Anatomical instruction and training for professionalism from the 19th to the 21st centuries

Section of the History of Medicine Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut 06520-8062, USA.
Clinical Anatomy (Impact Factor: 1.33). 07/2006; 19(5):403-14. DOI: 10.1002/ca.20290
Source: PubMed


For most of the 19th century, anatomists in the United States saw the affective, emotional aspects of human dissection as salient ingredients in professional formation. Professionalism (or "character") signified medical integrity and guaranteed correct professional conduct. As gross anatomy came under siege in the late-19th and early-20th centuries, crowded out of medical curricula by the new experimental sciences, medical educators rethought what it was that dissecting a human body stood to give medical students. As they embraced a new understanding of professionalism premised on an allegiance to science, anatomists celebrated the habits of mind and sensibility to scientific investigation that could be acquired at the dissecting table. One consequence was a deliberate distancing of gross anatomy from the "art of medicine," and with it a de facto suppression of attention to the affective components of human dissection. During this period in the opening decades of the 20th century, the norm of silence about the emotional dimensions of dissection was set in place. The confluence of various movements by the 1960s and 1970s both revived attention to the emotional experience of dissection and sparked a renewed discussion about the relationship between the affective components of learning anatomy and the professional formation of future healers. There is a need to balance the tension between the "affective" and "scientific" aspects of anatomy, and by extension the tension between the "art" and "science" of medical practice. One method is to use small-group "learning societies" as a means to cultivate and meld both dimensions of the professional ethic.

Download full-text


Available from: Lawrence Rizzolo, Apr 07, 2015
  • Source
    • "The " living anatomy " described in one noncadaver course addresses aspects of professionalism in very important ways that are also addressed elsewhere in the curriculum (McLachlan and Patten, 2006). Nonetheless, similar activities in the preclinical years at Yale do not appear to inspire the depth of self-reflection or artistic expression that students exhibit at the Service-of-Gratitude that concludes our course (Rizzolo, 2002; Warner and Rizzolo, 2006). On the Listserv, Rich Clough spoke passionately about his similar experience. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The central role that human dissection has long held in clinical education is being reevaluated in many institutions. Despite the impression that many institutions are abandoning dissection, very few have and most of those have reinstated dissection within a few years. What are the inherent qualities that lead institutions back to dissection? In our efforts to redesign a shortened dissection course, our consultations with a broad range of clinicians lead us to understand how the rhythms of clinical practice are modeled and developed in the small-group setting of the dissection laboratory. Following further consultation with colleagues who have experimented with different models of anatomy instruction, we discuss three themes in support of dissection. First, problem-solving in the dissection laboratory develops the habits-of-mind of clinical practice. Second, relating dissection to imaging modalities develops the spatial reasoning skills needed to understand computer simulations, interpret imaging data, and interact with surgeons, radiologists, and patients. Third, the human face of dissection fosters self-reflection and integration of the cognitive and affective skills required for medical practice. Through group process, the collaborative effort of dissection teams develops essential of attributes of clinical professionalism.
    The Anatomical Record Part B The New Anatomist 11/2006; 289(6):215-8. DOI:10.1002/ar.b.20117
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The authors present a Petri net approach to designing supervisory control logic (SCL) for integrated manufacturing systems and its application to design of the Laserlite Workstation Control System. Explicit representation of SCL is obtained by using Petri nets. Thus concurrency, choices, and precedence relations can be graphically visualized. Mathematical analysis can be conducted for both qualitative and quantitative properties of the control systems. Inconsistency errors and deadlock situations can be detected. The temporal properties can be derived by incorporating timing information into the net representation if needed. Based on the net representation of the system, control code in C or C++ can be systematically derived. Related control system components and their description using the Manufacturing Information Systems Toolkit for Building Integrated Control Systems are useful in specifying a practical implementation. New schemes can be exploited by modifying the net structure or changing the initial condition
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This article presents results from a longitudinal study following a cohort of medical students. Semistructured interviews are conducted every year, in which the students tell about their experiences learning medicine, their daily life, and their social activities in relation to university. The aim of the study is to analyze how medical students develop their professional competencies, values, and attitudes. This article focuses on the medical student's professional development in relation to the process of studying and learning anatomy. We analyze interviews conducted while the students are in their third and fifth semester. Anatomy plays a significant role in the medical student's educational process, on both a cognitive and emotional level. It seems that students in learning the subject matter adapt to fundamental values in the medical profession and are thus transformed into real medical students, sharing a unique experience. The implications for curricular development and professionalism are discussed, and this article argues that the issue of professionalism must be addressed in the educational process in the preclinical years and in relation to the basic sciences.
    Anatomical Sciences Education 07/2008; 1(4):154-8. DOI:10.1002/ase.31 · 2.98 Impact Factor
Show more