Survey of psychiatric treatment among psychiatric residents in Manhattan: evidence of stigma.

Columbia University Center for Psychoanalytic Training and Research, Columbia University Department of Residency Training, New York State Psychiatric Institute, New York, USA.
The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry (Impact Factor: 5.14). 11/2006; 67(10):1591-8. DOI: 10.4088/JCP.v67n1015
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT Psychiatric trainees seek personal psychiatric treatment for a variety of reasons including educational objectives, symptoms relief, or functional impairment. Data on the rate of psychiatric treatment among residents and the attitudes of residents toward personal treatment are limited. The purpose of this study was to determine the frequency and types of psychiatric treatment among residents and to assess residents' attitudes toward treatment.
A 51-item questionnaire was mailed to all postgraduate year (PGY)-2 through PGY-4 psychiatric residents training in Manhattan in the spring of 2002 (N = 288). Questionnaires were anonymous. Significance was tested using McNemar test of symmetry, dependent-groups t tests, or 2-way contingency table analysis where appropriate. The study was conducted from March 2002 through June 2002.
Forty-eight percent of residents returned the questionnaire. Among respondents, 57% were in individual psychiatric treatment, predominantly individual psychotherapy or psychoanalysis. The rate of medication treatment was 18%, corresponding to a 31% rate of medication use among those in psychotherapy. Residents felt that their training programs explicitly encouraged psychotherapeutic treatment but not medication treatment, and they were more likely to tell other residents and faculty about personal psychotherapy as compared with personal medication use. Residents felt that the use of medication carried "significant" stigma, while personal psychotherapy did not.
In this sample, residents believe there is "significant" stigma associated with the use of psychotropic medication, while psychotherapy is seen as a respected and valued educational and therapeutic experience. These findings deserve the attention of educators and emphasize the need for further research in this area.

  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The authors evaluated psychiatry resident participation in and description of personal psychotherapy, reasons for being in psychotherapy, and barriers to personal psychotherapy. All 14 program directors for programs accredited by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Delaware provided e-mail addresses for current categorical residents. The authors e-mailed a voluntary, anonymous, 10-min survey to residents through . The survey inquired about time spent in various aspects of training, value assigned to aspects of training, residents' involvement in their own psychotherapy, reasons for being in or not being in therapy, and overall resident wellness. Of the 328 residents e-mailed, 133 (40.5 %) replied to the survey, of which 34 (26.5 %) were in personal psychotherapy. Most residents described their psychotherapy as psychodynamic, once weekly, and located in a private practice not affiliated with the resident's academic center. Approximately half (49 %) were in treatment with a social worker (MSW, LCSW) or psychologist (PhD or PsyD). "Self-awareness and understanding" was the most commonly reported primary and contributing reason for being in psychotherapy. Close to half of the respondents (44.5 %) listed personal stress, substance dependence, mood, anxiety, or other psychiatric symptoms as the primary reason for seeking personal psychotherapy. The most common reasons for not entering psychotherapy were time and finances. Residents who were in personal psychotherapy valued personal psychotherapy as more important to training than residents who were not in personal psychotherapy. Half of all respondents reported that their program recommends psychotherapy. Far fewer residents responding to the survey reported being in psychotherapy than residents from some previous surveys. A continuing discussion of whether and how to accommodate personal psychotherapy in the training and education of psychiatry residents by psychiatry educators is warranted.
    Academic Psychiatry 11/2014; 39(1). DOI:10.1007/s40596-014-0219-3 · 0.81 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The personal health care issues of residents are important but have received minimal study. Available evidence suggests that residents experience difficulties obtaining care, partly related to both the demands of medical training and concerns about confidentiality and privacy. A self-report survey was distributed in 2000-2001 to advanced residents at the University of New Mexico Health Sciences Center. Questions related to personal health and health care attitudes, behaviors, preferences, and experiences, and vignettes related to personal illness and treatment. Here the authors report findings regarding preferences for obtaining health care "at" versus "outside" of one's training institution. Data from 141 residents are presented. A substantial minority of residents had obtained care outside of their institution in the preceding year. Residents expressed concerns about their medical privacy and confidentiality related to obtaining care within their own institution, including concerns about being seen by other residents or by past or future attendings. Women expressed more concern than did men on numerous issues, as did residents in primary care versus specialty training. Residents expressed a preference for care outside the training institution when taking into account confidentiality and prevention of embarrassment; care at their own institution was preferred when considering expense and scheduling. Outside care was more strongly preferred for more stigmatizing illnesses (e.g., mental health-related). Most residents felt poorly informed regarding their personal health care confidentiality rights and did not know whether their institution had confidentiality policies regarding residents who develop physical or mental health problems. Residents worry about confidentiality and privacy when deciding where to obtain personal medical care. Trainees' concerns are relevant to crafting policies on resident health care. Programs should strive to inform residents thoroughly about policies and rights pertaining to personal health care.
    Academic Psychiatry 02/2008; 32(1):20-30. DOI:10.1176/appi.ap.32.1.20 · 0.81 Impact Factor
  • Source
    Academic Psychiatry 01/2010; 34(1):75-8. DOI:10.1176/appi.ap.34.1.75 · 0.81 Impact Factor


Available from