Selective pressures for and against genetic instability in cancer: a time-dependent problem.

Department of Mathematics, University of California, Irvine, CA 92697, USA.
Journal of The Royal Society Interface (Impact Factor: 3.86). 02/2008; 5(18):105-21. DOI: 10.1098/rsif.2007.1054
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT Genetic instability in cancer is a two-edge sword. It can both increase the rate of cancer progression (by increasing the probability of cancerous mutations) and decrease the rate of cancer growth (by imposing a large death toll on dividing cells). Two of the many selective pressures acting upon a tumour, the need for variability and the need to minimize deleterious mutations, affect the tumour's 'choice' of a stable or unstable 'strategy'. As cancer progresses, the balance of the two pressures will change. In this paper, we examine how the optimal strategy of cancerous cells is shaped by the changing selective pressures. We consider the two most common patterns in multistage carcinogenesis: the activation of an oncogene (a one-step process) and an inactivation of a tumour-suppressor gene (a two-step process). For these, we formulate an optimal control problem for the mutation rate in cancer cells. We then develop a method to find optimal time-dependent strategies. It turns out that for a wide range of parameters, the most successful strategy is to start with a high rate of mutations and then switch to stability. This agrees with the growing biological evidence that genetic instability, prevalent in early cancers, turns into stability later on in the progression. We also identify parameter regimes where it is advantageous to keep stable (or unstable) constantly throughout the growth.

  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Genetic instability promotes cancer progression (by increasing the probability of cancerous mutations) as well as hinders it (by imposing a higher cell death rate for cells susceptible to cancerous mutation). With the loss of tumor suppressor gene function known to be responsible for a high percentage of breast and colorectal cancer (and a good fraction of lung cancer and other types as well), it is important to understand how genetic instability can be orchestrated toward carcinogenesis. In this context, this paper gives a complete characterization of the optimal (time-varying) cell mutation rate for the fastest time to a target cancerous cell population through the loss of both copies of a tumor suppressor gene. Similar to the (one-step) oncogene activation model previously analyzed, the optimal mutation rate of the present two-step model changes qualitatively with the convexity of the (mutation rate-dependent) cell death rate. However, the structure of the Hamiltonian for the new model differs significantly and intrinsically from that of the one-step model, and a completely new approach is needed for the solution of the present two-step problem. Considerable insight into the biology of optimal switching (between corner controls) is extracted from numerical results for cases with nonconvex death rates.
    Bulletin of Mathematical Biology 10/2014; DOI:10.1007/s11538-014-0027-7 · 1.29 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Mathematical and computational modeling approaches have been applied to every aspect of tumor growth from mutation acquisition and tumorigenesis to metastasis and treatment response. In this article, we discuss some of the current mathematical trends in the field and the exciting applications and challenges that lie ahead. In particular, we focus on mathematical approaches that are able to address critical questions associated with tumor initiation; angiogenesis and vascular tumor growth; and the new frontier of computer-aided, patient-specific cancer evaluation and treatment.
    The American Mathematical Monthly 11/2014; 121(9). DOI:10.4169/amer.math.monthly.121.09.840 · 0.32 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Carcinogenesis (cancer generation) relies on a sequence of mutations that transforms cells, leading to their unchecked growth. An important phenomenon in cancer is genetic instability, or an increased rate of mutations, with a higher associated cell death rate. Given the trade-off between an increase in mutant cells by higher mutation rate and higher loss of mutants through a higher death rate, we ask the question: what mutation rate is most advantageous for cancer? To seek an answer to this question, we investigate an optimal control problem of normal and mutant cell growth where the abnormal mutation rate plays the role of a time-dependent control. The analysis of this problem shows that the best “strategy” for the fastest time to cancer is to start with a high level of genetic instability initially, and then to switch to a low level of genetic instability. The exact shape of the optimal mutation rate as a function of time depends on how genetic instability contributes to the death rate of cells. If the death rate is a linear or an increasing concave function of the mutation rate, the optimal mutation rate is bang-bang, which changes from its highest to its lowest value with a finite jump discontinuity. However, if the death rate is an increasing convex function of the mutation rate, then the optimal control is a continuous decreasing function of time. Two known mechanisms of cancer initiation have been considered, an activation of an oncogene and an inactivation of a tumor-suppressor gene. Mathematical justification of the results of the first, a one-step process, is reported herein.
    Studies in Applied Mathematics 02/2010; 125(1). DOI:10.1111/j.1467-9590.2009.00476.x · 1.15 Impact Factor