FIGURE 2 - available via license: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
Content may be subject to copyright.
Source publication
The call for measuring synergies and trade-offs between water, energy, and food is increasing worldwide. This article presents the development and application of a country-level index that has been calculated for 181 nations using open databases. Following an assessment of 87 water-, energy-, and food-related indicators, 21 were selected to constit...
Contexts in source publication
Context 1
... second stage of the JRC:COIN methodology in the development of a composite indicator is the selection of the indicators that will constitute the index. Figure 2 shows that, for a given context (e.g., the WEF nexus), indicators and indices are developed from data to yield information that can ultimately be used for decision-and policy-making and the interactions between these aspects. These decisions and policies will then be based on firm knowledge, founded on verifiable information, which will limit knee-jerk decisions and conjecture. ...
Context 2
... there is a medium-to-strong correlation between the HDI and the WEF Nexus Index (R 2 = 0.57; Supplementary Figure 22 in Addendum E), these two indices represent contrasting facets of development (UNDP, 2018a,b). The former combines indicators relating to health, education and income (providing a nexus perspective of, amongst others, SDGs 3, 4, 8). ...
Similar publications
By synthetically producing nitrogen fertilizers from ammonia, the Haber-Bosch process has been feeding humanity for more than one hundred years. However, current ammonia production relies on fossil fuels, and is energy and carbon intensive. This commits humanity to emissions levels not compatible with climate goals and commits agricultural producti...
Citations
... The goal of these recommendations is to more successfully integrate the NEXUS concept into existing and future NEXUS initiatives so that these initiatives are truly successful, i.e., have a positive impact on the human, socio-cultural, economic, and environmental pillars of sustainability. Water, energy, and food are inextricably linked, meaning that actions in one of these areas have synergistic or often negative effects on the others at different levels and scales (Simpson et al., 2022). Increasing resource demand due to global population growth, not only in numbers but also in consumption patterns, is expected to increase dramatically in the coming decades (FAO, 2014). ...
... The initiation of the water-energy-food (WEF) NEXUS represents the largest step toward ensuring integrated resource management and resource security in the global context of climate crisis and resource scarcity (Taguta et al., 2022). It has gained undivided attention in academia, policy dialogue, industrial innovation, and development as it focuses on developing valuable tools for quantifying and assessing cross-sectoral relationships and interactions ( Fig. 1), and for integrative sectoral planning and growth perspectives (Eftelioglu et al., 2017;Simpson et al., 2022). Currently, more extended NEXUS schemes are introduced by different research teams, adding components, such as the Ecosystems (WEFE) (Bidoglio et al., 2019;Malago et al., 2021), Climate and Land (WEFCL) (Ramos et al., 2022), and Health (WEFH) (Slorach et al., 2020). ...
... The WEF nexus index consists of a collection of 21 indicators. However, it is difficult to reduce the status of a nation's integrated resource management to a single number [33]. This article does not measure the index due to limited access to data, but it does highlight the possibility of improving the availability and accessibility of water, food, and energy through the implementation of SAIL, which is associated with an increase in the WEF nexus index. ...
Indonesia, being an archipelagic country, ranks third in terms of climate risk. Sustainable islands (SAIL) are novel ideas offered as an effective way of achieving Indonesia's sustainable development while also accelerating climate change mitigation and adaptation. The water, energy, and food (WEF) nexus approach will be used to expand SAIL's programs. In this nexus, water is the most essential governing factor for the ecosystem and society. Thus, the SAIL program is adopting rainwater harvesting (RWH), a sustainable technology that supplies water with low energy and cost. To irrigate the crops and generate electricity, the island RWH tank is created by impounding surface runoff over natural landscape depressions equipped with a hydrokinetic power system. An RWH system with a pico-hydropower system is installed on the roofs of all island buildings for both household water consumption and electricity generation. The immediate implementation of the SAIL concept promises to boost Indonesia’s WEF nexus index. Keywords: Island; Nexus; RWH; Sustainability; WEF.
... The scope of the problem is particularly challenging in the modern agricultural industry (Allen and Prinsloo, 2018;Prinsloo and Lombard, 2015b), whereby extended knowledge gap challenges warrant new research and academic contributions to deal with the complexity and diversity of the sustainability criteria defined in a climate-smart agricultural context (refer to Figure A.1). Since agricultural sustainability goals govern the conditions for new energy installations on farms as part of the green energy production movement (Cagle et al., 2020;WWF, 2021), this thesis argues that floating PV sustainability should instead exploit the science of the total environment in the search for a new sustainability assessment paradigm (Alaoui et al., 2022;Luca et al., 2015;Santiago-Brown et al., 2015;Simpson et al., 2022). Within an agricultural context, the complexity and diversity of the impact assessments for floatovoltaics escalate, and the sustainability assessment becomes more problematic because the installation of newly planned PV systems permanently floats on life-and food-sustaining water reservoirs (to impact positively on farmland) (Hoffacker et al., 2017;Vema et al., 2022). ...
