Publications (61)105.89 Total impact
-
Article: Spatially resolved spectroscopy of the globular cluster RZ 2109 and the nature of its black hole
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We present optical HST/STIS spectroscopy of RZ 2109, a globular cluster in the elliptical galaxy NGC 4472. This globular cluster is notable for hosting an ultraluminous X-ray source as well as associated strong and broad [OIII] 4959, 5007 emission. We show that the HST/STIS spectroscopy spatially resolves the [OIII] emission in RZ 2109. While we are unable to make a precise determination of the morphology of the emission line nebula, the best fitting models all require that the [OIII] 5007 emission has a half light radius in the range 3-7 pc. The extended nature of the [OIII] 5007 emission is inconsistent with published models that invoke an intermediate mass black hole origin. It is also inconsistent with the ionization of ejecta from a nova in the cluster. The spatial scale of the nebula could be produced via the photoionization of a strong wind driven from a stellar mass black hole accreting at roughly its Eddington rate.09/2012; -
Article: Limits on [OIII] 5007 emission from NGC4472's globular clusters: constraints on planetary nebulae and ultraluminous black hole X-ray binaries in globular clusters
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We have searched for [OIII] 5007 emission in high resolution spectroscopic data from Flames/Giraffe VLT observations of 174 massive globular clusters (GCs) in NGC4472. No planetary nebulae (PNe) are observed in these clusters, constraining the number of PNe per bolometric luminosity, \alpha<0.8*10^{-7}PN/L_{\odot}. This is significantly lower than the rate predicted from stellar evolution, if all stars produce PNe. Comparing our results to populations of PNe in galaxies, we find most galaxies have a higher \alpha than these GCs (more PNe per bolometric luminosity - though some massive early-type galaxies do have similarly low \alpha). The low \alpha required in these GCs suggests that the number of PNe per bolometric luminosity does not increase strongly with decreasing mass or metallicity of the stellar population. We find no evidence for correlations between the presence of known GC PNe and either the presence of low mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs) or the stellar interaction rates in the GCs. This, and the low \alpha observed, suggests that the formation of PNe may not be enhanced in tight binary systems. These data do identify one [OIII] emission feature, this is the (previously published) broad [OIII] emission from the cluster RZ 2109. This emission is thought to originate from the LMXB in this cluster, which is accreting at super-Eddington rates. The absence of any similar [OIII] emission from the other clusters favors the hypothesis that this source is a black hole LMXB, rather than a neutron star LMXB with significant geometric beaming of its X-ray emission.04/2012; -
Article: Velocity Structure and Variability of [O III] Emission in Black Hole Host Globular Cluster RZ2109
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We present a multi-facility study of the optical spectrum of the extragalactic globular cluster RZ2109, which hosts a bright black hole X-ray source. The optical spectrum of RZ2109 shows strong and very broad [O III]\lambda \lambda 4959,5007 emission in addition to the stellar absorption lines typical of a globular cluster. We use observations over an extended period of time to constrain the variability of these [O III] emission lines. We find that the equivalent width of the lines is similar in all of the datasets; the change in L[O III]\lambda 5007 is \ltsim 10% between the first and last observations, which were separated by 467 days. The velocity profile of the line also shows no significant variability over this interval. Using a simple geometric model we demonstrate that the observed [O III]\lambda 5007 line velocity structure can be described by a two component model with most of the flux contributed by a bipolar conical outflow of about 1,600 km/s, and the remainder from a Gaussian component with a FWHM of several hundred km/s.07/2011; -
Article: Probing the GC-LMXB Connection in NGC 1399: A Wide-field Study with the Hubble Space Telescope and Chandra
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We present a wide-field study of the globular cluster (GC)/low-mass X-ray binary (LMXB) connection in the giant elliptical NGC 1399. The large field of view of the Advanced Camera for Surveys/WFC, combined with Hubble Space Telescope and Chandra high resolution, allow us to constrain the LMXB formation scenarios in elliptical galaxies. We confirm that NGC 1399 has the highest LMXB fraction in GCs of all nearby elliptical galaxies studied so far, even though the exact value depends on galactocentric distance due to the interplay of a differential GC versus galaxy light distribution and the GC color dependence. In fact, LMXBs are preferentially hosted by bright, red GCs out to >5 R eff of the galaxy light. The finding that GCs hosting LMXBs follow the radial distribution of their parent GC population argues against the hypothesis that the external dynamical influence of the galaxy affects the LMXB formation in GCs. On the other hand, field-LMXBs closely match the host galaxy light, thus indicating that they are originally formed in situ and not inside GCs. We measure GC structural parameters, finding that the LMXB formation likelihood is influenced independently by mass, metallicity, and GC structural parameters. In particular, the GC central density plays a major role in predicting which GCs host accreting binaries. Finally, our analysis shows that LMXBs in GCs are marginally brighter than those in the field, and in particular the only color-confirmed GC with LX > 1039 erg s–1 shows no variability, which may indicate a superposition of multiple LMXBs in these systems.The Astrophysical Journal 07/2011; 736(2):90. · 6.02 Impact Factor -
