Fig 2 - uploaded by Damian Zdzisław Gąsiorek
Content may be subject to copyright.
Source publication
The aim of this paper is to develop a method for optimizing the design of a disc spring valve system by reducing the aeration and cavitation effect which negatively influences the performance of a shock absorber. A fluid-structure interaction (FSI) model is used in order to modify the geometry of the valve interior and, in turn, to achieve better p...
Context in source publication
Context 1
... This section provides an introduction to the theory and triggering factors of aeration and cavitation in shock absorbers based on Dixon [2] and the analytical work conducted by the authors [18] and supported with experimental studies [19]. The aeration phenomenon in a shock absorber is defined as a process by which gas, typically nitrogen, is circu- lated through, mixed with, or dissolved in oil being used as a working fluid in shock absorbers. Gas is included in shock absorbers under certain pressure, separately from the oil, to provide compressibility to allow for the rod displacement volume compensation. Theory states [2,21] that a liquid exposed to a soluble gas (i.e. the liquid comes into contact with the atmosphere of a gas that can dissolve in it) is in one of three forms: liquid-gas solution, liquid-gas bubble emulsion or foam. The liquid-gas solution is prone to bubble formation when the pressure of the liquid-gas solution falls below the so- called saturation pressure. In this state, the liquid is no longer capable of retaining all the gas in its dissolved form and therefore bubbles occur. The solubility of gas in a liquid is directly proportional to the absolute pressure above the liquid surface (Henry’s law), and normally decreases with rising temperature [2]. All of the mentioned liquid-gas mixtures can be considered as liquid with pockets of gas or vapor. The dissolved gas has a significant influence on the oil mixture and thus on the shock absorber's behavior. The presence of gas bubbles is the cause of the damping force loss in the shock absorber. It is an undesirable and negative effect visible as asymmetry of the force displacement characteristic and should be minimized. Fig. 1 shows the influence of aeration on the damper performance based on the force-displacement characteristic obtained for a sequence of 1500 cycles. The energy of hydraulic friction absorbed by a shock absorber caused an increase in its temperature. The damper was cycled with high velocity of 1.5 m/s, three sequences (the first, the middle, and the last) of 500 cycles each were plotted to show deterioration of the force-displacement characteristic. Modeling the dynamics of gas bubble formation and transport is a task very difficult for several reasons. Most important ones are difference between time scales in which aeration processes occur (order of minutes) and the time scales of oil flow through a damper (order of seconds), existence of uncontrollable parameters on which bubble size depends and the bubble size itself (e.g. oil impurities and sharp edges), re-absorption of gas from bubbles surface, etc. The cavitation phenomenon occurs, when oil does rupture under the influence of tensile stress, the rupture of the fluid manifests itself as a number of very small cavities in the oil [1]. The process of cavitation depends among other considerations, on the purity of the liquid and the rate at which the liquid is stressed. Cavitation is the formation of pockets of vapor in a liquid. When the local ambient pressure at a point in the liquid falls below the liquid's vapor pressure, the liquid undergoes a phase change to a gas, creating "bubbles," or, more accurately, cavities, in the liquid. Changing temperatures alter the vapor pressure of a liquid dramatically, making it easier or harder for the local ambient pressure to dip below the vapor pressure to cause cavitation. The violent collapse of cavitation or aeration bubbles results in the production of noise as well as the possibility of material damage to nearby solid surfaces [1]. Noise is a consequence of the momentary large pressures that are generated when the contents of the bubble are highly compressed. This also results in a micro flow in the liquid caused by the volume displacement of a growing or collapsing cavity. A larger number of col- lapsing gas bubbles decreases the bulk modulus of the gas-oil mixture, and produces. Cavitation and aeration occur at restrictions where potential pressure energy is converted into kinetic energy increasing flow velocity and dramatically decreasing the pressure in the oil locally. Valve systems used in hydraulic dampers should be designed to minimize the possibility of occurrence of local low-pressure regions which contribute to the formation of gas or cavity bubbles. The remaining content of the paper is divided into five sections. Section 2 presents the working principles of shock absorbers and valve systems, while Section 3 provides an introduction to the methodology used to simulate structure-fluid interactions in a valve system and illustrates the process of fluid-structure model development. Section 4 discusses the proposed valve design optimization method, while Section 5 reports experimental results of this optimization process. Lastly, Section 6 presents the summary of the paper. This section presents the fundamental working principles of a hydraulic shock absorber. The hydraulic double-tube damper presented in Fig. 2 consists of a piston moving within a liquid-filled cylinder. As the piston is forced to move within the