SOIL

SOIL

Published by Copernicus Publications on behalf of European Geosciences Union

Online ISSN: 2199-398X

·

Print ISSN: 2199-3971

Disciplines: Soil Science

Journal websiteAuthor guidelines

Top read articles

259 reads in the past 30 days

Comparison of the quantities of the more stable and more labile fractions for the physical and thermal SOC fractionation schemes, with their correlation coefficient R2 and linear regression. Panel (a) shows the quantities of MAOC plotted against Cs. Panel (b) shows the quantities of POC plotted against Ca. The dataset is the intersection dataset, i.e. samples for which thermal and physical data are available (n=843).
Proportion of the Ca and POC fractions depending on the land cover. The black line in each box is the median, the lower and upper edges of the black rectangle are the respective first (Q1) and third (Q3) quartiles, and the lower and upper whiskers are the maximum between the minimum value or the first quartile minus 1.5 times the interquartile range (max⁡[min⁡;Q1-1.5×(Q3-Q1)]) and the minimum between the maximum or the third quartile plus 1.5 times the interquartile range (min⁡[max⁡;Q3+1.5×(Q3-Q1)]), respectively. Different letters indicate significant differences in the distribution of the values for the land cover according to a Kruskal–Wallis test (p<0.05) and a pairwise Wilcoxon rank sum test (p<0.05); lowercase letters are used for Ca and uppercase for POC.
Importance of the different categories of soil and environmental variables (climate, pedology, and land cover) for the four fractions Cs, MAOC, Ca, and POC and with TOCea as a comparison (in gCkg-1sample), assessed using the MDI and PI.
Investigating the complementarity of thermal and physical soil organic carbon fractions

November 2024

·

259 Reads

·

·

Marija Stojanova

·

[...]

·

Download

Aims and scope


Interactive Public Peer Review · Community driven · Not for profit

SOIL is a not-for-profit international scientific journal dedicated to the publication and discussion of high-quality research in the field of soil system sciences.

SOIL is at the interface between the atmosphere, lithosphere, hydrosphere, and biosphere. SOIL publishes scientific research that contributes to understanding the soil system and its interaction with humans and the entire Earth system. The scope of the journal includes all topics that fall within the study of soil science as a discipline, with an emphasis on studies that integrate soil science with other sciences (hydrology, agronomy, socio-economics, health sciences, atmospheric sciences, etc.).

Recent articles


Uncovering soil compaction: performance of electrical and electromagnetic geophysical methods
  • Article
  • Full-text available

December 2024

·

15 Reads

·

Luca Peruzzo

·

Matteo Longo

·

[...]

·

Francesco Morari

Monitoring soil structure is of paramount importance due to its key role in the critical zone as the foundation of terrestrial life. Variations in the arrangement of soil components significantly influence its hydro-mechanical properties and therefore its impact on the surrounding ecosystem. In this context, soil compaction resulting from inappropriate agricultural practices not only affects soil ecological functions, but also decreases the water-use efficiency of plants by reducing porosity and increasing water loss through superficial runoff and enhanced evaporation. In this study, we compared the ability of electric and electromagnetic geophysical methods, i.e., electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) and frequency-domain electromagnetic (FDEM) method, to assess the effects caused by both heavy plastic soil deformations generated by a super-heavy vehicle and the more common tractor tramlines on silty-loam soils. We then tested correlations between geophysical response and soil variables (i.e., penetration resistance, bulk density, and volumetric water content on collected samples) at different homogeneous areas defined by k-means clustering. This work is intended to be a contribution to clarify expectations about the use of geophysical techniques to rapidly investigate soil compaction at various spatial scales, dissecting their suitability and limitations. It also aims to contribute to the methodological optimization of agrogeophysical acquisitions and data processing in order to obtain accurate soil models through a non-invasive approach. Electrical prospecting has finer spatial resolution and allows a tomographic approach, requiring higher logistic demands and the need for ground galvanic contact. On the other hand, contactless electromagnetic induction methods can be quickly used to define the distribution of electrical conductivity in the shallow subsoil in an easier way. In general, compacted soil portions are imaged as high-electrical-conductivity anomalies relative to the context. Results, validated with traditional soil characterization, show the pros and cons of both techniques and how differences in their spatial resolution heavily influence the ability to characterize compacted areas with good confidence.


Freeze–thaw processes correspond to the protection–loss of soil organic carbon through regulating pore structure of aggregates in alpine ecosystems

Ruizhe Wang

·

Xia Hu

Seasonal freeze–thaw processes alter soil formation and lead to changes in soil structure of alpine ecosystems. Soil aggregates are basic soil structural units and play a crucial role in soil organic carbon (SOC) protection and microbial habitation. However, the impact of seasonal freeze–thaw processes on pore structure and their impact on SOC fractions have been overlooked. This study characterized the pore structure and SOC fractions of soil aggregates of the unstable freezing period, stable frozen period, unstable thawing period and stable thawed period in typical alpine ecosystems via a dry-sieving procedure, X-ray computed tomography scanning and elemental analysis. The results showed that pore networks of 0.25–2 mm aggregates were more vulnerable to seasonal freeze–thaw processes than those of >2 mm aggregates. The freezing process promoted the formation of >80µm pores of aggregates. The total organic carbon, particulate organic carbon and mineral-associated organic carbon contents of aggregates were high in the stable frozen period and dropped dramatically in the unstable thawing period, demonstrating that the freezing process was positively associated with SOC accumulation, while SOC loss featured in the early stage of thawing. The vertical distribution of SOC of aggregates was more uniform in the stable frozen period than in other periods. Pore equivalent diameter was the most important structural characteristic influencing SOC contents of aggregates. In the freezing period, the SOC accumulation might be enhanced by the formation of >80µm pores. In the thawing period, pores of <15µm were positively correlated with SOC concentration. Our results revealed that changes in pore structure induced by freeze–thaw processes could contribute to SOC protection of aggregates.


Daily mean of soil temperature and precipitation, photosynthetically active radiation (PAR), vegetation index, water table depth (site mean ± SD), gross photosynthesis, measured (dots) and model-predicted (line) ecosystem respiration (soil respiration for willow), and net ecosystem exchange. Annual modelling periods (April–March) are marked by a light-grey or white background.
Plot-wise mean annual fluxes of CH4 (a), N2O (b) and soil respiration (c) (CO2 eq.) as related to the mean annual WTD.
Fluxes of CH4 (a) and N2O (b) in 2019–2023. The error bars denote standard error. Note the different scale in the y axis in panel (a) for the latter half of the period.
Impact of crop type on the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions of a rewetted cultivated peatland

November 2024

·

10 Reads

Raising the water table is an effective way to abate greenhouse gas emissions from cultivated peat soils. We experimented a gradual water table rise at a highly degraded agricultural peat soil site with plots of willow, forage and mixed vegetation (set-aside) in southern Finland. We measured the emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4) and nitrous oxide (N2O) for 4 years. The mean annual groundwater table depth was about 54, 40, 40 and 30 cm in 2019–2022, respectively. The results indicated that a 10 cm rise in the water table depth was able to slow down annual CO2 emissions from soil respiration by 0.87 Mg CO2-C ha⁻¹. CH4 fluxes changed from uptake to emissions with a rise in the water table depth, and the maximum mean annual emission rate was 11 kg CH4-C ha⁻¹. Nitrous oxide emissions ranged from 2 to 33 kg N2O-N ha⁻¹ yr⁻¹; they were high in bare soil at the beginning of the experiment but decreased towards the end of the experiment. Short rotation cropping of willow reached net sequestration of carbon before harvest, but all treatments and years showed a net loss of carbon based on the net ecosystem carbon balance. Overall, the short rotation coppice of willow had the most favourable carbon and greenhouse gas balance over the years (10 Mg CO2 eq. on average over 4 years). The total greenhouse gas balance of the forage and set-aside treatments did not go under 27 Mg CO2 eq. ha⁻¹ yr⁻¹, highlighting the challenge in curbing peat decomposition in highly degraded cultivated peatlands.


