Variations in performance characteristics of commercial enzyme immunoassay kits for detection of antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies: what is the optimal cut off?

Department of Rheumatology, University of Schleswig-Holstein Campus Lübeck and Rheumaklinik Bad Bramstedt, Germany.
Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases (Impact Factor: 9.11). 01/2006; 64(12):1773-9. DOI: 10.1136/ard.2005.035279
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT Previous studies have shown considerable variation in diagnostic performance of enzyme linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs) for measuring antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies (ANCA) specific for proteinase 3 (PR3) and myeloperoxidase (MPO).
To analyse the performance characteristics of different commercially available direct ANCA ELISA kits.
ELISA kits for detecting PR3-ANCA and MPO-ANCA from 11 manufacturers were evaluated. Serum samples were taken from patients with Wegener's granulomatosis (15), microscopic polyangiitis (15), other vasculitides (10), and controls (40).
were compared with data obtained by indirect immunofluorescence (IFT). The diagnostic performance of the tests was analysed and compared by receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis.Results: Applying the manufacturers' cut off resulted in great variation in sensitivity of the commercial PR3-ANCA kits for diagnosing Wegener's granulomatosis (ranging from 13.3% to 66.7%), and of the MPO-ANCA kits for diagnosing microscopic polyangiitis (ranging from 26.7% to 66.7%). Specificities were relatively constant (from 96.0% to 100%). IFT was superior to all ELISAs (C-ANCA for Wegener's granulomatosis: sensitivity 73.3%, specificity 98%; P-ANCA for microscopic polyangiitis: sensitivity 86.7%, specificity 98%). The sensitivities of PR3-ANCA and MPO-ANCA ELISA kits were increased by lowering the cut off values. This reduced specificity but increased overall diagnostic performance.
The low sensitivity of some commercial kits reflects the high cut off levels recommended rather than methodological problems with the assays. Comparative analyses using sera from well characterised patients may help identify optimum cut off levels of commercial ANCA ELISA tests, resulting in better comparability of results among assays from different manufacturers.

  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic (ANCA) directed against proteinase 3 (PR3-ANCA) are a serological hallmark of small vessel vasculitis, particularly granulomatous with polyangiitis (GPA). To increase their sensitivity, some ELISA employ the human native PR3 combined with a recombinant protein. Their specificity in daily practice is still to be defined. Our objective was to compare the performance for GPA diagnosis of three PR3-ANCA assays in daily practice. Seventy-eight consecutive patients' sera with suggestive IIF. All sera were tested with a routine Enzyme Linked Immuno Assay (ELISA) employing a mixture of human native and human recombinant (hn+hr) PR3 (EUROIMMUN(TM)) compared to two assays using immobilized purified human PR3 (QUANTA Lite(TM) ELISA and QUANTA Flash(TM) Chimiluminescent assay (CIA), INOVA Diagnostics). Clinical data including BVAS score were collected retrospectively. Nineteen out of the 78 patients had GPA. The hn+hr PR3 ELISA had a good sensitivity (100%) but a lower specificity for the diagnosis of GPA (61.0%) than the assays using the sole native protein (hn ELISA: 81.4%, hn CIA: 69.5%). False positive results mainly consisted of patients with inflammatory bowel disease, who had a specific PR3-ANCA positivity assembly when coupling the assays. The antibody titers by human native PR3 assays, but not hn+hr assay, positively correlated with BVAS score. These results highlight the need of a close collaboration between physicians and immunologists. Combining assays including last generation CIA employing human native antigens should improve the performance of GPA's diagnosis.
    Autoimmunity reviews 06/2013; · 6.37 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: We have evaluated a new-multiplex immunoassay (FIDIS Vasculitis) for simultaneous detection and quantification of anti-MPO, -PR3, and -glomerular basement membrane (GBM) antibodies in diagnosis and follow-up of ANCA-associated vasculitides (AAV) and Goodpasture's disease. ANCA were determined in sera of (a) 87 consecutive patients with biopsy-proven pauci-immune NCGN and 72 controls; (b) 9 patients with Goodpasture's disease; and (c) 60 WG patients and 60 controls, previously used in a multicenter comparison of direct and capture ELISA for PR3-ANCA. Finally, for prediction of relapses, PR3-ANCA was measured in samples preceding relapse in 23 PR3-AAV patients and in 23 matched PR3-AAV patients without relapse. The relative sensitivity of the FIDIS Vasculitis assay was 97.4% for MPO-ANCA and 92.3% for PR3-ANCA; specificity was 100% and 97.2%, respectively. Evaluation of the anti-GBM antibody detection revealed a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 99.6%. The sensitivity for WG of the PR3-ANCA detection (71.6%) approached the performance of capture ELISA (74%), although at the cost of specificity (96.7% versus 100%). For prediction of relapses a rise of 50% in ANCA level by FIDIS Vasculitis appeared optimal (ROC curve) for prediction of relapses. However, as compared to capture ELISA, both positive (63% versus 76%) and negative (68% versus 72%) predictive values were reduced. In conclusion, simultaneous detection of anti-MPO, -PR3, and -GBM antibodies in the multiplex FIDIS Vasculitis assay has excellent performance in terms of diagnosis of patients with AAV or Goodpasture's disease. However, detection of rises in PR3-ANCA for prediction of relapses gives less optimal results when compared to capture ELISA.
    Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 09/2007; 1109:454-63. · 4.38 Impact Factor
  • American Journal of Kidney Diseases 04/2011; 57(4):532-5. · 5.29 Impact Factor


Available from