Mott transition and suppression of orbital fluctuations in orthorhombic 3d1 perovskites.
ABSTRACT Using t(2g) Wannier functions, a low-energy Hamiltonian is derived for orthorhombic 3d(1) transition-metal oxides. Electronic correlations are treated with a new implementation of dynamical mean-field theory for noncubic systems. Good agreement with photoemission data is obtained. The interplay of correlation effects and cation covalency (GdFeO3-type distortions) is found to suppress orbital fluctuations in LaTiO3 and even more in YTiO3, and to favor the transition to the insulating state.
- [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: In the Mott-Hubbard insulators YTiO3 and SmTiO3 we study optical excitations from the lower to the upper Hubbard band, d^1d^1 -> d^0d^2. The multi-peak structure observed in the optical conductivity reflects the multiplet structure of the upper Hubbard band in a multi-orbital system. Absorption bands at 2.55 and 4.15 eV in the ferromagnet YTiO3 correspond to final states with a triplet d^2 configuration, whereas a peak at 3.7 eV in the antiferromagnet SmTiO3 is attributed to a singlet d^2 final state. A strongly temperature-dependent peak at 1.95 eV in YTiO3 and 1.8 eV in SmTiO3 is interpreted in terms of a Hubbard exciton, i.e., a charge-neutral (quasi-)bound state of a hole in the lower Hubbard band and a double occupancy in the upper one. The binding to such a Hubbard exciton may arise both due to Coulomb attraction between nearest-neighbor sites and due to a lowering of the kinetic energy in a system with magnetic and/or orbital correlations. Furthermore, we observe anomalies of the spectral weight in the vicinity of the magnetic ordering transitions, both in YTiO3 and SmTiO3. In the G-type antiferromagnet SmTiO3, the sign of the change of the spectral weight at T_N depends on the polarization. This demonstrates that the temperature dependence of the spectral weight is not dominated by the spin-spin correlations, but rather reflects small changes of the orbital occupation.08/2006;
- [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: We introduce a novel computational approach for the investigation of complex correlated electron materials which makes it possible to evaluate interatomic forces and, thereby, determine atomic displacements and structural transformations induced by electronic correlations. It combines ab initio band structure and dynamical mean-field theory and is implemented with the linear-response formalism regarding atomic displacements. We apply this new technique to explore structural transitions of prototypical correlated systems such as elemental hydrogen, SrVO3, and KCuF3.Physical Review Letters 04/2014; 112(14):146401. · 7.73 Impact Factor
- [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: Materials with strong electronic Coulomb correlations play an increasing role in modern materials applications. “Thermochromic” systems, which exhibit thermally induced changes in their optical response, provide a particularly interesting case. The optical switching associated with the metal–insulator transition of vanadium dioxide (VO2), for example, has been proposed for use in numerous applications, ranging from anti-laser shields to “intelligent” windows, which selectively filter radiative heat in hot weather conditions. Are present-day electronic structure techniques able to describe, or – eventually even predict – such a kind of behavior? How far are we from materials design using correlated oxides? These are the central questions we try to address in this article. We review recent attempts of calculating optical properties of correlated materials within dynamical mean field theory, and summarize results for VO2 obtained within a novel scheme aiming at particularly simple and efficient calculations of optical transition matrix elements within localized basis sets. Finally, by optimizing the geometry of “intelligent windows,” we argue that this kind of technique can, in principle, be used to provide guidance for experiments, thus giving a rather optimistic answer to the above questions.physica status solidi (b) 09/2009; 246(9). · 1.49 Impact Factor
arXiv:cond-mat/0309102v3 [cond-mat.str-el] 19 Jan 2004
Mott transition and suppression of orbital fluctuations in orthorhombic 3d1perovskites
E. Pavarini,1S. Biermann,2A. Poteryaev,3A. I. Lichtenstein,3A. Georges,2and O.K. Andersen4
1INFM and Dipartimento di Fisica “A. Volta”, Universit` a di Pavia, Via Bassi 6, I-27100 Pavia, Italy
2Centre de Physique Th´ eorique, Ecole Polytechnique, 91128 Palaiseau Cedex, France
3NSRIM, University of Nijmegen, NL-6525 ED Nijmegen, The Netherlands
4Max-Planck-Institut f¨ ur Festk¨ orperforschung, Heisenbergstrasse 1, D-70569 Stuttgart, Germany
Using t2g Wannier-functions, a low-energy Hamiltonian is derived for orthorhombic 3d1transition-
metal oxides. Electronic correlations are treated with a new implementation of dynamical mean-field
theory for non-cubic systems. Good agreement with photoemission data is obtained. The interplay
of correlation effects and cation covalency (GdFeO3-type distortions) is found to suppress orbital
fluctuations in LaTiO3, and even more in YTiO3, and to favor the transition to the insulating state.
