Arterial versus capillary blood gases: a meta-analysis.

Department of Anesthesia, McGill University Health Center, Montreal, Quebec, Canada. <>
Respiratory Physiology & Neurobiology (Impact Factor: 1.97). 03/2007; 155(3):268-79. DOI: 10.1016/j.resp.2006.07.002
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT A meta-analysis determined whether capillary blood gases accurately reflect arterial blood samples. A mixed effects model was used on 29 relevant studies obtained from a PubMed/Medline search. From 664 and 222 paired samples obtained from the earlobe and fingertip, respectively, earlobe compared to fingertip sampling shows that the standard deviation of the difference is about 2.5x less (or the precision is 2.5x better) in resembling arterial PO(2) over a wide range of arterial PO(2)'s (21-155 mm Hg ). The lower the arterial PO(2), the more accurate it is when predicting arterial PO(2) from any capillary sample (p<0.05). However, while earlobe sampling predicts arterial PO(2) (adjusted r(2)=0.88, mean bias=3.8 mm Hg compared to arterial), fingertip sampling does not (adjusted r(2)=0.48, mean bias=11.5 mm Hg compared to arterial). Earlobe sampling is slightly more accurate compared to fingertip sampling in resembling arterial PCO(2) (arterial versus earlobe, adjusted r(2)=0.94, mean bias=1.9 mm Hg ; arterial versus fingertip, adjusted r(2)=0.95, mean bias=2.2 mm Hg compared to arterial) but both sites can closely reflect arterial PCO(2) (880 total paired samples, range 10-114 mm Hg ). No real difference between sampling from the earlobe or fingertip were found for pH as both sites accurately reflect arterial pH over a wide range of pH (587 total paired samples, range 6.77-7.74, adjusted r(2)=0.90-0.94, mean bias=0.02). In conclusion, sampling blood from the fingertip or earlobe (preferably) accurately reflects arterial PCO(2) and pH over a wide range of values. Sampling blood, too, from earlobe (but never the fingertip) may be appropriate as a replacement for arterial PO(2), unless precision is required as the residual standard error is 6 mm Hg when predicting arterial PO(2) from an earlobe capillary sample.

  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Introduction. Since its first publication in the medical literature, an extremely large number of references have demonstrated that the tonometric measurement of tissue perfusion is a reliable indicator of the actual condition of critically ill patients. Later a new method was developed by the introduction of sublingual tonometry for the determination of tissue perfusion. In comparison with gastric tonometry, the new method was simpler and could even be used in awake patients. Unfortunately, at present, because of severe failures of manufacturing, the device is withdrawn from commerce. Materials and Methods. In this study, we present a new method using a newly developed tool for the PslCO2 measurement in sublingual tonometry as well as the data for its validation in vitro and in vivo and the results of 25 volunteers and 54 COPD patients belonging to different GOLD groups at their hospitalization due to the acute exacerbation of the disease but already in a stable condition at the time of the examination. Results and Conclusion. The results of the performed examinations showed that the method is suitable for monitoring the actual condition of the patients by mucosal perfusion tonometry in the sublingual region.
    Critical care research and practice 01/2014; 2014:534130.
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In patients with impaired inspiratory muscle function or altered respiratory system mechanics, an imbalance between load and capacity can arise. The ventilatory control system normally compensates for this by increasing drive to maintain adequate alveolar ventilation levels, thereby keeping arterial CO2 within its normal range. To reduce work of breathing, a pattern of reduced tidal volume and increased respiratory rate occurs. This pattern itself may eventually reduce effective ventilation by increasing dead space ventilation. However, the impact of sleep on breathing and its role in the development of diurnal respiratory failure is often overlooked in this process. Sleep not only reduces respiratory drive, but also diminishes chemoresponsiveness to hypoxia and hypercapnia creating an environment where significant alterations in oxygenation and CO2 can occur. Acute increases in CO2 load especially during rapid eye movement sleep can initiate the process of bicarbonate retention which further depresses ventilatory responsiveness to CO2. Treatment of hypoventilation needs to be directed toward factors underlying its development. Nocturnal noninvasive positive pressure therapy is the most widely used and reliable strategy currently available to manage hypoventilation syndromes. Although this may not consistently alter respiratory muscle strength or the mechanical properties of the respiratory system, it does appear to reset chemosensitivity by reducing bicarbonate, resulting in a more appropriate ventilatory response to CO2 during wakefulness. Not only is diurnal hypoventilation reduced with noninvasive ventilation, but quality of life, functional capacity and survival are also improved. However, close attention to how therapy is set up and used are key factors in achieving clinical benefits. © 2014 American Physiological Society. Compr Physiol 4: 1639-1676, 2014.
    Comprehensive Physiology. 10/2014; 4(4):1639-76.
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Transcutaneous capnography is a noninvasive method useful for analysis of the behavioral tendency of transcutaneous CO 2 pressure (PtcCO 2) in patients undergoing polysomnography, to evaluate respiratory sleep disorders. Objective: Determine normative PtcCO 2 values in normal patients undergoing polysomnography. Method: One hundred seventy-nine patients who underwent polysomnography with simultaneous PtcCO 2 measurement were assessed by means of a transcutaneous capnograph (TCM4 series from Radiomiter). Results: The group classified as normal (N=53) presented a apnea/hypopnea index (AHI) ,5 events/per hour of sleep and their age groups varied between 7 and 76 years of age. Conclusion: Global mean values of PtcCO 2 in the normal group had a Gaussian distribution that varied between 33.1 and 50.0 mmHg (SD 4,363). Such findings allowed the establishment of normative PtcCO 2 values for normal individuals. Keywords: polysomonography, transcutaneous capnography, CO 2 pressure. RESUMO A capnografia transcutânea é um método não invasivo útil para análise da tendência comportamental da pressão de CO 2 transcutânea (PtcCO 2) 1,2,3 em pacientes submetidos à polissonografia para análise de transtornos respiratórios do sono. Objetivo: Determinar valores normativos da PtcCO 2 em pacientes normais submetidos à polissonografia. Método: Foram analisados 179 pacientes submetidos à polissonografia com medida concomitante da PtcCO 2 através de um capnógrafo transcutâneo. Resultados: O grupo classificado como normal (N=53) apresentou índice de apnéia/hipopnéia (AIH) ,5 eventos/hora de sono e faixa etária variando de 7 a 76 anos. Conclusão: Os valores da média global da PtcCO 2 no grupo normal apresentaram distribuição gaussiana variando de 33,1 a 50,0 mmHg (DP 4.363). Tais achados permitiram a criação de valores normativos da PtcCO 2 para indivíduos normais. Palavras-chave: polissonografia, capnografia transcutânea, pressão de CO 2 .
    18th Annual Meeting of the APSS, Minneapolis; 05/2014


Available from
May 20, 2014