The dynamics of the health labour market

Health, Nutrition and Population, Human Development Network, The World Bank, Washington, DC 20433, USA.
International Journal of Health Planning and Management (Impact Factor: 0.97). 04/2006; 21(2):101-15. DOI: 10.1002/hpm.834
Source: PubMed


One of the most important components of health care systems is human resources for health (HRH)--the people that deliver the services. One key challenge facing policy makers is to ensure that health care systems have sufficient HRH capacity to deliver services that improve or maintain population health. In a predominantly public system, this involves policy makers assessing the health care needs of the population, deriving the HRH requirements to meet those needs, and putting policies in place that move the current HRH employment level, skill mix, geographic distribution and productivity towards the desired level. This last step relies on understanding the labour market dynamics of the health care sector, specifically the determinants of labour demand and labour supply. We argue that traditional HRH policy in developing countries has focussed on determining the HRH requirements to address population needs and has largely ignored the labour market dynamics aspect. This is one of the reasons that HRH policies often do not achieve their objectives. We argue for the need to incorporate more explicitly the behaviour of those who supply labour--doctors, nurses and other providers--those who demand labour, and how these actors respond to incentives when formulating health workforce policy.

Download full-text


Available from: Marko Vujicic,
  • Source
    • "It is widely accepted that a key constraint to achieving the MDGs is the absence of a properly trained and motivated workforce and improving the retention of health workers is critical for health system performance [1]. Increasing attention is being paid to understanding the labour market dynamic in health [2]. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Motivation and retention of health workers, particularly in rural areas, is a question of considerable interest to policy-makers internationally. Many countries, including Vietnam, are debating the right mix of interventions to motivate doctors in particular to work in remote areas. The objective of this study was to understand the dynamics of the health labour market in Vietnam, and what might encourage doctors to accept posts and remain in-post in rural areas. This study forms part of a labour market survey which was conducted in Vietnam in November 2009 to February 2010. The study had three stages. This article describes the findings of the first stage - the qualitative research and literature review, which fed into the design of a structured survey (second stage) and contingent valuation (third stage). For the qualitative research, three tools were used - key informant interviews at national and provincial level (6 respondents); in-depth interviews of doctors at district and commune levels (11 respondents); and focus group discussions with medical students (15 participants). The study reports on the perception of the problem by national level stakeholders; the motivation for joining the profession by doctors; their views on the different factors affecting their willingness to work in rural areas (including different income streams, working conditions, workload, equipment, support and supervision, relationships with colleagues, career development, training, and living conditions). It presents findings on their overall satisfaction, their ranking of different attributes, and willingness to accept different kinds of work. Finally, it discusses recent and possible policy interventions to address the distribution problem. Four typical 'directions of travel' are identified for Vietnamese doctors - from lower to higher levels of the system, from rural to urban areas, from preventive to curative health and from public to private practice. Substantial differences in income from formal and informal sources all reinforce these preferences. While non-financial attributes are also important for Vietnamese doctors, the scale of the difference of opportunities presents a considerable policy challenge. Significant salary increases for doctors in hard-to-staff areas are likely to have some impact. However, addressing the differentials is likely to require broader market reforms and regulatory measures.
    Human Resources for Health 08/2011; 9(1):20. DOI:10.1186/1478-4491-9-20 · 1.83 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Increases in health expenditure, and hospital expenditure in particular, have been shown historically to lead to an increase in the demand for health workers (Barer et al. 1984; dussault and vujicic 2008; vujicic and Zurn 2006; WHO 2006). The shift in health spending patterns since 1996 in Canada, therefore, provokes several interesting policy research questions: What happened, after 1996, to the labour force participation of individuals trained in nursing in Canada? "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This paper examines trends in the nursing labour market in Canada over a period of dramatic fluctuations in hospital expenditures. We add to previous analysis that covered the period 1991-1996 and use Census data from 2001 to examine the relationship between hospital expenditure and nurse labour force participation. We find that shifts in labour force participation over the period 1991-2001 had a significant impact on the nursing supply in Canada. Individuals who were trained in nursing but were working outside the profession in 1996 because of budgetary reductions and layoffs in hospitals had largely been reabsorbed back into nursing jobs by 2001. Our analysis provides further empirical evidence that the labour force participation among individuals trained in nursing is driven to a large extent by demand-side factors.
    Healthcare policy = Politiques de sante 05/2011; 6(4):62-71. DOI:10.12927/hcpol.2011.22397
  • Source
    • "The literature is scarce on details regarding the governmental decisionmaking process for the introduction or entry of one new or extended healthcare practitioner role into practice over another, supporting the argument that such HHR decisions are politicized (Hall 2005). In reality, provincial ministries involved in HHR planning serve as de facto gatekeepers for the process through their control over education spending in this realm (Vujicic and Zurn 2006). The inclusion of HHR planning policy directions within broader government policy initiatives further complicates this role and the process to address identified issues, rendering the approach to addressing HHR issues even more complicated (Rowand 2002). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The healthcare system continues to evolve, requiring innovation to promote patient-centred, fiscally responsible healthcare delivery. This evolution includes changes to the skills and competencies required of the health human resources (HHR), both regulated and unregulated, who are central supports to healthcare delivery. This has become a priority agenda item at the international, national, provincial, regional and local levels. This paper describes the system factors that drive the emergence of HHR skill and competency needs, and explores the roles of various institutions in the identification of and response to HHR needs. Educational institutions play an important role in responding to emerging HHR needs. Their actual response to HHR skill and competency needs will ultimately depend on the risk posed to the organizations of either addressing, or not addressing, these needs. These decisions are complex and are balanced against strategic, operational and educational risks, benefits and realities within each given educational institution. Educational institutions - through their linkages with the workplace, industry, professional organizations and government - have a unique view and understanding of many facets of the complexity of HHR planning. This paper proposes that educational institutions play a pivotal role as levers in a more coordinated response to emerging HHR needs and, as such, should be intimately involved in comprehensive HHR planning.
    HealthcarePapers 02/2009; 9(2):6-19. DOI:10.12927/hcpap.2009.20774
Show more