Article: Testing stellar population synthesis models with Sloan Digital Sky Survey colors of M31's globular clusters
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: Accurate stellar population synthesis models are vital in understanding the properties and formation histories of galaxies. In order to calibrate and test the reliability of these models, they are often compared with observations of star clusters. However, relatively little work has compared these models in the ugriz filters, despite the recent widespread use of this filter set. In this paper, we compare the integrated colors of globular clusters in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) with those predicted from commonly used simple stellar population (SSP) models. The colors are based on SDSS observations of M31's clusters and provide the largest population of star clusters with accurate photometry available from the survey. As such, it is a unique sample with which to compare SSP models with SDSS observations. From this work, we identify a significant offset between the SSP models and the clusters' g-r colors, with the models predicting colors which are too red by g-r\sim0.1. This finding is consistent with previous observations of luminous red galaxies in the SDSS, which show a similar discrepancy. The identification of this offset in globular clusters suggests that it is very unlikely to be due to a minority population of young stars. The recently updated SSP model of Maraston & Stromback better represents the observed g-r colors. This model is based on the empirical MILES stellar library, rather than theoretical libraries, suggesting an explanation for the g-r discrepancy.05/2011; -
Article: Probing the GC-LMXB connection in NGC 1399: a wide-field study with HST and Chandra
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We present a wide field study of the Globular Clusters/Low Mass X-ray Binary (LMXB) connection in the giant elliptical NGC1399. The large FOV of the ACS/WFC, combined with the HST and Chandra high resolution, allow us to constrain the LMXB formation scenarios in elliptical galaxies. We confirm that NGC1399 has the highest LMXB fraction in GCs of all nearby elliptical galaxies studied so far, even though the exact value depends on galactocentric distance due to the interplay of a differential GC vs galaxy light distribution and the GC color dependence. In fact LMXBs are preferentially hosted by bright, red GCs out to $>5 R_{eff}$ of the galaxy light. The finding that GC hosting LMXBs follow the radial distribution of their parent GC population, argues against the hypothesis that the external dynamical influence of the galaxy affects LMXB formation in GCs. On the other hand field LMXBs closely match the host galaxy light, thus indicating that they are originally formed in situ and not inside GCs. We measure GC structural parameters, finding that the LMXB formation likelihood is influenced independently by mass, metallicity and GCs structural parameters. In particular the GC central density plays a major role in predicting which GC host accreting binaries. Finally our analysis shows that LMXBs in GCs are marginally brighter than those in the field, and in particular the only color-confirmed GC with $L_X>10^{39}$ erg s$^{-1}$ shows no variability, which may indicate a superposition of multiple LMXBs in these systems.05/2011; -
Article: Gemini/GMOS Imaging of Globular Cluster Systems in Five Early-type Galaxies
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: This paper presents deep high quality photometry of globular cluster (GC) systems belonging to five early-type galaxies covering a range of mass and environment. Photometric data were obtained with the Gemini North and Gemini South telescopes in the filter passbands g', r', and i'. The combination of these filters with good seeing conditions allows an excellent separation between GC candidates and unresolved field objects. Bimodal GC colour distributions are found in all five galaxies. Most of the GC systems appear bimodal even in the (g' -r') vs (r' -i') plane. A population of resolved/marginally resolved GC and Ultra Compact Dwarf candidates was found in all the galaxies. A search for the so-called "blue tilt" in the colour-magnitude diagrams reveals that NGC 4649 clearly shows that phenomenon although no conclusive evidence was found for the other galaxies in the sample. This "blue tilt" translates into a mass-metallicity relation given by Z \propto M^0.28\pm0.03 . This dependence was found using a new empirical (g' -i') vs [Z/H] relation which relies on an homogeneous sample of GC colours and metallicities. This paper also explores the radial trends in both colour and surface density for the blue (metal-poor) and red (metal-rich) GC subpopulations. As usual, the red GCs show a steeper radial distribution than the blue ones. Evidence of galactocentric colour gradients is found in some of the GC systems, being more significant for the two S0 galaxies in the sample. Red GC subpopulations show similar colours and gradients to the galaxy halo stars in their inner region. A GC mean colour-galaxy luminosity relation, consistent with [Z/H] \propto L_B ^0.26\pm0.08, is present for the red GCs. An estimate of the total GC populations and specific frequency SN values is presented for NGC 3115, NGC 3379, NGC 3923 and NGC 4649.05/2011; -
