Host ecology determines the relative fitness of virus genotypes in mixed-genotype nucleopolyhedrosis infections

Centre for Ecology and Hydrology, CEH Oxford, Oxford, UK.
Journal of Evolutionary Biology (Impact Factor: 3.23). 10/2004; 17(5):1018-25. DOI: 10.1111/j.1420-9101.2004.00750.x
Source: PubMed


Mixed-genotype infections are common in many natural host-parasite interactions. Classical kin-selection models predict that single-genotype infections can exploit host resources prudently to maximize fitness, but that selection favours rapid exploitation when co-infecting genotypes share limited host resources. However, theory has outpaced evidence: we require empirical studies of pathogen genotypes that naturally co-infect hosts. Do genotypes actually compete within hosts? Can host ecology affect the outcome of co-infection? We posed both questions by comparing traits of infections in which two baculovirus genotypes were fed to hosts alongside inocula of the same or a different genotype. The host, Panolis flammea, is a herbivore of Pinus sylvestris and Pi. contorta. The pathogen, PfNPV (a nucleopolyhedrovirus), occurs naturally as mixtures of genotypes that differ, when isolated, in pathogenicity, speed of kill and yield. Single-genotype infection traits failed to predict the 'winning' genotypes in co-infections. Co-infections infected and caused lethal disease in more hosts, and produced high yields, relative to single-genotype infections. The need to share with nonkin did not cause fitness costs to either genotype. In fact, in hosts feeding on Pi. sylvestris, one genotype gained increased yields in mixed-genotype infections. These results are discussed in relation to theory surrounding adaptive responses to competition with nonkin for limited resources.