PACS numbers: 71.27.+a, 71.30.+h, 71.15.Ap
Transition-metal perovskites have attracted much in-
terest because of their unusual electronic and magnetic
properties arising from narrow 3d bands and strong
Coulomb correlations . The 3d1perovskites are partic-
ularly interesting, since seemingly similar materials have
very different electronic properties: SrVO3 and CaVO3
are correlated metals with mass-enhancements of respec-
tively 2.7 and 3.6  while LaTiO3and YTiO3are Mott
insulators with gaps of respectively 0.2 and 1eV .
In the Mott-Hubbard picture the metal-insulator tran-
sition occurs when the ratio of the on-site Coulomb re-
pulsion and the one-electron bandwidth exceeds a criti-
cal value Uc/W,which increases with orbital degeneracy
[4, 5]. In the ABO3perovskites the transition-metal ions
(B) are on a nearly cubic (orthorhombic) lattice and
at the centers of corner-sharing O6 octahedra. The 3d
band splits into pdπ-coupled t2gbands and pdσ-coupled
egbands, of which the former lie lower, have less O char-
acter, and couple less to the octahedra than the latter.
Simplest theories for the d1perovskites are therefore
based on a Hubbard model with 3 degenerate,
t2gbands per B-ion, and the variation of the electronic
properties along the series is ascribed to a progressive
reduction of W due to the increased bending of the pdπ
hopping paths (BOB bonds).
This may not be the full explanation of the Mott tran-
sition however, because a splitting of the t2glevels can
effectively lower the degeneracy. In the correlated metal,
the relevant energy scale is the reduced bandwith asso-
ciated with quasiparticle excitations. Close to the tran-
sition, this scale is of order ∼ ZW, with Z ∼ 1 − U/Uc,
and hence much smaller than the original bandwith W.
A level splitting by merely ZW is sufficient to lower
the effective degeneracy all the way from three-fold to a
non-degenerate single band. This makes the insulating
state more favorable by reducing Uc/W[5, 6]. Unlike in
eg-band perovskites, such as LaMnO3, where large (10%)
cooperative Jahn-Teller (JT) distortions of the octahedra
indicate that the orbitals are spatially ordered, in the t2g-
band perovskites the octahedra are almost perfect. The
t2gorbitals have therefore often been assumed to be de-
generate. If that is true, it is conceivable that quantum
fluctuations lead to an orbital liquid  rather than or-
bital ordering. An important experimental constraint on
the nature of the orbital physics is the observation of an
isotropic, small-gap spin-wave spectrum in both insula-
tors. This is remarkable because LaTiO3is a G-type
antiferromagnet with TN=140K, m=0.45µB, and a 3%
JT stretching along a , while YTiO3is a ferromagnet
with TC=30K, m0∼0.8µB, and a 3% stretching along y
on sites 1 and 3, and x on 2 and 4  (see Fig.1).
We shall find that the t2g degeneracy is lifted at the
classical level. This is not due to the small JT distortions
via OB pdπ-coupling, but to the GdFeO3-type distortion
which tilts the corner-sharing octahedra around the b-
axis (by 0,9,12, and 20◦) and rotates them around the
c-axis (by 0,7,9, and 13◦), as we progress from cubic
SrVO3via CaVO3and LaTiO3to YTiO3[9, 10, 11, 12].
This distortion is driven by the increasing oxygen-cation
(OA) pdσ-covalency, and it primarily pulls closer 4 of the
12 oxygens neighboring a given cation. Moreover, 2
to 4 of the 8 cations neighboring a given B ion are pulled
closer . The t2g orbitals couple to the OA distor-
tion via oxygen (BOAdpπ-pdσ), and they couple directly
(AB ddσ) to the AB distortion. As seen in Fig.1, the
orthorhombic GdFeO3-type distortion also leads to qua-
drupling of the cell. These findings are consistent with
conclusions drawn in the most recent model Hartree-Fock
study. The correct magnetic orders in LaTiO3 and
YTiO3were also obtained with the LDA+U method .
