Tribhuvan University
Question
Asked 8 December 2018
Can we re-used the reinforcement extracted from demolition of a building for the construction of a new building?
Upon your experience.. in construction material.. can we
re-used the reinforcement extracted from demolition of a building for the construction of a new building?
Most recent answer
Not recommended. It may be in plastic state. Induced internal stress could be risk factor as well.
Popular answers (1)
Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University
Dear Kolawole Afolabi ... Thanks for answering...
13 Recommendations
All Answers (35)
University of Baghdad /College of Engineering /Department of Civil Engineering
If the reinforcement did not have any defect (cracks).
3 Recommendations
University of Kufa
I think it is possible, but under load level less than the loads and conditions of the buildings in which the steel bars were extracted from.
1 Recommendation
University of Information Technology and Communications
If the reinforcement didn't have any defect or problems like rust.
1 Recommendation
CRM Group
Never re-use these rebars for other construction because you know nether the steel grade (mechanical properties) nor the behavior of these reinforcement (fatigue, plastic deformation, ...) during their life and more particularly during the demolition.
The collected rebars must be scrapped to be re-used only by smelting (steel melting shop) to get new steel.
5 Recommendations
Faculty of Architecture, University of Lisbon
Colleague Jean-Françoise Noville is very correct.
1 Recommendation
City of Atlanta, GA
Never reuse rebar for actual structural construction. You might consider using it in a non-structural application such as curb or sidewalk on grade.
1 Recommendation
University of Mosul
Yes we can, l used for many new buildings in Iraq, at the embargo time I.e. before 20th year ago...
You can take sample and check fy and elongation for this reinforcement.
Thanks
2 Recommendations
Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University
Dear Mohannad H. Al-Sherrawi .. thanks for answering..
But did the defect (crack) will be checked by eyes and evaluated by site engineer or what..?
4 Recommendations
Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University
Dear Qasim M. Shakir .. thanks for answering..
So you think that the extracted steel is not that much effective and have not the same strength as it used for the first time.. so you prefer to use under low loading..
5 Recommendations
Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University
Ola Adel Qasim ... thanks for answering...
How can we evaluate that... is it just by direct check .. looking for any defect or rust.. or we need to do some laboratory tested..?
4 Recommendations
Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University
Dear Jean-François Noville ..thanks for answering..
Agree with the item, ... that mechanical properties will change, and an addition, to that, the changed can't be predicted or its almost has unknown behavior ... but.. there are many parts in the structure may need the minimum requirement of reinforcement...so can we increase this ratio by re-using that reinforcement..?
4 Recommendations
Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University
Dear
Chettri Nmesh
.... thanks for answering...3 Recommendations
Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University
Dear Soheyl Sazedj ... thanks for answering..
3 Recommendations
Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University
Dear Craig Rethwilm ... thanks for answering..
4 Recommendations
Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University
Dear Salim Kouloughli ... Thanks for answering
4 Recommendations
University of Karbala
Steel reinforcement is infinitely recyclable, More than 65% of all reinforcing bars are recycled, according to The Steel Recycling Institute. However, you can see
From the research above they can used but after making some mandatory test.
1 Recommendation
Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University
Dear Ayad A. Abdul-Razzak ... Thanks for answering..
So you think that the reinforcement extracted from old building is the same quality and strength as the new one..? You know that structural design based on the strength of steel reinforcement...
4 Recommendations
Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University
Dear Aymen J Alsaad .. thanks for answering.. and for the reference..
4 Recommendations
University of Dar es Salaam
A concrete reinforcement steel whether mild or high yield should meet specified minimum values given in standards for it to be suitable for reinforcement and these are:
1. Minimum yield stress, fy
2. Maximum tensile strength , ft
3. Minimum elongation at failure, dl
4. Minimum ratio: ft/fy
For cold worked steels a proof stress is specified, usually the stress at 0.02% elongation.
Steel obtained from a demolished building cannot meet the above criteria because of excessive bending of the steel during demolition which may make the steel yield. More over the steel is unlikely to be of uniform quality due to things like corrosion etc.
1 Recommendation
University of Mosul
I think we can use the reinforcement taken from demolition because the old buildings designed using the elastic theory i.e. the reinforcement doesn't reach fy.
So we can check the standard for this reinforcement ( mentioned by Dr Alex ) and decided if we use it or not depends on the results of the Laboratory...
Note: The reinforcement used must be clean.
Thanks
1 Recommendation
Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University
Dear Alex Mrema .. thanks for answering.. really useful information..
6 Recommendations
Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University
Dear Ayad A. Abdul-Razzak .. thanks for answering... thanks for sharing your opinion.. I really appreciate..
7 Recommendations
University of Mosul
شكرا جزيلا دكتور حسام علي
اتمنى لكم الموفقية والنجاح الدائم
تقبلوا بالغ تقديري واحترامي
Ladoke Akintola University of Technology
Right from my view,it is wrong,u can only take it to recycling industry to be recycled
1 Recommendation
Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University
Dear Kolawole Afolabi ... Thanks for answering...
13 Recommendations
Government College Of Engineering Aurangabad
never ever think of reusing reinforcement
extracted from demolition of a building for the construction of a new building. send such reinforcement for re rolling. after re rolling only you can think to use.
Similar questions and discussions
How can i increase tensile strength of concrete?
Debabrata Paul
I want to increase tensile strength of concrete.as a civil engineer we all desired a safe and economic structures that's why we use reinforcement so that it can take tension but now a days steel is becoming costly material as huge amount of steel is needed in one structure so I thought if I increase tensile strength of concrete then less steel will be used.
I searched ITZ in internet and I found that CH are responsible for less bonding in ITZ zone so how can i replace CH with CSH gel in the ITZ zone? or any other solution regarding this problem
Fake conferences organized by World Research Library (iierdl.org)
Bryar Hassan
I just started this question in order to aware the researchers about fake conferences is being held because some researchers are the victim of this fake conferences.
Are these organizations are running fake conferences?
http://www.iserd.co/
http://iierdl.org/
http://theiier.org/
Related Publications
Er bestaan vele ontwerpmethoden als hulpmiddel voor de ontwerpers in de civiele techniek en bouwkunde. Het is niet mogelijk om al deze ontwerpmethoden te bestuderen en toe te passen. Mede daarom zal een ontwerper proberen door onderzoek (ontwerptheorieën, -methoden en -technieken), waarnemingen (analyseren van de bestaande ontwerpen) en praktische...
De huidige regelgeving in Nederland houdt geen rekening met superhoogbouw of met gebouwen boven spoorwegen. Onhaalbare eisen of het gedogen van onveilige situaties zijn het gevolg. Onderzoekers van de TU Delft doen suggesties om landelijk met nieuwe regels te komen.
Vamberský, J.N.J.A., Th. S. de Wilde, S.I. Suddle, Derde dimensie zorgt voor hiate...