Situational plan of (a) the northernmost tip of the Antarctic Peninsula, with (b) James Ross Island (zoomed in view of the square in panel a), (c) a digital terrain model (DTM) of the north coast of James Ross Island (Ulu Peninsula), and (d) a panoramic image of the map shown in panel (c) with study sites 1–6 indicated (yellow arrows; view from Bibby Hill). The map was created in ArcGIS Desktop v.10.8.1, the DTM and map layers were generated using the Czech Geological Survey ČGS 2009 dataset, and the situational plan was created in Inkscape 1.2.2. The photograph was sourced from an archive belonging to the first author.
Correlation diagram for selected environmental variables (altitude) and physical (skelet – coarse-fraction content), chemical (SOC – soil organic carbon, EE-GRSP – easily extractable glomalin-related soil protein and GRSP – glomalin-related soil protein) and physicochemical (pH, exchangeable ion: K – potassium, Ca – calcium, Mg – magnesium and P – phosphorus contents) properties in Antarctic topsoil. Only significant correlations at P<0.05 are shown.
Derivative thermogravimetric curve of a tea sample (before decomposition) during pyrolysis in an N2 atmosphere.
Post-decomposition tea samples' derivative thermogravimetric curves (45 d exposure) during pyrolysis in an N2 atmosphere for (a) Site 3a (seal cadaver) and (b) Site 6.
Soil organic matter interactions along the elevation gradient of the James Ross Island (Antarctica)

November 2024

·

61 Reads

Around half of the Earth's soil organic carbon (SOC) is presently stored in the Northern Hemisphere permafrost region. In polar permafrost regions, low temperatures particularly inhibit both the production and biodegradation of organic matter. Under such conditions, abiotic factors such as mesoclimate, pedogenic substrate or altitude are thought to be more important for soil development than biological factors. In Antarctica, biological factors are generally underestimated in soil development due to the rare occurrence of higher plants and the short time since deglaciation. In this study, we aim to assess the relationship between SOC and other soil properties related to the pedogenic factors or properties. Nine plots were investigated along the altitudinal gradient from 10 to 320 m in the deglaciated area of James Ross Island (Ulu Peninsula) using a parallel tea-bag decomposition experiment. SOC contents showed a positive correlation with the content of easily extractable glomalin-related soil protein (EE-GRSP; Spearman r=0.733, P=0.031) and the soil buffering capacity (expressed as ΔpH; Spearman r=0.817, P=0.011). The soil-available P was negatively correlated with altitude (Spearman r=-0.711, P=0.032), and the exchangeable Mg was negatively correlated with the rock fragment content (Spearman r=-0.683, P=0.050). No correlation was found between the available mineral nutrients (P, K, Ca and Mg) and SOC or GRSP. This may be a consequence of the inhibition of biologically mediated nutrient cycling in the soil. Therefore, the main factor influencing nutrient availability in these soils does not seem to the biotic environment; rather, the main impact appears to stem from the abiotic environment influencing the mesoclimate (altitude) or the level of weathering (rock content). Incubation in tea bags for 45 d resulted in the consumption and translocation of more labile polyphenolic and water-extractable organic matter, along with changes in the C content (increase of up to +0.53 % or decrease of up to -1.31 % C) and a decrease in the C:N ratio (from 12.5 to 7.1–10.2), probably due to microbial respiration and an increase in the abundance of nitrogen-binding microorganisms. Our findings suggest that one of the main variables influencing the SOC/GRSP content is not the altitude or coarse-fraction content (for which a correlation with SOC/GRSP was not found); rather, we suspect effects from other factors that are difficult to quantify, such as the availability of liquid water.


Comparison of the quantities of the more stable and more labile fractions for the physical and thermal SOC fractionation schemes, with their correlation coefficient R2 and linear regression. Panel (a) shows the quantities of MAOC plotted against Cs. Panel (b) shows the quantities of POC plotted against Ca. The dataset is the intersection dataset, i.e. samples for which thermal and physical data are available (n=843).
Proportion of the Ca and POC fractions depending on the land cover. The black line in each box is the median, the lower and upper edges of the black rectangle are the respective first (Q1) and third (Q3) quartiles, and the lower and upper whiskers are the maximum between the minimum value or the first quartile minus 1.5 times the interquartile range (max⁡[min⁡;Q1-1.5×(Q3-Q1)]) and the minimum between the maximum or the third quartile plus 1.5 times the interquartile range (min⁡[max⁡;Q3+1.5×(Q3-Q1)]), respectively. Different letters indicate significant differences in the distribution of the values for the land cover according to a Kruskal–Wallis test (p<0.05) and a pairwise Wilcoxon rank sum test (p<0.05); lowercase letters are used for Ca and uppercase for POC.
Importance of the different categories of soil and environmental variables (climate, pedology, and land cover) for the four fractions Cs, MAOC, Ca, and POC and with TOCea as a comparison (in gCkg-1sample), assessed using the MDI and PI.
Investigating the complementarity of thermal and physical soil organic carbon fractions

November 2024

·

259 Reads

Partitioning soil organic carbon (SOC) in fractions with different biogeochemical stability is useful to better understand and predict SOC dynamics and provide information related to soil health. Multiple SOC partition schemes exist, but few of them can be implemented on large sample sets and therefore be considered relevant options for soil monitoring. The well-established particulate organic carbon (POC) vs. mineral-associated organic carbon (MAOC) physical fractionation scheme is one of them. Introduced more recently, Rock-Eval® thermal analysis coupled with the PARTYSOC machine learning model can also fractionate SOC into active (Ca) and stable SOC (Cs). A debate is emerging as to which of these methods should be recommended for soil monitoring. To investigate the complementarity or redundancy of these two fractionation schemes, we compared the quantity and environmental drivers of SOC fractions obtained on an unprecedented dataset from mainland France. About 2000 topsoil samples were recovered all over the country, presenting contrasting land cover and pedoclimatic characteristics, and analysed. We found that the environmental drivers of the fractions were clearly different, the more stable MAOC and Cs fractions being mainly driven by soil characteristics, whereas land cover and climate had a greater influence on more labile POC and Ca fractions. The stable and labile SOC fractions provided by the two methods strongly differed in quantity (MAOC/Cs=1.88± 0.46 and POC/Ca=0.36± 0.17; n=843) and drivers, suggesting that they correspond to fractions with different biogeochemical stability. We argue that, at this stage, both methods can be seen as complementary and potentially relevant for soil monitoring. As future developments, we recommend comparing how they relate to indicators of soil health such as nutrient availability or soil structural stability and how their measurements can improve the accuracy of SOC dynamics models.


Moderate N fertilizer reduction with straw return modulates cropland functions and microbial traits in a meadow soil

November 2024

·

10 Reads

Nitrogen (N) fertilization has received worldwide attention due to its benefits with regard to soil fertility and productivity, but excess N application also causes an array of ecosystem degenerations, such as greenhouse gas emissions. Generally, soil microorganisms are considered to be involved in upholding a variety of soil functions. However, the linkages between soil cropland properties and microbial traits under different N fertilizer application rates remain uncertain. To address this, a 4-year in situ field experiment was conducted in a meadow soil from the Northeast China Plain after straw return with the following treatments combined with regular phosphorus (P) and potassium (K) fertilization: (i) regular N fertilizer (N + PK), (ii) 25 % N fertilizer reduction (0.75N + PK), (iii) 50 % N fertilizer reduction (0.5N + PK), and (IV) no N fertilizer (PK). Cropland properties and microbial traits responded distinctly to the different N fertilizer rates. Treatment 0.75N + PK had overall positive effects on soil fertility, productivity, straw decomposition, and microbial abundance and functioning and alleviated greenhouse effects. Specifically, no significant difference was observed in soil organic carbon (SOC), total N, P content, straw C, N release amounts, microbial biomass C, N content, and cellulase and N-acetyl-D-glucosaminidase activities, which were all significantly higher than in 0.5N + PK and PK. Greenhouse gas emissions was reduced with the decreasing N input levels. Moreover, the highest straw biomass and yield were measured in 0.75N + PK, which were significantly higher than in 0.5N + PK and PK. Meanwhile, 0.75N + PK up-regulated aboveground biomass and soil C:N and thus increased the abundance of genes encoding cellulose-degrading enzymes, which may imply the potential ability of C and N turnover. In addition, most observed changes in cropland properties were strongly associated with microbial modules and keystone taxa. The Lasiosphaeriaceae within the module-1 community showed significant positive correlations with straw degradation rate and C and N release, while the Terrimonas within the module-3 community showed a significant positive correlation with production, which was conducive to soil multifunctionality. Therefore, our results suggest that straw return with 25 % chemical N fertilizer reduction is optimal for achieving soil functions. This study highlights the importance of abiotic and biotic factors in soil health and supports green agricultural development by optimizing N fertilizer rates in meadow soil after straw return.


