens
University of South Africa
A degree by publication is more than putting a staple through a pile of publications. Questions you should ask yourself:
1. Are the publications peer reviewed and then published in reputed journals?
2. When you select several articles for your phd thesis, do they demonstrate that you have developed a certain train of thoughts or developed a theory through these publications? Can you demonstrate developing a consistent theory or model through these publications?
Regarding 1) if your articles are peer reviewed and then published, then it serves as proof of a certain academic standard. If not, that has to come from the thesis itself.
Regarding 2) A phd thesis must demonstrate new knowledge, your addition to new knowledge, and how it relates to existing theories and knowledge. This means doing more work than just summing up the existing publications. It needs a beginning, text to join up the separate articles explaining how you got from A to B, and conclusions etc. The articles are only the raw materials.
Hope this can help you, writing a phd thesis remains a lot of work.

Similar questions and discussions

How to make academia relevant and academics more attractive on the labour market?
Discussion
63 replies
  • Henrik G.S. ArvidssonHenrik G.S. Arvidsson
Dear friends
I hope you had a nice summer. I sometimes get the comment that academia is not relevant from business colleagues and clients in my consultancy business. For me academia has always been something I have been careful not to associate my self too much with, even if I love to teach. My question is that if there is a way to bridge this gap or conflict between academics and practitioners? I often hear highly negative and degrading comments aimed towards academia from business leaders, some of which have themselves masters or Phd.
I think in the long run this is bad because it reduces the opportunities for academics and makes the transition between one field to another more difficult. I can my self admit to having a bias, meaning I would think twice before employing someone who has been in academia for an extended period of time.I realise this is something I need to work on, prejudice and generalisation is never good!. I think there are a lot of competent people in academia but in many ways academia has become a world of its own with little or no connection to the real world, making it more difficult to move from academia to for example a managerial role or consultancy, what works in theory doesn't always work in practice. Do you have any experiences from the vantage point of an academic? My experience is mainly from the other side, that of a business owner but it would be interesting to also hear the other side. Do you have any experiences? How can this gap between academia and "the world" be bridged or should it?How can we change the view of private businesses that academia is somehow a different world inhabited by some very odd creatures?
Also note that there is no intent of disrespect or hostility on my behalf towards academia or academics. I might have deep rooted issues with the current state of academia but many of my friends are academics. .
I wish you all a wonderful day

Related Publications

Article
Cyberlearning provides opportunities to many individuals who may not be able to participate in traditional campus-based counselor preparation programs. However, these opportunities will only be fruitful for the students if the online learning experience is of the highest quality. Thus, planning is an essential component of developing a high quality...
Article
Full-text available
A conceptual matrix for the development of professional identity as a counselor educator is presented as a method of promoting self-management for doctoral-level counselor education students. Seven areas of intentionality are discussed, suggested activities are provided in each category for a 4-year program period, and implications for current and...
Article
Reviews the need for a developmental conception as the aim of educational intervention. The rationale is presented and compared to the mental health treatment approach. A case is made for the importance of a primary intervention, an ego and moral development focus for the psychological education of pupils and young adults. (PsycINFO Database Record...
Got a technical question?
Get high-quality answers from experts.