Fig 3 - uploaded by Neven Matasovic
Content may be subject to copyright.
Geomembrane tear in Canyon C (after EMCON Associates 1994). 

Geomembrane tear in Canyon C (after EMCON Associates 1994). 

Source publication
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Analyses of the performance of the Chiquita Canyon and Lopez Canyon landfills in the 1994 Magnitude 6.7 Northridge earthquake illustrate deficiencies in the current state-of-practice for seismic design of geosynthetic liner systems and the promise of a new state-of-the-art method for performance-based design, and suggest necessary modifications to...

Contexts in source publication

Context 1
... EMCON Associates (1994) conducted a post-earthquake forensic investigation of the geomembrane tears. Samples of geomembrane were obtained from the two tear areas. In situ density measurements (using the sand cone method) were conducted on the soil above and below the tear areas and the soil was sampled for laboratory testing. An undrained shear strength of 62.2 kPa was reported for the low permeability soil-bentonite mixture beneath the Canyon C base geomembrane. EMCON Associates (1994) also conducted a series of interface shear tests on the geomembrane/ soil interfaces for the side slope liners in Canyon C and Canyon D. These tests were conducted in a 304.8 mm by 304.8 mm direct shear device. Geomembrane samples recovered from the landfill were used in the interface shear testing. All the testing was done using soil compacted to the in situ dry density at 2% above the in situ moisture content. Interface shear test results are summarized in Table 1. EMCON Associates (1994) repeated the direct shear tests using wetted interfaces and saturated soil with no decrease in interface shear strength. As part of the post-earthquake investigation, a study on the fracture morphology of the geomembrane was conducted by researchers at Drexel University using a scanning electron microscope to investigate the tear initiation and growth mechanism (EMCON Associates 1994). Six specimens from the Canyon C side slope geomembrane liner (S-1 to S-6) were sampled from at the locations indicated in the sketch presented in Fig. 3, i.e. adjacent to two tear faces. Based on the fracture morphology, it was concluded that the tear likely initiated from location of samples S-3 and S-4, i.e. at the fillet extrusion weld used to weld the patch at this location, and then propagated perpendicular to the dual hot wedge seam, i.e. perpendicular to the loading direction (EMCON Associates, ...
Context 2
... Table 7 presents a summary of the maximum tensile strain in the geomembrane from the analyses for cross section C1-C1. The maximum tensile strains for the two strong motion records were 4.3% to 3.8%. In both cases, the maximum tensile strain was at the anchor point at the top of the slope. The tensile strains calculated in the back analysis were well below the yield strain of the intact geomembrane. However, Giroud (2005) showed that failure in geomembranes in the field can occur in cases where the tensile strains are well below the yield strain due to strain concentration at seams and scratches in the geomembrane. Therefore, the procedure proposed by Giroud (2005) to estimate geomembrane strain concentration was followed to estimate the strain concentration and factor of safety for the geomembrane in cross section C1-C1. Giroud (2005) presented several correction factors that should be applied to the nominal yield strain of a geomembrane from uniaxial tensile testing to estimate the yield strain in the field. First, Giroud (2005) showed that the yield strain under plane strain conditions is lower than the yield strain in uniaxial tensile tests by a factor depending on Poisson’s ratio. Assuming a Poisson's ratio of 0.46 and a uniaxial yield strain of 12% for the HDPE geomembrane, the yield strain in case of plane strain will decrease to 10.9%. Giroud (2005) also showed that the yield strain will decrease due to scratches in the geomembrane according to the depth of the scratch, as illustrated in Fig. 9. Assuming that the ratio of the depth of the scratch to the geomembrane thickness is 0.2, the ratio of the yield strain of scratched geomembrane,  SY , to the intact geomembrane yield strain is 0.35 according to Fig. 9. This means the yield strain for a geomembrane with a scratch that penetrates 20% of the thickness of the geomembrane under plane strain conditions,  , is 3.8%. Giroud (2005) also provides a procedure that can be used to estimate the additional strain due to bending at a geomembrane seam perpendicular to the loading direction. Figure 10 shows a plot developed by Giroud (2005) for a 1- mm thick geomembrane and different types of seam. The fillet weld at the top of the patch where the tear initiated in cross section C1-C1, shown in Fig. 3, is perpendicular to the loading direction. Therefore, the Giroud (2005) procedure was used to estimate the incremental strain due to the seam at this location. Based upon an assumed thickness of 5 mm for the extrusion fillet weld, the additional strain due to bending at the seam was estimated to be 3.0%. Adding the calculated strain in geomembrane due to the earthquake loading (3.8%) to the bending strain due to the seam stress concentration, a total tensile strain in the geomembrane in the vicinity of the seam of 6.8% is calculated. Considering the strain ...

