Children's estimates of food portion size: the effect of timing of dietary interview on the accuracy of children's portion size estimates

Human Nutrition Research Centre, School of Clinical Medical Sciences, University of Newcastle, Room M1151, 1st Floor, William Leech Building, Framlington Place, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE2 4HH, UK.
British Journal Of Nutrition (Impact Factor: 3.34). 02/2008; 99(1):185-90. DOI: 10.1017/S0007114507791882
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT For food intakes to be converted into nutrient intakes a measure or estimate of the amount of food consumed is required. A number of methods have been developed to assist subjects in providing an estimate of portion size. Children's ability to use perception, conceptualisation and memory skills to estimate food portion size has not been investigated systematically. The aim of the present study was to test the effect of the timing of a dietary interview on the accuracy of estimates of food portion sizes made by children, using food photographs, food models and an interactive portion size assessment system, developed for use with children and based on portion sizes of foods consumed by children. Children (n 108) aged 4-14 years were supplied with known quantities of foods and asked to estimate the portion size of each food using each of the three portion size assessment tools. Interviews took place (a) with the food in view, (b) just after the child had eaten the food or (c) 24 h after the child had eaten the food. There were no significant differences in children's ability to estimate food portion size (either as served or as eaten) with timing of interview. That is, children were as accurate in their estimates of portion size 24 h after consuming the food as when the food was in view. Under these conditions many children were able to estimate food portion size utilising perception, conceptualisation and memory skills.

  • Source
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Accurate estimation of food portion size is of paramount importance in dietary studies. We have developed a small, chest-worn electronic device called eButton which automatically takes pictures of consumed foods for objective dietary assessment. From the acquired pictures, the food portion size can be calculated semi-automatically with the help of computer software. The aim of the present study is to evaluate the accuracy of the calculated food portion size (volumes) from eButton pictures. Participants wore an eButton during their lunch. The volume of food in each eButton picture was calculated using software. For comparison, three raters estimated the food volume by viewing the same picture. The actual volume was determined by physical measurement using seed displacement. Dining room and offices in a research laboratory. Seven lab member volunteers. Images of 100 food samples (fifty Western and fifty Asian foods) were collected and each food volume was estimated from these images using software. The mean relative error between the estimated volume and the actual volume over all the samples was -2·8 % (95 % CI -6·8 %, 1·2 %) with sd of 20·4 %. For eighty-five samples, the food volumes determined by computer differed by no more than 30 % from the results of actual physical measurements. When the volume estimates by the computer and raters were compared, the computer estimates showed much less bias and variability. From the same eButton pictures, the computer-based method provides more objective and accurate estimates of food volume than the visual estimation method.
    Public Health Nutrition 12/2013; DOI:10.1017/S1368980013003236 · 2.48 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Obtaining valid, reliable dietary intake data for young children is challenging. The objective of this study was to assess the validity, reliability, and acceptability of the addition of photography to traditional written diet diaries for recording young children's dietary intake. Twenty-two parents of preschoolers enrolled to complete a 2-day photographic diet diary for their child. Diaries were coded by a trained nursing student for food weight, calories, and macronutrients. A random sample of diaries was evaluated by an independent nutritionist to determine interrater reliability. Convergent validity was tested by comparing visual estimates and actual values of photos of 24 researcher-created meals/snacks. Acceptability was assessed through participants' feedback, completion rates for the project, project costs, and quality of the data obtained. Reliability was assessed by computing intraclass correlations between caloric and macronutrient data from 2 independent diary evaluators. Convergent validity was assessed by calculating intraclass correlations between visually estimated photo diary evaluations and actual premeasured researcher-created meals/snacks. Medium to large correlations between the 2 independent evaluators (.51-.63) were found for caloric and macronutrient values, with the exception of protein (r = –.21). Strong correlations (food served, r = .69-.96; food consumed, r = .66-.83) were obtained between visual estimates and actual values of calories and macronutrients for the premeasured foods. Preliminary results indicate the addition of photographs to a traditional diet diary may enhance the validity and reliability of prospective dietary intake recording. Parents and children indicated the activity was fun, and quality data resulted, indicating that this method is acceptable.
    ICAN Infant Child & Adolescent Nutrition 02/2009; 1(1):27-36. DOI:10.1177/1941406408330360

Full-text (2 Sources)

Available from
May 29, 2014