Discussion
Started 11 December 2024

Does 'intertextuality' support a work of fantasy? Contextually does it add interest in readers?

Speaking of 'hidden layers' in speculative fiction, too many texts, echoes and other references within the texts can be enticing the literature people. Does it really help a person who knew nothing about literary aspects understand its importance in that work?

Most recent answer

Intertextuality enriches the narrative by adding layers of meaning and connections to other texts, myths, and cultural references.In the fantasy genre, which often relies on world-building and myth-making, intertextuality provides depth and resonance by linking the fictional world to archetypes, stories, or historical events.Intertextuality supports fantasy works through world-building, reader engagement, and adding layers of meaning.Examples of intertextuality in fantasy works include Tolkien's references to Norse mythology and medieval literature in The Lord of the Rings, and Neil Gaiman's integration of myths and literary texts in American Gods.Intertextuality not only deepens the thematic and narrative complexity of fantasy works, but also increases their appeal by engaging readers on intellectual and emotional levels.

All replies (7)

Daniel Nisa Cáceres
Pablo de Olavide University
Intertextuality (dialogism, heteroglossia, etc.) is indeed present in any literary work, and speculative fiction is no exception. Whether it provides readers with contextual information or not--and to what extent, that depends on the readers' cultural background, previous reads, specific expertise, etc. I would go a bit further along these lines and add that translators of speculative fiction, for example, must be highly knowledgeable in how intertextual presences--or discoursive spectralities--are articulated so that the target readers of their translation find themselves exposed--rather than in possession of--to the same contextual, hypertextual, intertextual and intratextual constituents as the original readers.
2 Recommendations
بالتأكيد يمكن للتناص (الاقتباس) أن يعزز من قيمة العمل الخيالي ويزيد من اهتمام القرّاء عبر إضفاء عمق ومصداقية على السرد، مما يجعله أكثر إقناعا للمتلقي، إذ يربط النص بعوالم ثقافية وأدبية أوسع من خلال الإشارة إلى أساطير أو نصوص أو رموز مألوفة. يتيح ذلك للقراء استكشاف طبقات جديدة من المعنى ويضفي شعورًا بالألفة والتفاعل، مما يجعل التجربة القرائية أكثر جاذبية. كما يساهم في توسيع نطاق الجمهور وإثراء العالم الخيالي، شرط أن يكون التناص مدمجًا بعناية ليضيف قيمة دون تعقيد غير ضروري.
1 Recommendation
Intertextual elements would definitely help in portraying the author’s perception of the world in his literary work. This work, once finished, shall be an utterance in an open-ended dialogue, rejecting, emphasizing, modifying the other utterances’ perception of the world. This is simply what is meant by dialogism whether it is supralogically or equalogiclly delivered. The reader, who has the knowledge of dialogic relationship between too many cultural representations, resembles those who have an eye bird (panoramic) view of the complete elements of a scene, or the whole discourse of literary works in the open-ended dialogue of the most inclusive context of culture elements. I think my M.A. Thesis; Bakhtin’s Dialogism …., (with my humble devised perception of dialogism) would help much to fully understand the concept of “Intertextuality” as a manifestation of “Dialogism” with its variable shapes.
Eric Alloi
Université de Montréal
Intertextuality, while having been around in all art forms since the beginning of time, takes on more importance from the postmodern era and onward. As culture seeks to present variations on set structures, the "narrative effects" become as, and in some cases more, important than the story itself. Therefore, assuming a competent reader with common knowledge of other works, authors use intertextuality as common practice, as readers rejoice from being able to recognize an author's references. See Umberto Eco's work on this. Also, Mittel and his work on complex narratives in serials.
2 Recommendations
A S Raagavi
Bharath University
Eric Alloi, thank you for the suggestion. We do enjoy the author's references in works. When I was reading a work by Neil Gaiman for my research, I wondered how someone could understand and relate these intertexts and hypertexts he has imbibed in his novel. As Daniel Nisa Cáceres mentions, one must know how targeted readers achieve these. Alamir Muhamad Hindawy Sultan thank you. I will look into your M.A. thesis (if available online). أ.بدرية عامر القاسمية I agree it enhances the value of the fiction, and it does influence the imaginary world. Glad to know all your thoughts. It is definitely helpful to me.
Eric Alloi
Université de Montréal
A S Raagavi My M.A. thesis (while being available online if you can read French) had nothing to do with Intertextuality, I was studying identity and subjectivity in the intermedial works of Marilyn Manson! lol (I was in comparative literature at the time) I am now ongoing a Ph. D. in cinema, in research-creation option. My work continues to be about intermediality, which is a pretty important concept here in Montréal (Québec, Canada). I also did my B.A. in French Literature, so concepts like intertextuality are pretty basic stuff for me. You might be interested in reception studies, like Jauss and Eco. Concept of model reader.
Intertextuality enriches the narrative by adding layers of meaning and connections to other texts, myths, and cultural references.In the fantasy genre, which often relies on world-building and myth-making, intertextuality provides depth and resonance by linking the fictional world to archetypes, stories, or historical events.Intertextuality supports fantasy works through world-building, reader engagement, and adding layers of meaning.Examples of intertextuality in fantasy works include Tolkien's references to Norse mythology and medieval literature in The Lord of the Rings, and Neil Gaiman's integration of myths and literary texts in American Gods.Intertextuality not only deepens the thematic and narrative complexity of fantasy works, but also increases their appeal by engaging readers on intellectual and emotional levels.

Similar questions and discussions

Related Publications

Article
Joe Abercrombie's Red Country, Drood by Dan Simmons, Pierre Pevel's Les Lames du cardinal and The Way of Shadows written by Brent Weeks are the examples of fantasy novels used to show the function of intertextuality and intercultural relations in the translation of fantasy texts, with the fantasy worlds constituting a separate culture, which must b...
Article
The study of the natural laws of semantic organization of the musical text is a topical issue of contemporary musicology. In this connection a unique opportunity to immerse into the processes of text-generation is presented by research of instrumental compositions which have appeared on the basis of borrowing and modifi cation of an “alien” musical...
Article
The intertextual analysis of Dora illuminates an aspect of the cultural matrix that informed Freud's theory-building. Specifically, the trope of the suggestive text, a literal and symbolic agent of transgressive influence, signals an intertextual relationship between the case history and a vein of literary fiction that includes novels by some of Fr...
Got a technical question?
Get high-quality answers from experts.