Similar publications

Article
Full-text available
The interferometric SAR coherence-change technique with coherence filter and polarization (HH and HV) has been used to detect the parts of buildings damaged by the 2015 Gorkha Earthquake. A survey of the building damage was conducted in every house to evaluate the detection accuracy in the Khokana and Sankhu urban areas in the Kathmandu Valley of N...
Article
Full-text available
A case study of six-story reinforced concrete building subjected to five earthquakes with different characteristics have been analyzed using linear transient time history analysis. The study concentrate on the frequency point of view through comparing the frequency of the structure obtained from the modal analysis with frequency content of both the...
Article
Full-text available
To mitigate the potential seismic disasters dominated by the Longmen Shan fault zone (LFZ) in the Sichuan region, building up suitable magnitude estimation models for earthquake early warning (EEW) systems is important. In this article, the records from the mainshocks and aftershocks of the 2008 Wenchuan (Mw 7.9) and 2013 Lushan earthquakes (Mw 6.6...
Article
Full-text available
Two issues related to the average period τc early-warning parameter are the magnitude saturation effect on large earthquakes and considerable scatter for small earthquakes. To reduce the effect of these two issues on earthquake early warning systems (EEWSs), we introduce a new τc regression relationship derived from all P-wave time windows (PTWs) i...