Literature review of biocrust distribution studies. (a) Map of hotspot countries for biocrust distribution research. Numbers represent the publication count by authors from different countries from 1990 to 2022, and the top 12 countries are shown. The database is Web of Science, TS = (”biogenic crust*” OR ”biological crust*” OR ”biological soil crust*” OR ”biocrust*” OR ”microphytic crust*” OR ”microbiotic crust*” OR ”cyanobacterial*” OR ”algal*” OR ”lichen*” OR ”moss*” OR ”biotic crust*”) AND (”mapping*” OR ”distribution*” OR “ spatial pattern*”) AND (”dryland” OR ”hyper*arid*” OR ”arid*” OR ”semi*arid*” OR ”dry subhumid*”), with research interests in environmental sciences and/or ecology and a total of 700 papers. (b) Global biocrust data distribution, based on field surveys and literature compilation. The bar chart counts the number of entries for biocrust records (presence/absence or cover) for six continents (regions). Datasets have been collected and expanded from the published database (Chen et al., 2020; Rodriguez-Caballero et al., 2018) to 3848 items, Ning Chen et al. (unpublished data).
of three major approaches to studying biocrust distribution. Workflow of applying spectral characterization method (a), dynamic vegetation model (b), and geospatial model (c) in biocrust distribution studies. See the main text for a more detailed introduction to these methods.
Maps of global biocrust distribution. (a) Prediction based on vegetation dynamic model (Porada et al., 2019). (b) Prediction based on geospatial model (Rodriguez-Caballero et al., 2018). Permissions have been obtained from the relevant sources: Porada et al. (2019) and Rodriguez-Caballero et al. (2018).
Biocrust distribution and its critical influencing factors. (a) Biocrust cover map and its influencing factors. (a) Global biocrust distribution by random forest modeling. Based on a global biocrust database constructed by Ning Chen et al. (unpublished data), we expanded the biocrust data to 3848 entries through literature compilation and field surveys and fitted them with four types of remotely sensed environmental data, including climate, land use, soil properties, and elevation, to finally predict the suitable areas for the biocrust distribution and to quantify the biocrust cover. (b) Global average annual precipitation (1970–2020) – data from the WorldClim database (version 2.1). (c) Global soil texture distribution – data from HWSD (Harmonized World Soil Database, version 1.2). Precipitation and soil texture were taken as examples of environmental factors.
Potential approaches to building a standardized biocrust database. (a) Distribution of lichens in the GBIF database with an example photo; (b) environmental-monitor distribution map of MARAS database; (c) distribution of mosses and lichens in the PROBAV_LC100 database (light-yellow area) in northern Asia, for instance.
Advancing studies on global biocrust distribution

October 2024

·

100 Reads

·

1 Citation

Biological soil crusts (biocrusts hereafter) cover a substantial proportion of the dryland ecosystem and play crucial roles in ecological processes such as biogeochemical cycles, water distribution, and soil erosion. Consequently, studying the spatial distribution of biocrusts holds great significance for drylands, especially on a global scale, but it remains limited. This study aimed to simulate global-scale investigations of biocrust distribution by introducing three major approaches, namely spectral characterization indices, dynamic vegetation models, and geospatial models, while discussing their applicability. We then summarized the present understanding of the factors influencing biocrust distribution. Finally, to further advance this field, we proposed several potential research topics and directions, including the development of a standardized biocrust database, enhancement of non-vascular vegetation dynamic models, integration of multi-sensor monitoring, extensive use of machine learning, and a focus on regional research co-development. This work will significantly contribute to mapping the biocrust distribution and thereby advance our understanding of dryland ecosystem management and restoration.


The impact of agriculture on tropical mountain soils in the western Peruvian Andes: a pedo-geoarchaeological study of terrace agricultural systems in the Laramate region (14.5° S)

October 2024

·

208 Reads

This integrated pedo-geoarchaeological study focuses on three abandoned pre-Hispanic terrace agricultural systems near Laramate in the southern Andes of Peru (14.5° S), aiming to unravel the pedological and land-use history of the region, which served as a significant agricultural hub during pre-Hispanic times. The key objectives of the investigation involved contextualizing the former agricultural management system within its geomorphological and palaeoecological framework and assessing the impact of agricultural practices on soil development and quality by comparing non-irrigated agricultural terrace soils with their undisturbed palaeo-pedological counterparts. The Laramate terrace complex, with its diverse terrace systems and varied geomorphological and geological settings, provided an ideal setting for the investigation. This comprehensive examination integrated a range of methodologies, including field surveys, digital mapping, and geomorphological analysis based on GIS and remote sensing applications, soil analysis (e.g. grain size, bulk chemistry, nutrient budget), plant microfossils (phytoliths and starch), and radiocarbon dating. In the Laramate region, the geomorphological setting of terrace agricultural systems promotes their optimal functioning. The terraces are often located in sun-sheltered areas with western exposure on middle and lower slopes or valley bottoms, which mitigate intense solar radiation, reduce evapotranspiration, increase soil moisture, and minimize erosion. The study identifies three soil groups in the Laramate region: Phaeozems, Andosols, and Anthrosols. Unique characteristics of Phaeozems challenge typical descriptions, influenced by factors such as climatic seasonality, vegetation, fauna, lithology, and aeolian inputs. The terrace soils in the Laramate region are classified as Terric Anthrosols, showing no significant degradation even after long-term use. Their balanced acidity and nutrient levels support Andean crop cultivation. Traditional non-mechanized tools, such as the chaquitaclla and rucana, likely minimized soil disruption. The terrace tillage horizons have high organic matter, indicating intentional organic manuring. Phytolith concentrations suggest intensive agricultural activity, particularly maize cultivation, with varying patterns suggesting changes in cultivation, fertilization, or mulching practices over time. Starch grain identification aligns with phytolith analyses, reinforcing maize's significance in the region. Although the use of animal-origin fertilizers requires further investigation, there is no evidence of nutrient maintenance through seasonal burning. Irrigation was minimal, and the abandonment of the pre-Hispanic cultivation system was unlikely due to soil exhaustion or terrace instability. Overall, the pre-Hispanic history of terrace agriculture in the Laramate region extends over four development phases, reflecting dynamic interactions between environmental, cultural, and agricultural factors. The initial phase, from the Formative Paracas period to the Early Nasca period (800 BCE–200 CE), witnessed the establishment of agricultural terraces with simple terrace architecture, while the Middle Horizon (600–1000 CE) saw systematic areal expansion influenced by the Wari culture. Adaptations to drier conditions included terrace agriculture on volcanic soils. The Late Intermediate period (1000–1450 CE) witnessed hydrological variability and further terrace expansion to lower altitudes and less agriculturally suitable locations. The final phase, marked by the onset of the Hispanic colonial period in 1535 CE, saw the gradual abandonment of terrace agricultural systems due to demographic shifts and reorganization of production systems. Despite this, the historical trajectory underscores the adaptability and resilience of pre-Hispanic communities in the Laramate region, showcasing innovative terrace agriculture as a means of coping with changing environmental conditions across diverse landscape units.


SOC concentration distribution across the soil profile (0–100 cm) in relation to the treatments under different experiments in 2011 and 2021. CTM: mono-cropping of the main crops under conventional tillage; NTM: mono-cropping of the main crops under no-till mulch-based cropping systems with the use of cover crops, and NTR1 and NTR2 refer to bi-annual rotation of the main crops under no-till mulch-based cropping systems with the use of cover crops as described in Table 1. (a) MaiEx 2011: SOC concentration of the treatments in maize-based trial measured in 2011; (b) MaiEx 2021: SOC concentration of the treatments in maize-based trial measured in 2021; (c) SoyEx 2011: SOC concentration of the treatments in soybean-based trial measured in 2021; (d) SoyEx 2021: SOC concentration of the treatments in soybean-based trial measured in 2021; (e) CasEx 2011: SOC concentration of the treatments in cassava-based trial measured in 2011; and (f) CasEx 2021: SOC concentration of the treatments in cassava-based trial measured in 2021. Treatment(s) in bold within the brackets indicate the gain and significant (p<0.05) difference in concentrations between 2011 and 2021 for the same treatment at the same soil depth.
TN concentration distribution across the soil profile (0–100 cm) in relation to the treatments under different experiments in 2011 and 2021. CTM: mono-cropping of the main crops under conventional tillage; NTM: mono-cropping of the main crops under no-till mulch-based cropping systems with the use of cover crops, and NTR1 and NTR2 refer to bi-annual rotation of the main crops under no-till mulch-based cropping systems with the use of cover crops as described in Table 1. (a) MaiEx 2011: TN concentration of the treatments in maize-based trial measured in 2011; (b) MaiEx 2021: TN concentration of the treatments in maize-based trial measured in 2021; (c) SoyEx 2011: TN concentration of the treatments in soybean-based trial measured in 2021; (d) SoyEx 2021: TN concentration of the treatments in soybean-based trial measured in 2021; (e) CasEx 2011: TN concentration of the treatments in cassava-based trial measured in 2011; and (f) CasEx 2021: TN concentration of the treatments in cassava-based trial measured in 2021. Treatment(s) in bold within the brackets indicate the gain and significant (p<0.05) difference in concentrations between 2011 and 2021 under the same treatment at the same soil depth.
Carbon stock in mineral-associated and particulate organic matter (MAOM and POM) fractions across the whole profile (0–100 cm) in 2011 and 2021 under different treatments and experiments. CTM: mono-cropping of the main crops under conventional tillage; NTM: mono-cropping of the main crops under no-till mulch-based cropping systems with the use of cover crops, and NTR1 and NTR2 refer to bi-annual rotation of the main crops under no-till mulch-based cropping systems with the use of cover crops as described in Table 1. The uppercase letters on the bars indicate a significant difference (Tukey's test; p<0.05) of the C stock in MAOM between 2011 and 2021 in the same treatment and at the same soil depth, while the lowercase letters in front of the bars indicate a significant difference of the C stock in POM between 2011 and 2021 in the same treatment and at the same soil depth.
TN stock in mineral-associated and particulate organic matter (MAOM and POM) fractions across the whole profile (0–100 cm) in 2011 and 2021 under different treatments and experiments. CTM: mono-cropping of the main crops under conventional tillage; NTM: mono-cropping of the main crops under no-till mulch-based cropping systems with the use of cover crops, and NTR1 and NTR2 refer to bi-annual rotation of the main crops under no-till mulch-based cropping systems with the use of cover crops as described in Table 1. The uppercase letters on the bars indicate a significant difference (Tukey's test; p<0.05) of TN stock in MAOM between 2011 and 2021 in the same treatment and at the same soil depth, while the lowercase letters in front of the bars indicate a significant difference of TN stock in POM between 2011 and 2021 in the same treatment and at the same soil depth.
Comparison between the diachronic and synchronic approaches used to estimate SOC stock change rate (0–100 cm) from 2011 to 2021 under NT systems in the tropical red Oxisol of Cambodia (n=3; error bars = SE). (a) MaiEx (maize-based trial), (b) SoyEx (soybean-based trial), and (c) CasEx (cassava-based experiments). NTM: mono-cropping of the main crops under no-till mulch-based cropping systems with the use of cover crops; NTR1 and NTR2 refer to bi-annual rotation of the main crops under no-till mulch-based cropping systems with the use of cover crops as described in Table 1. The stock change rates using a diachronic approach were calculated by subtracting the stock of the same treatment in 2021 from the stock in 2011 and dividing by the number of years between the first and second samplings (10 years), while the stock change rates of NT systems in 2021 using a synchronic approach were calculated by subtracting the stock of each NT treatment from the stock of CTM in 2021, considering the control, and dividing by the number of years between the first and second samplings (10 years). Note that (*) indicates a significant difference (Tukey's test; p<0.05) in SOC stock between 2011 and 2021. Positive values indicate SOC stock accumulation; negative values indicate SOC loss.
Diachronic assessment of soil organic C and N dynamics under long-term no-till cropping systems in the tropical upland of Cambodia

