When fit is fundamental: performance evaluations and promotions of upper-level female and male managers.

Department of Psychology, Baruch College, City University of New York, New York, NY 10010-5585, USA.
Journal of Applied Psychology (Impact Factor: 4.31). 08/2006; 91(4):777-85. DOI: 10.1037/0021-9010.91.4.777
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT Using archival organizational data, the authors examined relationships of gender and type of position (i.e., line or staff) to performance evaluations of 448 upper-level managers, and relationships of performance evaluations to promotions during the subsequent 2 years. Consistent with the idea that there is a greater perceived lack of fit between stereotypical attributes of women and requirements of line jobs than staff jobs, women in line jobs received lower performance ratings than women in staff jobs or men in either line or staff jobs. Moreover, promoted women had received higher performance ratings than promoted men and performance ratings were more strongly related to promotions for women than men, suggesting that women were held to stricter standards for promotion.

  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Purpose – Voluntary employee turnover can be a challenge for all industries but high employee turnover has been a special concern in the hospitality industry, which is the context of this paper. The purpose of this paper is to incorporate a "trickle-down" perspective into the conventional research on turnover intention and satisfaction with supervision. The authors assess whether mid-level managers' satisfaction with senior managers' supervision is related positively to line employees' satisfaction with mid-level managers' supervision and, in turn, line employees' turnover intentions. Further, the authors examine whether the strength of this "trickle-down" effect is affected by the middle managers' gender. Design/methodology/approach – The authors tested our theoretical argument using a sample of 1,527 full-time employees in 267 different departments at 94 hotels in the USA and Canada. Hierarchical linear modeling was employed to analyze the data. Findings – The authors found a trickle-down effect of satisfaction with supervision, as predicted, and the effect was stronger for female than male middle managers. These findings open new avenues for addressing turnover issues for organizations and managers. Originality/value – This study extends the line of research on leadership and turnover in three ways. First, it shows how senior managers, who have no direct contact with line employees, can affect turnover intentions of line employees. Second, this research helps the authors know where to target efforts at intervention; by connecting middle managers' satisfaction with supervision with employees' turnover intentions, the authors know to target interventions to reduce turnover not just at line employees and supervisors but also at senior-level managers as well. Third, this study sheds light on the ongoing debate over "female advantage" in leadership (Eagly and Carli, 2003a, b; Vecchio, 2002, 2003) by examining not just how women are treated, but how their experience may reshape managerial dynamics. Introduction Voluntary employee turnover can be a challenge for all industries, but high employee turnover has been an especially serious concern in the hospitality industry (Lashley, 2001). It was estimated that the turnover rate in the hospitality industry is among the highest and can easily exceed 50 percent for entry-level employees (Hinkin and Tracey, 2000). The cost of turnover is considerable and the retention of competent
    Career Development International 01/2014; 19(7):836-856. DOI:10.1108/CDI-02-2014-0031
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Die direkte Führungskraft ist aufgrund ihres engen Kontaktes zu ihren MitarbeiterInnen besonders geeignet, diese gemäß ihrer Interessen und Fähigkeiten zu fordern und zu fördern. Dieser Artikel bietet einen zusammenfassenden Überblick über die Forschungsliteratur zur Bedeutung und Wirkungsweise von Führungsverhaltensweisen im Hinblick auf die berufliche Kompetenz- und Karriereentwicklung von MitarbeiterInnen. Die Verhaltensweisen gliedern sich in Förderungen im direkten Kontakt (Feedback, Vermittlung von Maßnahmen, Promotion, Vertrauen und Erwartungen, Zielvereinbarung, soziale Unterstützung, Vorbildverhalten) und Förderungen über die Gestaltung von kompetenz- und karriereförderlichen Arbeitsaufgaben und Arbeitsbedingungen (Delegation verantwortungsvoller Aufgaben, Einräumen von Handlungsspielräumen, Herstellen von Person-Job-Fit). Bei der Darstellung liegt ein besonderer Fokus auf geschlechterspezifischen Ergebnissen. Vor dem Hintergrund der bisherigen empirischen Erkenntnisse werden Empfehlungen für die Praxis und weitere Forschung abgeleitet. Abstract The direct manager which has close contact with his employees is suited to challenge and support them according to their interests and abilities. This paper provides a summary of the empirical literature about the meaning and mechanism of different leadership behaviors influencing employees’ competencies and career advancement. The leader’s behaviors are divided in two ways of support. The direct contact (feedback, training measures, promotion, trust and expectations, objectives’ management, social support, role model behavior) and support by providing competence and career enhancing tasks and job design (delegation of challenging tasks, job control, person-job-fit). Thereby a particular focus is placed upon gender-specific outcomes. Based on the actual research findings, additional recommendations for the career enhancement in practice and for future research are provided.
    Gruppendynamik und Organisationsberatung 03/2012; 43(1):91-112. DOI:10.1007/s11612-011-0174-3 · 0.05 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Purpose This paper seeks to examine the effect of shared leadership on the existing gap between male and female leadership influence in groups. Design/methodology/approach The leadership influence of 231 members from 28 committees was studied using a social networks methodology. Gender differences in committee members’ directive and supportive leadership influence were analyzed through two ANCOVA tests. Findings Results confirm significant differences between men and women’s leadership influence, as rated by their peers, using directive and supportive leader behaviors. Surprisingly, shared leadership has no significant effect on reducing this gender gap. Research limitations/implications Results cannot be extrapolated to all other types of groups, since the committees studied have very unique characteristics due to their low typical mutual interaction. Practical implications Organizations may need to consider complementary strategies in their group leadership design to prevent the emergence of strong gender gaps when leadership is shared. These strategies could involve training members to recognize gender inequalities in leadership status and assigning leadership roles formally to ensure more equal participation in leadership. Originality/value This paper examines the promise of gender equality in shared leadership and provides empirical data that shows that this promise is not being realized.
    Leadership & Organization Development Journal 03/2015; 36(1):17-34. DOI:10.1108/LODJ-11-2012-0147 · 0.63 Impact Factor


Available from