Citations

... They reported that geomembrane tears were initiated at the extrusion welding bead or along the edge of the extrusion weld. Kavazanjian et al. (2013) performed a numerical analysis to investigate the causes of failure at the Chiquita Canyon landfill. It was concluded that earthquake induced failure of the geomembrane occurred at points of strain concentration and scratches. ...
Article
The stress crack resistance (SCR) of high-density polyethylene (HDPE) geomembrane extrusion welds is examined for a 1.5 mm HDPE geomembrane and three different welding parameter combinations (denoted as “Cool”, “Good”, and “Overheated”). Results are reported for unnotched welds, unnotched sheet, and notched sheet. The average SCR for a Good extrusion weld is 23% of that of the unnotched sheet SCR. Little variation is found between the three welding parameter combinations for low geometry irregularity SCR weld specimens. There is no statistically significant difference between a good-quality fusion and extrusion weld. However, operator-dependent weld induced geometric irregularity (WIGI) greatly affects the SCR of extrusion welds. Extrusion welds with high WIGI have an average unnotched SCR of only 9% of the unnotched sheet. Extrusion welds with an overground surface can have an unnotched SCR as little as 1% of the best extrusion weld. Deleterious weld bead geometries are identified to provide a framework with which engineers can identify “high-risk” extrusion welds with respect to stress cracking.
... However, internal shear strength of GCL may decrease dramatically due to the hydration of bentonite (Fox and Stark 2015). The relatively low shear strength of GCL within liner system contributes to the formation of a potential slip interface, which is detrimental to stability of landfill (Feng et al. 2018;Kavazanjian et al. 2013). Hence, the internal shear strength of hydrated GCL has drawn extensive attention. ...
Chapter
Internal shear strength of geosynthetic clay liner (GCL) is of vital importance for the stability of waste containment facilities where GCLs are widely used as hydraulic barriers. This paper presents an experimental investigation of the internal shear strength of hydrated needle-punched geosynthetic clay liners (NP GCLs) under monotonic loading. A new dynamic direct shear apparatus with the capability to cover a large range of normal stress and displacement rate is developed. Series of direct shear tests on NP GCL for different normal stress levels and displacement rates are performed. The failure mechanism of hydrated GCL is explored through inspection of tested specimens and analysis of test results. The intrinsic relationship between peak/residual shear strength of NP GCL and displacement rate is also studied. Experimental results indicated that displacement rate has obvious effect on the peak shear strength of NP GCL, while the influence of displacement rate on residual shear strength is of little significance for the same normal stress level.
... Moreover, it was recommended that the factor of safety for critical applications is the one with a value that commensurates the level of confidence in understanding the interface shear strength parameters. Kavazanjian et al. (2013) reported numerical analysis and reported that the maximum tensile strain of geomembranes installed in bench anchors is more than that of the trench anchors. ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper presents the target reliability based design framework for V-shaped anchored trenches to resist the sliding action and pull-out of geosynthetic liners. V-shaped anchor trenches are subject to various uncertainties arising from inconsistency in parameter estimation, improper compaction of cover/backfilled soils, field construction practices, the assumption of relative slippage at soil-liner interface and invention of new design methods. Therefore, based on the compilation of interface friction angles between different types of geomembranes (GMB) and granular soils according to several published studies, the mean, standard deviation, and coefficient of variation are computed using statistical analysis. Moreover, a framework for reliability based design is presented by considering the unit weights of backfill and cover soil, interface friction angle and allowable GMB tensile force. The optimum allowable GMB tensile force needed to maintain the stability against pull-out failure by targeting various reliability indices is obtained for various design parameters. The obtained results highlight the potential benefits of reliability methods and encourage their implementation during the design of MSW landfills.
... Moreover, it was recommended that the factor of safety for critical applications is the one with a value that commensurates the level of confidence in understanding the interface shear strength parameters. Kavazanjian et al. (2013) reported numerical analysis and reported that the maximum tensile strain of geomembranes installed in bench anchors is more than that of the trench anchors. ...
Article
Anchor trenches for MSW landfills subject to various uncertainties arising from inconsistency in parameter measurement and determination, placement of fresh waste on the geomembrane (GM) liner, improper compaction of cover and backfilled soils, construction practices, assumption of relative slippage, and invention of new design methods. A wide range of variability is associated with the design parameters of the anchorage. Conventional factor of safety approach cannot account for the uncertainties involved. The drawback can be well addressed through reliability based approaches. The objective of the analysis discussed herein is to produce estimates of the probability of anchor trench failure as opposed to the conventional factor of safety. Therefore, a framework for the target reliability based design optimization (TRBDO) methodology is presented for the design of anchor trenches. This paper emphasizes the importance of allowable design strength of the liner considering the variability for rectangular and L-shaped rectangular anchor trenches.
Article
Tensile strain development in high-density polyethylene (HDPE) geomembrane (GMB) liner systems in landfills was numerically investigated. A new constitutive model for municipal solid waste (MSW) that incorporates both mechanical creep and biodegradation was employed in the analyses. The MSW constitutive model is a Cam-Clay type of plasticity model and was implemented in the finite difference computer program FLAC™. The influence of the friction angle of the liner system interfaces, the biodegradation of MSW, and the MSW filling rate on tensile strains were investigated. Several design alternatives to reduce the maximum tensile strain under both short- and long-term waste settlement were evaluated. Results of the analyses indicate that landfill geometry, interface friction angles, and short- and long-term waste settlement are key factors in the development of tensile strains. The results show that long-term waste settlement can induce additional tensile strains after waste placement is complete. Using a HDPE GMB with a friction angle on its upper interface that is lower than the friction angle on the underlying interface, increasing the number of benches, and reducing the slope inclination are shown to mitigate the maximum tensile strain caused by waste placement and waste settlement.
Article
A large scale centrifuge test of a geomembrane-lined landfill subject to waste settlement and seismic loading was conducted to help validate a numerical model for performance based design of geomembrane liner systems. The test was conducted using the 240g-ton centrifuge at the University of California at Davis under the U.S. National Science Foundation Network for Earthquake Engineering Simulation Research (NEESR) program. A 0.05mm thin film membrane was used to model the liner. The waste was modeled using a peat-sand mixture. The side slope membrane was underlain by lubricated low density polyethylene to maximize the difference between the interface shear strength on the top and bottom of the geomembrane and the induced tension in it. Instrumentation included thin film strain gages to monitor geomembrane strains and accelerometers to monitor seismic excitation. The model was subjected to an input design motion intended to simulate strong ground motion from the 1994 Hyogo-ken Nanbu earthquake. Results indicate that downdrag waste settlement and seismic loading together, and possibly each phenomenon individually, can induce potentially damaging tensile strains in geomembrane liners. The data collected from this test is publically available and can be used to validate numerical models for the performance of geomembrane liner systems.