October 2024

·

97 Reads

No-till (NT) cropping systems have been proposed as a strategy to combat soil degradation by storing soil organic carbon (SOC) and total nitrogen (TN). We quantified the impacts of NT cropping systems on the changes in SOC and TN stocks and in particulate and mineral-associated organic matter fractions (POM and MAOM), to 100 cm depth, from three 13-year-old experiments in a tropical red Oxisol in Cambodia using diachronic and equivalent soil mass approaches. Established in 2009 and arranged in a randomized complete-block design with triplicates, the experiments included maize (MaiEx)-, soybean (SoyEx)-, and cassava (CasEx)-based cropping systems. Each experiment comprised three treatments: (1) mono-cropping of main crops (maize, soybean, and cassava) under conventional tillage (CTM); (2) mono-cropping of main crops under NT systems with the use of cover crops (NTM); and (3) bi-annual rotation of main crops under NT systems with the use of cover crops (NTR), with both crops being presented every year and represented by NTR1 and NTR2. Soil samples were collected in 2021, 10 years after the last sampling. All the NT systems significantly (p<0.05) increased SOC stock in the topsoil in SoyEx and MaiEx and down to 40 cm in CasEx. Considering the whole profile (0–100 cm), the SOC accumulation rates ranged from 0.86 to 1.47 and from 0.70 to 1.07 Mg C ha-1 yr-1 in MaiEx and CasEx, respectively. Although SOC stock significantly increased in CTM at 0–20 cm in MaiEx and CasEx, it remained stable at 0–100 cm in all the experiments. At 0–5 cm, NTR systems significantly increased TN stock in all the experiments, while, in NTM systems, it was only significant in MaiEx and SoyEx. At 0–100 cm, TN stock in all the experiments remained stable under NTR systems, whereas a significant decrease was observed under NTM systems in SoyEx and CasEx. Although C-POM stock significantly increased under all NT systems limited to 0–10 cm in MaiEx and SoyEx, all the NT systems significantly increased C-MAOM stock in the 0–10 cm layer in MaiEx and SoyEx and down to 40 cm in CasEx. All the NT systems significantly increased N-POM stock at 0–10 cm in MaiEx and SoyEx, while a significant decreased in N-MAOM stock was observed below 5 cm in CasEx and below 40 cm in MaiEx and SoyEx. Our findings showed that long-term NT systems with crop species diversification accumulated SOC not only on the surface but also in the whole profile by increasing SOC in both the POM and MAOM, even in the cassava-based system. This study highlights the potential of NT systems for storing SOC over time but raises questions about soil N dynamics.


Insights into the prediction uncertainty of machine-learning-based digital soil mapping through a local attribution approach

September 2024

·

46 Reads

Machine learning (ML) models have become key ingredients for digital soil mapping. To improve the interpretability of their predictions, diagnostic tools such as the widely used local attribution approach known as SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP) have been developed. However, the analysis of ML model predictions is only one part of the problem, and there is an interest in obtaining deeper insights into the drivers of the prediction uncertainty as well, i.e. explaining why an ML model is confident given the set of chosen covariate values in addition to why the ML model delivered some particular results. In this study, we show how to apply SHAP to local prediction uncertainty estimates for a case of urban soil pollution – namely, the presence of petroleum hydrocarbons in soil in Toulouse (France), which pose a health risk via vapour intrusion into buildings, direct soil ingestion, and groundwater contamination. Our results show that the drivers of the prediction best estimates are not necessarily the drivers of confidence in these predictions, and we identify those leading to a reduction in uncertainty. Our study suggests that decisions regarding data collection and covariate characterisation as well as communication of the results should be made accordingly.


Depth extrapolation of field-scale soil moisture time series derived with cosmic-ray neutron sensing (CRNS) using the soil moisture analytical relationship (SMAR) model

September 2024

·

63 Reads

·

1 Citation

Ground-based soil moisture measurements at the field scale are highly beneficial for different hydrological applications, including the validation of space-borne soil moisture products, landscape water budgeting, or multi-criteria calibration of rainfall–runoff models from field to catchment scale. Cosmic-ray neutron sensing (CRNS) allows for the non-invasive monitoring of field-scale soil moisture across several hectares around the instrument but only for the first few tens of centimeters of the soil. Many of these applications require information on soil water dynamics in deeper soil layers. Simple depth-extrapolation approaches often used in remote sensing may be used to estimate soil moisture in deeper layers based on the near-surface soil moisture information. However, most approaches require a site-specific calibration using depth profiles of in situ soil moisture data, which are often not available. The soil moisture analytical relationship (SMAR) is usually also calibrated to sensor data, but due to the physical meaning of each model parameter, it could be applied without calibration if all its parameters were known. However, its water loss parameter in particular is difficult to estimate. In this paper, we introduce and test a simple modification of the SMAR model to estimate the water loss in the second layer based on soil physical parameters and the surface soil moisture time series. We apply the model with and without calibration at a forest site with sandy soils. Comparing the model results with in situ reference measurements down to depths of 450 cm shows that the SMAR models both with and without modification as well as the calibrated exponential filter approach do not capture the observed soil moisture dynamics well. While, on average, the latter performs best over different tested scenarios, the performance of the SMAR models nevertheless meets a previously used benchmark RMSE of ≤ 0.06 cm3 cm-3 in both the calibrated original and uncalibrated modified version. Different transfer functions to derive surface soil moisture from CRNS do not translate into markedly different results of the depth-extrapolated soil moisture time series simulated by SMAR. Despite the fact that the soil moisture dynamics are not well represented at our study site using the depth-extrapolation approaches, our modified SMAR model may provide valuable first estimates of soil moisture in a deeper soil layer derived from surface measurements based on stationary and roving CRNS as well as remote sensing products where in situ data for calibration are not available.


An ensemble estimate of Australian soil organic carbon using machine learning and process-based modelling

September 2024

·

133 Reads

Spatially explicit prediction of soil organic carbon (SOC) serves as a crucial foundation for effective land management strategies aimed at mitigating soil degradation and assessing carbon sequestration potential. Here, using more than 1000 in situ observations, we trained two machine learning models (a random forest model and a k-means coupled with multiple linear regression model) and one process-based model (the vertically resolved MIcrobial-MIneral Carbon Stabilization, MIMICS, model) to predict the SOC stocks of the top 30 cm of soil in Australia. Parameters of MIMICS were optimised for different site groupings using two distinct approaches: plant functional types (MIMICS-PFT) and the most influential environmental factors (MIMICS-ENV). All models showed good performance with respect to SOC predictions, with an R2 value greater than 0.8 during out-of-sample validation, with random forest being the most accurate; moreover, it was found that SOC in forests is more predictable than that in non-forest soils excluding croplands. The performance of continental-scale SOC predictions by MIMICS-ENV is better than that by MIMICS-PFT especially in non-forest soils. Digital maps of terrestrial SOC stocks generated using all of the models showed a similar spatial distribution, with higher values in south-eastern and south-western Australia, but the magnitude of the estimated SOC stocks varied. The mean ensemble estimate of SOC stocks was 30.3 t ha-1, with k-means coupled with multiple linear regression generating the highest estimate (mean SOC stocks of 38.15 t ha-1) and MIMICS-PFT generating the lowest estimate (mean SOC stocks of 24.29 t ha-1). We suggest that enhancing process-based models to incorporate newly identified drivers that significantly influence SOC variation in different environments could be the key to reducing the discrepancies in these estimates. Our findings underscore the considerable uncertainty in SOC estimates derived from different modelling approaches and emphasise the importance of rigorous out-of-sample validation before applying any one approach in Australia.