... Data-driven decision-making based on WEF Nexus Index, moving from model data to decision making (source:Simpson et al. (2022), page 4). ...
Floating Solar PV (FSPV, FPV or floatovoltaics) is an emerging decentralised energy concept in climate-smart agriculture that is quickly becoming a trend in water-rich regions with high land costs, land scarcity and underutilised water areas. FPV technology has excellent environmental compatibility properties, assists in shrinking a farm's carbon footprint, aids farms in decarbonisation towards a net-zero emissions goal, while supporting sustainable energy development towards better carbon taxation and green energy certification in sustainable farming ventures. Amidst a rapidly growing international interest in floating PV and agrivoltaic solutions as climate-solver technologies, current knowledge gaps around its environmental and energy-water-land resource impact uncertainties are the main barriers to floatovoltaic installation deployments. Current FPV performance and impact assessment methodologies still need to overcome critical knowledge gaps constraining fully functional evidence-based scientific assessments as a mandatory requirement to regulatory project permissions prescribed by law. This doctoral dissertation investigates the characterisation and quantification of floating photovoltaic power performance benefits, environmental impact offsets and economic sustainability profiles in a theoretical PV performance model-driven water-energy-land-food resource features. With FPV as natural resource preservation energy technology touching issues along the interplaying water-energy-land-food nexus dimensions (WELF-nexus), a robust validation of the technology's co-benefits and suggested impacts on the nexus of local energy-water-food (EWF) system was lacking. Rethinking environmental sustainability in the FPV context, this research investigation uncovers the root cause of current predictive analytical problems in floating PV characterisation as relating to critical knowledge gaps and modelling challenges in four dimensions: (a) reductionist thinking philosophy as an overwhelming modelling approach engaged by most current PV system assessment models; (b) low-priority role of the natural environmental system and micro-habitat in the integrated systems modelling characterisation of floating PV as a system of systems; (c) inadequate modelling consideration given the water-energy-land nexus system resources and linkages in a unidirectional open-loop linear assessment framework; and (d) modelling framework does not sufficiently cater for systemic interactions in the topological and ontological structures among the PV ecosystem components. Aiming to find a holistic systems thinking solution, the fourth industrial revolution offers information technology principles that enable subject-matter expert knowledge integration into the virtualization of intelligent energy production models using digital twin technology. As operational research paradigms for floating PV modelling, 4IR in digital twinning enables the study to define a new integrated theoretical framework for sustainability evaluation. Towards simulation analysis, this pluralistic-type systemic intervention can account for the extended range of resource-use-efficiencies and impact-effect-positives of floating PV technology in a computer-aided analysis-by-synthesis technique. While comparing the performances of FPV and GPV systems, this study makes a case for the systematisation of sustainability knowledge in the technogenic assessment for floating PV installations through the co-simulation modelling of a novel integrated technical energy-environmental-economic scientific sustainability assessment framework concept. This institutionalised sustainability framework mechanism drives the computer program logic and architecture in a computer synthesis methodology, to assess the integrative technological, economic and natural environmental system attributes in a pluralistic system dynamical way. The approach is further novel in that it covers both short-term and long-term perspectives in a cascaded closed-loop feedback system, with inter-domain feedback memory in a real-time computer synthesis methodology ensuring causal framework ontology modelling. The proposed sustainability definition and systemic framework policy for geospatial sustainability assessment offer a complex appraisal method and modelling technique that supports project decision-making in broad-spectrum environmental, economic and technical contexts that transcends the conventional technically biased scientific evaluation inherited from ground-mounted photovoltaics. The proposed theoretical reference framework and modelling technique offer multidimensional sustainability indicator dimensions, thus addressing critical decision-making domain elements focussed on by impact assessment practitioners, investment stakeholders and subject experts. The scientific investigation and results confer valuable insights into the value-laden sustainability qualities of FPV in pre-qualifying project-assessment experiments for future planned floating solar projects. The theoretical modelling, simulation and characterisation of floatovoltaic technology offer a data collection toolset for duly required scientific evidence of sustainability traits of the technology in support of the adoption, regularisation and licensing of floating photovoltaic renewable energy system installations. The research advances fresh philosophical ideas with novel theoretical principles that may have far-reaching international implications for developing floatovoltaic, agrivoltaic and ground-mounted PV performance models worldwide.
~
https://hdl.handle.net/10500/30091
... Therefore, WEFNI may be acknowledged as a crucial indicator of achieving SDGs 2, 6, and 7 at the country level or on any other scale. Simpson et al. (2022) stated that CI and WEF nexus approach does not solve all challenges related to human development and well-being. However, they can contribute initiation to integrated resources management and policy-making procedure and help to achieve SDGs. ...
