‘The Effect of Work on Mental Health: Does Occupation Matter?’

Department of Economics and Business Administration, Free University of Amsterdam & Tinbergen Institute, The Netherlands.
Health Economics (Impact Factor: 2.23). 10/2004; 13(10):1045-62. DOI: 10.1002/hec.929
Source: PubMed


This paper considers the effect of work choices on mental health and looks at whether this differs across occupations. This requires a model that can deal with the endogeneity in the relationship between health, occupation and work choices. We specify such a model and estimate it on a unique UK panel survey. The survey, called the National Child development Survey (NCDS), follows a cohort since their birth in 1958 until age 42. The analyses show us that early childhood health and ability have long lasting consequences for the mental health at the later ages. Females have lower levels of mental health. Mental health deteriorates with age for males and females, but the rate of deterioration is substantially lower for females. We also find that the rate of depreciation is lower when individuals work. For females we find large effects of occupation, for males we do not find this. Employment status is important for males, but not for females. For both genders we find very large effects of the onset of a long-standing illness. The probability of experiencing such an event depends on employment status, occupation and life style variables.

Download full-text


Available from: Ana Llena-Nozal,
  • Source
    • "Furthermore, the impact of becoming disabled on psychological distress may be mediated by the loss of job and income and by an increase in expenses (Burchardt, 2003; Jenkins & Rigg, 2004). The loss of social roles, such as job loss, is well known to be associated with psychological distress (Dooley, Fielding, & Levi, 1996; Llena-Nozal et al., 2004; Wheaton, 1990) and material deprivation is a strong psychological burden (Stronks, van de Mheen, Looman, & Mackenbach, 1998). In addition, the threat that a disability poses to future prospects may have psychological repercussion too. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This paper investigates whether education buffers the impact of physical disability on psychological distress. It further investigates what makes education helpful, by examining whether cognitive ability and occupational class can explain the buffering effect of education. Two waves of the 1958 British National Child Development Study are used to test the hypothesis that the onset of a physical disability in early adulthood (age 23 to 33) has a smaller effect on psychological distress among higher educated people. In total 423 respondents (4.6%) experienced the onset of a physical disability between the ages of 23 and 33. We find that a higher educational level cushions the psychology impact of disability. Cognitive ability and occupational class protect against the effect of a disability too. The education buffer arises in part because individuals with a higher level of education have more cognitive abilities, but the better social position of those with higher levels of education appears to be of greater importance. Implications of these findings for the social gradient in health are discussed.
    Social Science & Medicine 07/2010; 71(2):288-97. DOI:10.1016/j.socscimed.2010.04.004 · 2.89 Impact Factor
  • Source

  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: It is well-known that the place where people live influences their mental health. However, not all inhabitants experience these contextual effects in a similar way. The present study aims to explore the gender differential effects of work and income related contextual features. Previous research showed that gender differences in mental health result from a differential vulnerability and exposure to stressors. In addition, the differential expression hypothesis states that the expression of distress is gendered: while women show more internalizing problems, such as depression, men are more prone to externalizing problems, such as problem drinking. Pooled data from the multi-staged stratified cluster samples of the Belgian Health and Interview Surveys 2001 and 2004 were connected with data derived from the Socio-Economic Survey from 2001. The population sample was restricted to respondents of 15 years or more, consisting of 10092 men and 11284 women, inhabiting 590 statistical sectors. Design and population weights were applied. Linear multilevel analyses in SPSS were used to examine the influence of contextual effects on the frequency and severity of complaints of depression (SCL-90-R) and alcohol dependence (CAGE). At the individual level, employment status, social support (MOS), education, age, composition and equivalent income of the household were taken into account; at the level of the municipality unemployment rates, mean area income, and population density were added and gender specific interactions were tested. Results show consistent effects of the unemployment rate of the municipality on the occurrence of depression and drinking problems, independent of their individual employment status. In general, socio-economic characteristics of the place of residence are associated with mental health outcomes. Furthermore, this relationship is gendered. Cross-level interactions indicate that the unemployment rate has a stronger impact on the mental health of women, confirming the differential exposure and vulnerability hypotheses. In addition, the expression of distress caused by higher unemployment rates is gendered.
Show more