cylinder (pressure tube), a pressure differential is built across the piston and the liquid is forced to flow through valves located in the piston and the base-valve assembly. The presence of the piston divides the cylinder space into two chambers: (i) the rebound chamber, that portion of the cylinder above the piston and (ii) the compression chamber, that portion below the piston. The action of the piston transfers liquid to and from the reserve chamber, which surrounds the cylinder, through the base-valve assembly located at the bottom of the compression chamber. Two types of valves are used in the shock absorber: (1) intake valves and (2) control valves. The intake valves are basically check valves which provide only slight resistance to flow in one direction and prevent flow in the opposite direction when the pressure differential is reversed. Control valves are preloaded through a valve spring to prevent opening until a specified pressure differential has built up across the valve. The two working phases of a hydraulic shock absorber are distinguished as the compression phase and rebound phase. During the compression phase the rod is tucked into the damper, compression chamber volume decreases and oil flows through the piston compression intake valve (piston intake) and the base compression control valve (base valve) accordingly, to the rebound and reserve chambers. During the rebound phase the rod is rejected from the damper, the compression chamber volume increases and oil flows through the piston rebound control valve (piston intake) and base rebound intake valve (base intake) accordingly, to the rebound and reserve chamber. The piston and base valves has to be balanced during operation which requires to maintain the differential pressure over the piston has to be greater than the sum of differential pressure over the base valve and the gas pressure in the reserve chamber. This requires to adjust the pressure-flow characteristics of piston and base valves to meet valve balance conditions during a compression stroke. Valve unbalance results in an effect that the pressure in the rebound chamber becomes lower than the atmospheric pressure during a compression stroke. This low pressure causes cavitation or gas release from oil-gas mixture in whole rebound chamber volume. The paper considers a specific type of shock absorber valve, i.e. the clamped piston compression valve presented in Fig. 3. Such a valve system consists of a combination of disc springs, referred to further in the paper as a stack of discs or a disc stack. The number of discs, their diameters and thickness, directly affects the operational pressure-flow characteristics of the valve system. A valve system operation can be split into three regimes. In the first regime, there is only a small flow through bleeds of a very small area below 1mm2 in the so-called orifice disc while the stack of discs is complete- ly closed (Fig. 3a). The damping forces produced by the valve are therefore very small, similar to a drive along a smooth road such as a highway. The stack of discs starts opening in the second regime providing a typical range of damping forces (Fig. 3b). The last regime corresponds to the case when the stack is fully opened and the restriction is provided by the profiled channels in the piston component (Fig. 3c). This regime covers off-road conditions or violent ma- neuvers on the road. This work focuses on the second and third regime, corresponding to the minimum (initial) opening and the maximum opening of the valve system. Valve systems are characterized by the pressure-flow characteristics which are obtained during component- level tests with the use of a hydraulic test-rig equipped with a pump, a flow tool where the valves are assembled and measured, hydraulic lines, and a data acquisition system. The controller regulates the flow through the valve allowing a pressure-flow characteristic of a valve to be captured. The pressure is a differential pressure measured before and after the flow tool, evaluating the pressure drop across the valve assembly for a given flow rate. A hydro-mechanical valve system model usable from an engineering application perspective should be able to reproduce essential properties of a valve system during operation in a shock absorber. This requires a combination of two sub-models: (i) a finite element mechanical (stress/strain) model, and (ii) a flow model. The mechanical model obtains (i) stress in discs, (ii) displacement between the orifice and a valve seat; both as a function of the pressure load. The opening of a disc stack can also be expressed as a function of an outflow area vs. pressure load. If the shock absorber geometry is known, then the flow model allows the outlet flow rate through the valve system as a function of the pressure load to be obtained. The input of the ...
Similar publications
This work describes first-of-kind experiments to measure fluid-structure interactions (FSI) on a clamped-free-clamped-free (CFCF) compliant panel at Mach 5.8 in a free-piston compression-heated Ludwieg tube. Baseline experiments with a rigid panel were performed to isolate the effect of panel thickness and gross angle-of-attack on the aeroelastic r...
Fluid-structure interaction (FSI) has resulted in both complex applications and computing algorithmic improvements. This multi-physics problem consists of a fluid domain and a structural domain with the interaction in between which has been developed into a very attractive method for researchers and industrial applications. The aim of this paper is...
