Variation in orthopaedic surgeons' perceptions about the indications for rotator cuff surgery

Hospital for Special Surgery, New York, New York, United States
The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery (Impact Factor: 4.31). 10/2005; 87(9):1978-84. DOI: 10.2106/JBJS.D.02944
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT Epidemiologic studies have demonstrated substantial variations in per capita rates of many surgical procedures, including rotator cuff repair. The purpose of the current study was to characterize orthopaedic surgeons' attitudes concerning medical decision-making about rotator cuff surgery and to investigate the associations between these beliefs and reported surgical volumes.
A survey was mailed to randomly selected orthopaedic surgeons listed in the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons directory. Only individuals who had treated patients for a rotator cuff tear, or had referred patients for such treatment, within the previous year were asked to complete the two-page survey. The survey comprised fifteen questions regarding clinical opinion, including four regarding hypothetical cases. Clinical agreement was defined as >80% of the respondents answering similarly.
Of the 1100 surveys that were mailed, 539 were returned (a response rate of 49%). Of the 539 respondents, 316 (58.6%) had treated or referred patients with a rotator cuff tear in the previous year. There was a significant negative correlation between the surgeon's estimation of the failure rate of cuff repairs in the United States and that surgeon's procedure volume (r = -0.21, p = 0.0003), indicating that surgeons with a lower procedure volume are more pessimistic about the results of surgery than are those with a higher procedure volume. Arthroscopic, mini-open, and open cuff repairs were preferred by 14.5%, 46.2%, and 36.6% of the respondents, respectively. Surgeons who performed a higher volume of procedures were less likely to perform open surgery (p < 0.0001). There was clinical agreement regarding only four of the nine clinical questions and none of the four questions about the hypothetical vignettes.
We found significant variation in surgical decision-making and a lack of clinical agreement among orthopaedic surgeons about rotator cuff surgery. There was a positive correlation between the volume of procedures performed by the surgeon and the surgeon's perception of outcome, with surgeons who had a higher procedure volume being more enthusiastic about rotator cuff surgery than those who had a lower procedure volume.

Download full-text


Available from: Stephen Leonard Lyman, Apr 20, 2015
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: To determine if community equipoise exists concerning the effectiveness of bracing in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis. Bracing is the standard of care for adolescent idiopathic scoliosis despite the lack of strong reasearch evidence concerning its effectiveness. Thus, some researchers support the idea of a randomized trial, whereas others think that randomization in the face of a standard of care would be unethical. A random of Scoliosis Research Society and Pediatric Orthopaedic Society of North America members were asked to consider 12 clinical profiles and to give their opinion concerning the radiographic outcomes after observation and bracing. An expert panel was created from the respondents. They expressed a wide array of opinions concerning the percentage of patients within each scenario who would benefit from bracing. Agreement was noted concerning the risk due to bracing for post-menarchal patients only. : This study found a high degree of variability in opinion among clinicians concerning the effectiveness of bracing, suggesting that a randomized trial of bracing would be ethical.
    Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics 01/2007; 27(3):270-6. DOI:10.1097/01.bpb.0000248579.11864.47 · 1.43 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Introducción: Para identificar si existe o no discrepancia entre los médicos de equipo de fútbol en decisiones a pie de campo, se realiza una encuesta sobre casos clínicos comunes. Material y método: Durante la reunión anual de la Asociación Española de Médicos de Equipos de Fútbol se realizó una encuesta individual y anónima sobre 7 supuestos médicos de asistencia inmediata en el terreno de juego. Los casos hacían referencia a episodios reales que obligan a una toma de decisión rápida. Resultados: Los encuestados valoran reducir la luxación en vestuario con un máximo de 2 intentos y retirar al jugador. En cuanto al traumatismo torácico y el esguince del ligamento lateral externo del tobillo de grado II, la mayoría recomienda la retirada y no realizar infiltraciones. En una elongación de isquiotibiales, la mitad de los encuestados tendría en cuenta las sensaciones del jugador. En una contusión craneal con desorientación transitoria, la mayoría de médicos no retiraría al jugador. Ante una herida contusa en la cabeza, se prefieren las grapas a los puntos y realizar la sutura en el vestuario. En la parada cardiorrespiratoria, la mayoría de los médicos propone iniciar las maniobras de reanimación cardiopulmonar inmediatamente en el terreno de juego. Discusión: Los resultados obtenidos tienen diferente grado de disparidad, por lo que se anima a las distintas asociaciones médicas de nuestro ámbito a que elaboren protocolos y consensos acerca de las acciones que se deben tomar. Predominan, no obstante, las actitudes conservadoras y preservadoras de la salud del futbolista.
    Apunts Medicine de l'Esport 01/2006; 41(152). DOI:10.1016/S1886-6581(06)70026-3
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Purpose Cricket fast bowlers are prone to the development of Myofascial pain syndrome and in particular active myofascial trigger points in their rotator cuff muscles of the shoulder joint (Scott, et al. 2001). This is due to the severe stresses placed upon the muscles, bones and joints of the shoulder as a result of the high velocity throwing action (Bartlett, et al.1996). In muscles containing active myofascial trigger points a decrease in the stretch range of motion as well as the maximal contractile force is noted, these two factors may negatively affect the speed at which a fast bowler deliver the ball (Travell, Simons and Simons, 1999). Dry needling is viewed as the most effective means of deactivating myofascial trigger points leading to in increase in both the contractile force and range of motion of the affected muscle, which could increase the speed at which the bowler delivers the ball (Wilks, 2003). The aim of the study was to determine the immediate effect of dry needling active myofascial trigger points of the rotator cuff on bowling speed in action cricket fast bowlers. Method The study consisted of 40 participants (randomly split into two equal groups of 20) each with shoulder pain of a myofascial origin. Group A (intervention group) received the dry needling intervention in their most tender active myofascial trigger point. While participants in Group B (control group) received no treatment. Bowling speeds were measured both before and after the intervention, to determine its effect on bowling speed. IV Data was entered into MS Exel spreadsheet and imported into SPSS version 15 (SPSS Inc.,Chicago, Iiiinois, USA), which was used for data analysis. Paticipants were evaluated on bowling speed, Algometer readings and Numerical pain rating Scale (NRS) both pre and post intervention. Participants were also asked if they believed the intervention increased, decreased or had no effect on their bowling speeds. Two sample t-test was used to compare baseline values between the groups. A repeated measure ANOVA was used to compare the rate of change of each outcome over time in the two groups. Pearson’s correlation analysis (intra-group) was used to assess the strength and magnitude of correlations of the changes in the outcomes. The McNemar – Bowker test and Weighted Cohen’s kappa statistics were calculated to assess agreement between perceived and actual levels of change. Results A significant treatment effect was observed in the intervention group were an increase in bowling speed, algometer readings as well a decrease in Numerical pain rating scale(NRS) scores was observed. There was also a perceived increase in the speed the participants delivered the ball in the intervention group. No significant changes were observed in the control group. The findings of this study indicate that dry needling as a treatment modality would be beneficial to fast bowlers in not only increasing their speeds but also the pain experienced as a result of active myofascial trigger points. Dissertation submitted in partial compliance with the requirements for the Master’s Degree in Technology: Chiropractic at the Durban Institute of Technology, 2008.