The predicted moment and orbital order in YTiO3were
confirmed by NMR  and neutron scattering , but
not in LaTiO3. These static mean-field methods are not
appropriate for the metallic systems, however.
In this letter, we shall (i) present a new implementa-
tion of a many-body method [19, 20], which allows for
a quantitative, material-specific description of both the
Mott transition and the orbital physics, and (ii) use it to
explain why some of the d1perovskites are metallic and
others are insulators, why the metals have different mass
enhancements and the insulators different gaps. Such
properties can be described by a low-energy, multi-band
the occupied t2g orbitals for LaTiO3 (top) and YTiO3
(bottom) according to the LDA+DMFT calculation.
oxygens are violet, the octahedra yellow and the cations
orange. In the global, cubic xyz-system directed ap-
translations are a=(1,−1,0)(1 + α),
and c=(0,0,2)(1 + γ), with α,β,γ small.
to 4 are: a/2, b/2, (a+c)/2, and (b+c)/2.
ab-plane is a mirror (z ↔ −z), and so is the Ti bc-plane
(x ↔ y) when combined with the translation (b-a)/2. See:
Pbnm primitive cell (right), subcell1 (left), and
b=(1,1,0)(1 + β),
The Ti sites 1
H = HLDA+1
im(?=m′)σ(Umm′ − Jmm′)nimσnim′σ, (1)
where nimσ = a+
tron with spin σ in a localized orbital m at site i.
This Hamiltonian depends on how the imσ-orbitals
are chosen.HLDAis the one-electron part given by
density-functional theory (LDA), which should provide
the proper material dependence. Recently it has become
feasible to solve (1) using the dynamical mean-field ap-
proximation (DMFT) and to obtain realistic physical
properties. In the original LDA+DMFT implemen-
tations it was assumed that the on-site block(s) of the
single-particle Green function is diagonal in the space of
the correlated orbitals, and these were taken as orthonor-
mal LMTOs approximated by truncated and renormal-
ized partial waves. Although these approximations are
good for cubic t2gsystems such as SrVO3, they dete-
riorate with the degree of distortion. Our new implemen-
tation of LDA+DMFT uses a set of localized Wannier
functions in order to construct a realistic Hamiltonian
(1), which is then solved by DMFT, including the non-
imσaimσ, and a+
imσcreates an elec-
E (eV)E (eV) E (eV)
0.5 0.5 0.5
-1 0 1
0 0 0
0.1 0.1 0.1
Nm,n(E) Nm,n(E) Nm,n(E)
FIG. 2: t2g LDA DOS matrix (states/eV/spin/band) in the
Wannier representation.On-site-1 elements: Nxz,xz (red)
Nyz,yz (green), and Nxy,xy (blue).
Nxz,xy (green), and Nxy,yz (blue). εF ≡ 0.
diagonal part of the on-site self-energy.
For an isolated set of bands, a set of Wannier functions
constitutes a complete, orthonormal set of orbitals with
one orbital per band. For the d1perovskites we take
the correlated orbitals to be three localized t2gWannier-
orbitals, and in HLDAwe neglect the degrees of free-
dom from all other bands. In order to be complete, such
a Wannier orbital must have a tail with e.g.Opπ and
Ad characters. Our Wannier orbitals are symmetrically
orthonormalized Nth-order muffin-tin orbitals (NMTOs)
, which have all partial waves other than Bxy, yz,
andzx downfolded. Such a t2g NMTO can have on-site
egcharacter, and that allows the orbital to orient itself
after the surroundings, although xy,yz, and zx refers to
the global cubic axes defined in Fig.1. Fourier transfor-
mation of the orthonormalized 12×12 NMTO Hamilto-
nian, HLDA(k), yields on-site blocks and hopping inte-
grals. For the on-site Coulomb interactions in Eq.(1),
we use the common assumption that, as in the isotropic
case, they can be expressed in terms of two parameters:
Umm=U, Umm′=U − 2J, and Jmm′(?=m)=J . From
Ref.24, J=0.68eV for the vanadates and 0.64eV for the
titanates. Since our Hamiltonian involves only correlated
orbitals, so that the number of correlated electrons is
fixed, the double-counting correction amounts to an ir-
relevant shift of the chemical potential. H is now solved
within DMFT, i.e.under the assumption that the com-
ponents of the self-energy between different sites can be
neglected. As a result, the self-energy can be obtained
from the solution of an effective local impurity model
which involves only 3 correlated orbitals.
