Figure 3 - uploaded by Allan Krill
Content may be subject to copyright.
Hopkinsʼ Plate 4. The oriented grain of the crystalline rocks seems to show that they have been modified by the polar magnetic attraction. From Hopkins (1844).

Hopkinsʼ Plate 4. The oriented grain of the crystalline rocks seems to show that they have been modified by the polar magnetic attraction. From Hopkins (1844).

Source publication
Book
Full-text available
Textbooks teach the principles of science. Lyellʼs geology textbooks emphasized vertical crustal movement. He avoided far-fetched continental-drift hypotheses by Hopkins in 1844 and Pepper in 1861. Their notions of drift were supported by fossil and paleoclimate evidence, but their causes were global magnetism and electrochemical crystallization an...

Contexts in source publication

Context 1
... forming the most western part of the great northern transverse land mass that extended unbroken far into Asia. Therefore, at the very beginning of Devonian time there came into existence an almost circumpolar land, whose only submerged portion lay in the North Pacific, and which was formed by the union of Laurentia, Baltica, and Angara (see Fig. 434.) The great Canadian geologist, Sir William Dawson, of McGill University, labored long to make known the plant life of the Devonian, and since he termed it the Erian flora after the Erian rocks in which it is entombed, taking the name from lake Erie and the Erie division of the New York state geologists, Suess in 1909 gave the ...
Context 2
... the plant life of the Devonian, and since he termed it the Erian flora after the Erian rocks in which it is entombed, taking the name from lake Erie and the Erie division of the New York state geologists, Suess in 1909 gave the continent the name of Eria. It is the old ancestral continent of the modern Holarctic region of the zoölogists (see Fig. ...
Context 3
... Their footprints are known in eastern North America in great variety (Figs. 460, 461), but good skeletons are exceedingly rare. In Europe, on the other hand, their skeletons are more common, and, so far as known, the animals were of the same kinds as those of America. From this and other evidence it appears that the great northern continent Eria (Fig. 434) was still intact and was the land across which the plants and animals of Triassic time readily migrated to and fro. Crocodile-like reptiles of the sprawling type (Mystriosuchus, Fig. 458) and other active forms (Aëtosaurus, Pl. 31, Fig. 9) were common. Genuine turtles occur in the Triassic rocks, showing the group originated in the ...
Context 4
... glacial deposits (Talchir) preceded the Permian submergence. In North America, tillites seemingly of Permian age are known about Boston, Massachusetts, and striated stones have been reported on Prince Edward Island; in England and Germany also they occur at the base of the Permian. For the complete distribution of these glacial deposits, see Fig. ...
Context 5
... must be given. Such evidence relates mainly to the wide-spread deposits of Permian age which have a flora in their lower beds that has been called the Glossopteris flora (Fig. 432). This flora occurs throughout the southern hemisphere, and paleobotanists hold that it could only have been so widely distributed across a continuous land (see Fig. 434). Belief in the existence of Gondwana is widespread among European geologists, but many American workers do not yet believe in it, mainly because they hold strongly to the theory of the permanence of the oceanic basins and continents. Without this continent, on the other hand, paleontologists cannot explain the known distribution of ...
Context 6
... the Greater Mediterranean. -To the north of Gondwana lay the great medial ocean which Suess has named Tethys, after the consort of Oceanus (see Fig. 434). The present Mediterranean is a remnant of this once grand middle ocean which widely extended unbroken from France and Spain into the eastern Indian and Pacific oceans, from time to time connecting with the Arctic Ocean by way of the Ural geosyncline. How often it was in open connection with the Atlantic is not yet clear, but that it ...
Context 7
... the 1915 edition, Wegener showed a sketch of continents before the Atlantic Ocean had opened (Fig. 30). Since we have already seen the Snider-fit and the Bullardfit, it is appropriate to now call this one the Wegener-fit. Wegener did not try to plot much geologic evidence on this fit-map. But note two geologic elements that he did try to represent by dashed lines: the continuation of the fold-belt from France, Britain, and Ireland ...
Context 8
... his drawings seemed to show that the poles had indeed moved, even though polar wander was not a requirement of his theory. The horizontal lines across his globes encourage this misunderstanding. They seem to show the Equator lying across ancient Africa. These horizontal lines were not needed, and were not shown in a few of his globes (such as Fig. 33). Climate indicators convinced Wegener that the continents had moved with respect to the poles, but the evidence could not rule out the possibility of some polar wandering as well. ...
Context 9
... for his second textook, Schuchert redrew his map and removed those arrows (Fig. 36). One might suppose that he removed the arrows because they could still not be explained. But in fact, he knew that they now had been explained, by the theory of continental drift. (Fig. 37). When he plotted the distribution of continental ice sheets on this map, the isolated glacial deposits fit together in a single ice cap of ...
Context 10