Download full-text


Available from: Rosemary S Hails,
    • "When a plant has become infected, there are several limitations in measuring and generalizing the costs (expressed as reduced growth, reproduction and/or life span) of infection for the host. Firstly, the outcome of any given host genotype– pathogen genotype interaction can be influenced by abiotic conditions such as temperature and nutrient status (Laine 2007; Wolinska & King 2009) as well as simultaneously occurring microbes (Hodgson et al. 2004; Laine 2011). Secondly , any association between pathogen damage and reduction in host performance can be masked if infection alters host development (Shykoff & Kaltz 1998; Pan & Clay 2003; Korves & Bergelson 2004), or if the resistance reaction itself, successful or not, changes resource allocation to growth and development via plant hormones that are also entangled in disease resistance (Navarro et al. 2008; Alcazar et al. 2011; Robert-Seilaniantz, Grant & Jones 2011; Denanc e et al. 2013b; Vos, Pieterse & van Wees 2013). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: 1.Plants have evolved different strategies to resist pathogens but little is known about how effective, stable and costly these mechanisms are in perennial plants across multiple growing seasons.2.We conducted a laboratory experiment to assess resistance variation in Plantago lanceolata against the powdery mildew causing fungus Podosphaera plantaginis, and to measure possible trade-offs between the different resistance strategies. To test stability and costs of resistance we established common garden populations of plants possessing three different resistance strategies: qualitative resistance that is the ability to block pathogen infection, quantitative resistance that is the ability to mitigate pathogen development, and susceptibility. We measured their performance with and without disease for three years.3.There were no trade-offs between qualitative and quantitative resistance and the components of quantitative resistance were positively correlated.4.Throughout the three year common garden study, pathogen loads were significantly affected by host resistance in the study populations. Qualitative resistance efficiently blocked infections but contrary to laboratory obtained results; quantitative resistance did not hinder epidemic growth.5.We detected costs in plant performance for qualitative and quantitative resistance compared to susceptible plants in absence of the pathogen. The costs of infection varied according to resistance strategy, pathogen load and plant age.6.Synthesis. In perennial plants the costs and benefits of resistance need to be evaluated over multiple years as they may change with plant age. Our results give new insights into how polymorphism in resistance can be maintained through costs of resistance in plant performance and through shifts in resource allocation between vegetative growth and reproduction under infection.This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
    Journal of Ecology 03/2015; 103(2). DOI:10.1111/1365-2745.12373 · 5.52 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Some coevolutionary models predict a modulation of virulence and reciprocal adaptive dynamics that may result in a more stable relationship (Dawkins and Krebs, 1979; Ebert, 1998; Ebert and Herre, 1996), under some conditions, such as a highly host-specific parasite (Kirchner and Roy, 2002). Generalist parasites are less likely to evolve reduced virulence because they confront multiple hosts, and the different hosts confront multiple pathogens (Thomas et al., 2003; Vojvodic et al., 2012; Hodgson et al., 2004). These conditions lead to parasite–parasite competition, increasing both parasites' virulence and host-resistance mechanisms. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Ant social parasites evolve adaptive relationships with their hosts. Theoretically, coevolution predicts strong selection to maximize fitness of the parasite that minimizes costs to its host, which potentially leads to the evolution of benign interactions. We studied the demographic and behavioral traits of the ant social parasite Megalomyrmex symmetochus (Solenopsidini), an agro-predator that feeds on larvae and fungal garden products of their host, Sericomyrmex amabilis (Attini). Based on demographic data from 15 parasitized colonies, the proportion of parasitic workers to those of the host is 1:2. Moreover, defensive prophylactic behaviors observed during infections with Metarhizium brunneum, a generalist entomopathogen, and Escovopsis, a specialized fungal garden parasite, showed that S. amabilis works extensively to remove and control fungal infections, in contrast to M. symmetochus. M. symmetochus, however, performed intraspecific allogrooming during infections with Escovopsis and M. brunneum, suggesting that they may recognize fungal pathogens and indirectly limit dispersion of spores. Our results indicate that M. symmetochus did not have a strong role in maintaining a hygienic nest.
    Insectes Sociaux 02/2014; 61(x):xxx-xxx. DOI:10.1007/s00040-013-0331-5 · 1.02 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "SfCOL-A OBs were 4.4-fold more potent than SfCOL-wt OBs, indicating that the presence of other genotypes diminished the pathogenicity of the population, as observed in an isolate of SeMNPV [14]. Interactions between genotypes within baculovirus populations can have positive [12,19,39], negative [14] or neutral [40] influence on transmissibility, specifically affecting factors that influence the ability of the pathogen to infect, replicate and transmit to a new host. In contrast, all individual genotypes in the SfNIC population had lower pathogenicity than the wild-type isolate; indeed, interactions between SfNIC variants increased the transmissibility of wild-type population [7,12,19]. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: A Colombian field isolate (SfCOL-wt) of Spodoptera frugiperda multiple nucleopolyhedrovirus (SfMNPV) is a mixture of different genotypes. To evaluate the insecticidal properties of the different genotypic variants, 83 plaque purified virus were characterized. Ten distinct genotypes were identified (named A through J). SfCOL-A was the most prevalent (71±2%; mean ± SE) showing a PstI restriction profile indistinguishable to that of SfCOL-wt. The remaining nine genotypes presented genomic deletions of 3.8 - 21.8 Kb located mainly between nucleotides 11,436 and 33,883 in the reference genome SfMNPV-B, affecting the region between open reading frames (ORFs) sf20 and sf33. The insecticidal activity of each genotype from SfCOL-wt and several mixtures of genotypes was compared to that of SfCOL-wt. The potency of SfCOL-A occlusion bodies (OBs) was 4.4-fold higher than SfCOL-wt OBs, whereas the speed of kill of SfCOL-A was similar to that of SfCOL-wt. Deletion genotype OBs were similarly or less potent than SfCOL-wt but six deletion genotypes were faster killing than SfCOL-wt. The potency of genotype mixtures co-occluded within OBs were consistently reduced in two-genotype mixtures involving equal proportions of SfCOL-A and one of three deletion genotypes (SfCOL-C, -D or -F). Speed of kill and OB production were improved only when the certain genotype mixtures were co-occluded, although OB production was higher in the SfCOL-wt isolate than in any of the component genotypes, or mixtures thereof. Deleted genotypes reduced OB potency but increased OB production of the SfCOL-wt population, which is structured to maximize the production of OBs in each infected host.
    PLoS ONE 10/2013; 8(10):e77271. DOI:10.1371/journal.pone.0077271 · 3.23 Impact Factor
Show more