Supported Employment Outcomes of a Randomized Controlled Trial of ACT and Clubhouse Models

Department of Psychiatry, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, California, United States
Psychiatric Services (Impact Factor: 2.41). 11/2006; 57(10):1406-15. DOI: 10.1176/
Source: PubMed


In a randomized controlled trial, a vocationally integrated program of assertive community treatment (ACT) was compared with a certified clubhouse in the delivery of supported employment services.
Employment rates, total work hours, and earnings for 121 adults with serious mental illness interested in work were compared with published benchmark figures for exemplary supported employment programs. The two programs were then compared on service engagement, retention, and employment outcomes in regression analyses that controlled for background characteristics, program preference, and vocational service receipt.
Outcomes for 63 ACT and 58 clubhouse participants met or exceeded most published outcomes for specialized supported employment teams. Compared with the clubhouse program, the ACT program had significantly (p<.05) better service engagement (ACT, 98 percent; clubhouse, 74 percent) and retention (ACT, 79 percent; clubhouse, 58 percent) over 24 months, but there was no significant difference in employment rates (ACT, 64 percent; clubhouse, 47 percent). Compared with ACT participants, clubhouse participants worked significantly longer (median of 199 days versus 98 days) for more total hours (median of 494 hours versus 234 hours) and earned more (median of $3,456 versus $1,252 total earnings). Better work performance by clubhouse participants was partially attributable to higher pay.
Vocationally integrated ACT and certified clubhouses can achieve employment outcomes similar to those of exemplary supported employment teams. Certified clubhouses can effectively provide supported employment along with other rehabilitative services, and the ACT program can ensure continuous integration of supported employment with clinical care.

Download full-text


Available from: William A Hargreaves, Jun 20, 2014
  • Source
    • "Another kind of service, often called support groups, was oriented towards families and relatives (Citron et al. 1999; Cook et al. 1999; Kageyama and Oshima 2007; Wai-Tong et al. 2008). In addition to these organizations, which are often informal, several articles analyzed other types of non-profit service, such as clubhouses (Aquila et al. 1999; Macias et al. 2006; Norman 2006; Schonebaum et al. 2006), acute crisis interventions (Greenfield et al. 2008), online support (Perron 2002), support for homeless people (Taylor et al. 2007), and support in relation to education (Ratzlaff et al. 2006; Wassef et al. 1998). One focus is of course the service produced and delivered by the organization, but in some articles a great deal of space was assigned to more analytical issues, such as the life phases of the support groups (Mohr 2004), the consumer identity of NPOs and consumer staff (Felton 2005; Yuen and Fossey 2003), and how to provide self-help support in collaboration with the mental health system in rural communities (Bjorklund and Pippard 1999). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Non-profit organizations (NPO) for mental health are becoming significant actors. Here, their roles in welfare society as understood in research are identified and analyzed. Results from recent research publications on the mental health field are synthesized and categorized in order to find out their origin, theoretical orientation, and view on mental health NPO’s in relation to the public welfare systems. Relevant publications are primarily from the US, empirically oriented, and addressing surveys on both individual and organizational level. NPOs were most often seen as consensus-oriented service organizations, while very few (4%) were seen as conflict-oriented advocates (i.e., anti-professional). It is concluded that these NPOs are most often studied as complements or alternatives to existing public welfare services rather than on their own terms, and that research on the topic lacks more complex theoretical attempts.
    International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations 06/2012; 23(2). DOI:10.1007/s11266-011-9196-2 · 1.24 Impact Factor
  • Source
    Article: Evidence?
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The translational diffusion coefficient of Brownian particles in the ternary liquid mixture water-ethanol-chloroform near a plait point has been studied by the autocorrelation spectroscopy method. It is found that the effective viscosity etaeff exhibits a strong anomaly close to the plait point. This anomaly can be explained in terms of the existence of a "correlated layer" of liquid mixture of thickness equal to the correlation length xi on the surfaces of the Brownian particles.
    Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal 02/2004; 28(2):197-9. DOI:10.2975/28.2004.197.199 · 1.16 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This paper presents an overview of Assertive Community Treatment (ACT) as an evidence-based practice in mental health care. We then consider current evidence for FACT (ACT for forensic populations) and FICM (intensive case management for forensic populations) and the ways these models have been extended and adapted to serve mentally ill persons in a variety of criminal justice settings. The available evidence about the effectiveness of these models towards preventing recidivism among criminally-justice involved persons with mental illness is weak. We conclude with several suggestions for how the clinical model of FACT needs to be expanded to incorporate interventions aimed at reducing criminal behavior and recidivism.
    Community Mental Health Journal 11/2007; 43(5):527-44. DOI:10.1007/s10597-007-9092-9 · 1.03 Impact Factor
Show more