Despite the importance of Water-Energy-Food (WEF) evaluations in disseminating information about WEF security challenges, no study on WEF security at a State or Union Territory (UT) level has been conducted in India. We have quantitatively analysed the WEF nexus at State/UT level in India using Pardee RAND WEF Nexus Index (PR-WEFNI) for 2015-16 and 2019-20. The Government of India has implemented several policies to ensure India's WEF security. However, none of the studies have analysed the potential impact of implemented policies in WEF nexus changes. We have proposed an indicator-based approach, i.e., a Policy Implementation Score (PIS), which indicates a policy's progress (in %). PIS is calculated by aggregating indicators related to WEF policy implementation to quantitatively investigate the impact of implemented governmental policies on WEF nexus changes. Results indicated significant variations in WEF sub-indices across States/UTs over the two years under consideration. Most States/UTs showed an increase in the Water Sub-index (WSI) and Energy Sub-index (ESI) due to higher values of Water PIS and Energy PIS but a decrease/no changes in the Food sub-index (FSI) due to lower Food PIS. Moreover, overall WSI, ESI, FSI and WEFNI of India increased by 15%, 6.6%, 0.1% and 8%, respectively , in 2019-20 compared to 2015-16. This study assessed the WEF security status of Indian States/UTs, which helped to recognise respective resource-insecure areas. This approach can help policymakers identify problems, make further modifications, and develop area-specific policies to achieve resource security across India's States/ UTs and other developing economies worldwide.
... En este sentido, Simpson et al. (2022) argumentan que la palabra nexo significa principalmente conectar, aunque su aplicación puede ser variada. Es por ello que el nexo WEF se puede describir comenzando con la sociedad, la cual se encuentra en el centro del sistema ofertando y demandando los tres recursos vitales (Figura 1). ...
... Pero, tanto el clima como el medio ambiente, se gestionan y regulan a través de una gobernanza y políticas públicas eficientes o deficientes, por ello estos elementos se encuentran representados por las capas exteriores del sistema (verde y café respectivamente de la Figura 1), formando una parte integral del nexo que tienen como principal objetivo generar un desarrollo sostenible. A pesar, de que la sociedad se localizó en el centro del sistema como principal ofertante y demandante de los tres recursos, también son los responsables de que se lleve a cabo una adecuada gobernanza e implementación de políticas públicas en beneficio de todos (Simpson et al., 2022 Es así que el nexo WEF se puede considerar como una herramienta para facilitar la gobernanza y guiar la cooperación intersectorial, debido a que la oferta y la demanda de los tres recursos son interdependientes a nivel global, nacional, regional y local (Li et al., 2019). ...
La creciente demanda mundial de agua dulce, energía y alimentos ha generado que la comunidad científica desarrolle un nuevo enfoque, para analizar, evaluar e implementar medidas de mitigación ante esta gran crisis. Es así como surge el concepto nexo agua-energía-alimentos (WEF, por sus siglas en inglés) el cual se refiere a las interacciones que se dan entre estos tres recursos, con todas sus sinergias y compensaciones que resultan de esta relación. Por lo tanto, esta investigación tiene como finalidad explicar cómo se fue desarrollando el concepto desde sus orígenes en la Conferencia Nexus de Bonn en 2011, cuáles han sido las herramientas y metodologías de análisis más empleadas y finalmente, observar algunos casos de éxito. Concluyéndose que lograr un análisis integral de los tres recursos y no evaluar cada recurso por separado, proporcionará una serie de estrategias que ayudarán a reducir los efectos adversos de tipo ambiental, social y económico.
... Therefore, this study proposes a calculation method for the comprehensive WEF security index (WEFSI) by using equal weights for each individual resource security index (presented above) to calculate its arithmetic mean. This follows the concept developed and presented by Simpson et al. (2022). ...
Nexus approaches provide an efficient way to analyze the dynamic evolution of the water-energy-food nexus (WEFN), yet there is a need to close the science-policy divide by making simulation models more practically relevant. This study incorporates society, economy and environment systems (SEE) into the WEFN, simulating a broad environmental system. A system dynamics model is constructed to simulate and dynamically track the development of the WEF-SEE system in Hunan Province, China. The developed model is applied to assess WEF-SEE system trajectories from 2021 to 2035 against nine policy goals formulated by the Hunan Provincial Government. Baseline results suggest that Hunan Province will have a surplus of grain production and will be in a state of "self-sufficiency" in water resources. The energy security situation is not as optimistic, with imports being required to meet demand. The sustainable development of the WEF Nexus will be constrained by resource shortages. As the future development of Hunan Province outpaces environmental protection policies, water pollution and CO2 emissions and are expected to increase. Intra-system trade-offs and synergies under the impacts of different policies indicate that the implementation of an indicative policy has the intended impact within its particular subsystem, but may lead to trade-offs in other subsystems. Due to system interconnectedness, the simultaneous implementation of multiple policies may increase or hinder progress towards certain goals. For example, expanding planting area increases food production, but increase agricultural water demand and water pollutant discharge, counter to water security goal and environmental protection goals. Cross-system impacts must be considered when choosing policies. This study advances environmental system analysis and evaluation, and contributes to practical policy recommendations, providing useful insights for Hunan Province, especially considering potential trade-offs and synergies. Such information could lead to more effective, holistic environmental policy formulation.