In this paper the possibility of the optimization of coupled problems in par-titioned approaches is discussed. As a special focus, surface coupled problems of fluid-structure interaction are considered. Well established methods of optimization are ana-lyzed for usage in the context of coupled problems and in particular for a solution through partit...
Assessment of burnt forest area provides an important input for understanding the ecological, social as well as economic impacts of forest fires. The present study aims to develop a methodology for rapid assessment of burnt forest areas at the country-wide scale based on a statistical sampling approach. Forest Survey of India issues alerts of fores...
In this paper we introduce a new multi-vector update quasi-Newton (MVQN) method for implicit coupling of partitioned, transient FSI solvers. The new quasi-Newton method facilitates the use of ‘black-box’ field solvers and under certain circumstances can be demonstrated to provide Newton-like convergence behaviour for strongly coupled FSI benchmark...
Citations
... While the previous works are limited to a combination of separated hydraulic and structural behaviors, 2-way f luid-structure interaction is an advanced method to numerically evaluate an interactive hydro-mechanical behavior of a damper. The method was included in the published works from Czop, et al [8] and Buczkowski, et al [9]. Buczkowski's team showed the modeling techniques and the results to a comprehensive level in both structural and hydraulic sides. ...
div class="section abstract"> As the automotive industry undergoes significant changes in the dynamic behavior of vehicles and increasing demand for rapid product design, accurate prediction of product performance in the early stages has become more crucial than ever in the competitive environment. Shim-stack-type hydraulic dampers are widely used in automotive parts for both internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles and electric vehicles (EV). EVs are even more sensitive to damper performance as ICE, which is a major NVH source has been removed. However, the industry still faces challenges in obtaining accurate models of dampers due to their highly nonlinear hydro-mechanical behavior. Bleed slits in a shim-stack-type hydraulic damper play a key role in determining the blow-off characteristics of dampers, and therefore, accurate prediction of the blow-off characteristics is crucial in evaluating the damping performance of a vehicle. Bleed flow analyses are conducted at two levels: component level and assembly system level. For the component level analysis, computational fluid dynamics (CFD) is utilized to analyze bleed flow characteristics corresponding to various bleed slits, which are validated by conducting experimental flow bench tests. For the assembly system level analysis, a dynamic 1-dimensional (1-D) system model is developed for a target passive hydraulic damper to evaluate the effect of bleed slits on the assembly level. The damper characteristic of the proposed method and a conventional method with a constant discharge coefficient are compared. An experimentally measured damper characteristic from a dynamo is used to validate the system model.
</div
... Piston rod acceleration values are presented in time and frequency domains. The correlation between 1/8th and complete 360° finite element FSI model of valve assembly is achieved (Czop et al., 2012) Von-Misses stresses of valves are evaluated for total valve deformation of 0.44 mm and well correlated. The throttle deformation of orifice slice is modelled (Zhou et al., 2008). ...
... Such elements include, for example, shock absorbers. A large number of works related to the research of shock absorbers are devoted to the development of mathematical models (Domnyshev et al., 2019;Hou et al., 2011;Mollica and Youcef-Toumi, 1997;Ramos et al., 2005), parameter optimization and structural modernization (Ankitha and Rupa Sri, 2021;Czop et al., 2012;Duym, 2000;Więckowski et al., 2018;Wszołek, 2016), as well as research using CFD and FEM analysis (Chen et al., 2013;Duym, 2000;Herr et al., 1999;Lee, 1997;Shams et al., 2007). It should be noted that a significantly smaller number of works are devoted to the study of the operation of components and assemblies of cars (including shock absorbers) during operation in cold climates (Chernukhin, 2013;Chernukhin et al., 2020;Dolgushin et al., 2019), although this is an actual scientific direction for many regions of the world. ...
The use of modern materials and technical fluids allows you to operate cars at negative temperatures, but in some regions of the world (for example, in Siberia), the ambient air temperature can fall below 243 K for several weeks or even months. The operation of trucks at such a temperature refers to extreme conditions that force the special preparation of equipment. This preparation consists not only of special maintenance, but also of carrying out some activities that are carried out immediately before starting the engine and driving. The essence of these measures is, among other things, the thermal preparation of the components and assemblies of the vehicle before departure.This work is devoted to the thermal preparation of truck shock absorbers. It is revealed that the use of oils, the kinematic viscosity of which significantly depends on the ambient temperature, is a limiting factor in the winter operation of shock absorbers. The simulation of the operation of electric flexible heaters for shock absorbers in the SolidWorks Flow Simulation environment was carried out and the preheating efficiency was evaluated. It is established that the temperature distribution of the shock absorber fluid during heating of two-pipe shock absorbers occurs unevenly, but despite this, preheating significantly improves the characteristics of shock absorbers and contributes to the safe and long-lasting operation of trucks.
