Stigma and the acceptability of depression treatments among African Americans and Whites. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 22, 1292-1297

Boston University Medical Center, Geriatrics Section, Boston, MA 02118-2393, USA.
Journal of General Internal Medicine (Impact Factor: 3.42). 09/2007; 22(9):1292-7. DOI: 10.1007/s11606-007-0276-3
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT Stigma is associated with depression treatment, however, whether stigma differs between depression treatment modalities is not known, nor have racial differences in depression treatment stigma been fully explored.
To measure stigma for four depression treatments and estimate its association with treatment acceptability for African Americans and whites.
Cross-sectional, anonymous mailed survey.
Four hundred and ninety African-American and white primary care patients.
The acceptability of four depression treatments (prescription medication, mental health counseling, herbal remedy, and spiritual counseling) was assessed using a vignette. Treatment-specific stigma was evaluated by asking whether participants would: (1) feel ashamed; (2) feel comfortable telling friends and family; (3) feel okay if people in their community knew; and (4) not want people at work to know about each depression treatment. Sociodemographics, depression history, and current depressive symptoms were measured.
Treatment-specific stigma was lower for herbal remedy than prescription medication or mental health counseling (p < .01). Whites had higher stigma than African Americans for all treatment modalities. In adjusted analyses, stigma relating to self [AOR 0.43 (0.20-0.95)] and friends and family [AOR 0.42 (0.21-0.88)] was associated with lower acceptability of mental health counseling. Stigma did not account for the lower acceptability of prescription medication among African Americans.
Treatment associated stigma significantly affects the acceptability of mental health counseling but not prescription medication. Efforts to improve depression treatment utilization might benefit from addressing concerns about stigma of mental health counseling.

  • Source
    • "As a result of these comparisons, we can conclude that whites prefer pharmacological treatments and an intermediate acceptance of psychotherapeutic treatment. Whites, African- Americans, and Latinos seem to hold very different attitudes regarding acceptance of the therapy prescribed for depression, confirming the influence of the cultural environment on the stigma (Givens et al., 2007b; Interian et al., 2007; Kanter et al., 2008). Furthermore, this could be seen as a factor within the daily practice of psychiatry when prescribing a certain indicated treatment to a person of a particular ethnic group. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The aim of this study was to ascertain whether there is any evidence of stigma related to the use of antidepressants. Using the PubMed and MEDLINE databases, we searched for the terms stigma, antidepressants, and depression. A protocol was developed to extract information from the papers, which were identified and explored further. Thirty-two papers were identified. We found that the stigma against depression differs from stigma against the use of antidepressants. Stigma against depression does not impact on therapeutic adherence to antidepressant use. Stigma related to antidepressant use appears to be linked with perceived emotional weakness, severity of illness, an inability to deal with problems, and a lack of belief in the therapeutic efficacy of antidepressants. Stigma against medication can be a useful target for interventions, just like the stigma related to depression. However, clinicians must be careful in avoiding the medicalization of symptoms.
    The Journal of nervous and mental disease 11/2011; 199(11):866-71. DOI:10.1097/NMD.0b013e3182388950 · 1.81 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Race and/or ethnicity may be related to the use of religious counseling. Compared to whites, African Americans are more likely to find spiritual counseling acceptable and less likely to find prescription medication acceptable for the treatment of depression [26]. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Although racial/ethnic differences have been found in the use of mental health services for depression in the general population, research among Veterans has produced mixed results. This study examined racial/ethnic differences in the use of mental health services among 148 Operation Enduring/Iraqi Freedom (OEF/OIF) Veterans with high levels of depression and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms and evaluated whether religious coping affected service use. No differences between African American, Hispanic, and Non-Hispanic white Veterans were found in use of secular mental health services or religious counseling. Women Veterans were more likely than men to seek secular treatment. After controlling for PTSD symptoms, depression symptom level was a significant predictor of psychotherapy attendance but not medication treatment. African American Veterans reported higher levels of religious coping than whites. Religious coping was associated with participation in religious counseling, but not secular mental health services.
    Depression research and treatment 07/2011; 2011(2090-1321):192186. DOI:10.1155/2011/192186
  • Source
    • "The issue of seeing the problem 'as their own issue' parallels abused women's experience (Hegarty and Taft, 2001): if a person looks at depression or intimate partner violence as being their own problem, then they are inclined to turn fi rst to family, friends and personal resources. Even though this was a sample recruited through primary care, our respondents tended to view personal and social resources as more benefi cial than professional help, perhaps an indication that concerns about the stigma associated with professional interventions retain potency (Givens et al., 2007). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Resilience refers to the capacity for successful adaptation or change in the face of adversity. This concept has rarely been applied to the study of distress and depression. We propose two key elements of resilience - ordinary magic and personal medicine - which enable people to survive and flourish despite current experience of emotional distress. We investigate the extent to which these elements are considered important by a sample of 100 people, drawn from a longitudinal study of the management of depression in primary care in Victoria, Australia. We also assess how respondents rate personal resilience in comparison with help received from professional sources. Our data are obtained from semi-structured telephone interviews, and analysed inductively through refinement of our theoretical framework. We find substantial evidence of resilience both in terms of ordinary magic - drawing on existing social support and affectional bonds; and in terms of personal medicine - building on personal strengths and expanding positive emotions. There is a strong preference for personal over professional approaches to dealing with mental health problems. We conclude that personal resilience is important in the minds of our respondents, and that these elements should be actively considered in future research involving people with experience of mental health problems.
    Health 11/2008; 12(4):439-52. DOI:10.1177/1363459308094419 · 2.10 Impact Factor
Show more


Available from