Paris School of Business
Question
Asked 31 August 2013
Can we combine the Porter 5 forces model and the value net model of Brandenburger and Nalebuff?
Some authors add the complementor as 6th force to Porter’s model. Porter himself acknowledges in recent writings to now include cooperation and the creation of value for all stakeholders in the field. But I didn’t find proposals clearly linking the 2 models.
All Answers (3)
Hi Vincent, please have a look at this link: http://www.terry.uga.edu/~jlturner/7950/Lecture10IndustryAnalysis2013.pdf
FOM University of Applied Sciences for Economics and Management
I don't think it is necessary to add the complementors to the 5 forces model because those groups included in the model are actually all possible complementors. In my oppinion it would be more accurate to improve the model's description of the interaction between the different forces.
VU School of Management
Both Proter and Brandenburger et al bear little relationship to how companies strategize today. See http://www.iveybusinessjournal.com/topics/strategy/does-the-thinking-of-yesterdays-management-gurus-imperil-todays-companies#.Um5gMdf8JLM
Similar questions and discussions
Related Publications
In the context of globalisation, the sustainability of traditional manufacturing sectors depends on the ability of firms to modernise and diversify. To remain competitive against emerging economies in high-volume and low-technology areas, firms must engage in high-value manufacturing. This paper uses theoretical underpinnings from strategic managem...
Competitive strategies remain a central topic of research in strategic management. Recent conceptual developments and practices reveal possible additional types of competitive strategies due to the advances in information as well as manufacturing technologies. This paper proposes a conceptual extension of the generic strategies originally developed...
In recent years, Unmanned Combat Aerial Vehicles (UCAV) have attracted a lot of attention both in our country and in the world. These products, which require high technology and a sustainable R&D infrastructure, stand out as "game-changing" force multipliers in terms of their abilities and the tasks they achieve. However, only certain countries can...