... for his second textook, Schuchert redrew his map and removed those arrows (Fig. 36). One might suppose that he removed the arrows because they could still not be explained. But in fact, he knew that they now had been explained, by the theory of continental drift. (Fig. 37). When he plotted the distribution of continental ice sheets on this map, the isolated glacial deposits fit together in a single ice cap of reasonable size. The directions of ice movement made a meaningful pattern, with ice flowing more or less away from the center, in India, Australia and also South America. Du Toitʼs discussion of the ...
Context 11
... cited Du Toitʼs paper and used parts of it. It seems that he started to put more detail on his world map by drawing Du Toitʼs new arrows in South Africa instead of his previous ones (see Fig. 36). But he did not add the new arrows to South America. And he removed the northward-pointing arrows in India and Australia. He had no reason to doubt those data. He must have removed the arrows so that students using this textbook would not be distracted by those ice-flow directions and the new ideas of continental ...
Context 12
... presented a map of Permian or Carboniferous Glaciation (Fig. 38). On this map he plotted the data in such a way that glaciation is mostly limited by the same line of latitude. But his written text explained that the Permo-Carboniferous glacial ice actually extended far beyond that limit, toward the ...
Context 13
... showed a map of world glaciation in Pleistocene time, where ice-free Alaska and Siberia are clearly visible (Fig. 39). Canada and Scandinavia had been heavily glaciated in the Pleistocene. If they had been at the same latitude in the PermoCarboniferous, why had they not been glaciated then? And why was southern Africa heavily glaciated in the Permo-Carboniferous but not at all in the Pleistocene? Coleman had no answers to these questions, but did not ...
Context 14
... paper had few sketch maps and geologic profiles, but they were intriguing. One map showed the close fit of continents in Gondwana, and the huge area of shallow marine sediments that would be shortened and compressed to form the Himalayas (Fig. 43, area c). And the profiles showed how mountain ranges formed by continental collisions (Fig. 44). But his paper must have been a disappointment. For some reason, his large colored map was not included and was totally unavailable to readers. This publication consisted largely of discussion of the rock patterns and the various folds of an ...
Context 15
... works (Fig. 53) were not readily avalable to American readers; only his 1922-book was actually translated in his lifetime. His publications on displacement theory were far too similar. His first two papers, in 1912, had the title Entstehung der Kontinente, and his first book-title was nearly the same: Entstehung der Kontinente und Ozeane. Although he ...
Context 16
... in fold mountain ranges? Willis avoided putting any numbers on it. But most geologists, even fixists, were forced to accept that continental material had moved hundreds of miles to form the Alps and the Himalayas. That is why Wegener and Argand showed ancient India as being incredibly long in this maps of Pangaea (see Fig. 32) and Gondwana (see Fig. 43). India was presumably shortened by horizontal compression to form the ...
Context 17
... for continental drift was extensive. And he accepted that convection currents in the mantle must be the underlying mechanism. But he did not understand convection processes as well as Holmes had done. In Du Toitʼs version, the oceans were not involved in the convection, and the convection cells were flat, with almost no vertical component (Fig. 63). To function properly, convection must be driven by vertical density differences, and could not be mainly horizontal as his figure shows. The North American scientist who understood convection currents best was David Griggs , a geophysicist at Harvard. He published a paper in the American Journal of Science in 1939 that employed theory ...
Context 18
... of the main questions at present discussed by geologists is: Do continents drift? To this no definite answer can be given, but it will be possible in the sequel to indicate the sort of evidence that suggests the possibility that, for instance, South Africa and South America once lay side by side (Fig. 307) [Fig. 64]. Perhaps the matter may be settled by measurement, for a succession of longitude observations taken at a particular site in Greenland makes it appear possible that Greenland is nowadays drifting at an appreciable rate towards America. Bailey 1939, p. 19. We have in these few instances noted that Britain formerly enjoyed much warmer ...
Context 19
... the glaciated localities extend somewhat beyond the limits of a single hemisphere, it would appear that the earth's crust has not migrated as a whole, but that in late Carboniferous times Gondwanaland was a fairly compact unit clustered about the South Pole, and that its constituent parts have since drifted asunder into their present positions (Fig. ...
Context 20
... explained his paleogeographic interpretations even more fully than Schuchert had done, giving more of the details of fossils and stratigraphy. He expanded the discussion of Cambrian faunal provinces (Fig. 73), which I find quite fascinating. These provinces became key evidence for later recognition of the Iapetus Ocean in plate tectonics. Grabau 1921, p. 227-231. Separate Faunal Provinces -In the study of Cambrian faunas it becomes apparent that there are distinct faunal provinces, and that the organisms of one have little or nothing in ...
Context 21
... clouds were finally gone from the Atlantic coast on all three maps of Late Cretaceous time (Fig. 83). By then, Pangaea had broken up and the Atlantic Ocean had opened. For the three maps of Cenozoic time, no clouds were shown anywhere on the maps (Fig. 84). When Dunbar wrote that the clouds were "a device to hide critical areas" we can understand this as meaning a device to hide the ocean, which did not yet exist east of North ...

