SKY and genetic fingerprinting reveal a cross-contamination of the putative normal colon epithelial cell line NCOL-1.
ABSTRACT In vitro studies addressing the primary prevention of colon carcinoma are preferably conducted using normal colonic cells, because these cells are more likely to represent the potential target for prevention in vivo. Established cell lines of normal colonic origin are mostly lacking; however, this is probably due to the difficulties associated with establishment of such cell lines. Cross-contamination with malignant cells is a frequent event, and so any successfully established cell line of normal origin should be scrutinized prior to further investigation. We performed a cytogenetic (spectral karyotyping) and genetic fingerprint (Promega PowerPlex ES multiplex system and Applied Biosystems AmpFlSTR SGM Plus multiplex system) analysis of the putative normal colon epithelial cell line NCOL-1, derived from two different sources (NCOL-1a and 1b). We show that NCOL-1a and 1b are probably derived from the colon carcinoma cell line LoVo, with a matching probability of 99.9995, most probably through cross-contamination. Karyotypes of LoVo and NCOL-1a were identical; NCOL-1b displayed additional marker chromosomes. Our findings highlight the importance of molecular and cytogenetic characterization of established cell lines to avoid drawing misleading conclusions from the original findings.
- SourceAvailable from: Elizabeth R Lawlor[Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: Despite intensive treatment with chemotherapy, radiotherapy and surgery, over 70% of patients with metastatic Ewing's Sarcoma Family of Tumors (EFT) will die of their disease. We hypothesize that properly characterized laboratory models reflecting the drug resistance of clinical tumors will facilitate the application of new therapeutic agents to EFT. To determine resistance patterns, we studied newly established EFT cell lines derived from different points in therapy: two established at diagnosis (CHLA-9, CHLA-32), two after chemotherapy and progressive disease (CHLA-10, CHLA-25), and two at relapse after myeloablative therapy and autologous bone marrow transplantation (post-ABMT) (CHLA-258, COG-E-352). The new lines were compared to widely studied EFT lines TC-71, TC-32, SK-N-MC, and A-673. These lines were extensively characterized with regard to identity (short tandem repeat (STR) analysis), p53, p16/14 status, and EWS/ETS breakpoint and target gene expression profile. The DIMSCAN cytotoxicity assay was used to assess in vitro drug sensitivity to standard chemotherapy agents. No association was found between drug resistance and the expression of EWS/ETS regulated genes in the EFT cell lines. No consistent association was observed between drug sensitivity and p53 functionality or between drug sensitivity and p16/14 functionality across the cell lines. Exposure to chemotherapy prior to cell line initiation correlated with drug resistance of EFT cell lines in 5/8 tested agents at clinically achievable concentrations (CAC) or the lower tested concentration (LTC): (cyclophosphamide (as 4-HC) and doxorubicin at CAC, etoposide, irinotecan (as SN-38) and melphalan at LTC; P<0.1 for one agent, and P<0.05 for four agents. This panel of well-characterized drug-sensitive and drug-resistant cell lines will facilitate in vitro preclinical testing of new agents for EFT.PLoS ONE 12/2013; 8(12):e80060. · 3.53 Impact Factor
- Cancer Genetics and Cytogenetics 11/2005; 163(1):97-97. · 1.93 Impact Factor
- 01/1970: pages 255-275;