to all previous studies, we take all components of the
self-energy matrix Σmm′ between different Wannier func-
tions on a given B-site into account . From this 3×3
matrix, by use of the Pbnm symmetry (Fig.1), we con-
struct a 12×12 block-diagonal self-energy matrix. The
latter is then used together with HLDA(k) to obtain the
Green function at a given k-point. Fourier transforma-
tion over the entire Brillouin zone yields the local Green
function associated with a primitive cell and its 3×3 on-
site block is used in the DMFT self-consistency condition
in the usual manner. The 3-orbital impurity problem
is solved by a numerically exact quantum Monte Carlo
scheme. To access temperatures down to 770K, we
use up to 100 slices in imaginary time. 106QMC sweeps
and 15-20 DMFT iterations suffice to reach convergence.
Finally, the spectral function is obtained using the max-
imum entropy method .
We now present the LDA results for the four per-
ovskites. Fig. 2 displays the on-site DOS matrix Nmm′(ε)
in the representation of the xy,yz, and zx Wannier func-
tions.SrVO3 is cubic and its t2g band with a width
W=2.8 eV consists of 3 non-interacting subbands, each of
which is nearly 2D and gives rise to a nearly logarithmic
DOS peak. In CaVO3, W is reduced to 2.4eV because
the Wannier orbitals are misaligned by the GdFeO3-type
distortion and because some of their O2p character is
stolen by the increased OA covalency, which drives this
distortion. The energy of the xy Wannier orbital (the
center of gravity of Nxy,xy) is 80meV lower than that of
the degenerate xz and yz orbitals, and small off-diagonal
DOS elements appear. Going from the vanadates to
the titanates, the effects of OA and (Ad)(Bt2g) cova-
lency increase dramatically, because now A and B are
1st rather than 3rd-nearest neighbors in the periodic ta-
ble. As consequences, the increased misalignment and
loss of oxygen character reduces the bandwidths to 2.1
and 2.0eV in LaTiO3and YTiO3, and weak hybridiza-
tion with the Ad bands deforms the t2gband.A pseudo-
gap which starts out as a splitting of the van Hove peak
in CaVO3, deepens and moves to lower occupancy as
we progress to LaTiO3 and YTiO3. The deep pseudo-
gap in YTiO3is mainly caused by the hybridization with
the Yxy orbital. The xy,yz,andzx Wannier orbitals are
now strongly mixed and diagonalization of the on-site
blocks of HLDAyields three singly-degenerate levels with
the middle (highest) being 140 (200) meV above the
lowest in LaTiO3, and 200 (330) meV in YTiO3. This
splitting is not only an order of magnitude smaller than
the t2g bandwidth, but also smaller than the subband-
widths, in particular for LaTiO3. As a consequence, the
eigenfunction for the lowest level is occupied by merely
0.45electron in LaTiO3and 0.50 in YTiO3, while the re-
maining 0.55 (0.50)electron occupies the two other eigen-
functions. The eigenfunction on site 1 with the lowest en-
ergy is 0.604|xy? + 0.353|xz? + 0.714|yz? in LaTiO3and
0.619|xy?−0.073|xz?+0.782|yz?in YTiO3. The splittings
are large compared with the spin-orbit splitting (20meV)
and kT, and they are not caused by the JT distortions, as
we have verified by turning them off in the calculations.
Next, we turn to the LDA+DMFT results. Calcula-
-4-4-4666 -3 -3-3 -2 -2 -2-1 -1-1000111222333444555666
-4-4 -4 -3 -3-3-2-2 -2 -1-1 -1000111222333444555
0.8 0.8 0.8
DOS states/ev/spin/band DOS states/ev/spin/bandDOS states/ev/spin/band
J=0.64 eVJ=0.64 eV
FIG. 3: DMFT spectral function at T = 770K (thick line)
and LDA DOS (thin line). µ ≡ 0.
tions were performed for several values of U between 3
and 6eV. We found that the critical ratio Uc/W decreases
when going along the series: SrVO3, CaVO3, LaTiO3,
and YTiO3. This is consistent with the increasing split-
ting of the t2glevels and indicates that the Mott transi-
tion in the d1series is driven as much by the decrease
of effective degeneracy as by the reduction of bandwidth.