Gully rehabilitation in southern Ethiopia – value and impacts for farmers

September 2024

·

128 Reads

Gully erosion can be combatted in severely affected regions like sub-Saharan Africa using various low-cost interventions that are accessible to affected farmers. For successful implementation, however, biophysical evidence of intervention effectiveness needs to be validated against the interests and priorities of local communities. Working with farmers in a watershed in southern Ethiopia, we investigated (a) the effectiveness of low-cost gully rehabilitation measures to reduce soil loss and upward expansion of gully heads; (b) how farmers and communities view gully interventions; and (c) whether involving farmers in on-farm field trials to demonstrate gully interventions improves uptake, knowledge, and perceptions of their capacity to act. On-farm field experiments, key-informant interviews, focus group discussions, and household surveys were used to collect and analyse data. Three gully treatments were explored, all with riprap, one with grass planting, and one with grass planting and check-dam integration. Over a period of 26 months, these low-cost practices ceased measurable gully head expansion, whereas untreated gullies had a mean upward expansion of 671 cm, resulting in a calculated soil loss of 11.0 t. Farmers had a positive view of all gully rehabilitation measures explored. Ongoing rehabilitation activities and on-farm trials influenced the knowledge and understanding of similar gully treatments among survey respondents. On-farm experiments and field day demonstrations empowered farmers to act, addressing pessimism from some respondents about their capacity to do so.


Addressing soil data needs and data gaps in catchment-scale environmental modelling: the European perspective

September 2024

·

121 Reads

·

1 Citation

To effectively guide agricultural management planning strategies and policy, it is important to simulate water quantity and quality patterns and to quantify the impact of land use and climate change on soil functions, soil health, and hydrological and other underlying processes. Environmental models that depict alterations in surface and groundwater quality and quantity at the catchment scale require substantial input, particularly concerning movement and retention in the unsaturated zone. Over the past few decades, numerous soil information sources, containing structured data on diverse basic and advanced soil parameters, alongside innovative solutions to estimate missing soil data, have become increasingly available. This study aims to (i) catalogue open-source soil datasets and pedotransfer functions (PTFs) applicable in simulation studies across European catchments; (ii) evaluate the performance of selected PTFs; and (iii) present compiled R scripts proposing estimation solutions to address soil physical, hydraulic, and chemical data needs and gaps in catchment-scale environmental modelling in Europe. Our focus encompassed basic soil properties, bulk density, porosity, albedo, soil erodibility factor, field capacity, wilting point, available water capacity, saturated hydraulic conductivity, and phosphorus content. We aim to recommend widely supported data sources and pioneering prediction methods that maintain physical consistency and present them through streamlined workflows.


Luminescence dating approaches to reconstruct the formation of plaggic anthrosols

August 2024

·

78 Reads

Plaggic anthrosols demonstrate the significant and widespread influence of agriculture on the landscape of northern Europe and testify to increased land-use intensity over the last millennium. However, a lack of established chronologic methods to interrogate these soils has hindered research on their formation history, so the timing and process of plaggic anthrosol development remain poorly quantified. Recently, luminescence dating methods have emerged as a tool for tracing the past movement of grains, including within the soil column. This study combines two primary luminescence methods – single-grain feldspar infrared stimulated luminescence (IRSL) along with post-infrared infrared stimulated luminescence (pIRIR) measurements and small-aliquot (or multi-grain) quartz optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) – to reconstruct the formation of a plaggic anthrosol at Braakmankamp (eastern Netherlands). Toward this aim, we present a new method to identify well-bleached single grains of feldspar using the ratio of the grain's IRSL and pIRIR signals as a filter. The results provide both methodological and applied archaeological insights. Both small-aliquot quartz OSL and single-grain feldspar pIRIR ages yield reliable ages for plaggen deposits when the new filtering approach is used to remove poorly bleached feldspar grains from the analysis. Single-grain pIRIR feldspar has the added benefit of revealing complex soil formation histories for naturally bioturbated deposits, including those at the base of the plaggen layer. Augmenting this information with conventional quartz OSL dating builds confidence in the geo-chronologic record and allows us to reconstruct the timing and processes of plaggic anthrosol formation in Braakmankamp. According to the luminescence dating results, land clearance occurred around 900–1000 years ago, and accumulation of plaggen material began around 700–800 years ago. The average accumulation rate of plaggen material is estimated at ∼ 1.1 mmyr-1.


Overview of site. Photos of study site in (a) 1996 (photo credit: C. Michael Reynolds) and (b) 2011 showing plant colonization of the different soil types and phytoremediation treatment plots. (c) Overview of the original phytoremediation treatment plots (outlined in thick black lines). Half of the plots are soils from a gravel pad originally contaminated with crude oil (white background), and half are soils from near a leaking diesel fuel storage tank that has been contaminated (grey background). The original treatments applied in 1995 were as follows: no treatment (c1, c2), planted with annual ryegrass (p1), a mix of annual ryegrass and Arctared fescue (p2), treated with fertilizer (f), and/or no added nutrients (no “f” indicated). For this follow-up study, original plots were each subdivided into six subsections (outlined in dashed grey lines) to allow for pseudo-replication.
Estimated percentage cover of vegetation groups in either crude oil (a–d) or diesel (e–h) plots. Measurements were based on visual estimates in each of the six sub-plots. The values shown are means with 95 % confidence intervals (N=6); note that the y axes have different scales. Treatments indicated are as follows: no treatment (c1, c2), planted with annual ryegrass (p1), a mix of annual ryegrass and Arctared fescue (p2), treated with fertilizer (f), and/or no added nutrients (no “f” indicated). Significant differences in percentage cover are indicated by different letters, where “NS” indicates that no significant differences were found.
Measures of (a) most probable number (MPN) of diesel-degrading microorganisms or (b) total microbial biomass as measured by PLFA biomarkers in either crude oil (dark grey) or diesel (light grey) soils. Measurements were based on 10 triplicate 1 g soil samples. The values shown are means with 95 % confidence intervals (N=6). Treatments indicated are as follows: no treatment (c1, c2), planted with annual ryegrass (p), a mix of annual ryegrass and Arctared fescue (p2), treated with fertilizer (f), and/or no added nutrients (no “f” indicated). Significant differences in percentage cover are indicated by different letters, where “NS” indicates that no significant differences were found.
Non-metric multidimensional scaling ordination analysis (NMDS) of soil PLFAs (a, b) or 16S rRNA genes (c, d) from crude-oil-contaminated (a, c) or diesel-contaminated (b, d) soils, with subsequent fitting of environmental vectors onto the ordination (P<0.05). The vectors are as follows: NO3 refers to nitrate, CEC refers to the cation exchange coefficient, veg.num refers to the total vegetation counts (excluding trees), tree.num refers to the total number of trees, TPH refers to the total petroleum hydrocarbons, and sand refers to the soil texture (i.e., % sand, % silt, % clay). Solid symbols indicate treatments originally fertilized. Treatments indicated are as follows: no treatment (c1, c2), planted with annual ryegrass (p1), a mix of annual ryegrass and Arctared fescue (p2), treated with fertilizer (f), and/or no added nutrients (no “f” indicated).
Differential sequence analysis showing significantly enriched (Padj<0.001) bacterial OTUs from crude-oil-contaminated soils (a–c) and diesel-contaminated soils (d–f). Pairwise comparisons include initially fertilized (F) versus planted with one or two grasses (P), initially planted and fertilized (PF) versus planted only (P), and initially fertilized (F) versus planted and fertilized. Negative log2 fold change (left of vertical grey line) values represent OTUs significantly enriched in the treatment listed first, while positive log2 fold change (right of vertical grey line) represents OTUs significantly enriched in the second listed initial treatment. Only the top 15 differentially abundant OTUs with the highest log2 fold changes are represented. Multiple observations per row represent OTUs belonging to the same genus. Colours represent phyla, while genera ending with “.un” indicate unclassified taxa.
Long-term legacy of phytoremediation on plant succession and soil microbial communities in petroleum-contaminated sub-Arctic soils

August 2024

·

28 Reads

Phytoremediation can be a cost-effective method of restoring contaminated soils using plants and associated microorganisms. Most studies follow the impacts of phytoremediation solely across the treatment period and have not explored long-term ecological effects. In 1995, a phytoremediation study was initiated near Fairbanks, Alaska, to determine how the introduction of annual grasses and/or fertilizer would influence degradation of petroleum hydrocarbons (PHCs). After 1 year, grass and/or fertilizer-treated soils showed greater decreases in PHC concentrations compared to untreated plots. The site was then left for 15 years with no active site management. In 2011, we re-examined the site to explore the legacy of phytoremediation on contaminant disappearance, as well as on plant and soil microbial ecology. We found that the recruited vegetation and the current bulk soil microbial community structure and functioning were all heavily influenced by initial phytoremediation treatment. The number of diesel-degrading microorganisms (DDMs) was positively correlated with the percentage cover of vegetation at the site, which was influenced by initial treatment. Even 15 years later, the initial use of fertilizer had significant effects on microbial biomass, community structure, and activity. We conclude that phytoremediation treatment has long-term, legacy effects on the plant community, which, in turn, impact microbial community structure and functioning. It is therefore important to consider phytoremediation strategies that not only influence site remediation rates in the short-term but also prime the site for the restoration of vegetation over the long-term.