Article: Fading of the X-ray flux from the black hole in the NGC 4472 globular cluster RZ 2109
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We present the results of new X-ray observations of XMMU 122939.7+075333, the black hole (BH) in the globular cluster RZ 2109 in the Virgo Cluster galaxy NGC 4472. A combination of non-detections and marginal detections in several recent Swift and Chandra observations show that the source has varied by at least a factor of 20 in the past 6 years, and that the variations seem not just to be "flickering." This variation could be explained with changes in the absorption column intrinsic to the source no larger than those which were previously seen near the peak of the 1989 outburst of the Galactic BH X-ray binary V404 Cyg. The large amplitude variations are also a natural expectation from a hierarchical triple system with Kozai cycles -- the mechanism recently proposed to produce BH-white dwarf (WD) binaries in globular clusters. On the other hand, variation by such a large factor on timescales of years, rather than centuries, is very difficult to reconcile with the scenario in which the X-ray emission from XMMU 122939.7+075333 is due to fallback of material from a tidally destroyed or detonated WD. Comment: 5 pages, no figures, accepted to MNRAS Letters09/2010; -
Article: A new globular cluster black hole in NGC 4472
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We discuss CXOU~1229410+075744, a new black hole candidate in a globular cluster in the elliptical galaxy NGC~4472. By comparing two Chandra observations of the galaxy, we find a source that varies by at least a factor of 4, and has a peak luminosity of at least $2\times10^{39}$ ergs/sec. As such, the source varies by significantly more than the Eddington luminosity for a single neutron star, and is a strong candidate for being a globular cluster black hole. The source's X-ray spectrum also evolves in a manner consistent with what would be expected from a single accreting stellar mass black hole. We consider the properties of the host cluster of this source and the six other strong black hole X-ray binary candidates, and find that there is suggestive evidence that black hole X-ray binary formation is favored in bright and metal rich clusters, just as is the case for bright X-ray sources in general. Comment: 6 pages, one 2-panel figure, 2 tables; accepted to MNRAS08/2010; -
Article: A Variable Black Hole X-Ray Source in a NGC 1399 Globular Cluster
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We have discovered an accreting black hole (BH) in a spectroscopically confirmed globular cluster (GC) in NGC 1399 through monitoring of its X-ray activity. The source, with a peak luminosity of L_x=2x10^39 ergs/s, reveals an order of magnitude change in the count rate within ~10 ks in a Chandra observation. The BH resides in a metal-rich [Fe/H]~0.2 globular cluster. After RZ2109 in NGC 4472 this is only the second black-hole X-ray source in a GC confirmed via rapid X-ray variability. Unlike RZ2109, the X-ray spectrum of this BH source did not change during the period of rapid variability. In addition to the short-term variability the source also exhibits long-term variability. After being bright for at least a decade since 1993 within a span of 2 years it became progressively fainter, and eventually undetectable, or marginally detectable, in deep Chandra and XMM observations. The source also became harder as it faded. The characteristics of the long term variability in itself provide sufficient evidence to identify the source as a BH. The long term decline in the luminosity of this object was likely not recognized in previous studies because the rapid variability within the bright epoch suppressed the average luminosity in that integration. The hardening of the spectrum accompanying the fading would also make this black hole source indistinguishable from an accreting neutron star in some epochs. Therefore some low mass X-ray binaries identified as NS accretors in snapshot studies of nearby galaxies may also be BHs. Thus the discovery of the second confirmed BH in an extragalactic GC through rapid variability at the very least suggests that accreting BHs in GCs are not exceedingly rare occurences. Comment: 8 pages, 2 figs. Accepted for publication in ApJ07/2010; -
Article: A systematic study of low mass X-ray binaries in the M31 globular cluster system
