The phylogenetic relationships of flies in the superfamily Empidoidea (Insecta : Diptera)

The University of Tennessee Medical Center at Knoxville, Knoxville, Tennessee, United States
Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution (Impact Factor: 3.92). 07/2007; 43(3):701-13. DOI: 10.1016/j.ympev.2007.02.029
Source: PubMed


We conducted a molecular phylogenetic study of the Empidoidea, a diverse group of 10,000 species of true flies, with two major goals: to reconstruct a taxonomically complete and robustly supported phylogeny for the group and to use this information to assess several competing classifications for the clade. We amassed 3900+ nucleotides of coding data from the carbamoylphosphate synthase domain of the rudimentary locus (CAD) and 1200+ nucleotides from the large nuclear ribosomal subunit (28S) from 72 and 71 species, respectively, representing several orthorrhaphan and cyclorrhaphan families and all previously recognized empidoidean subfamilies. Independent and combined phylogenetic analyses of these data were conducted using parsimony, maximum likelihood, and Bayesian criteria. The combined matrix included 61 taxa for which both CAD and 28S sequences were obtained. Analyses of CAD first and second codon positions alone and when concatenated with 28S sequences yielded trees with similar and largely stable topologies. Analyses of 28S data alone supported many clades although resolution is limited by low sequence divergence. The following major empidoid clades were recovered with convincing support in a majority of analyses: Atelestidae, Empidoidea exclusive of Atelestidae, Hybotidae sensu lato, Dolichopodidae+Microphorinae (including Parathallassius), and Empididae sensu lato (including Brachystomatinae, Ceratomerinae, Clinocerinae, Empidinae, Hemerodromiinae, Oreogetoninae, and Trichopezinae). The branching arrangement among these four major clades was Atelestidae, Hybotidae, Dolichopodidae/Microphorinae, Empididae. Previously recognized subclades recovered with robust support included Hybotinae, Brachystomatinae, Tachydromiinae, Clinocerinae (in part), Hemerodromiinae, Empidinae, and Empidiini.

21 Reads
  • Source
    • "The characters uniting Syrphoidea + Schizophora are monotype ommatidia, dorsal arista and lever-like phallapodeme (Wada 1991; Cumming et al. 1995). By contrast, molecular data suggest Syrphoidea are paraphyletic and the Pipunculidae are sister to the Schizophora (Collins & Wiegmann 2002; Moulton & Wiegmann 2007; Wiegmann et al. 2011). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The morphology of the metathorax of brachyceran Diptera is examined, particularly the metapleuron in the superfamily Syrphoidea comprising two families Syrphidae and Pipunculidae. The homologies of the metepisternum (EPS) and metepimeron (EPM) are redefined based on the metapleural suture (PlS), which bears an internal apophysis. A new interpretation of the metathorax is provided for Syrphidae. Members of Schizophora and Pipunculidae have an articulation between EPM and the first abdominal tergite in common and the (metapleural-abdominal) articulation is indicated as a synapomorphy for them. In some species of Syrphidae the well-developed metapostnotum is articulated with the first abdominal tergite and the (metapostnotal-abdominal) articulation is diagnostic of a subgroup of the family. The articulations are evaluated and discussed with respect to abdominal flexion of Diptera.
    Insect systematics & evolution 10/2014; 45(4):395-414. DOI:10.1163/1876312X-45012112 · 0.81 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Genital morphology is still the main decisive diagnostic character used in the morphological identification and subsequent classification. Studies carried out over the last few decades indicate the family Hybotidae is to be monophyletic (Chvala 1983, Collins and Wiegmann 2002, Sinclair and Cumming 2006, Moulton and Wiegmann 2007). The family includes ca. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Empidoidea is one of the largest extant lineages of flies, but phylogenetic relationships among species of this group are poorly investigated and global diversity remains scarcely assessed. In this context, one of the most enigmatic empidoid families is Hybotidae. Within the framework of a pilot study, we barcoded 339 specimens of Old World hybotids belonging to 164 species and 22 genera (plus two Empis as outgroups) and attempted to evaluate whether patterns of intra- and interspecific divergences match the current taxonomy. We used a large sampling of diverse Hybotidae. The material came from the Palaearctic (Belgium, France, Portugal and Russian Caucasus), the Afrotropic (Democratic Republic of the Congo) and the Oriental realms (Singapore and Thailand). Thereby, we optimized lab protocols for barcoding hybotids. Although DNA barcodes generally well distinguished recognized taxa, the study also revealed a number of unexpected phenomena: e.g., undescribed taxa found within morphologically very similar or identical specimens, especially when geographic distance was large; some morphologically distinct species showed no genetic divergence; or different pattern of intraspecific divergence between populations or closely related species. Using COI sequences and simple Neighbour-Joining tree reconstructions, the monophyly of many species- and genus-level taxa was well supported, but more inclusive taxonomical levels did not receive significant bootstrap support. We conclude that in hybotids DNA barcoding might be well used to identify species, when two main constraints are considered. First, incomplete barcoding libraries hinder efficient (correct) identification. Therefore, extra efforts are needed to increase the representation of hybotids in these databases. Second, the spatial scale of sampling has to be taken into account, and especially for widespread species or species complexes with unclear taxonomy, an integrative approach has to be used to clarify species boundaries and identities.
    ZooKeys 12/2013; 365(365):263-78. DOI:10.3897/zookeys.365.6070 · 0.93 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "There is certainly a need to search for new genes and other molecular characters. Many recent molecular papers are the result of analyses of similar or identical gene sequences, often generated by the same laboratory or collaborative team (e.g., Wiegmann et al. 2000, 2011; Yang et al. 2000; Collins & Wiegmann 2002a,b; Moulton & Wiegmann 2007; Petersen et al. 2007; Yeates et al. 2007; Bertone et al. 2008; Kutty et al. 2008, 2010; Peterson et al. 2010; Trautwein et al. 2010, 2011). We encourage total evidence analyses of combined molecular and morphological data modelled after Dikow (2009b), who analyzed and compared the contributions of the data sets on the resulting cladograms of Asilidae. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The male terminalia character system in Diptera is reviewed. The phylogenetic implications of apomorphic changes are traced on published cladograms. New synapomorphies include: anteroventral parameral apodeme for the Tipulomorpha; parameral sheath encompassing desclerotized aedeagus for Neodiptera (exclusive of Axymyiidae); endoaedeagus for Xylophagomorpha + Tabanomorpha. Apystomyiidae are classified as the sister group to the Eremoneura based on four synapomorphies (lateral ejaculatory processes absent, subepandrial sclerite extending from base of hypoproct to phallus, bacilliform sclerites extending to tips of the epandrium and surstyli functionally developed, but not articulated) and lack of eremoneuran synapomorphies (i.e., loss of gonostyli, presence of postgonites and phallic plate). The Diptera sperm pump with a functional ejaculatory apodeme is a possible autapomorphy of Diptera, exclusive of Nymphomyiidae and Deuterophlebiidae. Internal details of the male terminalia of Sylvicola and Mycetobia (Anisopodidae), Hilarimorpha (Hilarimorphidae) and Apystomyia (Apystomyiidae) are newly illustrated and homologies of the aedeagus, paramere and sperm pump of the Tipuloidea are clarified.
    Insect systematics & evolution 01/2013; 44(3-4):373-415. DOI:10.1163/1876312X-04401001 · 0.81 Impact Factor
Show more