Dysplastic naevi with moderate to severe histological dysplasia: A risk factor for melanoma

Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts, United States
British Journal of Dermatology (Impact Factor: 4.28). 12/2006; 155(5):988-93. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2133.2006.07466.x
Source: PubMed


The risk of malignant melanoma associated with histologically dysplastic naevi (HDN) has not been defined. While clinically atypical naevi appear to confer an independent risk of melanoma, no study has evaluated the extent to which HDN are predictive of melanoma.
To estimate the risk of melanoma associated with HDN. Secondarily, the risk associated with number of naevi and large naevi is estimated.
We enrolled 80 patients with newly diagnosed melanoma along with 80 spousal controls. After obtaining information on melanoma risk factors and performing a complete cutaneous examination, the most clinically atypical naevus was biopsied in both cases and controls. Histological dysplasia was then assessed independently by 13 dermatopathologists (0, no dysplasia; 1, mild dysplasia; 2, moderate dysplasia; 3, severe dysplasia). The dermatopathologists were blinded as to whether the naevi were from melanoma subjects or controls. Multivariate analyses were performed to determine if there was an independent association between the degree of histological dysplasia in naevi and a personal history of melanoma.
In persons with naevi receiving an average score of > 1 (i.e. naevi considered to have greater than mild histological dysplasia), there was an increased risk of melanoma [odds ratio (OR) 2.60, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.99-6.86] which persisted after adjustment for confounders (OR 3.99, 95% CI 1.02-15.71). Very few dermatopathologists reliably graded naevi of subjects with melanoma as being more dysplastic than naevi of control subjects. Among the entire group, the interobserver reliability associated with grading histological dysplasia in naevi was poor (weighted kappa 0.28).
HDN do appear to confer an independent risk of melanoma. However, this result may add more to our biological understanding of melanoma risk than to clinical assessment of risk, because HDN assessed by a single pathologist generally cannot be used to assess risk of melanoma. Future studies should be directed at establishing reproducible, predictive criteria for grading naevi.

Download full-text


Available from: Michael S Rabkin,
  • Source
    • "Given the importance of melanocytic nevi, studies have been conducted to establish criteria for grading dysplasia, as occurs with cervical intraepithelial lesions or adenomas of the gut, for example. Shors et al.7 and Arumi-Uria et al.8 found a statistically significant relationship between the degree of dysplasia and the risk for melanoma, and this finding could prove the usefulness of grading these lesions. However, Shors et al. found low agreement among the 13 dermatopathologists that participated in the study. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Dysplastic nevi are among the most important cutaneous melanoma simulators. They are important risk markers for this neoplasia and can be its potential precursors. Some authors found a statistically significant relationship between the degree of dysplasia and the risk for developing melanoma. However, reproducibility of grading criteria ranged from poor to fair in the researched articles. To test the reproducibility of the grading criteria proposed by Sagebiel et al. regarding dysplastic nevi. Histological specimens of 75 dysplastic nevi were graded, independently and in a blinded fashion, according to preestablished criteria, by a panel of 10 pathologists with different levels of experience. Diagnostic agreement was calculated using weighted kappa and intraclass correlation coefficients. The average of weighted kappa values was 0.13 for all observers, 0.12 for dermatopathologists, 0.18 for general pathologists and 0.05 for residents. Intraclass correlation coefficient values were 0.2 for all observers, 0.18 for dermatopathologists, 0.33 for general pathologists and 0.15 for residents. Histopathological grading for dysplastic nevi was not reproducible in this Brazilian series, so the criteria used are not a helpful histopathological parameter for clinicopathological correlation.
    Anais brasileiros de dermatologia 02/2013; 88(1):23-31. DOI:10.1590/S0365-05962013000100002 · 0.72 Impact Factor

  • Heart, Lung and Circulation 12/2000; DOI:10.1046/j.1443-9506.2000.08102.x · 1.44 Impact Factor

  • New England Journal of Medicine 01/2004; 349(23):2233-40. DOI:10.1056/NEJMcp023017 · 55.87 Impact Factor
Show more