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We investigate low mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs) in the M31 globular cluster (GC) system using data from the 2XMMi catalogue. These X-ray data are based on all publicly available XMM-Newton observations of the galaxy. This new survey provides the most complete and homogeneous X-ray survey of M31's GCs to date, covering >80% of the confirmed old clusters in the galaxy. We associate 41 X-ray sources with confirmed old clusters in the M31 cluster catalogue of Peacock et al. (2010). Comparing these data with previous surveys of M31, it is found that three of these clusters are newly identified, including a bright transient source in the cluster B128. Four additional clusters, that are not detected in these 2XMMi data, have previously been associated with X-ray sources from Chandra or ROSAT observations. Including these clusters, we identify 45 clusters in M31 which are associated with X-ray emission. By considering the latest optical GC catalogues, we identify that three of the previously proposed X-ray clusters are likely to be background galaxies and two have stellar profiles. We consider the properties of LMXB-hosting clusters and confirm significant trends between the presence of an LMXB and the metallicity, luminosity and stellar collision rate of a cluster. We consider the relationship between the luminosity and stellar collision rate of a cluster and note that LMXB hosting clusters have higher than average stellar collision rates for their mass. Our findings strongly suggest that the stellar collision rate is the dominant parameter related to the presence of LMXBs. This is consistent with the formation of LMXBs in GCs through dynamical interactions. Comment: Accepted for publication in MNRAS: 14 pages, 9 figures, 4 tables06/2010; -
Article: The M31 globular cluster system: ugriz and K-band photometry and structural parameters
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We present an updated catalogue of M31 globular clusters (GCs) based on images from the Wide Field CAMera (WFCAM) on the UK Infrared Telescope and from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS). Our catalogue includes new, self-consistent ugriz and K-band photometry of these clusters. We discuss the difficulty of obtaining accurate photometry of clusters projected against M31 due to small scale background structure in the galaxy. We consider the effect of this on the accuracy of our photometry and provide realistic photometric error estimates. We investigate possible contamination in the current M31 GC catalogues using the excellent spatial resolution of these WFCAM images combined with the SDSS multicolour photometry. We identify a large population of clusters with very blue colours. Most of these have recently been proposed by other work as young clusters. We distinguish between these, and old clusters, in the final classifications. Our final catalogue includes 416 old clusters, 156 young clusters and 373 candidate clusters. We also investigate the structure of M31's old GCs using previously published King model fits to these WFCAM images. We demonstrate that the structure and colours of M31's old GC system are similar to those of the Milky Way. One GC (B383) is found to be significantly brighter in previous observations than observed here. We investigate all of the previous photometry of this GC and suggest that this variability appears to be genuine and short lived. We propose that the large increase in its luminosity my have been due to a classical nova in the GC at the time of the previous observations in 1989. Comment: Accepted for publication in MNRAS: 17 pages, 11 figures and 3 tables. Table 1 is available in full from http://www.astro.soton.ac.uk/~m.b.peacock/m31gc.html10/2009; -
Article: Shrinking the Braneworld: Black Hole in a Globular Cluster
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: Large extra dimensions have been proposed as a possible solution to the hierarchy problem in physics. One of the suggested models, the RS2 braneworld model, makes a prediction that black holes evaporate by Hawking radiation on a short timescale that depends on the black hole mass and on the asymptotic radius of curvature of the extra dimensions. Thus the size of the extra dimensions can be constrained by astrophysical observations. Here we point out that the black hole, recently discovered in a globular cluster in galaxy NGC 4472, places the strongest constraint on the maximum size of the extra dimensions, L < 0.003 mm. This black hole has the virtues of old age and relatively small mass. The derived upper limit is within an order of magnitude of the absolute limit afforded by astrophysical observations of black holes.06/2009; -
Article: The Globular Cluster System in the Inner Region of M87