Similar publications

Article
Full-text available
Terrane accretion is a ubiquitous process of plate tectonics that delivers fragments of subduction-resistant lithosphere into a subduction zone, resulting in events such as ocean plateau docking or continental assembly and orogenesis. The post-collisional extension of continental terranes is a well-documented tectonic process linked with gravitatio...

Citations

... Although it was well researched and presented in a few respectable books by Wegener and other scientists, it was ridiculed by geologists and fossil experts. The strong evidence for it was kept out of geology textbooks and scientific journals for 40 years (Krill 2014). Then continental drift was corroborated by a new type of data-the magnetic record of rocks on the seafloor. ...
Article
Full-text available
The aquatic ape hypothesis for human evolution can account for all the traits that distinguish humans from chimpanzees. This scientific paradigm has been considered impossible. It would require that human ancestors maintained a semiaquatic lifestyle for millions of years, whereas hominin fossils indicate relatively dry terrestrial environments. Here I propose a marine aquatic evolution that is speculative, but compatible with all the fossil and genetic evidence. In this hypothesis, hominins evolved from chimpanzee-like apes that became stranded on proto-Bioko — new volcanic islands with no terrestrial foods available. The apes were forced to eat shellfish and seaweed. From wading in water on two legs to obtain food, their bodies evolved to become bipedal. Naked skin, blubber, and protruding noses were also aquatic adaptations. Brain-size increase resulted from marine fatty acid DHA. Some of these hominins escaped to mainland Africa and their bipedal descendants are recorded at the famous fossil sites. The volcanic islands grew and evolved into Bioko, and the hominins that remained there evolved into Homo sapiens. They gave up their marine diet and semiaquatic habitat after food became available on the evolving island. Then, during one of the low sea-level stands in the Pleistocene epoch, humans walked to the mainland on the emergent Bioko land bridge. Unlike earlier aquatic ape ideas, the Bioko scenario can be tested by DNA. If the human genome includes a retrovirus that is otherwise only found in endemic animals on Bioko, it would show that our ancestors came from there. Unfortunately, Bioko and west-central Africa are not interesting to traditional paleoanthropologists, because they do not contain fossils.
Article
Full-text available
The continental drift controversy has been deeply analysed in terms of rationalist notions, which seem to find there a unique topic to describe the weight of evidence for reaching consensus. In that sense, many authors suggest that Alfred Wegener’s theory of the original supercontinent Pangea and the subsequent continental displacements finally reached a consensus when irrefutable evidence became available. Therefore, rationalist approaches suggest that evidence can be enough by itself to close scientific controversies. In this article I analyse continental drift debates from a different perspective which is based on styles of thought. I’ll argue that continental drift debate took much longer than it was usually recognized with two styles of thought coexisting for hundreds of years. These were fixism and mobilism and they were always confronting their own evidence and interpretations and functioning as general frameworks for the acceptability of a specific theory. Therefore, this text aims to bring much broader sociological elements than usually involved in the analysis of the continental drift theory.