Question
Asked 15 March 2013

A benefit management model that works or one that doesn't work?

I would like to hear what you think about achieving benefits realization and about a business cases role to gain the realization of IT projects? Is there any theory you can recommend, and why? or if you know of research or a researcher in the topic?

Popular answers (1)

Crispin Richard Coombs
Loughborough University
In my experience the value of a Business case is purely to secure the funding to resource the project. Once the project starts benefits identified in the business case are quickly forgotten and not revisited in any evaluation (if one occurs). The most well known benefits management model was presented by Ward and Daniel (1996) in their benefits management book. Other authors that would be worth searching for are John Ward, Joe Peppard, Neil Doherty and Colin Ashurst. Looking for benefits management groups on Linkedin will also provide access to a reasonably strong benefits management practitioner community. Hope that helps. Crispin
3 Recommendations

All Answers (3)

Crispin Richard Coombs
Loughborough University
In my experience the value of a Business case is purely to secure the funding to resource the project. Once the project starts benefits identified in the business case are quickly forgotten and not revisited in any evaluation (if one occurs). The most well known benefits management model was presented by Ward and Daniel (1996) in their benefits management book. Other authors that would be worth searching for are John Ward, Joe Peppard, Neil Doherty and Colin Ashurst. Looking for benefits management groups on Linkedin will also provide access to a reasonably strong benefits management practitioner community. Hope that helps. Crispin
3 Recommendations
Jos van Hillegersberg
JADS.nl and University of Twente
Benefit management also plays a key role in project management methods like Prince2, if you look at the process framework (http://www.prince-officialsite.com/) you will find that benefit realization is a core activity that is carried out at the initiation phase, during the project and also at closure of a project. It is also an important activity to achieve a higher level of project management maturity in Prince2 maturity models. However, research that assesses to what extent this actually happens in practice is scarce. One of our PhDs (Silja Eckartz) did explorative research to assess the current state of BC as a benefit realization tool, see chapter 2-4 of her PhD thesis downloadable at http://doc.utwente.nl/81676/
1 Recommendation
Nourel sørensen
Copenhagen Business School
Crispin and Jos, Thank you for yours input. I appreciate it a lot!
Nourel

Similar questions and discussions

Related Publications

Book
Der IT-Dienstleister eines global agierenden Technologiekonzerns (in dieser anonymisierten Fallstudie als IDT bezeichnet) ist ein international führender Anbieter von IT-Lösungen und IT-Outsourcing. Ein breites Portfolio entlang der IT-Dienstleistungskette wird mittels Consulting, Software- und Systemintegration sowie IT-Infrastruktur-Managements g...
Article
Mit einer serviceorientierten Architektur (SOA) geht die strikte Forderung einher, das IT-Servicemanagement entsprechend den Geschäftsfunktionen der unterstützten Geschäftsprozesse auszurichten. Es gilt, die im Rahmen einer Applikation genutzten Services jederzeit identifizieren zu können, um in der Lage zu sein, strategisch, planerisch und operati...
Got a technical question?
Get high-quality answers from experts.