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We have identified 1057 globular cluster candidates in a WFPC2 image of the inner region of M87. The globular cluster luminosity function (GCLF) can be well fitted by a Gaussian profile with a mean value of m0V=23.67±0.07 mag and σ=1.39±0.06 mag. The GCLF in five radial bins is found to be statistically the same at all points, showing no clear evidence of dynamical destruction processes based on the luminosity function (LF). Similarly, there is no obvious trend between the half-light radius of the clusters and the galactocentric distance. The core radius of the globular cluster density distribution is Rc=56'', considerably larger than the core of the stellar component (Rc=68). The mean color of the cluster candidates is V-I=1.09 mag, which corresponds to an average metallicity of Fe/H=-0.74 dex. The color distribution is bimodal everywhere, with a blue peak at V-I=0.95 mag and a red peak at V-I=1.20 mag. The red population is only 0.1 mag bluer than the underlying galaxy, indicating that these clusters formed late in the metal-enrichment history of the galaxy and were possibly created in a burst of star/cluster formation 3-6 Gyr after the blue population. We also find that both the red and the blue cluster distributions have a more elliptical shape (Hubble type E3.5) than the nearly spherical galaxy. The average half-light radius of the clusters is ≈2.5 pc, which is comparable to the 3 pc average effective radius of the Milky Way clusters, although the red clusters are ≈20% smaller than the blue ones.The Astrophysical Journal 01/2009; 513(2):733. · 6.02 Impact Factor -
Article: The Ages of Globular Clusters in NGC 4365 Revisited with Deep HST Observations
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We present new Hubble Space Telescope (HST) NIC3, near-infrared H-band photometry of globular clusters (GCs) around NGC 4365 and NGC 1399 in combination with archival HST WFPC2 and ACS optical data. We find that NGC 4365 has a number of globular clusters with bluer optical colors than expected for their red optical-to-near-infrared colors and an old age. The only known way to explain these colors is with a significant population of intermediate-age (2-8 Gyr) clusters in this elliptical galaxy. On the other hand, our result for NGC 1399 is in agreement with previous spectroscopic work that suggests that its clusters have a large metallicity spread and are nearly all old. In the literature, there are various results from spectroscopic studies of modest samples of NGC 4365 globular clusters. The spectroscopic data allow for either the presence or absence of a significant population of intermediate-age clusters, given the index uncertainties indicated by comparing objects in common between these studies and the few spectroscopic candidates with optical-to-near-IR colors indicative of intermediate ages. Our new near-IR data of the NGC 4365 GC system with a much higher signal-to-noise ratio agree well with earlier published photometry, and both give strong evidence of a significant intermediate-age component. The agreement between the photometric and spectroscopic results for NGC 1399 and other systems lends further confidence to this conclusion and to the effectiveness of the near-IR technique.The Astrophysical Journal 12/2008; 634(1):L41. · 6.02 Impact Factor -
Article: [O III] λ5007 Emission from the Black Hole X-Ray Binary in an NGC 4472 Globular Cluster
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We present the discovery of [O III] λ5007 emission associated with the black hole X-ray binary recently identified in a globular cluster in the Virgo elliptical galaxy NGC 4472. This object is the first confirmed black hole X-ray binary in a globular cluster. The identification of [O III] λ5007 emission from the black hole hosting globular cluster is based on two independent fiber spectra obtained at the VLT with FLAMES, which cover a wavelength range of 5000-5800 Å at a spectral resolution of about 6000. In each of these spectra we find an emission line at 5031.2 Å with an uncertainty of several tenths of an angstrom. These are consistent with [O III] λ5007 emission at the 1475 ± 7 km s-1 radial velocity of the globular cluster previously determined from an analysis of its absorption lines. This agreement within the small uncertainties argues strongly in favor of the interpretation of the line as [O III] λ5007 emission from the black hole hosting globular cluster. We also find that the emission line most likely has a velocity width of several hundred km s-1. Such a velocity width rules out a planetary nebula explanation for the [O III] λ5007 emission and implicates the black hole as the source of the power driving the nebular emission.The Astrophysical Journal 12/2008; 669(2):L69. · 6.02 Impact Factor -
Article: Ultraviolet Hubble Space Telescope Observations of the Jet in M87
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We present new ultraviolet photometry of the jet in M87 obtained from Hubble Space Telescope (HST) WFPC2 imaging. We combine these ultraviolet data with previously published photometry for the knots of the jet in radio, optical, and X-ray and fit three theoretical synchrotron models to the full data set. The synchrotron models consistently overpredict the flux in the ultraviolet when fitted over the entire data set. We show that if the fit is restricted to the radio through ultraviolet data, the synchrotron models can provide a good match to the data. The break frequencies of these fits are much lower than previous estimates. The implied synchrotron lifetimes for the bulk of the emitting population are longer than in earlier work but still much shorter than the estimated kinematic lifetimes of the knots. The observed X-ray flux cannot be successfully explained by the simple synchrotron models that fit the ultraviolet and optical fluxes. We discuss the possible implications of these results for the physical properties of the M87 jet. We also observe increased flux for the HST-1 knot that is consistent with previous results for flaring. This observation fills in a significant gap in the time coverage early in the history of the flare and therefore sets constraints on the initial brightening of the flare.The Astrophysical Journal 12/2008; 624(2):656. · 6.02 Impact Factor -