Particle size and density fractionation protocol (adapted from Balesdent et al., 1998). The POM fraction is the sum of the cPOM, fPOM, cSand and fSand fractions, while the MAOM fraction is the sum of the cSilt, fSilt and Clay fractions.
Soil organic carbon stock and additional carbon (ΔSOC) stock of bulk soils and physical fractions (n=4) at QualiAgro and La Cage experiments. The error bars represent the standard deviations. Grouped bars with different letters are significantly different between agricultural practices (Tukey HSD; p<0.05). CON-QA: conventional agriculture without organic inputs, BIOW: biowaste compost, MSW: municipal solid waste compost, FYM: farmyard manure, CON-LC: conventional agriculture, CA: conservation agriculture and ORG: organic agriculture. The POM fraction is the sum of the cPOM, fPOM, cSand and fSand fractions, while the MAOM fraction is the sum of the cSilt, fSilt and Clay fractions.
Soil organic carbon stock and additional carbon (ΔSOC) stock of bulk soils, active carbon (Ca) and stable carbon (Cs) (n=4) at QualiAgro and La Cage experiments. The error bars represent the standard deviations. Grouped bars with different letters are significantly different between agricultural practices (Tukey HSD; p<0.05). CON-QA: conventional agriculture without organic inputs, BIOW: biowaste compost, MSW: municipal solid waste compost, FYM: farmyard manure, CON-LC: conventional agriculture, CA: conservation agriculture and ORG: organic agriculture.
Distribution of total carbon and additional carbon in carbon kinetic pools (Cmin, carbon mineralized); active; and stable carbon) or fractions (POM and MAOM) under agricultural practices. The error bars represent the standard errors. Grouped bars with different letters are significantly different between agricultural practices (Tukey HSD; p<0.05).
What is the stability of additional organic carbon stored thanks to alternative cropping systems and organic waste product application? A multi-method evaluation

August 2024

·

98 Reads

The implementation of agroecological practices often leads to additional soil organic carbon storage, and we have sought to assess the biogeochemical stability of this additional carbon. To achieve this, we implemented a multi-method approach using particle size and density fractionation, Rock-Eval® (RE) thermal analyses and long-term incubation (484 d), which we applied to topsoil samples (0–30 cm) from temperate Luvisols that had been subjected in >20-year-long experiments in France to conservation agriculture (CA), organic agriculture (ORG) and conventional agriculture (CON-LC) in the La Cage experiment and to organic waste product (OWP) applications in the QualiAgro experiment, including biowaste compost (BIOW), residual municipal solid waste compost (MSW), farmyard manure (FYM) and conventional agriculture without organic inputs (CON-QA). The additional carbon resulting from agroecological practices is the difference between the carbon stock of the bulk soil and physical fractions or carbon pools in the soil affected by agroecological practices and that of the same soil affected by a conventional practice used as control. The incubations provided information on the additional carbon stability in the short term (i.e. mean residence time, MRT, of <2 years) and showed that the additional soil organic carbon mineralized faster than the carbon in the conventional control at La Cage but slower at QualiAgro. In OWP-treated plots at QualiAgro, 60 %–66 % of the additional carbon was stored as mineral-associated organic matter (MAOM-C) and 34 %–40 % as particulate organic matter (POM-C). In CA and ORG systems at La Cage, 77 %–84 % of the additional carbon was stored as MAOM-C, whereas 16 %–23 % was stored as POM-C. Management practices hence influenced the distribution of additional carbon in physical fractions. Utilizing the PARTYSOC model with Rock-Eval® thermal analysis parameters, we found that most, if not all, of the additional carbon belonged to the active carbon pool (MRT∼30–40 years). In summary, our comprehensive multi-method evaluation indicates that the additional soil organic carbon is less stable over decadal and pluri-decadal timescales compared to soil carbon under conventional control conditions. Our results show that particle size and density fractions can be heterogenous in their biogeochemical stability. On the other hand, although the additional carbon is mainly associated with MAOM, the high proportion of this carbon in the active pool suggests that it has a mean residence time which does not exceed ∼50 years. Furthermore, agroecological practices with equivalent additional carbon stocks (MSW, FYM and CA) exhibited a higher proportion of additional carbon in POM-C under MSW (40 %) and FYM (34 %) compared to CA (16 %), which suggests a high chemical recalcitrance of POM-C under OWP management relative to conservation agriculture. Additional soil organic carbon derived from organic waste, i.e. biomass that has partially decomposed and has been transformed through its processing prior to its incorporation in soil, would be more biogeochemically stable in soil than that derived directly from plant biomass. The apparent contradictions observed between methods can be explained by the fact that they address different kinetic pools of organic carbon. Care must be taken to specify which range of residence times is considered when using any method with the intent to evaluate the biogeochemical stability of soil organic matter, as well as when using the terms stable or labile. In conclusion, the contrasting biogeochemical stabilities observed in the different management options highlight the need to maintain agroecological practices to keep these carbon stocks at a high level over time, given that the additional carbon is stable on a pluri-decadal scale.


Temporal development of DNA pools and 18O enrichment during incubation with 18O water. Upper panels depict iDNA pools and enrichment in (a) agricultural soils and (b) forest soils. Lower panels depict eDNA pools and enrichment in (c) agricultural soils and (d) forest soils. Violin plots represent 18O enrichment of DNA pools (atom percent excess), and dot-and-line plots represent DNA pool sizes over time. Asterisks indicate significant differences (p value < 0.05) from time point 0.
Microbial pool sizes in the two investigated soils after incubation at three different temperatures for 24 h. Results for agricultural soils are shown in panels (a), (c), and (e). Forest soils are shown in panels (b), (d), and (f). Microbial biomass C is shown in panels (a) and (b), iDNA contents are shown in panels (c) and (d), and eDNA contents are shown in panels (e) and (f). Statistically significant differences between pool sizes at the three investigated temperatures are marked with different letters above the violin plots.
Mass-specific microbial process rates and CUE in the two investigated soils after incubation at three different temperatures for 24 h. Results for agricultural soils are shown in purple hues and for forest soils in green hues. A20, A30, and A45 indicate agricultural soils incubated at 20, 30, and 45 °C, respectively. F20, F30, and F45 indicate forest soils incubated at 20, 30, and 45 °C, respectively. Statistically significant differences between pool sizes at the three investigated temperatures and respective soils are marked with different letters above the violin plots. Capital letters are used for differences between agricultural soils, whereas lowercase letters are used to indicate differences between forest soil.
Improving measurements of microbial growth, death, and turnover by accounting for extracellular DNA in soils

July 2024

·

80 Reads

Microbial respiration, growth, and turnover are driving processes in the formation and decomposition of soil organic matter. In contrast to respiration and growth, microbial turnover and death currently lack distinct methods to be determined. Here we propose a new approach to determine microbial death rates and to improve measurements of microbial growth. By combining sequential DNA extraction to distinguish between intracellular and extracellular DNA and 18O incorporation into DNA, we were able to measure microbial death rates. We first evaluated methods to determine and extract intracellular and extracellular DNA separately. We then tested the method by subjecting soil from a temperate agricultural field and a deciduous beech forest to either 20, 30, or 45 °C for 24 h. Our results show that while mass-specific respiration and gross growth either increased with temperature or remained stable, microbial death rates strongly increased at 45 °C and caused a decrease in microbial biomass and thus in microbial net growth. We further found that also extracellular DNA pools decreased at 45 °C compared to lower temperatures, further indicating the enhanced uptake and recycling of extracellular DNA along with increased respiration, growth, and death rates. Additional experiments including soils from more and different ecosystems as well as testing the effects of factors other than temperature on microbial death are certainly necessary to better understand the role of microbial death in soil C cycling. We are nevertheless confident that this new approach to determine microbial death rates and dynamics of intracellular and extracellular DNA separately will help to improve concepts and models of C dynamics in soils in the future.


