Question
Asked 28 January 2017

Do you know any NOISEMAKERS in ANCIENT GREECE and ROME?

I am searching for NOISEMAKERS in ANCIENT GREECE and ROME, in art depictions and archaeological finds.
I know that "Draco" in the Roman army is one possibility but I need one more simple piece.  It is possible exist as music instrument.  Please I am not interested in children's toys.  
I attach one actually and traditional noisemaker, it is very similar to the one I am searching but isn't the same.
Thanks.

Most recent answer

Joachim Neumaier
Ia am an independent researcher related to the museum of Bichen but open for all.
Anyway it would be worthwile to study the axe in a larger context, the archaeological as well as the iconographical.

All Answers (8)

James Kelly
University College London
There are quite a few used in religious ceremonies etc. The rhombus was a piece of wood swung around the head on a piece of string, to simulate thunder and provide an accompaniment to ceremonies worshipping Zeus. There's a good presentation on slideplayer of some primitive instruments / noisemakers and their representation in ancient art. It even has some reproductions of their sounds.
1 Recommendation
Mª Engracia Muñoz Santos
University of Valencia
I think that is a noisemaker...
Joachim Neumaier
Ia am an independent researcher related to the museum of Bichen but open for all.
In the part of Germany, where I live, this is used in carnival. In some regiones they call it Rätsche.
1 Recommendation
Joachim Neumaier
Ia am an independent researcher related to the museum of Bichen but open for all.
It is used as well in the alaman-swiss-alpine-swabian carnival as in the rhineland area (Cologne, etc.).
1 Recommendation
Joachim Neumaier
Ia am an independent researcher related to the museum of Bichen but open for all.
Espero que habrá oportunidad de poner en marcha una publicación conjunta compartida por arqueólogs y etnógrafos.
Timothy Edward Jones
Swansea University
The samian image looks more like a bestiarius wielding a large axe, it certainly appears in this context in numerous bull fighting scenes c.f.
Bird, J. (2012) ‘Arena scenes with bulls on South Gaulish samian’, in D. Bird (ed.) Dating and Interpreting the Past in the Western Roman Empire: Essays in Honour of Brenda Dickinson, Oxford, Oxbow, 135-148.
wrt noisemakers, a 2008 Time Team from Caerwent showed a modified bone that was claimed to be one, if you contact Wessex Archaeology they may know where it is curated
Mª Engracia Muñoz Santos
University of Valencia
Thanks!! it is very interesting!!  I think it is possibly a bestiarius.  I look for the Bird's work.  Thanks! 
Joachim Neumaier
Ia am an independent researcher related to the museum of Bichen but open for all.
Anyway it would be worthwile to study the axe in a larger context, the archaeological as well as the iconographical.

Similar questions and discussions

Is there research on opera's topical or current events subtext?
Question
4 answers
  • Gloria Lee McmillanGloria Lee Mcmillan
The current Metropolitan Opera production (Feb. 2017) is Antonin Dvorak's Rusalka.  This opera contains what may be viewed as current events references. 
The Grove Dictionary of Music entry on rhetoric and music states that after the Baroque period, the rhetorical underpinnings of music were no longer studied.  But in the 20th C., such highlighted rhetoric in art music is causing a revival of interest.
QUOTE
What still remains to be fully explained is how these critical interrelationships often controlled the craft of composition. These developments are unclear partly because modern musicians and scholars are untrained in the rhetorical disciplines, which since the beginning of the 19th century have largely disappeared from most educational and philosophical system. It was only in the early 20th century that music historians rediscovered the importance of rhetoric as the basis of aesthetic and theoretical concepts in earlier music. An entire discipline that had once been the common property of every educated man has had to be rediscovered and reconstructed during the intervening decades, and only now is it beginning to be understood how much Western art music has depended on rhetorical concepts. ("Rhetoric and Music." Grove Dictionary of Music. Blake Wilson et al.)
UNQUOTE
Does anyone know of research that specifically analyzes the rhetorical aspects of modern era opera since Wagner to now?
Given that directors have much leeway in creating subtexts in classic and contemporary works, this is a topic that is open for more study.

Related Publications

Got a technical question?
Get high-quality answers from experts.