Article: Luminosity Function of Faint Globular Clusters in M87
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We present the luminosity function to very faint magnitudes for the globular clusters in M87, based on a 30 orbit Hubble Space Telescope (HST) WFPC2 imaging program. The very deep images and corresponding improved false source rejection allow us to probe the mass function further beyond the turnover than has been done before. We compare our luminosity function to those that have been observed in the past, and confirm the similarity of the turnover luminosity between M87 and the Milky Way. We also find with high statistical significance that the M87 luminosity function is broader than that of the Milky Way. We discuss how determining the mass function of the cluster system to low masses can constrain theoretical models of the dynamical evolution of globular cluster systems. Our mass function is consistent with the dependence of mass loss on the initial cluster mass given by classical evaporation, and somewhat inconsistent with newer proposals that have a shallower mass dependence. In addition, the rate of mass loss is consistent with standard evaporation models, and not with the much higher rates proposed by some recent studies of very young cluster systems. We also find that the mass-size relation has very little slope, indicating that there is almost no increase in the size of a cluster with increasing mass.The Astrophysical Journal 12/2008; 650(2):885. · 6.02 Impact Factor -
Article: Wide Field CAMera survey of M31 globular clusters: low‐mass X‐ray binaries
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We investigate the relationship between low-mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs) and globular clusters (GCs) using United Kingdom Infrared Telescope (UKIRT) observations of M31 and existing Chandra, XMM–Newton and ROSAT catalogues. By fitting King models to these data, we have estimated the structural parameters and stellar collision rates of 239 of its GCs. We show a highly significant trend between the presence of a LMXB and the stellar collision rate of a cluster. The stellar collision rate is found to be a stronger predictor of which clusters will host LMXBs than the host cluster mass. We argue that our results show that the stellar collision rate of the clusters is the fundamental parameter related to the production LMXBs. This is consistent with the formation of LMXBs through dynamical interactions with little direct dependence on the neutron star retention fraction or cluster mass.Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society Letters 12/2008; 392(1):L55 - L59. -
Article: Color Bimodality in M87 Globular Clusters
[show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We present an analysis of a 50 orbit HST ACS observation of the M87 globular cluster system. We use the extraordinary depth of this dataset to test whether the colors and magnitudes show evidence for a mass-metallicity relation in globular cluster populations. We find only a weak or absent relation between the colors and magnitudes of the metal poor subpopulation of globular clusters. The weakness or absence of a color-magnitude relation is established over a wide range in luminosity from $M_V=-11$ to $M_V=-6$, encompassing most of the M87 globular clusters. The constancy of the colors of the metal-poor subpopulation seen in our 50 orbit observation is in contrast to suggestions from single orbit ACS data that the metal-poor globular clusters in M87 and several other galaxies show a "blue tilt." The formal best fit for the mass-metallicity relation for the metal-poor subpopulation in our much deeper data is $Z\propto M^{0.08\pm0.05}$. Our analysis of these data also shows a possible small "red tilt" in the metal-rich globular cluster subpopulation. While either of these small tilts may be real, they may also illustrate the limit to which mass-metallicity relations can be determined, even in such extraordinarily deep data. We specifically test for a wide range of systematic effects and find that while small tilts cannot be confirmed or rejected, the data place a strong upper limit to any tilt of $|0.20|\pm0.05$. This upper limit is much smaller than some earlier claims from single orbit data, and strongly limits self-enrichment within globular clusters. This mass-metallicity relation for globular clusters is also shallower than the relation for galaxies, suggesting that the formation mechanisms for these two types of objects are different.11/2008;
Top co-authors
Top Journals
Institutions
-
2004–2011
-
Michigan State University
- Department of Physics and Astronomy
East Lansing, MI, USA
-
-
2007–2009
-
Yale University
- Department of Astronomy
New Haven, CT, USA -
University of Southampton
- Physics and Astronomy
Southampton, ENG, United Kingdom
-
-
2005
-
State of Michigan
Lansing, MI, USA
-
-
1991
-
Johns Hopkins University
Baltimore, MD, USA
-
-
1970
-
Yale-New Haven Hospital
New Haven, CT, USA
-