Levels of supply chain sustainability standards' (n=56) soil protection content ambitions in individual sub-categories. Level rating criteria are explained in Table 1. Note that (1) levels are applied to the sub-categories defined by the Standards Map, and (2) the category originally called “other criteria on soil” in the Standards Map is renamed to “NPK, pH analysis” as this was the only actual topic covered.
Correlation between standard use measured in thousands of hectares of land and standard ambition level using available data (n=18). The relationship is not statistically significant.
Crops covered by third-party agricultural sustainability standards relevant to soil quality (n=56) and those reported in food retail companies' (n=49) literature as being subject to a specific sustainability standard. Notes: 1. retail companies usually report “sugar” as a commodity rather than the specific crop; in only one data point (1.8 %) is sugar beet explicitly reported. 2. Some companies report “fruits and vegetables” as a generic crop category.
Can corporate supply chain sustainability standards contribute to soil protection?

July 2024

·

53 Reads

Companies increasingly view soil degradation in their supply chains as a commercial risk. They have applied sustainability standards to manage environmental risks stemming from suppliers' farming operations. To examine the application of supply chain sustainability standards in soil protection, we conducted a study using global data on existing sustainability standards and their use in the food retail industry, a key sector in agrifood supply chains. Soil quality is a priority objective in retail sector sustainability efforts: 41 % of the investigated companies apply some soil-relevant standard. However, the standards lack specific and comprehensive criteria. Compliance typically requires that farmers are aware of soil damage risks and implement some mitigation measures; however, no measurable thresholds are usually assigned. This stands in contrast to some other provisions in a number of standards, such as deforestation criteria. There are two probable causes of this difference: companies and certification bodies have prioritised other environmental challenges (e.g. pesticide use, biodiversity loss in tropical biomes) over soil degradation. Also, there are practical constraints in the useful standardisation of soil sustainability. Effective soil sustainability provisions will require measurable, controllable, and scalable multidimensional interventions and compliance metrics. Often, these are not yet available. The development of necessary practical tools is a priority for future research.


Investigating the synergistic potential of Si and biochar to immobilize Ni in a Ni-contaminated calcareous soil after Zea mays L. cultivation

July 2024

·

44 Reads

·

1 Citation

In Iran, a significant percentage of agricultural soils are contaminated with a range of potentially toxic elements (PTEs), including Ni, which need to be remediated to prevent their entry into the food chain. Silicon (Si) is a beneficial plant element that has been shown to mitigate the effects of PTEs on crops. Biochar is a soil amendment that sequesters soil carbon and that can immobilize PTEs and enhance crop growth in soils. No previous studies have examined the potentially synergistic effect of Si and biochar on the Ni concentration in soil chemical fractions and the immobilization thereof. Therefore, the aim of this study was to examine the interactive effects of Si and biochar with respect to reducing Ni bioavailability and its corresponding uptake in corn (Zea Mays) in a calcareous soil. A 90 d factorial greenhouse study with corn was conducted. Si application levels were 0 (S0), 250 (S1), and 500 (S2) mgSikg-1 soil, and biochar treatments (3wt %) including rice husk (RH) and sheep manure (SM) biochars produced at 300 and 500 °C (SM300, SM500, RH300, and RH500) were utilized. At harvest, the Ni concentration in corn shoots, the Ni content in soil chemical fractions, and the release kinetics of DPTA (diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid)-extractable Ni were determined. Simultaneous utilization of Si and SM biochars led to a synergistic reduction (15 %–36 %) in the Ni content in the soluble and exchangeable fractions compared with the application of Si (5 %–9 %) and SM (5 %–7 %) biochars separately. The application of Si and biochars also decreased the DPTA-extractable Ni and Ni content in corn shoots (by up to 57 %), with the combined application of SM500 + S2 being the most effective. These effects were attributed to the transfer of Ni in soil from more bioavailable fractions to more stable iron-oxide-bound fractions, related to soil pH increase. SM500 was likely the most effective biochar due to its higher alkalinity and lower acidic functional group content which enhanced Ni sorption reactions with Si. The study demonstrates the synergistic potential of Si and SM biochar for immobilizing Ni in contaminated calcareous soils.


High capacity of integrated crop–pasture systems to preserve old soil carbon evaluated in a 60-year-old experiment

July 2024

·

102 Reads

Integrated crop–pasture rotational systems can store larger soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks in the topsoil (0–20 cm) than continuous grain cropping. The aim of this study was to identify if the main determinant for this difference may be the avoidance of old C losses in integrated systems or the higher rate of new C incorporation associated with higher C input rates. We analyzed the temporal changes of 0–20 cm SOC stocks in two agricultural treatments of different intensity (continuous annual grain cropping and crop–pasture rotational system) in a 60-year experiment in Colonia, Uruguay. We incorporated this information into a process of building and parameterizing SOC compartmental dynamical models, including data from SOC physical fractionation (particulate organic matter, POM > 53 µm > mineral-associated organic matter, MAOM), radiocarbon in bulk soil, and CO2 incubation efflux. This modeling process provided information about C outflow rates from pools of different stability, C stabilization dynamics, and the age distribution and transit times of C. The differences between the two agricultural systems were mainly determined by the dynamics of the slow-cycling pool (∼MAOM). The outflow rate from this compartment was between 3.68 and 5.19 times higher in continuous cropping than in the integrated system, varying according to the historical period of the experiment considered. The avoidance of old C losses in the integrated crop–pasture rotational system resulted in a mean age of the slow-cycling pool (∼MAOM) of over 600 years, with only 8.8 % of the C in this compartment incorporated during the experiment period (after 1963) and more than 85 % older than 100 years old in this agricultural system. Moreover, half of the C inputs to both agricultural systems leave the soil in approximately 1 year due to high decomposition rates of the fast-cycling pool (∼POM). Our results show that the high capacity to preserve old C of integrated crop–pasture systems is the key for SOC preservation of this sustainable intensification strategy, while their high capacity to incorporate new C into the soil may play a second role. Maintaining high rates of C inputs and relatively high stocks of labile C appear to be a prerequisite for maintaining low outflow rates of the MAOM pool.


Schematic diagram of sampling design with sample locations and land use pattern illustrated. Image from Getlost Maps.
(a) Mean (with standard error) respiration rates of soil for four land uses. Letters indicate the least significant difference (P<0.05) between the land uses at each time. (b) Cumulative respiration for four land uses across a 15 d incubation period. Each point represents the mean of five replicates. Error bars indicate least significant differences (P<0.05) between land uses at each time.
Organic carbon content (a) and the total organic C per fraction (b) for each soil fraction within the bulk soil from topsoils (0–10 cm) collected from four land uses. fPOC is free particulate organic carbon, oPOC is aggregate-occluded particulate organic matter, fine-fraction MAOC is coarse-grained (>53 µm) mineral-associated organic carbon, and coarse-fraction MAOC is fine-grained (>53 µm) mineral-associated organic carbon. Lower-case letters indicate least significant differences (P<0.05) between the same fractions across land uses according to the REML mixed-effects model and Tukey's post hoc testing.
Double-normalized (a) C K-edge spectra and (b) N K-edge spectra of finely ground bulk soil samples from each land use produced by near-edge X-ray absorption fine structure. Spectra have been stretched in the y direction to visualize each land use. (a) Vertical lines indicate (1) quinones at 284.7 eV, (2) aromatic C at 285.5 eV, (3) aliphatic C at 287.3 eV, (4) phenolic C–OH at 288.2 eV, (5) carboxyl C–OOH at 289.0 eV, and (6) O-alkyl C at 289.8 eV. (b) Vertical lines indicate (1) aromatic N in six-membered rings at 398.8 eV, (2) amide at 401.2 eV, and (3) alkyl-N at 406 eV.
Spectral maps showing the distribution of mineral OH, aliphatic C, aromatic C, and polysaccharide C obtained through Synchrotron-based infrared microspectroscopy by analysis of sections (200 nm thickness) obtained from intact microaggregates of soil from four land uses (remnant vegetation, pasture, plantation, and cropped) (bars are 25 µm). The spectral map of one of the two to three replicates analysed for each land use is shown. Maps were obtained from 32 co-added scans (4 cm-1 resolution) with a 2.5 µm step size. The spectra obtained from each map were used to form regression analyses. Pixels where the absorption peak could not be detected above the baseline noise were excluded from regressions.
The influence of land use and management on the behaviour and persistence of soil organic carbon in a subtropical Ferralsol

July 2024

·

51 Reads

·

1 Citation

A substantial carbon (C) debt has been accrued due to long-term cropping for global food production emitting carbon dioxide from soil. However, the factors regulating the persistence of soil organic C (SOC) remain unclear, with this hindering our ability to develop effective land management strategies to sequester organic C in soil. Using a Ferralsol from semi-arid subtropical Australia, alteration of bulk C contents and fractions due to long-term land use change (up to 72 years) was examined with a focus on understanding whether SOC lost due to cropping could be restored by subsequent conversion back to pasture or plantation. It was found that use of soil from cropping for 72 years resulted in the loss of >70 % of both C and N contents. Although conversion of cropped soil to pasture or plantation for up to 39 years resulted in an increase in both C and N, the C contents of all soil fractions were not restored to the original values observed under remnant vegetation. The loss of C with cropping was most pronounced from the particulate organic matter fraction, whilst in contrast, the portion of the C that bound strongly to the soil mineral particles (i.e. the mineral-associated fraction) was most resilient. Indeed, aliphatic C was enriched in the fine fraction of mineral-associated organic matter (<53 µm). Our findings were further confirmed using Synchrotron-based micro-spectroscopic analyses of intact microaggregates, which highlighted that binding of C to soil mineral particles is critical to SOC persistence in disturbed soil. The results of the present study extend our conceptual understanding of C dynamics and behaviour at the fine scale where C is stabilized and accrued, but it is clear that restoring C in soils in semi-arid landscapes of subtropical regions poses a challenge.


