Comparison of Shape-Matching and Docking as Virtual Screening Tools

OpenEye Scientific Software, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87507, USA.
Journal of Medicinal Chemistry (Impact Factor: 5.45). 02/2007; 50(1):74-82. DOI: 10.1021/jm0603365
Source: PubMed


Ligand docking is a widely used approach in virtual screening. In recent years a large number of publications have appeared in which docking tools are compared and evaluated for their effectiveness in virtual screening against a wide variety of protein targets. These studies have shown that the effectiveness of docking in virtual screening is highly variable due to a large number of possible confounding factors. Another class of method that has shown promise in virtual screening is the shape-based, ligand-centric approach. Several direct comparisons of docking with the shape-based tool ROCS have been conducted using data sets from some of these recent docking publications. The results show that a shape-based, ligand-centric approach is more consistent than, and often superior to, the protein-centric approach taken by docking.

Download full-text


Available from: Paul C D Hawkins, Oct 01, 2015
64 Reads
  • Source
    • "The goal of ligand–protein docking is to predict the predominant binding mode(s) of a ligand with a protein of known three-dimensional structure. Virtual screening on the basis of molecular descriptors and physicochemical properties of active ligands has great usefulness in finding hits and leads through library enrichment for screening (28), a strategy that is also well-used for reducing and enriching the library of ligands for molecular docking; there are recent reports that ligand shape-matching does as well as, if not better than, docking (29). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The urgent need of neuraminidase inhibitors (NI) has provided an impetus for understanding the structure requisite at molecular level. Our search for selective inhibitors of neuraminidase has led to the identification of pharmacophoric requirements at various positions around acyl thiourea pharmacophore. The main objective of present study is to develop selective NI, with least toxicity and drug like ADMET properties. Electronic, Steric requirements were defined using kohnone nearest neighbour- molecular field analysis (kNN-MFA) model of 3D-QSAR studies. Results generated by QSAR studies showed that model has good internal as well as external predictivity. Such defined requirements were used to generate new chemical entities which exhibit higher promising predicted activities. To check selective binding of designed NCE's docking studies were carried out using the crystal structure of the neuraminidase enzyme having co-crystallized ligand Oseltamivir. Thus, molecular modelling provided a good platform to optimize the acyl thiourea pharmacophore for designing its derivatives having potent anti-viral activity.
    Iranian journal of pharmaceutical research (IJPR) 03/2014; 13(1):49-65. · 1.07 Impact Factor
    • "Other methods are based on the assumption that molecules with a similar shape behave similar. These shape-based methods compare the volume of molecules and have been applied successfully in virtual screening and clustering [16] [17]. Molecular scaffolds offer an alternative way to describe molecular structures in a way that is particularly close to how a chemist sees a molecule. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Multiple factors have to be optimized in the course of a drug discovery project. Traditionally this includes potency on a single target, eventually specificity as well as the pharmacokinetic, physicochemical and the safety profile. Recently an additional dimension has been added by realizing that the therapeutic outcome of a drug is often determined not only by its activity on a single target but by its activity profile across a variety of biological targets. To address the polypharmacology of drug candidates many compounds are tested on a set of targets or in phenotypic screens generating a tremendous amount of data. To extract useful information computational methods at the interface of proteomics and cheminformatics are indispensable. This review will focus on some recent developments in this field. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Computational Proteomics in the Post-Identification Era.
    Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 05/2013; 1844(1). DOI:10.1016/j.bbapap.2013.05.010 · 4.66 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Because ROCS uses atom-centered Gaussian functions to describe the molecular shape [19,20], it can perform a rapid shape superposition without a considerable loss of accuracy, compared to when the hard-sphere volumes is employed. In recent studies [15,57], ROCS was shown to be comparable with, and often better than, structure-based approaches in virtual screening, both in terms of overall performance and consistency [17]. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Background To improve the utility of PubChem, a public repository containing biological activities of small molecules, the PubChem3D project adds computationally-derived three-dimensional (3-D) descriptions to the small-molecule records contained in the PubChem Compound database and provides various search and analysis tools that exploit 3-D molecular similarity. Therefore, the efficient use of PubChem3D resources requires an understanding of the statistical and biological meaning of computed 3-D molecular similarity scores between molecules. Results The present study investigated effects of employing multiple conformers per compound upon the 3-D similarity scores between ten thousand randomly selected biologically-tested compounds (10-K set) and between non-inactive compounds in a given biological assay (156-K set). When the “best-conformer-pair” approach, in which a 3-D similarity score between two compounds is represented by the greatest similarity score among all possible conformer pairs arising from a compound pair, was employed with ten diverse conformers per compound, the average 3-D similarity scores for the 10-K set increased by 0.11, 0.09, 0.15, 0.16, 0.07, and 0.18 for STST-opt, CTST-opt, ComboTST-opt, STCT-opt, CTCT-opt, and ComboTCT-opt, respectively, relative to the corresponding averages computed using a single conformer per compound. Interestingly, the best-conformer-pair approach also increased the average 3-D similarity scores for the non-inactive–non-inactive (NN) pairs for a given assay, by comparable amounts to those for the random compound pairs, although some assays showed a pronounced increase in the per-assay NN-pair 3-D similarity scores, compared to the average increase for the random compound pairs. Conclusion These results suggest that the use of ten diverse conformers per compound in PubChem bioassay data analysis using 3-D molecular similarity is not expected to increase the separation of non-inactive from random and inactive spaces “on average”, although some assays show a noticeable separation between the non-inactive and random spaces when multiple conformers are used for each compound. The present study is a critical next step to understand effects of conformational diversity of the molecules upon the 3-D molecular similarity and its application to biological activity data analysis in PubChem. The results of this study may be helpful to build search and analysis tools that exploit 3-D molecular similarity between compounds archived in PubChem and other molecular libraries in a more efficient way.
    Journal of Cheminformatics 11/2012; 4(1):28. DOI:10.1186/1758-2946-4-28 · 4.55 Impact Factor
Show more