The Study of Entheses: Proposal of a Standardised Scoring Method for Twenty-Three Entheses of the Postcranial Skeleton

Department of Experimental Evolutionary Biology, Anthropology Unit, University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy.
Collegium antropologicum (Impact Factor: 0.61). 04/2007; 31(1):291-313.
Source: PubMed


Entheses are always visible on the bone, although with variable forms and degrees of expression. The term "robusticity" indicates the "normal" osseous markings at entheses, while "enthesopathy", indicates the presence of enthesophytes or osteolytic areas. A scoring method for enthesopathy development has already been proposed. In this paper, a standardised descriptive and photographic scoring method is proposed for the robusticity of 23 postcranial skeleton entheses. For each enthesis, 3 levels of development are described, corresponding, in general, to a weak-moderate expression (degree 1), strong development (degree 2) and very strong development (degree 3). The interobserver error of about 20% seems acceptable given the great morphological variability of these traits.

Download full-text


Available from: Maria Giovanna Belcastro,
1 Follower
16 Reads
  • Source
    • "Estimation of adult age-at-death was carried out by considering the long bones morphology, while for subadults we considered dental eruption, following Ubelaker (1989), and the dimensions of long bones (Scheuer and Black, 2000). Wherever possible, indicators of pathology were documented (Ortner Putschar, 1985), along with stress markers and enthesopathies (Kennedy, 1989; Mariotti et al., 2007). For each burial the minimum number of individuals (NMI) was calculated. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Between 1984 and 1986, during the consolidation and restoration of the Romanesque Church of San Giuliano (Selargius, Sardinia), some inhumations dated to different chronological phases (XI-XIII AD and XVIII-XIX AD) were found. The excavations, carried out by Soprintendenza Archeologica per le province di Cagliari e Oristano, by Soprintendenza ai B.A.A.A.S of the same provinces and the city council, covered the Church in its total extension. The reconstruction of biological profile was made difficult due to the lack of archaeological information. In the sample here presented, the traditional anthropological methods for the estimation of biological and pathological characters were applied. The results suggest the presence of infant and adult individuals, both male and female. In this work, currently in progress, we report the preliminary investigations conducted on a small sample of a population of Southern Sardinia.
    Towards a Next-Generation Anthropology: challenges and synergies-21° CONGRESSO dell’Associazione Antropologica Italiana, Bologna/Ravenna; 09/2015
    • "Following Mariotti et al. (2004) each EC was also recorded with respect to osteophytic (OF) and osteolythic (OL) development. Note that Mariotti et al. (2007) also proposed the recording of " robusticity " for each enthesis, however, this could not be applied in this article since the authors propose different standards for each enthesis and they do not provide standards for any of the fibrocartilaginous humeral entheses examined here. As was the case with the Hawkey and Merbs (1995) method, OL development was not recorded in the case of the common flexor and common extensor origins (Hawkey and Merbs, 1995). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In the past decade there have been extensive discussions on the potential utility of entheseal changes (EC) as activity markers. Nevertheless, no study to date has compared different EC recording protocols with respect to their correlation to activity patterns. This article records changes on fibrocartilaginous entheses of the upper limbs of 90 male skeletons from the documented Athens Collection using the Hawkey and Merbs (Int J Osteoarchaeol 5 (1995) 324-338), Mariotti et al. (Collegium Antropol 28 (2004) 145-159), and Villotte et al. (Am J Phys Anthropol 142 (2010) 224-234) recording schemes in order to determine which one exhibits the highest correlation with activity. Activity is assessed by means of the recorded profession of each individual, as well as employing cross-sectional geometric properties. Generalized Linear Models are used to explore the impact of age, body mass, and activity on EC expression. Our results agree with previous studies that age is the primary factor determining EC, whereas body mass is the second most influential factor. In contrast, activity in the form of profession or cross-sectional geometry rarely showed a significant correlation to EC expression and no clear pattern could be discerned irrespective of the recording technique. However, bilateral differences in the impact of age and body mass in EC expression were traced and may relate to activity patterns. The differences found in the bilateral impact of age and body mass highlight the fact that the activity patterns of the individuals under examination must play an underlying role to EC expression, though current recording schemes for EC do not capture this, rendering further work in the direction of developing more elaborate recording standards imperative. Am J Phys Anthropol, 2015. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
    American Journal of Physical Anthropology 08/2015; DOI:10.1002/ajpa.22822 · 2.38 Impact Factor
    • "In some instances, especially regarding tarsal articular facet terminology , we also refer to Szalay and Schrenk (1998). Among the terms related to muscle and ligament attachment sites, we use the term " enthesis " as defined by Mariotti et al. (2007): simple surface irregularities, or osteo-productive/erosive formations, both produced by the bone as a response to mechanical loads related to movements and exerted by tendons and/or ligaments. Muscular reconstruction was performed by identifying their bony entheses in extant sloths, anteaters and armadillos, and analyzing fossil sloths by searching for homologous features. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This article presents a morphofunctional analysis of the hind limb of Santacrucian (Early Miocene) sloths from southernmost Patagonia (Argentina). These fossil sloths were mid sized to large animals, ranging from 40 to 120 kg, and their postcranial skeleton was markedly different in shape compared with that of extant tree sloths, which vary from 2 to 10 kg. The functional anatomy of the hind limb of Santacrucian sloths was compared with that of living xenarthrans (tree sloths, anteaters, and armadillos), which involved reconstruction of the hind limb musculature and comparative and qualitative morphofunctional analyses, and hypotheses on the biological role of the hind limb in terms of preferences in substrate, posture, and strategies of locomotion were formulated. The hind limb of Santacrucian sloths bears strong resemblances to that of living South American anteaters in stoutness of skeletal elements, form of the characteristics related to muscular and ligamentous attachments, and conservative, pentadactylous strong-clawed pes. The musculature was very well developed, allowing powerful forces, principally in entire limb adduction, crus flexion and extension, pes extension, and toe prehension. These functional features, together with those of the forelimb, are congruent with climbing behavior, and support the hypothesis that Santacrucian sloths were good but slow climbing mammals. However, their climbing strategies were limited, owing principally to their comparatively large body size, and they relied to a large extent on their powerful musculature and curved manual and pedal unguals for both moving and standing on the arboreal supports.
    The Anatomical Record 05/2015; 298(5):842-864. DOI:10.1002/ar.23114
Show more