... Yang (2001) carried out multiparameter coupling simulation and experimental research on the mechanical characteristics of the impact, obtained the shock absorber flowfield characteristics and tested the controllable design ability of the shock absorber. Czop et al. (2012) carried out numerical calculations and analysis on fluid-solid coupling of hydraulic shock absorbers, obtained the flowfield characteristics in the damping valve of a hydraulic shock absorber, proposed a method to optimize the internal structure of the damping valve and carried out experimental verification. ...
To design a high-quality vehicle shock absorber, the internal structure of the piston assembly of a shock absorber is analyzed in this study. Using the fluid–solid coupling method, a high-precision flow grid model and a solid finite element model of the stacked valve are built and analyzed. A bidirectional fluid–solid coupling method is proposed, which can be adopted to simulate and analyze the dynamic nonlinear response characteristics for a stacked valve slice of a vehicle shock absorber in Workbench software. The results indicate that the superposition valve slice maximum occurs at the inner radius, but the area of maximum deformation is near the piston hole and the maximum deformation is about 0.0636 mm. When the stack valve plate just opens the valve, the displacement and speed of the stack valve plate will simultaneously produce a jump change. The results of the calculation analysis are broadly in line with the test results, which indicates that the bidirectional fluid–solid coupling method is accurate and dependable, and can be used to study the dynamic characteristics of vehicle shock absorbers. This has important reference value for the optimization design of the internal valve system of vehicle shock absorbers.
... In this sense, the main novelty of the article is the development and validation of a simplified damper model with a high level of accuracy. This model greatly simplifies the complexity of the models available in the literature (Alonso, 2006;Czop et al., 2012;Dixon, 2007), which consider phenomena such as temperature, cavitation, and compressibility. Hence, the presented model is accurate and also suitable for hard realtime applications. ...
... On the other hand, the piston valve controlling the oil passage in the compression cycle is a shim valve (Dixon, 2007) composed by two metallic discs with four rectangular holes in the piston. Both the disc valve and the shim valve are control valves preloaded to prevent opening until a specified pressure differential has built up across them (Czop et al., 2012). ...
... In Figure 3(c), it can be seen that the base valve controlling the rebound cycle is an intake valve, that is, a valve which provides only slight resistance to flow in one direction and prevents flow in the opposite direction (Czop et al., 2012) with four conducts in the body and a metallic disc with a spring. On the other hand, the base valve controlling the compression cycle is a shim valve (Dixon, 2007) composed by four metallic discs with six circular holes in the body. ...
In this study, the development and validation of a simplified nonlinear dynamic model of a passive twin-tube hydraulic shock absorber is presented. First, the experimental dynamic response is characterized. Then, the numerical model is presented where flow, pressure, displacement, and velocity are considered. Finally, the numerical–experimental correlation is performed on force-movement dynamic behavior to prove the accuracy of the proposed model. The final goal of the model is to be integrated in a real-time driving simulator for ride comfort studies.
... It consists of a FEM mechanical (stress/strain) model and a flow model. In this topic Czop et al. (2012) proposed an advanced FSI model to understand and optimize performance of a valve system assembled in a piston-rod of a double-tube shock absorber regarding aeration/cavitation phenomena. This is a modification of the two-way FSI method: firstly, the deformations of a stack of discs, caused by a pressure load, are transferred to the CFD-model; then the CFD-model is re-evaluated in the deformed configuration. ...
The paper investigates cavitation effect which negatively influences the performance of a monotube shock absorber of road vehicle (passenger car). For better understanding of this phenomena, three physical models of shim stack valves are analyzed. Validation results allowed selecting the most appropriate valve model in presence of cavitation processes. A mathematical model of monotube damper with consideration of fluid compressibility and cavitation phenomena is developed. Simulation results are validated by experimental data obtained on hydraulic test rig. Based on the selected approach, a simplified method suitable for assessment of cavitation processes in automotive monotube shock absorbers is proposed. After investigation it is found that damping force when cavitation occurs mainly depends on the initial pressure and absorber inner diameter.
... Shock absorber or damper is a power dissipating device, no matter if an existing, dry friction one or a recently created Magnetorheological damper which utilizes Magnetically Responsive fluid, all transforms the kinetic energy of actions into thermal energy [1]. Damping powers might be exceptionally difficult. ...
