Methods of defining best practice for population health approaches with obesity prevention as an example

Calgary Health Region, 1402 29th St NW, Calgary, Alberta T2N 2T9, Canada.
Proceedings of The Nutrition Society (Impact Factor: 5.27). 12/2006; 65(4):403-11. DOI: 10.1079/PNS2006520
Source: PubMed


Childhood obesity has reached a crisis stage and has become a population health issue. The few traditional systematic reviews that have been done to identify best practice provide little direction for action. The concept of evidence-based practice has been adopted in health care, and in medicine in particular, to determine best practice. Evidence-based medicine has its origins in the scientific method and for many researchers this concept means strict adherence to standards determining internal validity in order to justify a practice as evidence based. Practitioners addressing population health face challenges in identifying criteria for determining evidence, in part because of the nature of population health with its goal of shifting the health of whole populations. As well, the type of evidence provided by more traditional critical appraisal schema is limiting. Expanded approaches in finding and defining evidence have been proposed that use: expert panels; broad and inclusive search and selection strategies; appraisal criteria that incorporate context and generalizability. A recent synthesis of 147 programmes addressing childhood overweight and obesity provides a concrete example of using a broader approach to identify evidence for best practice (Flynn et al. 2006). Incorporating evaluation and population health frameworks as criterion components in addition to traditional methodological rigour criteria, this synthesis has identified programmes that provide contextual information that can be used to populate what Swinburn et al. (2005) have described as the 'promise table'. Using this approach a range in 'certainty of effectiveness' and a range in 'potential for population impact' are integrated to identify promising strategies. The exercise can provide direction for agencies and practitioners in taking action to address obesity.

15 Reads
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The increasing prevalence of obesity in children is an issue in many countries across the world. While undernutrition (in terms of deficient nutrient intake) continues to be a problem for many children, overnutrition (in terms of energy intake in excess of needs) is an increasing public health concern. Our genetic make−up has evolved to deal with an environment where food is scarce at times and plentiful at other times. In this type of environment the capacity for fat deposition means that we are more likely to survive through periods when food is scarce. Our bodies may also seek to minimise energy expenditure in order not to expend too much of our fat stores. Children today are faced with an environment where food is of a high quality and plentiful, and there are many opportunities to limit physical activity. Play is often focused on sedentary games and entertainment,such as watching television. Many children today are, therefore, dealing with an environment which promotes obesity.
    Gastrointestinal Nursing 07/2007; 5(6):14-19. DOI:10.12968/gasn.2007.5.6.24285
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: To explore the everyday consumption of meals and snacks from the child's perspective, among those with healthier v. less healthy dietary habits. The sample in this qualitative study comprised two groups of Danish schoolchildren aged 10 to 11 years, one with a healthier diet (n 9) and the other with a less healthy diet (n 8). Both groups were recruited from respondents to a dietary survey. Semi-structured interviews took their starting point in photographs of their meals and snacks taken by the children themselves. Both subgroups of children had a meal pattern with three main meals and two to four snacks. We found a connection between the nutritional quality of the diet and the social contexts of consumption, especially with regard to snacks. Among children with healthier eating habits, both snacks and meals tended to be shared social events and items of poor nutritional quality functioned as markers of a special social occasion. This was not the case among children with less healthy eating habits. All children described particular rules governing food consumption within their families. Although only some of them had participated in the development of these rules, and despite the fact that rules were different and were perceived as having been developed for different reasons, children from both subgroups tended to accept them. The results of the study suggest that dietary interventions designed to promote children's health should focus more on the different social contexts of consumption and more on the role of parents.
    Public Health Nutrition 09/2008; 12(6):739-47. DOI:10.1017/S1368980008003248 · 2.68 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Public health practitioners and policy-makers working to address the burden of chronic disease are increasingly seeking to use best practices given the need to make thoughtful program and policy choices with limited resources. While the evidence base in chronic disease prevention is growing through a number of different information sources, there is often a disconnect between the desire to use best practices and their implementation. This is related not only to individual and organizational barriers in terms of time and resources, but also to lack of agreement on what constitutes best practice and what sources of evidence are valid guides for practice. This is compounded by lack of user-friendly and streamlined access to credible best practice evidence and decision making/practice supports. In response to these needs, six years ago Canadian researchers, policy-makers and practitioners came together to begin working on creating a best practice system in Canada for health promotion and chronic disease prevention. This article presents an overview of the development of the Canadian Best Practices Portal and in particular how an evolution in thinking about best practice methodology and evidence will contribute to an enriched knowledge base for health promotion and chronic disease prevention policy, practice and research.
    Canadian journal of public health. Revue canadienne de santé publique 09/2008; 99(5):I1-8. · 1.02 Impact Factor
Show more


15 Reads