Improving patient safety by identifying latent failures in successful operations

Department of Surgery, University of Oxford, London, UK.
Surgery (Impact Factor: 3.11). 08/2007; 142(1):102-10. DOI: 10.1016/j.surg.2007.01.033
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT The risk of technical failure during operations is recognized, but there is evidence that further improvements in safety depend on systems factors, in particular, effective team skills. The hypotheses that small problems can escalate to more serious situations and that effective teamwork can prevent the development of serious situations, were examined to develop a method to assess these skills and to provide evidence for improvements in training and systems.
Observations were made during 24 pediatric cardiac and 18 orthopedic operations. Operations were classified by accepted indicators of risk and the observations used to generate indicators of performance. Negative events were recorded and organized into 3 levels of clinical importance (minor problems, those negative events that were seemingly innocuous; intraoperative performance, the proportion of key operating tasks that were disrupted; and major problems, events that compromised directly the safety of the patient or the quality of the treatment). The ability of the team to work together safely was classified using a validated scale adapted from research in aviation. Operative duration was also recorded.
Both escalation and teamwork hypotheses were supported. Multiple linear regression suggests that for every 3 minor problems above the 9.9 expected per operation (P <.001), intraoperative performance reduces by 1% (P = .005), and operative duration increases by 10 minutes (P = .032). Effective teams have fewer minor problems per operation (P = .035) and consequently higher intraoperative performance and shorter operating times. Operative risk affected intraoperative performance (P = .004) and duration (P <.001), with the type of operation affecting only duration (P <.001). Eight major problems were observed; these showed a strong association with risk, intraoperative performance, teamwork, and the number of minor problems.
Structured observation of effective teamwork in the operating room can identify substantive deficiencies in the system, even in otherwise successful operations. Decreasing the number of minor problems can lead to a smoother, safer, and shorter operation. Effective teamwork can help decrease the number of small problems and prevent them from escalating to more serious situations. The most effective and sustainable route to improved safety is in capturing these minor problems and identifying related system improvements, combined with training in safe team working. This method is a validated and practical way to improve performance during otherwise successful operations.

  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: We hypothesized that the National Aeronautics and Space Administration "threat and error" model (which is derived from analyzing >30,000 commercial flights, and explains >90% of crashes) is directly applicable to pediatric cardiac surgery. We implemented a unit-wide performance initiative, whereby every surgical admission constitutes a "flight" and is tracked in real time, with the aim of identifying errors. The first 500 consecutive patients (524 flights) were analyzed, with an emphasis on the relationship between error cycles and permanent harmful outcomes. Among 524 patient flights (risk adjustment for congenital heart surgery category: 1-6; median: 2) 68 (13%) involved residual hemodynamic lesions, 13 (2.5%) permanent end-organ injuries, and 7 deaths (1.3%). Preoperatively, 763 threats were identified in 379 (72%) flights. Only 51% of patient flights (267) were error free. In the remaining 257 flights, 430 errors occurred, most commonly related to proficiency (280; 65%) or judgment (69, 16%). In most flights with errors (173 of 257; 67%), an unintended clinical state resulted, ie, the error was consequential. In 60% of consequential errors (n = 110; 21% of total), subsequent cycles of additional error/unintended states occurred. Cycles, particularly those containing multiple errors, were very significantly associated with permanent harmful end-states, including residual hemodynamic lesions (P < .0001), end-organ injury (P < .0001), and death (P < .0001). Deaths were almost always preceded by cycles (6 of 7; P < .0001). Human error, if not mitigated, often leads to cycles of error and unintended patient states, which are dangerous and precede the majority of harmful outcomes. Efforts to manage threats and error cycles (through crew resource management techniques) are likely to yield large increases in patient safety. Copyright © 2015. Published by Elsevier Inc.
    Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery 02/2015; 149(2):496-507.e4. DOI:10.1016/j.jtcvs.2014.10.058 · 3.99 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The Vascular Society has published numerous reports on the performance of vascular procedures.1 In March 2012, we published mortality data after elective abdominal aortic aneurysm repair for every trust in the UK and were disappointed that it was not accepted for publication in the BMJ.2 The report showed that a quality improvement programme implemented by our society was associated with a reduction in national mortality rates—from 8% to 2.4%—which is lower than in many European countries. Using more stringent criteria than those of the Society for Cardiothoracic Surgery, the report identified three borderline performing and five non-contributing units. This information was reported to the medical directors of these trusts.Surgeons should not always be blamed for poor performance, however. Service delivery in vascular medicine has changed greatly. Many procedures (especially open abdominal aortic aneurysm repair) now involve preoperative multidisciplinary team assessments, joint consultant operations, specialist vascular anaesthetists, and a highly trained team that cares for patients in intensive care and on the ward. Failures therefore need to be analysed carefully to identify reasons for poor outcomes. Some years ago, Great Ormond Street Hospital identified failures at handover between the operating theatre and intensive care as the point at which babies were at greatest risk.3 Poor outcomes can therefore be caused by system failures rather than poor operative technique.4If we are to modernise our health service, the culture needs to encourage services to improve. This cannot be achieved by blaming an individual for an organisational failure. Being open about results and encouraging teams to improve is the key.NotesCite this as: BMJ 2012;345:e5058
    BMJ (online) 07/2012; 345(jul31 1):e5058-e5058. DOI:10.1136/bmj.e5058 · 16.38 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The expectations of pediatric cardiac surgeons grow as the specialty evolves and yesterday's challenges become tomorrow's routine. The pioneering era of fast-paced major technical advances is behind us. Integration of surgery, cardiology, anesthesia, intensive care, and nursing is now the basis of incre-mental improvements in perioperative performance and long-term out-comes. Surgeons can be natural leaders of this process because their skills, roles, and experience are crucial in the preoperative, intra-operative, and postoperative care of the patient and their family. However, the personality traits that draw physicians to the specialty of surgery and contribute to the drive to become a successful technical surgeon may be at odds with the collaborative aspects of this microsystem, both inside and outside the oper-ating room. The potential for disruptive behavior on the part of the surgeon to impede the functioning of a large multidisciplinary team providing care of the upmost complexity raises fundamental questions about how to design tools and checks to create reliable pediatric cardiac surgical teams.
    Pediatric and Congenital Cardiac Care: outcomes Analysis, 1st edited by P. Barach, J. Jacobs, S.E. Lipshultz, P. Laussen (Eds, 01/2015: chapter Leadership, Surgeon Well-Being, and Other Non-technical Aspects of Pediatric Cardiac Surgery: pages 293-306; Springer.

Full-text (2 Sources)

Available from
May 29, 2014