The liquid flow through orifices produces larger damping, whereas the cushioning effect comes from the fluid’s compressibility. The hydraulic damper design is subjected to constant high pressure necessary to achieve the required forces, which drastically increases during the dynamic operation. Damper has different orifices or piston valves that lead to different flow losses. The main objective behind this work is to investigate the effect of number of orifices on the damping force at different velocities for rear side two-wheeler automobile mono tube damper. Three different orifice opening cases are considered for simulations and experiments such as two-orifice opening, six-orifice opening and ten-orifice opening.
div class="section abstract"> A damper is one of the most important elements in a vehicle suspension system. The damper valves are a fully coupled hydraulic system where the suspension fluid flow interacts with the elastic response of the valve structure. The base valve in the hydraulic damper plays a significant role in compression damping force characteristics of a damper, and therefore designing of the base valve is critical for damping force tuning. In this paper, the impact of the base valve design complexity reduction is quantitatively analyzed. The Current base valve design is restrictive which prevents achieving the required compression damping force ranges without a substantial base valve body parts library. A new base valve assembly is suggested with one more degree of freedom via a restrictor plate. Introducing this new element allows reducing the number of base valve designs for damping performance tuning. The design of the new base valve is engineered from existing designs with the aid of computer aided simulation for improving the tuning range of the damper with reduced number of valve body parts. Finite Element (FE) methods are utilized to evaluate the new base valve structural strength and validated by conducting experimental structural hub crush strength test. For the hydraulic performance of the new base valve design, Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulations were carried out for meeting damping force requirement. A test flow bench was built to validate the computational models. The new base valve is also a cost-effective solution to meet compression damping force tuning range and resolution.
</div
Основою сучасної методології дослідження рейкових транспортних засобів є математичне моделювання. Математична модель повинна враховувати такі властивості як просторовий характер руху окремих рухомих частин досліджуваного об’єкту, нелінійні характеристики пружно-дисипативних елементів системи, випадковий характер збурень, які передаються на гідравлічний апарат, властивості рідини, як робочого тіла. Гідравлічний гаситель коливань являє собою гідравлічний циліндр з штоком та системою калібрувальних отворів і клапанів, які спрацьовують в залежності від режиму роботи. Для опису характеристики роботи гідравлічного амортизатора, як правило, використовується класичний закон течії рідини через дросельний отвір, заснований на законах Бернуллі і рівнянні витрати рідини [1]. Використання такої закономірності для сучасних конструкцій пристроїв гасіння коливань вагонів не відповідає опису дійних процесів, які відбуваються за типовими умовами експлуатації. До особливостей робочих процесів пасивних гасителів коливань слід віднести взаємодію робочої рідини з рухомими деталями та її течію по каналах і через калібровані отвори з місцевим штучним опором. Окрім того, внаслідок постійних перепадів тиску через зміну напрямків руху рідини виникають пульсації, які слід враховувати при проектуванні конструкції для більш ефективної роботи пристрою. У статті представлена розроблена узагальнена математична модель гідравлічного гасителя коливань пасажирського вагона типу НЦ-1100, яка враховує нестаціонарні гідромеханічні процеси, що дозволяє
провести дослідження впливу робочих параметрів на характеристики роботи апарату.
The objective of this paper is to investigate the operation of a mono-tube damper through the application of Computational Fluid Dynamics analysis to the piston and flows through a series of flexible shims which cover exits of the piston orifices. The shims and orifices combine to form a system of variable area flow paths of the damper in parallel with the permanent bleed orifices. Shim stack stiffness characteristics were obtained using experimental and Finite Element techniques. The deflection characteristics were non-linear and were highly dependent upon small gaps present between shims and the restraining bodies. With the nature of the shim deflection being highly complex the computational fluid dynamics models investigated the shim deflection using a global uniform displacement method and also a more representative displacement based upon the finite element shim modelling. It was observed that the global displacement models allowed radially inward flow to establish and also overpredicted pressure drops. Finite element analysis of the shims allowed accurate representation of flow paths to be simulated which closely matched experimental and mathematical predictions. The computational fluid dynamics analyses showed that the discharge velocity for the global shim offset is greater than that from a variable shim deflection calculation. The damper pressure drop is highly dependent upon the shape of the flow path formed by the shim deflection. The presence of sharp direction changes through the piston and valve assembly leads to increased damping rates and piston pressure drops.