The model scheme of soil carbon (C) dynamics. Model I and Model II share similar structure except that Model II includes a C flow from MBC to heavy POC (red arrow) but Model I does not.
Distributions of glucose-derived C in soil C pools: microbial biomass C (MBC), mineral-associated organic C (MAOC), particulate organic C (POC). The left y axis is absolute amounts of glucose C in the MAOC, POC, and MBC pools. The right y axis is relative contribution of newly stabilized C to total glucose C input. The error bars represent the standard errors of four replicates. The vertical dashed line divides the x axis into five sampling sites, each with fencing treatment in the first column and grazing treatment in the second column.
Correlation of glucose-derived POC and MAOC on MBC (a) and soil texture (b). Shaded areas represent the 95 % confidence intervals for the regression lines.
Modeled SOC content at steady state under two types of C input conditions. The two different C input scenarios for each site are separated by a dotted line. The upper and lower ends of boxes denote the 0.25 and 0.75 percentiles, respectively. The solid line and dot in the box mark the median and mean of each dataset. The open circles denote outliers. Asterisks represent significant differences between Model I and Model II (*P<0.05, **P<0.01, ***P<0.001).
Dissolved carbon flow to particulate organic carbon enhances soil carbon sequestration

July 2024

·

173 Reads

·

3 Citations

Particulate organic carbon (POC) and mineral-associated organic carbon (MAOC), which are two primary components of the soil carbon (C) reservoir, have different physical and chemical properties as well as biochemical turnover rates. Microbial necromass entombment is a primary mechanism for MAOC formation from fast-decaying plant substrates, whereas POC is typically considered the product of structural litter via physical fragmentation. However, emerging evidence shows that microbial by-products derived from labile C substrates can enter the POC pool. To date, it is still unclear to what extent dissolved C can enter the POC pool and how it affects the subsequent long-term soil organic carbon (SOC) storage. Our study here, through a 13C-labeling experiment in 10 soils from 5 grassland sites as well as a modeling analysis, showed that up to 12.29 % of isotope-labeled glucose C (i.e., dissolved C) was detected in the POC pool. In addition, the glucose-derived POC was correlated with 13C-MBC (microbial biomass carbon) and the fraction of clay and silt, suggesting that the flow of dissolved C to POC is dependent on interactions between soil physical and microbial processes. The modeling analysis showed that ignoring the C flow from MBC to POC significantly underestimated soil C sequestration by up to 53.52 % across the 10 soils. The results emphasize that the soil mineral-regulated microbial process, besides the plant structural residues, is a significant contributor to POC, acting as a vital component in SOC dynamics.


Ectomycorrhizal (ECM) fungal co-occurrence network parameters analyzed in this study. OTU: operational taxonomic unit.
Co-occurrence networks of ectomycorrhizal (ECM) fungal communities in each study forest: Jaén and Segura. Graphs are inferred through the Gephi software by using the Fruchterman–Reingold and ForceAtlas algorithms. In each site network, each node number represents an ECM fungal OTU (see Table S1 for the taxonomic assignment and network metrics for each forest), and the node size is related to the hub score index (i.e., a proxy of keystone taxa). Co-occurring OTUs are connected by edges whose width indicates the co-occurrence strength (co-exclusions were not detected among ECM fungal taxa across the study sites). Within each forest ECM fungal community, a shared node color indicates a separate module (legends) inferred by Gephi (Table S1). Nodes in light-grey color indicate non-co-occurring OTUs in each forest network.
Correlations between average ECM fungal OTU abundance and network parameters (Box 1). Network metrics calculated for each ECM fungal OTU are inferred through the Gephi software. Correlation tests are calculated with the Spearman method using the Bonferroni adjustment for the dataset of each study forest: Jaén and Segura. Significant correlations (p<0.05) are plotted per site, indicating positive (red) or negative (blue) correlations.
Co-occurrence ECM fungal networks and contributions of fungal OTUs to soil extracellular enzymatic activity in Jaén and Segura. Co-occurring OTUs are marked with bold blue lines in the graphs and classed by fungal orders and keystone taxa with asterisks. Heatmaps show the estimated values (positive in red and negative in blue) of ECM fungal OTUs, explaining at least one soil enzymatic activity by elastic net (ENET) regularization models. The estimated values are 0.1-scaled. We used order as the main resolving taxonomic category to visualize trends of ECM fungi in predicting enzymatic activities within a network context and incorporating phylogenetic relationships. The ECM fungal OTU taxonomic assignment and estimated values are listed in Table S3.
Ectomycorrhizal fungal network complexity determines soil multi-enzymatic activity

June 2024

·

58 Reads

·

1 Citation

Soil functioning is intrinsically related to the structure of associated biological communities. This link is barely understood in the multispecies context of soil microbial communities, which often requires complex analytical approaches to discern structural and functional roles of microbial taxa inhabiting the soil. To investigate these ecological properties, we characterized the assembly and soil functioning contribution of ectomycorrhizal (ECM) fungal communities through co-occurrence network analysis. Co-occurrence networks were inferred from ECM root tips of Cistus albidus, Quercus faginea and Q. ilex on a regional scale, in Mediterranean mixed forests. Soil enzymatic activities related to carbon and nutrient cycling were also measured, and soil functionality outcomes related to ECM fungal network structure were evaluated on the community to taxon levels. Network complexity relied on habitat characteristics and seasonality, and it was linked to different dominant ECM fungal lineages across habitats. Soil enzymatic activities were habitat-dependent, driven by host plant identity and fungi with reduced structuring roles in the co-occurrence network (mainly within Thelephorales, Sebacinales and Pezizales). ECM fungal co-occurrence network structure and functioning were highly context-dependent, pointing to divergent regional fungal species pools according to their niche preferences. As increased network complexity was not related to greater soil functionality, functional redundancy might be operating in Mediterranean forest soils. The revealed differentiation between structural and functional roles of ECM fungi adds new insights into the understanding of soil fungal community assembly and its functionality in ecosystems.


Soil respiration across a variety of tree-covered urban green spaces in Helsinki, Finland

June 2024

·

51 Reads

·

2 Citations

As an increasing share of the human population is being clustered in cities, urban areas have swiftly become the epicentres of anthropogenic carbon (C) emissions. Understanding different parts of the biogenic C cycle in urban ecosystems is needed in order to assess the potential to enhance their C stocks as a cost-efficient means to balance the C emissions and mitigate climate change. Here, we conducted a field measurement campaign over three consecutive growing seasons to examine soil respiration carbon dioxide (CO2) fluxes and soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks at four measurement sites in Helsinki, representing different types of tree-covered urban green space commonly found in northern European cities. We expected to find variation in the main drivers of soil respiration – soil temperature, soil moisture, and SOC – as a result of the heterogeneity of urban landscape and that this variation would be reflected in the measured soil respiration rates. In the end, we could see fairly constant statistically significant differences between the sites in terms of soil temperature but only sporadic and seemingly momentary differences in soil moisture and soil respiration. There were also statistically significant differences in SOC stocks: the highest SOC stock was found in inactively managed deciduous urban forest and the lowest under managed streetside lawn with common linden trees. We studied the impacts of the urban heat island (UHI) effect and irrigation on heterotrophic soil respiration with process-based model simulations and found that the variation created by the UHI is relatively minor compared to the increase associated with active irrigation, especially during dry summers. We conclude that, within our study area, the observed variation in soil temperature alone was not enough to cause variation in soil respiration rates between the studied green space types, perhaps because the soil moisture conditions were uniform. Thus, irrigation could potentially be a key factor in altering the soil respiration dynamics in urban green space both within the urban area and in comparison to non-urban ecosystems.


Journal metrics


5.8 (2023)

Journal Impact Factor™


10.8 (2023)

CiteScore™


1.774 (2023)

SNIP


2.022 (2023)

SJR


max. EUR 93 per published page

Article processing charge

Editors