... Therefore, this study proposes a calculation method for the comprehensive WEF security index (WEFSI) by using equal weights for each individual resource security index (presented above) to calculate its arithmetic mean. This follows the concept developed and presented by Simpson et al. (2022). Equal weighting emphasizes WEFN's polycentric philosophy that each resource system has equal importance (Owen et al. 2018). ...
This article applies the Water-Energy-Food (WEF) nexus to explore the relationships between Iraq's water (demand and supply), energy (oil, gas and electricity), and food production, moving beyond sector-specific studies. Thus, this is a WEF analysis of a country that is emerging from years of conflict and instability and is among the first WEF applications to Iraq at the national (as opposed to regional or metropolitan) level. We utilize various open-source data, peer reviewed and grey literature to survey environmental conditions, setting the ground for the study of WEF interrelationships. We note the decline in the quality and availability of water, focusing on it as a key input into both agricultural and oil production. We argue that the declining quality and availability of water over many decades is unable to sustain both present agricultural practices and rising oil output, highlighting the difficulty of increasing the outputs of these sectors. As such, the article underlines the need for a multi-sectoral approach in dealing with the present challenges of water, energy and food production and argues that a radical restructuring of the relations between the sectors is required. We offer policy recommendations that seek to overcome internal barriers, constraints that exist and are potentially solvable within Iraq, and other measures geared towards external barriers, including the actions of neighbors.
Water, energy and food (WEF) security are key indicators of sustainable development. Realization of sustainable development goals (SDGs) by countries is achieved through a water-energy-food-ecosystem nexus framework. Climate change is a threat to food, energy and water security in the Horn of Africa. The main aim of this review is to assess the status and prospects of WEF nexus as it relates to SDGs in the horn of Africa. The countries considered were Ethiopia, Eritrea, Somalia and Djibouti. The review indicated that the four countries have a challenge in achieving SDGs 2, 6 and 7. Djibouti had the highest (50.9) WEF index in the region followed by Ethiopia and Somalia at 47.5 and 36.8, respectively while Eritrea had the lowest WEF index of 35.8. The energy sub-index was the best performer in the region with an average index of 56 while water and food sub-indices were the worst at 36. Political instability, insecurity, inadequate infrastructure, weak institutional and legal framework are some of the challenges facing WEF and sustainable development in the region. Climate change adaptation measures should be incorporated into the water, energy, food and ecosystem (WEFE) nexus using an integrated approach. Modelling WEFE requires integration of models and should also focus on interactions among the sub-systems.
There is a need to address resource security and distributional justice in developing countries. People need water, energy, and food to sustain their livelihoods and to achieve sustainable development. The interactions between these resource sectors form the crux of water-energy-food (WEF) nexus assessments. In this study, we have utilised the WEF Nexus Index to analyse 54 African nations for whom sufficient data was available in 2019. The results for several countries were analysed to illustrate the opportunities and constraints for future development. The analysis demonstrates that, for many African countries, policies that undergird investments in energy supply projects are needed to unlock available freshwater resources to meet their food requirements. Such projects can be utilised to enhance the ability of farmers to manage water through drought-proofing rainfed agriculture, an increase in irrigation development, or both. WEF nexus-based studies, policies, and projects must be focussed on the direct and indirect achievement of SDGs 1, 2, 6, 7, and 13, both in terms of access and availability, to ensure distributional justice, especially in the African context. Such actions, combined with broad public participation, can have a ripple effect on other SDGs such as SDGs 5, 10, and 17, thereby reducing inequalities and building partnerships to attain these aspirational goals. The assessment of Africa’s relatively low scores in terms of the WEF Nexus Index does not represent a negative narrative. Instead, it provides an entry point to understanding the underlying challenges, through which more detailed analyses can lead to identified solutions and policies. Many African countries are trapped in an environment that could be termed a ‘poverty-unemployment-inequality nexus’ (due to the interlinkages that exist between these ‘wicked’ problems). The WEF Nexus Index provides high-level insights into these opportunities.