The main features of the photoemission spectra for all
four materials, as well as the correct values of the Mott-
Hubbard gap for the insulators , are reproduced by
taking U constant ∼5eV. This is satisfying, because U
is expected to be similar for vanadates and titanates,
although slightly smaller for the latter .
we show the DMFT spectral functions together with the
LDA total DOS. For cubic SrVO3we reproduce the re-
sults of previous calculations [21, 28]: the lower Hubbard
band (LHB) is around −1.8eV and the upper Hubbard
band (UHB) around 3eV. Going to CaVO3, the quasi-
particle peak looses weight to the LHB, which remains at
−1.8eV, while the UHB moves down to 2.5eV. These re-
sults are in good agreement with photoemission data
and show that SrVO3and CaVO3are rather similar, with
the latter slightly more correlated. Similar conclusions
were drawn in Ref.21. From the linear regime of the
self-energy at small Matsubara frequencies we estimate
the quasi-particle weight to be Z=0.45 for SrVO3 and
0.29 for CaVO3. For a k-independent self-energy, as as-
sumed in DMFT, this yields m∗/m = 1/Z = 2.2 for
SrVO3and 3.5 for CaVO3, in reasonable agreement with
the optical-conductivity values 2.7 and 3.6.
For LaTiO3 and YTiO3 the LHB is around −1.5eV,
in accord with photoemission.
ilar bandwidths, the gaps are very different, 0.3 and
1eV, and this also agrees with experiments.
is consistent with our findings that the t2g-level split-
tings are smaller and (U − 2J)c/W is larger in LaTiO3
than in YTiO3, where the orbital degeneracy is effec-
Despite very sim-
numbers reveals that for the titanates one orbital per site
is nearly full, in contrast to LDA. It contains 0.88electron
in LaTiO3and 0.96 in YTiO3. The orbital polarization
increases around the metal-insulator transition and be-
comes complete thereafter. Thus, for the vanadates, each
orbital is approximately 1/3 occupied for all U in the
range 0to 6eV. The nearly complete orbital polarization
found by LDA+DMFT for the two insulators indicates
that correlation effects in the paramagnetic Mott insu-
lating state considerably decrease orbital fluctuations,
and makes it unlikely that YTiO3is a realization of an
orbital liquid. In LaTiO3 some orbital fluctuations
are still active, although quite weak. The occupied or-
bital in LDA+DMFT is 0.586|xy?+0.275|xz?+0.762|yz?
for LaTiO3 and 0.622|xy? − 0.029|xz? + 0.782|yz? for
YTiO3. Hence, it is nearly identical with the ones we
obtained from the LDA as having the lowest energy.
For YTiO3 our orbital is similar to the one obtained
in Ref. and for LaTiO3 it is similar to the one ob-
tained in Refs.[9, 15].Our accurate Wannier func-
tions show why these orbitals (Fig.1, left) have the
lowest energy: The positive (blue) lobes have bonding
nearest cations –those along – and the negative (red)
lobes have bonding xy character on the next-nearest
cations –those along [1-11]– whose oxygen surrounding
is favorable for this type of bond, i.e.where (Op)(Yxy)
pdσ-hybridization is strong. The former type of AB co-
valency dominates in LaTiO3, while the latter dominates
in YTiO3, where the shortest YO bond is merely 10%
longer than the TiO bond. The difference seen (Fig.1,
right side) between the orbital orders in the two com-
pounds is therefore quantitative rather than qualitative;
it merely reflects the extent to which the orbital has
the bc-plane as mirror. The two different JT distortions
of the oxygen square is a reaction to, rather than the
cause of the difference in the orbital orders. This differ-
ence is reflected in the hopping integrals between nearest
neighbors: tx=ty=99 (38) meV and tz=105 (48) meV
for LaTiO3(YTiO3). These hoppings are fairly isotropic
and twice larger in LaTiO3 than in YTiO3. Moreover,
the hoppings to the two excited orbitals are stronger in
YTiO3 than in LaTiO3. All of this is consistent with
LaTiO3being G-type anti- and YTiO3ferromagnetic at
low temperature, and it warrants detailed future calcu-
lations of the spin-wave spectra.
In conclusion, we have extended the LDA+DMFT ap-
proach to the non-cubic case using ab-initio downfolding
in order to obtain a low-energy Wannier Hamiltonian.
Applying this method to the Mott transition in 3d1per-
ovskites, we have explained the photoemission spectra
and the values of the Mott gap without adjustable pa-
rameters, except a single value of U. The Mott transition
is driven by correlation effects and GdFeO3-type distor-
tion through reduction, not only of bandwidth, but also
Diagonalization of the matrix of occupation
111− 1 = (|xy? + |xz? + |yz?)/√3 character on the
of effective orbital degeneracy. Correlation effects and
cation covalency suppress orbital fluctuations in the high-
temperature paramagnetic insulating phase of LaTiO3
We thank J.Nuss, G.Khaliullin, E.Koch, J.Merino,
M.Rozenberg,A.Bringer,M.Imada for useful discussions
and the KITP Santa Barbara for hospitality and sup-
port (NSF Grant PHY99-07949). Calculations were per-
formed at MPI-FKF Stuttgart and IDRIS Orsay (project
No.021393). S.B. acknowledges support from the CNRS
and the EU (Contract No.HPMF-CT-2000-00658).
 M. Imada, A. Fujimori, and Y. Tokura, Rev. Mod. Phys.
70, 1039 (1998).
 H. Makino et al., Phys. Rev. B 58, 4384 (1998).
 Y. Okimoto, et al., Phys. Rev. B 51, 9581 (1995).
 M.J. Rozenberg, Phys. Rev. B 55, R4855 (1997).
 E. Koch, O.Gunnarsson, R.M. Martin, Phys. Rev. B 60,
15714 (1999); S. Florens et al., ibid. 66, 205102 (2002).
 N. Manini, G.E. Santoro, A. Dal Corso, and E. Tosatti,
Phys. Rev. B 66, 115107 (2002).
 B.Keimer et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 3946 (2000);
C.Ulrich et al., Phys.Rev.Lett.89,167202(2002).
 M. Cwik et al., cond-mat/0302087.
 M. Eitel et al., J. Less-Common Met. 116, 95 (1986).
 M.J. Rey et al., J. Solid State Chem. 86, 101 (1990).
 M.H. Jung, and H. Nakotte, unpublished.
 By 0, 10, 13, and 21% of the average OA distance.
 By 0, 3, 4, and 10% of the average AB distance.
 M.Mochizuki,andM.Imada, Phys.Rev.Lett.91, 167203
(2003); T. Mizokawa, D.I. Khomskii, and G.A. Sawatzky,
Phys. Rev. B 60, 7309 (1999).
 I. Solovyev, N. Hamada, and K. Terakura, Phys. Rev B
53, 7158 (1996); H. Sawada, and K. Terakura, ibid. 58,
 M.Itho et al. J.Phys.Soc.Jap. 68, 2783 (1999).
 J. Akimitsu et al. J. Phys. Soc. Japan 70, 3475 (2001).
 A. Georges, G. Kotliar, W. Kraut, M.J. Rozenberg, Rev.
Mod. Phys. 68, 13 (1996).
 V.Anisimov et al. J J.Phys:Cond.Matt.9,7359(1997);
A.I.Lichtenstein and M. I. Katsnelson, Phys.Rev.B 57,
 I.A. Nekrasov et al., cond-mat/0211508.
 O.K. Andersen and T. Saha-Dasgupta, Phys. Rev B 62,
16219 (2000); Bull. Mater. Sci. 26, 19 (2003).
 R.FresardandG.Kotliar, Phys.Rev.B56,12909 (1997).
 T.Mizokawa andA.Fujimori,Phys.Rev.B54,5368(1996).
 Σmm′(?=m)(ω) ?= 0 in non-cubic systems, also in the eigen-
representation of the density matrix. In Fig.2, a large
Nmm′(?=m)points to a large Σmm′(?=m).
 J.E. Hirsch and R.M.Fye,Phys.Rev.Lett.56,2521(1986).
 J.E. Gubernatis, M. Jarrell, R. N. Silver and D. S. Sivia,
Phys. Rev. B 44, 6011 (1991).
 A.Liebsch, Phys.Rev.Lett.90,096401(2003).
 K. Maiti et al., Europhys. Lett. 55, 246 (2001); A.
Sekiyama et al., cond-mat/0206471.
 A. Fujimori et al, Phys. Rev. B 46, 9841 (1992); K.
Morikawa et al., ibid. 54, 8446 (1996).